Little Sprout ropes Little Hitch and Little Sunny into an attempt to find his missing mommy. Little do the three little ponies suspect what this innocent adventure will lead to.
Sunny surprises Hitch with a proposal to go on a date. Hitch is extremely nervous because Sunny isn't just a friend, she's his childhood friend. Will the date go off without a hitch?
Hitch does a favor for Pipp to help her get famous recording the first ever sighting of a Manticore. Things do not go as planned, and Izzy is determined to figure out where it all went wrong.
While Sunny and her friend's are cleaning up the lighthouse, they come across several pages of fiction Sunny wrote as a filly. As they bond over the stories, Pipp realizes that Sunny might be onto something that could make her a star.
Hitch is curious why mayonnaise is taboo, especially now that the other words are not. There's only one pony he can turn to for answers, but can he really trust Izzy isn't embellishing the details? I mean, mayonnaise volcano is hyperbole... right?