Fearing that Nightmare Night will be cancelled, Pipsqueak heads off on an adventure to rescue the missing ponies. But when he finds a manor house in the middle of the Everfree forest with two rather strange ponies who live there, he bites off more than he can chew. Can Pip find the missing ponies and save his beloved Nightmare Night?

Something's amiss in Ponyville. The inhabitants start having vivd and terrifying nightmares that they all but forget about during the day. But it still leaves them shaken. Can they find the source of these nightmares and put an end to them before it's too late?