This story is a sequel to If Wishes were Ponies . . . .
Harry Potter and the CMC have somehow managed to survive their first year at Hogwarts. Equestria has met Earth, and both are astonished at what they've discovered. The Muggles think Equus is a planet from another galaxy, or dimension. The Wizards all think that Equestria is Atlantis. The evidence for both groups appears conclusive. The changelings haven't been idle, though. And neither has been Tom Riddle and his supporters.
Wow, hit Featured on the first day, 12/08/20, and lasted until the 12th! Yeah, Ch. 1-4! Looks like Ch. 5 put it back for a short time. Ch. 6 lasted an hour on Featured. Ch.s 7-present lasted at least 2, and as many as 5 hours! (Except Ch 29, on Memorial Day -- no show)
Art work by: Mix-up. You can find him at DeviantArt, or his Youtube Channel.
Ah ****, here we go again.
Nice to see you around again, looking forward to read more of this story again.
I'm glad to see you around! I was getting worried!
IT'S BACK !
thumbs.gfycat.com/BelatedUltimateCopperbutterfly-size_restricted.gif
Well well a wild story appears time to devour it with reckless abandon.
Glad to see you back :)
So glad to see this story continued. I loved the first one.
Well I guess I will have to go on break now and pull a Twilight, thanks for the update!
Oh boy, there are still 3 more horcruxes left if I'm not mistaken. Tom's diary, the snake Nagini and one other, though I can't remember what it was. So, I'm thinking its going to be the diary this time.
I thought you were dead mate good to see the saga continued though
Oh wow, a sequel. Im so looking forward to this, i was just rereading the original story too!
YES!
YES!
YES!
It's back!
This has just made my year.
I am crying from sheer joy right now
Well can’t say 2020 all bad now!
Yay
Santa, is that you? It's a bit early, but considering the year... Thanks!
10571731
no just those two, you might be forgetting the piece he kept for himself.
10571775
That and the fact that nagini isn't a horcrux yet. That doesn't happen till the triwizard tournament year.
Wooooo! Glad to see you continuing the story! My favorite harry potter mlp crossover continues!
All i can think of wen i saw this was
A sequel is here
HOLY SHIT IT'SBACK!
Was afraid we weren't going to see a continuation. Glad to see this posted.
Bonus chapter for each 100 upvotes, or have you decided that's crazy?
Yay!
10571859
I'm wondering how long it will take to hit one hundred. I'm betting it will be several hundred within twenty-four hours.
There's just untold happiness knowing we finally get a sequal, though now I need to reread book 1. I can't wait to read about Elly some more~
Best Christmas present i expect to get this year, Hurray!
Yes here we go! Now I wonder how the diary reacted to all of this or are we going to be seeing a young Tom Riddle appear? I wonder who will be stirring up trouble beyond Umbridge, Starlight Glimmer, and Chrysalis?
Hooray! I've been waiting ages for the sequel! So excited!!!
WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOT you are freaking awesome man... l LOVED the first one, and have been praying you would make another one
I can’t wait for the next chapter.
Hell yeah sequal time post pones reading to reread first story
10571731
Actually two, harry and the 4 hgward's items, now the diary and nagini are left, but nagini may or may not be a horocruxe at this point, that will depend on if Voldy make her one before going for harry or not.
Cool, it's back
Oh my gosh you’re starting a second book that’s amazing. I’m so excited to read.
https://youtu.be/tmrWeliK4fk
https://youtu.be/XJneTwffqsY
https://youtu.be/W7Dvt2PmWgI
https://youtu.be/lowij-5Q5Xg
I really really like Harry Potter and ponies together it’s a great combo
Huzzah! Interesting start so far.
Congrats on making the featured box. I had no doubts this great first chapter would reach that milestone.
10571714
STOMP STOMP
I can not believe it! The best Christmas gift!
Impeccable timing! I JUST FINISHED the first story today and then THIS popped up! Well, now I know what I'll be doing for the next year. Watching for this story to progress!
And so it begins anew...
May Discord have mercy on our souls.
And thus, the second year has officially started.
I like your approach of trying to explain the werewolf curse in the wizard, with a reasonable reaction theory to Equestrian magic. Still, does this mean the normal human, with zero magic whatsoever, cannot contract werewolf curse? Since there is no Animagus magic in them to begin with.
also at the end hi Dobby
10571969
Actually the Horcruxes were Harry, The Diary, The Gaunt Family Ring, Slytherin's locket, Hufflepuff's cup, Ravenclaw's Diadem, Nanagi. Only three of those are from the founders of Hogwarts since Voldemort could never get the sword. So all that would be left are the Diary, which would be in Lucius Malfoy's possession and Nanagi, if she wasn't made a Horcrux AFTER Voldemort came back.
10572180
Because the werewolf curse requires magic to operate, and you can't give magic to a non-magical, a non-magical would just die from rabies.
Tom has no idea what he is in for
By the way the story hit the featured box already
Awesome! Always wondered if this would continue... will look forward to avidly reading it!
Oh Yeah, Dobby is finally here, I can't wait until he is freed from the Malfoy's control and maybe Harry could ask him to join as his Family's House Elf then, also any chance that Harry could ascend into an Alicorn later on in the story, maybe not this one but one later down the line in one of the other book stories?
Glad to see it's finally out.
Well this was an interesting chapter, now I wonder if a whole new villain will come and threaten both worlds?
i loved the first one and so far im loving the second one keep up the good work sir and or ma'am