The crowd that had gathered impressed Silver, but he tried not to focus on that. He told himself to think of them back as the cartoons they once were. They were players, they were cartoons, they were anything but real people right now. He pushed his mind into sales mode and reared up on the podium. "Good morning, Canterlot! I'm so glad to see so many ponies could make it out on such short notice."
The crowd wasn't entirely ponies. It seemed rumors had indeed been flying, as one full-sized dragon coiled at the end of the crowd, a few zebra were mixed through the crowd, two minotaurs he could spot easily, and even a diamond dog pack. All cartoons right now, yes, not people. "I'm sure many of you heard about what happened..."
A voice whispered in his mind, ~Two days ago.~
"Two days ago, but I want to set the record straight, and give a big thanks to those who prevented a bad situation from becoming worse," said Silver, getting into the swing of his spiel. Was he lying? Yes. Was it bad? No. At least, he didn't think so. The crowd seemed curious for the moment. Silver decided curious was a good emotion. "There I was, walking down the hallway when, snap. I had pushed myself too hard in my test, and my magic started flowing out of control. Thinking quickly," Silver dramatically gestured with his hooves, "Professor Thetics grabbed me in his magic! He knew I had been foolhardy and began reminding me that I needed more practice, and being friends with the princesses wouldn't get me any breaks in his class. He was tough, but fair, but while he was saying this, the magic didn't stop. He tried to cut the flow, but it was far too late. I exploded violently, and injured several, including the professor, who even now is still unconscious in the hospital."
Silver backed from the podium a moment, glancing away as if he were having some feelings about it. Maybe he was. He wasn't even sure anymore. "Thank you, Professor Thetics. If you weren't there, so many more could have been hurt. To those who were hurt anyway, my deepest apologies. To the staff of the school, who throw themselves in harm's way so that we can learn magic, you have my humblest of thanks."
The crowd was starting to react, murmuring about the bravery of that teacher.
"To that end!" said Silver, "I am donating this." He nudged the bag of bits forward. "I want Professor Thetics to receive a wing added to the school in his honor, to commemorate teachers who give their all, sometimes literally, for the best of their students. Thank you, Mister Thetics. I hope you know how much you are appreciated."
A polite round of clopping and stomping came from the crowd as one pony raised a hoof, "I heard you were locked away!" A chorus joined in questioning, looking to one another and back at Silver.
Silver nodded, "Of course I was! My magic was spiking dangerously. Celestia, Princess Celestia, came swiftly to my side and soothed the dangerous flow, but they couldn't know if I would spike up again or not. I stayed until it was definitely safe. Her decisive action kept me from hurting anypony else, or myself. I thought I felt it touch and go for a little there." A small part of Silver balked at all the pure, unfiltered, bullshit he was spewing. "But, it is with heavy heart that I must resign as a student. Despite the professor's sincerest efforts, I could be a hazard, and nopony deserves that kind of danger."
The crowd didn't need to know he was as good as kicked out already, though that hadn't been made official yet. They appeared to be eating it up. The general inability for Equestrians to detect lies was working to his benefit, and they seemed to be on his side. "To the ponies still injured, I waive my stipend towards their families until they are well again. It is no replacement for their loved ones, recovering in a hospital, but... it's all I have. I hope it will be taken in the spirit given, and I will trouble their loved ones no further."
~What are you doing?~ came Luna's voice, ~You are taking blame for everything.~
~A guilty man, er, pony confessing and pumping for a brighter future is a lot easier to explain than 'it's complicated'. Everypony's innocent but me,~ replied Silver silently before he opened his mouth, "I know some of you remember me, from Tirek's visit. I'm sorry my past with Canterlot is so checkered, but I love this city, from the bottom of my heart. I've found my wives here, and I want to raise my foals here. Canterlot, I am sorry I hurt you. Please forgive me." He held out a hoof towards Night, who joined him quietly. Fast appeared a moment later, galloping up and tackling the both of them.
Silver squirmed his way free with a nervous chuckle, "This is Fast Change, living up to her first name. I will be submitting to the watchful gaze of my wives until I have become a better pony, worthy of this great city. If you see me without one or both of them at my side for the next few months, you should call a guard and I will surrender to them."
The reaction was mixed at this request. The idea of having somepony so dangerous seemed to not sit well with them. Soft clops announced the approach of Luna, "That will not be necessary," she said, voice carrying easily without the podium's amplifying magic. "Silver Lining, present yourself."
Silver moved in front of Luna, standing up straight on his haunches. Luna reached out and pressed him to the ground, "Silver Lining, ambassador of the human people. Do you agree that your magic could be used for great harm?"
Silver nodded from his low position, "I do."
Luna nodded, "Do you wish to use this power for, or against, the people?"
Silver sat up suddenly, "For!"
Luna smiled, "Then I extend an invitation, to learn. You will be educated in the way of the warlocks. Your destructive magic will be reined in, to be used if, and only if, the well-being of Equestrian citizens demands it. Does this please you?"
Silver bobbed his head quickly, "I want to use my magic for good, for everyone. I don't want anypony hurt."
Luna turned to the crowd, "We will shape this colt. He stands before you raw and dangerous, but we will hone him, and he will wield his magic for the good of all. Let us put aside his mistakes as the fumblings of the foal he is. Even I have erred once. His actions are that of a guardian, not a vandal."
Silver waved a hoof, "Princess Luna, you're too much. This isn't about me. I didn't call all these ponies here for me."
The crowd got a little confused again at Silver's words until he continued, "I wanted to thank everypony that gave so much to get me here. This city, as a whole, has worked so hard to make me feel welcome. I'll do what I can to return the favor."
Celestia sat, drinking softly from a teacup before she looked back up at Silver and Luna, "That went well."
Silver nodded slowly, "I don't think they all went for it, but enough did. They'll be scared of me, or impressed, maybe both, depends on the pony, but most of them have entirely forgotten you two did anything remotely wrong."
Luna snorted, "I did nothing wrong to begin with."
Silver raised a brow, "You are illegally enchanting."
Luna frowned a moment, "I am... what?"
Celestia tilted her head slightly, "I do believe he complimented you, sister."
Luna extended her wings, only to settle them over Silver, "This pony is mine."
Celestia nodded, "I wouldn't dream of separating you two. His wives might have something else to say."
She looked over to said wives, who had been sitting there looking a bit cowed.
Fast tilted her head at Luna, "Do you share?"
Luna raised a brow high, "Pardon? Ah, you are the secondary wife." She pointed a wing at Night, "And you, the primary."
Night Watch made an almost-snarl, clearly intimidated, "I want to stay that way..."
Fast glanced at Night, then at Luna, and finally to Silver, "So?"
Luna tilted her head, "So? There can only be one first wife."
Fast shrugged, "So? You're not a wife. You're his consort. Stop acting like you don't love him and kiss him already."
Luna darkened subtly, "But we are not intimate!"
Fast snorted, "Oh please. You've let this stallion go balls deep and I've heard him describe you. You're as intimate as they get. Stop pretending and kiss the idiot already."
Luna looked to Night Watch with a challenging look, "Surely you would not approve of your stallion having feelings for his consort?"
Night glanced nervously at Celestia, who was watching everything between tea sips. "It's... a bit late for that. He has the feelings. He has too many of those, feelings that is. If you two can..." She waved a wing at Luna, "Have your feelings without the drama, I wouldn't complain."
Luna turned her gaze on Silver, "Well, this is your fault. What do you want?"
Silver smiled nervously, "I don't think I ever made that a secret? Will you be my mare, even if we are just consorts? I want to hear your worries and your triumphs. I want to make you happy." He looked over at his wives, "I may invite company. I, uh, know Fast's been practically biting at the bit."
Fast moved up quickly beside Silver, looking Luna over, "So?"
Luna snorted, "We will consider."
Celestia gave her subtle little smile, "My little sister can't keep her consorts straight."
Luna adopted a predatory pose, "Tia! That was not in the least amusing. May we remind you that it was your doing that brought calamity, that only he, consort or otherwise, deflected with his own name and goodwill."
Celestia raised a gold hoof, "Which would not be required if he didn't conjure hostile magic." She frowned a touch at Silver, "I have not forgotten that. We should speak of it. Why did you reach for such dangerous magic? Did you believe that teacher was a true danger?"
Silver took his turn to darken with shame, "No, I... It was stupid. I was wrong, just wrong."
Celestia shook her head, "How can I know you will not do it again? That is a very dangerous mind that reaches so readily for deadly tools when surprised."
Luna bristled, "He has apologized, and will train with the warlocks! There is no need for further chastising."
Celestia seemed to disagree. She took a gentle sip from her glass, "I would not trust Discord to not think certain ways. It is in--"
With a flash, Discord stepped out from behind Celestia, "Did I hear someone calling my name?"
Night and Fast both relocated behind Silver quickly. Silver raised a hoof, "Hey Discord."
Discord flashed a grin, "Ah, the pony who treats me like anypony else. Of course, he's not really a pony. So how's the horn treating you?"
"I kinda blew up the school I was in," admitted Silver, seeing little reason to lie with Discord involved.
His shaggy brows rose together, "Oh my my. I do hope no one was hurt?"
Celestia softly snorted, "We were just discussing that."
He sat down in mid-air, floating, "Well don't let me stop you! Wait..." He squinted at Silver, "I remember you! Tirek tossed you like an empty sack. I didn't recognize you before."
Silver cringed a little at the memory, "Yeah, thanks for that. You're feeling better now, after Twilight helped?"
Discord nodded before he frowned, "How did you know about that?"
Silver smiled, "I have my secrets, but don't sweat it. My magic's gone for that. Everything I could know has already happened. I won't tell C--" Silver found his lips had been sealed with a zipper. It was a very strange sensation. He conjured a silvery hand to undo it, but didn't try to speak again.
Celestia gave him a scathing look, "Control yourself, we have things to discuss." Discord zipped his own lips and went quiet, allowing Celestia to continue. She looked at Silver directly, "Your heart is a strange place, from what little I've heard Luna share. You desire great compassion and goodness, but carry depravity and violence seething beneath the surface. I want to believe the compassion is greater. You have been hurt by my ponies, and never sought revenge from them, but then you so quickly prepare a lethal defense to a very non-lethal attack. If you were truly a colt, it would be easier to forgive, but you are not."
Fast moved up beside Silver, "Stop beating him like that. He's sorry, he said so, and he means it. What's further telling him how much he messed up going to help?"
Luna directed a wing at Fast, "I agree. Silver has confessed wrongdoing, and moved to compensate. He will learn better control under my supervision. Love and tolerate, sister. Is that not your credo, or do we forget that the moment something dangerous appears?"
Celestia seemed displeased by Luna's words, "I will forgive you, assuming you speak for a pony you care for." She reached out a wing towards Silver, brushing the tips against his nose. He sneezed quickly. "You should have stayed a colt longer. You're cuter when you're innocent." She rose to her hooves, "Consider the matter closed, for now. I hope we never have to speak of it again."
Silver raised a hoof, "One thing. You'll want to bring Thetics up to speed on what I said about him. I doubt he'll mind that much being greeted as a hero and having me out of the school, but we don't want him disagreeing with what I said."
Celestia raised a brow, "Your ability to lie unabashedly is also concerning. I will see that the professor is spoken to. Good day." She departed quietly.
Discord flopped onto the cushion Celestia had been on, "Well, now that only the cool kids are left, let's play a game!"
Luna rose to her own hooves, "I too should return to my duties." And shortly she was gone.
Discord looked to the three ponies left, waggling his brows. Fast and Night looked nervous, but Silver approached, "Sure. What games do you like?"
As it turned out, Discord played a good hand of poker.
You know you've really highlighted one of Celestia's big problems when it comes to how she is often portrayed. She says that Luna is supposed to be her equal in the first episode yet it rarely actually feels like they are as it always seems to be Celestia in charge. Also with how she treats those she feels are threats it often seems like the reason they become threats is because of how she treats them. Many would take offense to being treated like she does Silver at times and it's no big surprise when they later 'prove' her right.
5762882 She is the biggest mother hen in the kingdom.
I am displeased.
Yes, the professor should be spoken to. But, he should also be "Spoken" to about his behaviour...He got burned? Bitch, please, he brought that on himself. I don't ask for him to be whippped. I ask for him to be disciplined and be made to understand where did he go wrong and make sure there are no repeated performance. It's what lead to this whole debacle in the first place.
Also...It seem like Silver is having some sort of Disorder...Like the one mentioned in the other story that I read about a character with Mary-Sue Alicorn curse (and no, it is not 'wonderful' but a true curse...everyone 'love' him because of that curse and also because of that, monsters from beyond start pouring in the world) after he was freed of that curse...He is being unhealthily forgiving even when he had his ear cut off, lynched by a few ponies leading to angry mob with torches, pitchforks, insults and injuries done to the EoH for standing up for him.
Shitz ain't normal, yo.
5763715 So he should actively pursue a jerk of a teacher instead of working on behalf of the entire kingdom? Of the two, one's kind of a bigger boogaloo to chase. As an adult, getting back at someone who yelled at him seems... petty... Sure, he held him still, but that was dwarfed by 'pulling the gun', and exploded when said gun was discharged into several ponies, teacher included. Forget that guy. He was a jerk, but that's all he was, a jerk. There are bigger things. Silver should have kept his cool and shown up the guy be being a good student, and maybe reported him for using magic on him without permission. If he had done that in the first place, a lot of drama could have been avoided.
But where would we be without drama?
I think this is one of the things that my older age than the average for this site creates a rift in perspective. Poor Silver shares my desire to seek the bigger answer and toss aside the lesser. Is it the best way? Probably not, but it's mine.
5763809 *Raised eyebrown*
Do you understand the word discipline?
5763821 Sure, but what do you yell at him for, and how. Be careful. If you yell at him for what he didn't do, officially, you could blow the whole story apart. He stopped a dangerously surging student, he did not bully one.
5763829 ???
And which part about showing him and make him understand what was wrong that he did mean then?
Yelling is counter productive...
5763715
I'm quite certain Celestia will have a interesting talk with Professor Thetics. Fun subjects of this talk may include what will happen to his teaching carrier, if he deviates from the governments 'official' story. Also, Celestia will undoubtedly let him know how disappointed she is in his behavior. On the other hand, Celestia will likely be a bit more subtle about it then the way I lay it out in my comment. No need to browbeat a half-dead pony in a burn ward too much.
As this story stays mostly focused of Silver, we will probably not see this talk in the story, but it will likely still happen off screen.
I do have one amusing thought related to this chapter. Will this new school wing have a ribbon cutting ceremony, when it is finished? If so, I imagine that both Professor Thetics and Silver would be kind of obligated to be there. I imagine such a event would be very awkward and possibly drama filled.
5763924 The best that could be done would be to watch him to see if he repeats with some other student and step in only at that time. His interactions with Silver, officially, were that of a hero. To act any otherwise would be foolish.
5763930 More Drama? Yes plz.
5763931 Private meeting perhaps...or subtle wordplay...But, meh...
Anyway...I constipate?...Uh...anticipate? Hhmmmm...whatever...him becoming a warlock...
Edit: It fascinated me...Another Warlock.
5763930 Interesting way of seeing it.
The staff throw themselves "in harm's way."
There are two spaces between "a" and "hoof."
Night Watch made an "almost-snarl."
5763989 Fixed! Only three? I'm amazed. What think ye?
5764013 To be perfectly honest, I'm a bit disappointed that Silver was able to wrap everything up so neatly. As it stands now, it really seems like he managed to fix all of the many problems that had been created, and that's a shame because problems are the source of conflict, which is the source of drama, which is entertainment. Now, just because it looks that way doesn't mean it is that way, but still...
That said, I honestly can't hold this against the story. Silver's actions were entirely plausible, and it's well-established that the ponies simply don't handle subtlety or dissembling very well, so it makes total sense that this would work. On a similar note, I will admit that I did feel a bit of psychic satisfaction at having Silver's wives hash things out with Luna. Fast, in particular, was great for her irreverence - "balls deep" indeed! It was nice to see the issue of Luna's hang-up about having feelings for a consort be brought into the open and put to rest, all without getting into issues of rearranging who is where in the herd.
I suppose the best way to summarize is that this felt like an ending, which was kind of sad, but it was a well-deserved one.
5764028 Huh, you bring up a point there. We could be reaching an end-of-story with Silver's booting from the school. Next chapter, The Silver Warlock?
5764036 It depends. On the one hoof, Silver is leaving his current locale, which was sort of what the current story is predicated on - however, he hasn't finished learning magic per se; he's just going into a different specialty than he planned, war magic rather than internal enhancement. He's still studying, just under Luna instead of some professors.
The biggest change is that this is rapidly going to shrink the tertiary cast members now. While he might still visit Rough and Trixie (who will likely have their own reactions to Silver's announcement), and Celestia might want to check in from time to time, it really seems like Silver has shrunk his circle to just his herd and Luna. Who would want to be around somepony that's so potentially dangerous? From now on, will he even have much reason to leave the palace? If he becomes a shut-in who doesn't interact with anypony, then the story might start to feel rather constrained.
5764052 What scares some, might attract others. He'll make new friends at the new locale too, non? I'll be doing my best to keep the story interesting, but it's just a matter of if this warrants a new story or nay.
ok I like the speech even if it was total B S but silver pulled his fat out of the fire so to speak but ware did he land him self at?
and Silver and Luna are out in the open now or more in the open I should say.
exultant work David Silver I will be watching to see ware this is all going.
Harts Fire.
P S I did not forget about the professor but after Silver speech he is in the free and clear.
5764055 Well, the others went through thirty-something chapters before changing the story, so there's a consistency issue to consider. But if you don't think much of that, then I suppose so. The major question is if this marks a large enough shift in Silver's life that it effectively closes the book on how things were before.
In all honesty, there's a strong case to be made that it does. After all, he's since lost Celine, gotten married to two other mares, formalized his relationship with Luna, and is now studying under her, rather than at the academy (which means he's now spending the vast majority of his time living in the palace, either in the "ambassadorial suite" with his wives or in Luna's boudoir, or wherever she's going to be teaching him). Maybe another chapter to wrap things up with here (how are Rough and Trixie holding up after all this?), and that might be the end of it.
Of course, there'll be continuing fallout from all of this, since no mop-up operation is perfect (and while the ponies might have bought his story, I wonder about other races, to say nothing of opportunists among other nations). Likewise, the injured ponies are likely to have strong feelings, leaving aside the suddenly-heroic Professor Thetics. And wasn't Silver supposed to have physical therapy with Meadow Leaper? (I wonder if Fast would want to join? Probably not, but it's worth thinking about.)
that (it's the start of a chapter, so we don't know who "they" is)
Silver can get pretty slimy when he needs to. He should go into politics full time.
5773149 Fixed, thankee.
Discord flopped onto the cushion Celestia had been on, "Well, now that only the cool kids are left, let's play a game!"
Sing and reenact this...
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7f-hQrLrrec
6316236 Discord is amazing.
6316274 I still say he is Text & this is rightly his fault in the first place, even if he thought he was helping one hapless human.
At least he knows it!
Seriously, he put on an amazing act. I guess it comes with being a game master. Weaving tales for the ones with tails.
Thetics getting off free and clear leaves a truly horrible taste in my mouth... almost enough to push me over the edge into disliking the story actually.
Hope something happens to him later.
8597582
Good stories should never have awful things happen in them.
The one who caused the problem gets away scot clean. Again.
And is rewarded, again.
The kidnappers are thanked.
The rapist gets away with almost rape.
The child abusers, for all we know, only has to say sorry. They probably don't have to mean it either.
The teacher who restrain a pony, and without dealing with the flame first gets a wing dedicated to himself.
While he should not have gathered a fireball, he had to do something! Now that dick-head teacher knows he can bully Silver with absolute impunity and Celestia will back him in doing so. For someone so experienced, her ideas and notions are pure shit and impressively stupid. I am starting to like Luna. Our Lunar Pegasus is cool enough. Fast... erm well she's exuberant, that's for sure. Silver needs to grow a spine. Right now he is a doormat of epic proportions and he will only be picked on more and more.
I can imagine it's hard to beat 4 jokers and a debit card.
I can't decide if I love this story or if I'm starting to hate it. So, well done triggering a response! In some ways it's actually nice that Silver finally deserves some of the shit flung at him for once. It's not all his fault, but it's the first time he is clearly in the wrong for one of the disasters. err, besides the whole Luna incident after Tirek I guess.
Professor Thetics is completely in the wrong and just generally outright scum. It's not unreasonable to knock Silver out once he starts summoning fireballs though. While being a bad idea to prevent Silver from keeping it contained, he would have no way to know Silver wouldn't just start flinging them everywhere either. Remember kids, don't conjure fireballs you don't intend to use!
Add a few other the other disasters to that list.
The entire ordeal at the start with the shape shifting.
Just about everything involving Luna from start to, well now.
Getting scolded for defending himself at school.
The problem is it's so damn logical and reasonable every time. There's always a reason for it, and they are good ones. Silvers response to each is reasonable too from a "minimum harm" or "greater good" perspective. They are almost all the choices I would want made in each case. In aggregate however, I don't know how there can possibly be any trust, love, or compassion left in him for any of them. It's a miracle Silver isn't a seething ball of hate by now, so good on him.
I hate it because it's all woven so well into the story to make it fit so well. So many stories just dump the bad garbage on the main character out of no where, but every one of these makes sense in context. no, wait, I take that back, Twilight's lazy attempt at fixing him seems a little off, but that's way back in the first one. Still, that's all good story telling, so I love it. Its just so frustrating too.