(Sequel to Nightmares and Lunascapes)

Mageismoiras. Fate Magic. Twilight Sparkle has read the book given to her and has learned of "old magic". With that knowledge, she is now ready to bring Fluttershy back to life. But as events begin to happen in Ponyville, she is left to wonder if it is truly her friend that she raised.

Applejack and Rarity find comfort in Big Macintosh as they come to terms with the loss of their friend. Applejack, as a sibling, and Rarity, as his special somepony. As the events that Twilight Sparkle has brought upon the town occur, Rarity learns that somepony is not happy with her newfound love.

Discord, upon learning what Twilight Sparkle truly intended to do with the knowledge he gave her, finally decides that he must put a stop to the three princesses' actions at any cost.

This story coincides with the events in "The Return To Flatts".