Feb
15th
2016
Twilestia or Twiluna · 11:19pm Feb 15th, 2016
The problem with writing a fanfic with two ships that you support competing with each other is that it can be very hard to decide which ship actually gets to win. So instead of stalking the groups everypony has joined, I thought it would be nice for the fans of this story to calmly and kindly explain why they prefer one or the other. The ending will remain a surprise, but this way, it's easier for me to know what everypony wants plot line wise.
Thank you,
Forestpip
Comments are appreciated!
I'm not shier I could help because I'm fine with both it would depand on how you do celestia and luna. So I'm fine with earth celestia, luna or what I've seen in some fics both getting her.
3757161 Thanks for the feedback!
3757168 your welcome sorry I coudn't be much help
3757254 That's okay. Your opinion is just that, yours. I'd rather know what you think than not know. I don't want someone to feel in a strong way towards the ship I don't go with. I like making people happy with what I do
3757270 that is a good trite to have but at the same time don't do something that in the end makes you unhappy even if you like making others happy
3757371 That's what I was trying to do with this story. It seems like a pretty even balance between both making others and myself happy
I haven't started reading yet, but I think a good idea (though a bit on the dark side from what I've gathered) would be that neither of them would get to be with twilight, whether because she has her eye on somepony else, doesn't think of them that way, or whatever.
3757376 okay if you say so
3757386 Thanks for the input. I've thought this kind of an ending over, but I'm not sure whether or not I want to use it. I hope you get the chance to read the story! I'm growing really proud of it.
Yes.
Personally, I like luna and want luna to win because I'm biased that way. Regardless, I'll still read the story and see how it turns out and be heartbroken if need be. Or it could turn out like a three some. Who knows?
Luna ftw.
My instinctive response, since I can't really decide between them either, is that good sisters share with each other.
Ummmm...This is a tough one. But, I think I'll have to go with Celestia. Mainly because this is probably Tia's only chance at a relationship-she's the Untouchable Sun. Luna, on the other hand, is newly returned-she doesn't have that deeply ingrained God reputation the ponies have come to respect her-not worship her. She's mysterious. She's powerful. She's sexy. She's not the maternal figure everypony grew up under. That would be Celestia. Celestia, who has but one close companion, other than Luna. Twilight.
I guess it would also make sense to mention that no matter how much I've shipped it, I've always felt like Twiluna has...clashed, in a way. i don't really know how to explain it. I just think Twilestia has more of a...spark.
3763379 I was leaning towards that one myself. Thanks for your input!
3763533 No problem!
3781513 I wouldn't be opposed to that actually. Thanks for the suggestion! I hadn't thought of that.