Ever since Twilight started teaching Apple Bloom the art of potion making, Apple Bloom has been begging to try her hoof at a love potion. But with memories of a certain Hearts and Hooves Day still fresh in every pony's mind, Twilight is hesitant. She's decided to give Apple Bloom a chance to prove she's ready - by letting her mix other, less potent emotions she and the other Crusaders can sample.

This story takes place between the events of Twilight Time and Twilight's Kingdom.