• Member Since 17th Jul, 2013
  • offline last seen Mar 21st, 2020

Next Gen Wonderbolt


hey

Sequels1

T

We are hated, disrespected, hunted, killed, banished.

We aren't respected as living beings.

So what are we gonna do? We're gonna fight for our lives.

We are changelings, and we deserve respect.

Chapters (2)
Comments ( 89 )

An interesting little fic. I always pictured Luna to be more sympathetic towards the predigest.

Yeah, I'm gonna be honest here, I've been on this site for some years and changeling angst stories really are a dime a dozen. The basic idea itself isn't flawed, but so many authors snap their shins by doing the same thing everyone else does which, while not entirely applying here, often goes as follows:

The changelings are routinely victimized and woobified to the point where they are discriminated or persecuted worse than most minority human counterparts (with changeling genocide often being used as a plot device to hammer it in), while the ponies are utterly vilified as a species of fascist, ignorant spoiled brats, where basically the worst aspects of humanity are focused into them (ironically, something a lot of people hate Conversion Bureau) with Celestia, Cadance and/or Shining Armor being the worst of them all. And more often than not, the main character is a JerkSue OC Changeling who leads the way of defeating/'showing the light' to the 'evil, corrupt and racist Equestrian government (more often than not the nobles, because after all, Nobles are ALWAYS evil) and constantly exonerates, along with the story, anything bad the changelings do because "they're just trying to survive" (even though there's no canon evidence they need love to survive, are starving, etc, but mostly just popular headcanon/fanon).

And in all honesty, this story really doesn't do anything different that two dozen other authors haven't already and to be fair, done better. I don't hate this story or you, but for a lack of a softer word, it feels trite. It's been done, ya know?

I know I'm likely coming off as way unnecessarily harsh on you, I don't mean to, trust me, it's nothing personal. But I've just never been a fan of Changeling Angst stories, at all. Not just because it's overdone, but because of how much it constantly relies of twisting canon to make it work, like any other 'Draco in Leather Pants story', especially the utter demonization of the pony characters we know and love. That's not to say I don't believe in the existence of perfectly good or neutral changelings (hell, a story I'm writing is about civilian changeling immigrants), but well, I think Starman Ghost, author of Body and Mind, put it better than I:

I think that for the most part it comes down to lazy writing: people want to write the changelings more sympathetically than "that race that's always evil," but they can't reconcile that with them attacking Equestria, so they go the opposite route and make Equestria the bad guys.

You can admit the changelings did a bad thing without leaping to "they're all evil and must die." It's kind of a central theme of the show.

Comment posted by Next Gen Wonderbolt deleted Apr 30th, 2014

4316817 I want the changelings to be respected as living, breathing, things. Not racial tolerance. I want them to have respect for their existence. People to respect their lives. They don't need to love them. Just to know they are living beings on the same level as they are.

4316817 I can also see how the story fits perfectly with the evidence provided, but the character is fighting for the respect of his people as they are. People. You shpuld respect life and living things for who they are. That was the focus of the story, not that changelings aren't evil and this one isn't saying that they aren't because his message can be interpreted as a threat. Luna was there because she had a better understanding of the situation. Respect Existence or Expect Resistance. He'll fight for his right to live. Not for love but for tolerance and respect of his existence and for him as a living thing. Plus I used twilight sparkle and not Celestia or Cadenve because, in my opinion, Twilight is more respected than most ponies.

4314874
I double your mustache and then devide it by two.
:moustache::moustache:

I suggest you make another few chapters out of this. It's truly a work of art and you can't expect me to finish reading here willingly.

At leased think it over of writing more to this. :twilightsheepish:

But for now I wish you very good day. :moustache:

4318338 there just might be an epilogue if the majority of people want it. I'll leave it up to you guys.

4317150
4317181

First off, thank you for replying and not getting angry. And while I understand where some of my criticism do not fit with what you were intending here, there are still some problems I have with it.

Okay, so the argument in the story is that changelings deserve the right to live and exist just like the ponies do. Fair enough and I'm totally behind that, but when you look at the show canon, there is nothing that suggests ponies do not respect the changelings' right to exist. In the show and comics, the changelings shown are the Queen and soldiers (not ordinary civilian changelings) and the conflicts between them were military invasions which the changelings themselves started and where they actively tried to invade and subjugate Equestria and the pony populace.

The fundamental problem I find is that how can the changelings ask to have their lives and existence as people respected by the ponies when they themselves were not at all willing to do the same for the them in the first place?

It's not to say they can't and shouldn't be respected as people, but respect is a two-way street and this story just seems to make it out that the ponies are the ones at fault here, ya know?

4318337
:yay::scootangel::yay:
:eeyup::moustache::eeyup: NOPE!
:eeyup::moustache::eeyup:
:yay::scootangel::yay: "Generic content"

the cake is a lie!

Yes, this is perfect, 10/10. Kinda feel there could be a further story here., but it works as it is.

4319334 Thank you! But there might be a little something something for everyone in just a bit. So keep watch for it!

~Xela

FUCK YEAH.
VIVA LA REVOLUTIONES.
(Sequel please)

i will be very very angry if this does not get another few chapters! this is such a great start only to end like that! keep it up! and i will be watching you to see if it will be made X3

4319534 As I have said before, an epilogue is on it's way. :twilightsmile:

Though I feel it may not be as good as I would hope. :unsuresweetie:

Oh God, this cliffhanger is worse than the last! :raritydespair:

4319772 :rainbowlaugh:

I'm sorry! :twilightblush:

To those you reading the OPTIONAL Epilogue, there's a good chance of a sequel.

A CHANCE, a good one but it's still a CHANCE.

..This epilogue....It teases us...


feed us...
Feed us!

FEED US!

PERFECT ENDING BUT I WANT A SEQUELLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ahem, amazing little story here. LOVED it.

-Con Arty

4319807 Fear not, for a sequel is bound to happen. :eeyup:

4319827

I will be watching.... :raritywink:

-Con Arty

It's great. I think I'm speaking for all of us when I say that we all want a sequel to this.

Awesome, but you need to make a sequel now.

4320228 Good. If you weren't planning on making a sequel, I would have been forced to take drastic measures. Do not ask what my drastic measures are, as I do not want to make you feel threatened (All I will say is I have a small group of hacker friends that owe me a few favors, not that I would use one of my favors on you. I am quite connected to people who can do things...).

4320253 Sorry, I have a bad habit of metaphorically 'flexing my muscles' to make a point... Don't be too off-put about it.

4320310 it's fine! I have a pretty good sense of humor. Which means I don't take a lot of things seriously.

4320318 I wasn't joking about the friends who owe me favors and stuff, but yeah, it takes a lot to actually get me to use my resources. I don't actually use them unless I absolutely must, but I can bluff people out with them. Like I said 'flexing my muscles'...

In short, when I put on my serious face, I mean business, but I generally am pretty laid-back.

4320349 You seem like someone who can fake being serious for a good laugh :) that's probably just my over friendliness talking now

4320353 I am only serious when I feel like I need to be. When I 'act serious' I generally mean it. When things get serious, I get scary serious.

Some guy crossed me once when things were serious(this whas back when I went through a whole foruming phase), he ended up ditching his account and leaving the site for good after I 'picturized' him.

This seems like its the intro to a really awesome story of marvelous proportions. We like, more.

are you sh@#$%$& me!? you end it like that?! oh hell no you better make more to his! i mean it ends on such a cliff hanger! not only that who was the stallion?! (shinning)
and yes pizel pony this is WORSE than the last one! XD seriously i am scared for him!

Well I wonder which side Celestia will take :pinkiecrazy:

yoU DI D TH E THI N G
PERF, 13749534174/10

Definitely do more man. This is pretty good, and I'd like to see where you take it.

Login or register to comment