"You want us to keep a journal?"
"That's right." Twilight reached under the crystal table and pulled out a set of six identical books that she then passed out to her gathered fiends. "I can see now what the problem was with my initial theory."
"It was wrong?" Rainbow Dash said through a smirk.
"It ignored very obvious contradictions?" Applejack added.
"You never came up with a catchy name for it?" was Pinkie's contribution.
Twilight gave them a level look. She loved her friends, dearly so, but stars above did they know exactly how to push her buttons. "The problem was that it wasn't broad enough. I tried to analyze each individual ability as a singular anomaly, when I really should have been looking at the event as a whole."
As always, the problem was tunnel-vision. She'd thought she'd found a reasonable (not to mention ground-breaking) solution early on, then tried to force the new data to fit it. Only the arrival of a complete workshop and all its tools had managed to finally convince her that her second Special Talent theory didn't cut the mustard.
Which brought her back to the drawing board. No more assumptions, no more wild conjecture. This time everything would stem from the three fundamentally true facts that she knew.
One. Starswirl created a spell for an unknown purpose, but could not complete it.
Two. She completed the spell by incorporating friendship which led to a wildly different result when cast.
Three. On an irregular basis, she and her friends compoundingly receive new abilities, objects, and tools.
Everything else had to stem from those facts. Logically, the next step was research.
"One of the fundamental truths of the scientific method," she said, "is that if you collect enough data, eventually a pattern will emerge. That's why I'd like to request everyone's help in recording as much data as possible."
"Sounds like a fine idea by me." Applejack rifled through the pages, letting them whisper past the edge of her hoof as a clever bit of spellwork added new pages when she got near the end. "What exactly should we write?"
An expected question, and one Twilight was ready for. "Anything and everything. Details of new abilities you get. How they interact with your existing ones. The weather and what activities you were doing when a new ability appeared. I'm happy if you just use it as a normal journal and write down your daily thoughts." She rather hoped they would, in fact. It'd be an excellent record to see if there were any subtle mental changes going on that they might not notice otherwise. "There's no such thing as too much data."
"You say that now," Dash said, idly tossing and catching her book. "But that's just ‘cause Pinkie and Rarity haven't filled theirs up with party plans and dress sketches."
"No worries here," Pinkie countered, "I have whole filing cabinets of party plans. This little book wouldn't even hold the ones I have for Fluttershy alone!"
"If you flip to the back," Twilight instructed, "You'll find a handy reference guide with a list of all the abilities we've documented so far along with a brief description of them. Please use the listed names for each power when writing about them so we don't mix up similar ones."
The sound of pages turning filled the air as they all flipped to the relevant pages, followed by a shout of surprise.
"My skill's supposed to be for making monster traps!?" Rainbow Dash exclaimed. "That's… actually kinda awesome. Why didn't anypony tell me? Wait, why did someone else know and I didn't?"
"You'll find the answer in my section." Rarity visibly preened in anticipation of oncoming praise. "Page vii, subsection two."
"Perk: Hoarder's Eyes," Pinkie Pie read aloud, "’The ability to manifest textboxes containing the name of any object along with a short description.’ Neato! What do I have?" She flipped a page. "Huh. MacGyver, Medaka, and Tool box. The last one makes sense, but what are those others? They sound like pastries from Fleece."
"We're not sure, but I think they're words in some foreign language that don't have an Equestrian equivalent," Twilight answered. "For some reason Rarity's identifying ability acts differently when trying to perceive other abilities."
Rarity nodded. "It's hard enough to pin them down as it is—like trying to focus on the shimmer of heat haze in the distance—and when I do the color of the text is different and some of the words are difficult to read."
"A Mushroom Kingdom..." Fluttershy mused quietly as she read her own entries. "That's why it's so big."
"In any case," Twilight continued, "I've enchanted the journals so whenever Rarity or I make an edit to the index, either to add a new listing or fill in more details as we discover them, the change should propagate into your copies as well."
"Cool. Yeah, sure, I'll make sure I write stuff in it or whatever." Rainbow Dash tossed her journal through the door that led back to her house. "More importantly: who wants to help me trap a monster?"
"That may be the plum stu—"
"I haven't the time for—"
"Hey, if no one's up for it, I'm sure the Crusaders would be more than willing."
Dash grinned.
Rarity and Applejack sent her dirty looks.
Dash grinned harder.
"...Consarnit Dash."
"Fine. But nothing more ferocious than a pukwudgie."
And with that, Dash should be much less jealous - she doesn't have an ability to make things that easily and safely break, she has a perk for building MONSTER TRAPS which allows her to reuse any materials from failed traps. That's like, 20% cooler.
Again, a great job on the dialogue, exchanges and future chapter set-up in this latest chapter. Love the logical alterations to the reasons for keeping journals as well as Twilight explaining some of the enchantments on the journals and Rainbow eventually realizing that her talent is meant for making monster traps. And definitely loved Applejack's reaction to Rainbow's invitation to go monster hunting and the suggestion that the Cutie Mark Crusaders could help her out. Who wants to bet that at least one of Rainbow's monster traps is going to end up catching a cheap crook using a disguise and special effects? Or that she ends up building ghost traps that are most effective after the ghosts have been weakened by blasts from multiple proton guns? Or that my imagination is just running away with me? Again?
Anyway, very certainly looking forward to more of this.
...and suddenly the Manticore population decreased!
Yaaay Rainbow found a way to appreciate her power! :D It’s a little odd that she didnt realize she now has knowledge on how to build monster traps in the first place, but eh. Should be fun to see what she makes! Also super handy that one of Rarity’s random abilities provides them with a little more information!
11311657
11311505
A slight clarification on Rainbow's terrible luck. She has a skill derived from and optimized for monster traps... but not any specific blueprints. At best, she can make bigger versions of the kind of traps she already uses in pranks (tripwires and snares, if my memory of canon serves) but nothing new beyond the scope of her own inventiveness.
But things might change later this week.
11311565
Nah, she wanted to make a trap to catch monsters, not to kill them. At the very least, it might encourage them to not get close to Ponyville in the future.