• Member Since 24th Oct, 2017
  • offline last seen Aug 20th, 2020

Moonshade44


Comments ( 42 )

Wait, the hell's going on here? The original was removed? This was uploaded? And... from what looks like a different account?

8508958
Yea, sorry. It's something I decided to do after I started talking to family and some of my friends about my other works. I don't think they'd like to read this kind of story at all, so I made an account specifically for my NSFW works

8509161
That makes sense. No need to disturb your loved ones with this kind of stuff.

8509161
Though you could have just ask one of the site's modifiers to simply transfer the story into your new smut account so you didn't have to lose those likes, comments, and people who had it in there library. Just saying.

8509729
Oh, I actually didn't know they could do that

8509888
Well they can, they help me move a story that I was collaborating with an author who didn't feel like writing anymore to someone else.

Kix

8510871
Ok, did not know that

8523699
If you like it, you might want to check out my stories. This one is a collaboration between me and Moonshade / Kix, with her writing Ruby and a few other characters further down the line, and me writing Birgir (my OC) and Fiera (originally Aceofspades69's OC, used with his permission), and us working together on everything else.

The stories on my own account are done by me alone, but they and this one take place in the same FoE continuity (which is a bit different from non_creepy_nickname's FoE "canon" and more heavily relies what on Schorl Tourmaline established in her FoE stories - which you should check out as well if you haven't done already, by the way). From what we've planned right now, this story and my Freeville Chronicles will eventually intersect, with Eadgil from my story running into Birgir and Ruby when he visits Canterlot again.

Usually I get angry a lot at certain points of a Fall of Equestria story. Not so much here.
Wish there was more.

8616308
We're working on it. Unfortunately we have been busy with other projects, work and being sick

8616308

Usually I get angry a lot at certain points of a Fall of Equestria story. Not so much here.

Birgir's and Ruby's relationship pretty much starts as a broken one simply due to the overall situation, but at least they're trying to fix it, because they actually do care for each other. They just both have no idea how to actually accomplish that at this point. Birgir is more progressive than most caribou, but he's still a good bit more determined by his upbringing and cultural heritage than e.g. Baldr or Eadgil from my other FoE story, Freeville Chronicles, and that does make the situation more difficult - and Ruby's position doesn't give her much control over the situation (although I'm sure she'll try her best to use the little bit of influence she has), and it could be argued that she suffers from something similar to Stockholm syndrome. At the current point, the best thing they can do is try their best to not make it worse.

One thing that pisses me off to no end about many Fall of Equestria stories is that the characters aren't really characters. For example, take Vestri from Twipet's story Sun's Setting. What exactly is it that sets him apart from other caribou? The answer is: the only thing that sets him apart is the fact that he's the king's right-hand man, and that's not even a character trait. He shares the exact same views and habits as any other caribou and could essentially be replaced by anyone else with no difference to the story. He's little more than a cock on legs when it comes down to it. Now I'm not saying that all my characters are perfectly fleshed out and unique, e.g. Birgir and Eadgil from my other FoE story are arguably similar characters (Aceofspades69 has outright confused them with each other a few days ago), but I see this similarity as an unfortunate mistake that I'll eventually have to remedy at some point (particularly because these two characters will eventually run into each other). I at least try to write my characters in a way that sets them apart. You can't do that when you just take the stereotype of "the usual caribou", and then slap a name tag on him.

I'm not going to say much about Ruby here, since she's Moonshade's character.

8648605
Shit, I think I got drunk and started to rant again. :pinkiecrazy:

This is so cute and I love it, if only there were more foxes tho... (^.^) still great tho!

8824735
8824872
The next chapter is on the way. :twilightsmile:

That said, we don't really have plans to include foxes in this story. I know there are foxes in FoE (although only in Twipet's stories so far), but the concept is underdeveloped. To be honest, not sure about Moonshade44, but I don't really know what to do with them. If you want to participate in fleshing them out, you might take a look at the Fall of Equestria Redux group, particularly the Species thread and the Google Docs & FAQ thread. Hope to see you there. :twilightsmile:

Birgir has a good heart compared to the others, I like him, a caribou who dislikes the treatment of the mares, such stories are hust to rare. Poor Ruby though. Whenever I read A fall of Equestria story, I feel story for the fillies, given in some stories they are treated like mares, no child should suffer such a fate. Only few stories show fillies unharmed.

Sorry, had to get rid of the filly thought.

8894789
Lol, you do know Ruby is 18, so she isn't technically a filly

8894794
I should have been more specific, I meant I fell sorry for her worry about her family. The filly thing, I have just seen too many stories of Fall of Equestria where fillies are treated the same way as mares are and I care for kids in general. Thus it makes me feel sorry for the foals in this universe whenever I read those stories.

8894805
Uh-huh. In some stories, filies are not harmed until they are mares themselves. But, given how Birgir is, I imagine he wouldn’t tollerate seeing a filly getting raped by his fellow caribous.

8894794
Funny. So far, I imagined her being in her early Twenties. :pinkiecrazy: I guess 18 works though.

Birgir is in his late Twenties or early Thirties.

8894789
8894801
I am never going to have on-screen foalcon scenes in any of my stories, period. Being a former victim of child abuse myself, I don't think I could write that even if I wanted to (which I absolutely do not).

That said, I think at least some of the villains in FoE (like Ivangir for example) wouldn't shy away from touching a filly. Of course, Birgir is (mostly) a good guy, and thus doesn't condone that. I am going to address the long-term psychological consequences of fawn abuse in my other story, The Freeville Chronicles, though.

8894940
I see. You see, I care greatly for kids and I have seen Fall of Equestria stories where fillies are raped and humilated just as grown mares are. This breaks my heart as no child derserves something like this. Only a few stories show the Caribou, sparing them until they are 18. Thus, I’m happy to see authors like you showing not any Caribou supports this brutal treatment

8894964
Indeed. If one would harm any filly, or known foals like the CMC or Dinky, I would make this Caribou pay in a very hurtful way.

8652420

It's a good kind of rant. I admit, my comment was sort of... bland? Jaded? I don't know, was probably tired at the time, so I usually keep what I say limited then. But it did give me new insight, new things to think about. It's sort of difficult for me to pin down ideas and supporting evidence to back up my arguments and such, so my way of judging things is based off of paying attention to details, remember things I've seen/heard/read and use the wisdom from that stuff (which I have a complicated explanation for to try and help justify it) to form a general feeling about a particular argument, then forget the evidence soon after. :P
It's easier for me to retain feelings about something than it is to remember lots of details to support my argument, as those details come and go whenever they want, usually coming back to me shortly or long after I've tried to justify myself.

" He pauses again for a second. “Huh. That’s odd. I have no trouble forming Herrin in my mind, but as soon as I try to form the other variant, I feel a sudden rush of panic.” "

Foreshadowing.
This is some conspiracy shit right here.

8894968
It's ok. There's already a crossover of the Doomguy (2016) doing it.
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/340131/fall-of-equestria-bringer-of-doom
Que the BFG Division.

9088767
It's actually foreshadowing for my other story, Freeville Chronicles. :pinkiecrazy:

I Really like birgir's character, not being like the others, wanting to help the mares.

9247842
Well, only in the sense to make them happy in their new life, probably

9247949
Well, it's complicated. Yes, at this point in the story, that is probably his goal - but he also realizes that he doesn't really understand them. I think that's his one redeeming quality - his ability to understand that reality doesn't always adhere to his own preconceived notions.

9248030
But trying to help the mares, Making them Feel better, being Friendly, its a Good Thing.

9248036
When it comes down to it, it's a way of inducing Stockholm syndrome.

Login or register to comment