• Member Since 26th Sep, 2012
  • offline last seen Apr 22nd, 2014

Commodore64


I run a youtube channel and like to read MLP fanfics. I'm hoping on writing some and posting them to my youtube channel or interviewing some of the writers on the site for new videos

T
Source

Pinkie Pie and Rainbow Dash have been together for the past few months, but are reluctant to tell their friends about it.

Chapters (5)
Comments ( 26 )

um... i dunno what to think of this, really. :rainbowderp:
Fluttershy's little language slip really annoyed me though, it was WAY too out of character. :facehoof:

Well, Fluttershy felt kind of OOC, but I'll give you a thumb based on the D'awwww inducing Rainbowpie scene

1808075>>1808056
Well, first of; Thank You for giving me some actually constructive criticism. :pinkiehappy: I was really expected comments like "I fucking hate PinkieDash and I fucking hate this story". As for Fluttershy, this is my first fic, so I'm still getting used to writing these people (or ponies, I still need to get used to that too) as the characters everybody knows them as. Also, I've grown accustomed to the Kevin Smithian writing style of "little plot and lot's of talking", so putting breaks in Fluttershy's dialog felt kinda wrong for some reason. I do have an explanation for Fluttershy's more collective tone of speech planned in the next chapter, so look out for that. :moustache:

i could understand pinkie cursing :3 vinyl definitly but not fluttershy:trollestia:

I've got to say, you've got a decent setup, and a decent writing style, but, alas, like the others, my only real complain lies with Fluttershy. However, I totally get that you're a new writer, and still trying to capture how to write out the characters(I've been there, thought not yet in this fandom). I say, keep going, keep writing, and you can only get better. I'm looking forward to the next chapter.

Not bad. I feel like you've got Dash and Pinkie down pretty well, Macintosh okay from what little we saw (though saying he didn't like Fluttershy's animals much seems odd), but Fluttershy seemed somewhat OOC. I mean, I understand that she's a little more mellow, but it's still jarring to have her swearing. She's not just scared of lots of things, she's also shy, with low self-esteem. There is a difference.
Your Pinkie/Dash stuff, however, is nicely done.

know what im kind of tired with everyone making doctor and derpy a couple,gets kind of old after a while

2025542
I'm sorry, I couldn't help it :applecry:

2025548 its ok mate,its just derpdoctor is SOOOO overused

2026436
I've personally never seen DerpDoctor as a ship and I use it like the companions on the actual Doctor Who show, where Derpy likes the Doctor but he's too obsessed with his time-travel to notice or care. I've noticed that the Doctor is basically asexual over the past 5 years of watching the show.

And then they had to lock Tootsie Flute out of the room while watching the movie. (They being Lyra and Bon Bon)

I am totally ok with this, as long as we get rainbowpie and derpydoc adventures.
And their reactions just make it. just :rainbowhuh::twilightoops:

You forgot the G :

Vinyl's lasses fell straight off of her face, landing on the floor

Oh and great story btw ( i might not follow it thought since i know jack shit about doctor who.)

1808056

Fluttershy's little language slip ... out of character.

Mmm, I agree here. Typically best to adhere to canon characterization when doing a shipfic...
Other than that, made me smile. :twilightsmile:

EDIT: Started reading chapter two:

Fluttershy seemed so happy, so collected, so confident. She had stopped stuttering as much, and she had even starting swearing at a few points.

Ohhhhhh, okay. Makes more sense. :twilightsheepish:

2088021
Thanks for the edit. Although, don't be scared away, because I don't plan on adding any DW continuity that won't be explained in the story since Pinkie, Dash, Octavia, and Vinyl also know jack shit about Doctor Who.

2086353
RainbowPie, DerpyDoc, and VinylTavia adventures to be precise.

derpdoctor...biiiig surprise - _-
oh yeah and you said "We're not looking for the approval of ponyville,we're looking for the approval of Ponyville" did you mean equestria mate?

2130001

Well you didn't include the entire sentence. Yeah, excuse me for wanting to write Doctor Who because I'm a fan.

D'awww, that scene with Pinkie and Dash was heart meltingly adorable.

This is a good story and could be a great story, but you need an editor. Some of the sentences felt off.

"We could call it 'Pinkie and Dashie's Cupcake Factory'"

:ajsmug: I see what you did there

Pinkie began to laugh again "Alrighty then. Hey, that rhymed"

:rainbowlaugh: Ahh Pinkie, you and your 4th wall breaks.

AHAA!!

I KNEW SOMEPONY WAS WATCHING THEM!!


I felt it.

XDDD

Best ending EVER

10/10 Mustaches
:moustache::moustache::moustache::moustache::moustache::moustache::moustache::moustache::moustache::moustache:

"We could call it 'Pinkie and Dashie's Cupcake Factory'"

References.

Login or register to comment