At a tea party with all of her friends, Fluttershy returns from the kitchen to find her beloved Angel Bunny dead on the floor. "Okay! Who Killed Angel Bunny?"
Fluttershy has returned to Sweet Apple Acres a week after the events of "Bats!" in order to check in on her new animal friends, only to find they have disappeared from their sanctuary, and Applejack won't tell her.
Twilight takes the foals into Whitetail Woods for the annual Nightmare Night scare tradition. However things don't go as expected. Twilight comes back, scared out of her mind, and the foals are mentally broken. What happened?
Twilight has failed, or rather, she has succeeded. Her darkness is her power, and together with her husband, Queen Twilight has a new plan for all of Equis. War is brewing as the black castle rises, and hope is now but a happy memory.