I’m guessing that the film with different pictures in each square is memories, the broken heart held together by band-aids is Cupid’s repair, and the heart with the devil inside is lust. I’m guessing these are Cutie Marks.

The other three images are, in my opinion, representative of ‘boosts’ that we/the MC can get.
The first obviously grants an increase in power, but of what type I am unsure of (be it political, economic, physical, mental, arcane, or otherwise).
The picture of the Changeling (I’m going to refer to it as such because of their being more suitable) has and the words ‘spy friend’ leads me to believe that we’ll/the MC’ll have a friend, ally or acquaintance who’s in possession of spy training and is thusly able to... creatively enter areas they otherwise wouldn’t be allowed into if selected. And may act as an impromptu, if most likely not-entirely-willing, assassin.
The Key and Skull image and the words ‘every key’ have me coming to the conclusion that a skeleton key (or something similar) will come into the MC’s possession. Note that ‘every’ can be stretched extremely far, to the point that it could include EVERYTHING! Meaning it could work like the Elder Scrolls artefact known as ‘The Skeleton Key’.

10131719
But which cute mark would go best with the other three?

10131719
Without them contradicting

What would any of you do?

So far a think the MC is less of a creature and more of a supernatural madness, it seems like most of are powers and goals will be the spread of this madness. That in mind I think the cupids repair and spy friend would be the most useful