Princess Cadance, or rather, just Cadance now, growled and huffed angrily as she watched Starlight and Twilight come into her room. She didn’t see why they had to do this today, why they had to do this at all. Actually, she did know. It was for Sombra, or, rather, as the stallion preferred, Alex, to embarrass her. Having those two come in to teach her about friendship. As if she were a foal and didn’t know anything. She knew about friendship, even if she had to admit that she hadn’t been acting very friendly lately. Not that many of them were acting friendly toward her.
The room they were in was the room she’d been staying in since that day, the one where all of her hard work went spiraling downward. It wasn’t a particularly awful room. In fact, most ponies would say it was quite lovely, with a nice, soft bed situated right next to the window overlooking the royal garden, and a large private bathroom attached to it. Coincidentally, perhaps intentionally, it was the room Alex was made to stay in during his first several days in the castle. However, Cadance continued to think of it as the prison she knew it was. She’d been locked in, the windows sealed shut and reinforced with magic, making escape impossible, her meals being sent to her by Luna herself to make sure that any opportunity she could have to try and leave was shut down. And although she was allowed to leave now to explore the castle, something Alex wasn't granted during his time staying there, it was still a prison, one that she was still staying in, even if Alex had told her she’d been pardoned.
Starlight, however, didn’t see it the way she did, quickly commenting on its niceness as she walked in, saying how she wished she had a room as nice as it in Twilight’s castle, earning her a glance from her alicorn counterpart that entered with her, and an eye roll along with a flick of her mane from Cadance herself.
“So what now?” she asked frustratedly. “Do we start with you two telling me I just need to forgive those ponies who’ve committed the same crimes as me and got away with it?”
“Well, let's not get into the politics of Equestria just yet,” Starlight laughed a bit nervously. “For now, let’s just focus on our first lesson: acceptance. It was my first lesson, and I’m sure it’ll be a great place for you to start, too.”
“Oh, I see. I’m supposed to accept all those things, accept that my husband- my now ex husband, has full custody over our daughter and accept that everypony in Equestria hates me now because of that little stunt those three decided to pull. I get it.”
“Uhhh… not quite that,” Starlight chuckled, getting more and more anxious. “Uh, um, Twilight, why don’t you start us off?”
“Oh, um, so, uhh…” Twilight trailed off nervously, feeling quite small in the face of her old foal sitter and friend. “Um… you should, um… I…”
Cadance sighed, her anger dissipating at seeing the mare who, in her eyes, was still a filly, saying to her, “Look, I get it. I already know what you’re going to say. You’re going to tell me that I need to accept that I messed up and try to move forward and mend fences, and then we’ll both pretend that I’m taking what you say to heart and changing when really, I won’t. I’m not going to accept this outcome, not that there’s anything I can do about it. You might as well just leave me alone and check off whatever checkboxes you're supposed to on the list I know you have.”
“I- I’m not- I didn’t-”
“It’s nothing personal to you, Twilight. I have absolutely nothing against you and don’t hold you responsible for anything. There are five ponies I blame for this, and I promise you’re not one of them, so don’t go thinking I hate you. It’s just that I know I won’t be changing my mind about any of this because I know I’m in the right. I know I’m being mistreated, and you won’t be able to change my mind.”
“I… I’m… I guess we’ll just go and try again later... if you... really feel like that...”
Cadance could see the sadness in Twilight’s eyes and truly felt bad. She could honestly say she didn’t mean to have Twilight feeling bad if she could help it. However, she knew that was just how things went. She was not going to change her mind no matter how many friendship lessons she was given, and that was a fact. Her former sister-in-law might as well have done something else instead of wasting her time. Even as much as she hated seeing the expression on her face, she figured it was better than sitting through whatever they had planned.
Starlight could see the same look on Twilight's face and hurriedly stepped in front of her before she could say anything else.
“What Twilight means is that we’ll go and try this lesson again later,” Starlight quickly announced. “I mean, what are we thinking, diving into all the icky stuff when we don’t even know each other?” With that, she held out her hoof and smiled widely, saying, “Hi, my name is Starlight Glimmer, and I’m a pony from Sire’s Hollow who’s studying friendship under Twilight Sparkle. What’s your name?”
Cadance let out a sigh at that and grumbled under her breath, rolling her eyes. This was going to be a long night.
The next two or three hours were spent with the three of them introducing themselves to each other, with Cadance trying her best to not doze off as Starlight seemingly talked on end. It was mostly her explaining her history and what she’d done while Cadance sat bored as she stared at her expressionlessly, occasionally commenting a simple ‘wow’ or an ‘I didn’t know that' every so often. Apparently, she’d been up to no good at one point, which the pink alicorn didn’t know about, although she largely lost the details as she sat thinking about how irritating and humiliating all of this was.
“Oh wow, look at the time,” Starlight said as she looked at the lone clock in the former princess’s room, finally finished telling her life's story. “We’ve been at this for quite a while. I hope I haven’t chatted you to death. Twilight and I will be back tomorrow for your next lesson. Might as well get the first few in a row off to get the train rolling, as they say!”
“I can’t wait,” the pink pony commented sarcastically, adding, “although I was wondering if I could talk to my sister alone?”
“Oh! Uh, sure!” Twilight got out, surprised by her request. “I mean, if that’s okay with you, Starlight.”
“I don’t have an issue with it,” Starlight responded. “I’ll just let you two be and head back to our room.”
“I’ll see you in a few minutes then,” Twilight smiled as she left, closing the door behind her. Cadance waited a few seconds to make sure she was completely gone before she started to speak again.
“Twilight, you know I’m sorry right?” she started after a few moments, catching her by surprise. “You know I really mean it when I say I have nothing against you, and still think of you as my friend, right?”
“Huh? Oh, yeah, of course! And I still think of you as my friend, too!”
“Then you’ll trust me when I say that this isn’t all my fault?”
“...what? Why are you-”
“I know what you're going to say, and yes, I do take responsibility and admit that part of it is my fault, but I’m not guilty like they say. They’re not treating me right.”
“Cadance, you know I can’t-”
“I know you can’t say I’m not or do anything about it, but you believe me, right Twilight?” She stared the purple mare in the eyes, and didn’t like the sad, disbelieving look she got back from her.
“How long have you known me, Twilight?” she asked desperately. “When have I ever done anything openly malicious? I’m not like that, and you know that. I’m not the evil mastermind they’re making me out to be."
“Nopony said you were evil-” Twilight tried to say before she was interrupted
“Yes, I went along with what he said, and yes, I was angry at Celestia for what she did to me, but I’m not how you’re all making me out to be. That was him, too. That was his plan, to set himself up to be ruler. I should’ve seen it beforehoof, but I didn’t, and now everypony hates me because of him. That whole trial was a stunt to deflect blame to me. You have to know that, right, Twilight?”
Twilight sighed sadly, not wanting to tell her sister, her now ex-sister, what she needed to hear.
“Cadance…” she trailed off, looking at her hooves for a moment before looking back up to her. “You know I can’t believe you right?”
“What?” she asked back with genuine confusion, as though Twilight were speaking to somepony else.
“You- you lied to me and hurt my brother. You have to know that I can’t trust what you’re telling me. And even if I could, what can I do? What’s done is done. There’s not…”
“Oh…” Cadance trailed off, not expecting that reaction from her. “Well… I guess you hate me, too.”
“That’s not true!” Twilight said defensively. “You’re still one of my best friends! But… I just… I want to help you get better, which is why I volunteered to help you with friendship. Alex was going to have Fluttershy help you with Starlight instead of me, but I volunteered because I care about you.”
“Yeah, well, as I said, I know I’m in the right, so I’m not going to change my mind. You’ll just be wasting your time.”
“I still want to try and help you. I believe in you, and know you can move past this. Besides, I know that everypony doesn’t hate you, even if it seems like that right now. Remember, Starlight was in the exact same position as you before, maybe even worse, and look at her now! She’s one of my best friends, too, and helping out students in my School of Friendship!”
“Whatever,” Cadance sighed as she turned away. “You can go now. If you see Flurry Heart, tell her mommy loves her very much despite whatever Shining Armor is saying about me to her.”
Twilight moved up to wrap her wing around her old foal sitter in a hug, telling her, “I believe in you Cadance. I know you can get better if you try, and before long, this will all be ancient history.”
Dear Cadenza, stop being a Karen.
10731869
Signed- Everypony!
Its sad but Cadence is right.....
its a matter of perspective. To victors goes the spoils and winner writes the history and basically the Sombra and her scheme is 2 sides of the same coin. Just Sombras side was up and Cadences ended up at bottom as a pawn to further Sombras hold on Equestria.
Also at this point can Cadence as she realises that she basically lost all her cards ask for asylum in Prance lets say? I mean she can ask for banishemnt or exile from equestria and ask for citizenship in Prance. It would be a new start and its not like Flurry wouldnt be able to visit her on vacations as she gets older. Who knows maybe Cadence could make something there to fullfill what she has lost.
The best revenge is to live happily and fullfilled to spite the ones who try to put u down
oh neat you're going for a more realistic sociopath depiction
10732078
no, Cadance is a blame shifting sociopath who took advantage of a vulnerable and hurt pony to get her way.
Sombra is a victim in this story. Plus, we LITERALLY can read sombras thoughts and EVEN THE ORIGINAL sombra didnt want to take over equestria. Cadance is textbook sociopath
10721793
10722891
10732078
The first two are just me listing her crimes that she committed in her attempt to take the throne. The third is me responding to you. She's wrong, plain and simple. She can try to say she doesn't deserve anything happening to her, that she's being mistreated, but she's wrong. Alex wasn't exactly a factor ever, she and Sombra intended for what was basically a magic A.I that would cease to exist when their plan reached a certain point, but he either was a human before he was kidnapped by Sombra, or he quickly gained full self awareness and is indistinguishable from a pony. Alex never conspired with her or Sombra.
Other villains have received harsher punishments for significantly less:
NMM tried to usurp the throne and bring eternal night, the second one isn't actually said to be a crime, got 1,000 years in a location she would've died almost instantly on.
Discord was basically just harassing and vandalizing property, got 1,000 years in a cell so small he couldn't even blink.
Chrysalis and her changelings kidnapped and impersonated others to drain love until the wedding offered a feast. Banished at high speeds out of the nation. Later turned to stone for other crimes.
Sombra stoned and shattered Amore, which given the circumstances, you could say was an act of self defense before enslaving the Empire to free the Umbrum. The first one could be called use of excessive force as she couldn't defend herself then though. The Celestia and Luna invaded the Empire to avenge a tyrant (to Sombra at least) and free it's citizens that were legally his at that point. Self inflicted or not, he and the Empire were banished for 1,000 years.
Tirek drained magic, again, never stated as an actual crime. 1,000 years in Tartarus.
Cozy Glow, imprisoned in Tartarus, then turned to stone later for similar crimes to a few of the others, but should've received some form of protection because of her age.
You know one thing all of them have in common? None of them received a trial. Cadence committed even worse crimes for reasons just as poor, or less justified than the others, but she got a trial, and was pardoned with a few conditions. Consequences be damned, I would've executed her just for what she tried to do to Shining. How do you justify putting your spouse, the parent of your child, in a position you planned for them to die in, and say you love them? If there is a God and there are nine circles in Hell, I could guarantee you she would go to the lowest level, reserved for traitors.
10732013
Everyone. Everything in existence signed that letter.
I think the reason Celestia chose Twilight is that she had picked up that Cadences personal development had plateaued. Meanwhile Twilight had continued to grow and mature over time, while she still has a long way to go she’s making progress. Potentially more then Cadence ever could have achieved, and for a simple reason. While Twilight had more advantages then most ponies, she didn’t ever feel entitled to them. Cadence on the other hand let the advantages spoil her rotten, now for the first time things aren’t going her way and she mentally can’t handle it.
It’s very likely she’s going to continue butting heads with reality because her whole life Celestia inadvertently enabled her behavior. It wouldn’t surprise me if the Crystal Empire was just something Celestia hoped would placate her. Considering how she has no qualms with playing with ponies lives. Who cares if some backwater city state gets an incapable ruler. As long as it keeps her family happy that’s all that matters.
Reading this story I can’t help but compare it too the “All American Girl” series, where Celestia’s obsession with having a family causes harm to those around her. The best example would be her pushing the main character “Daisy Jo” to reconcile with her racist, elitist, and delusional mother Rarity. Ignoring the physiological harm it’s doing to her, her husband, and potentially her kids, nevermind the rest of the elements caught in the cross fire as it draws public attention. In this story, Celestia ignored Cadences condition likely because of her obsession with maintaining her “alicorn” family much the same way. Now Equestria as a whole has to deal with the fallout, while Twilight try’s to save some scrap of the image she had of Cadence before all this.
Like I said, Twilight's friendship lessons are going to go nowhere, simply because Cadance doesn't want or see the need to reform. All they're doing is giving her opportunities to gaslight Twilight onto her side.
10732446
I’m kind of getting the feeling Twilight is coming to terms with the fact that Cadence may have never been who she thought she was. I am actually hoping that in later chapters she’ll start looking back at her memories without the rose-colored glasses. She’s learning a bitter lesson, but it will help her grow and mature.
10732315
that's the worst part about sociopaths. They legitimately do not understand (or often care) about the consequences of their actions and just what they've done to others.
Their own twisted internal moral code is literally the only one that matters to them and since she didnt GET AWAY with anything or INTEND anything too awful she thinks she's A-ok morally. and she can justify her treatment of sombra because he's bad, shining was going to stop what was hers by right, etc.
She cares about others, but only in the sense of their benefit to her or how they make her feel.
Shining, twilight, celestia, none are their own person to her but accessories to her own life
Damn Cadance really doesn't understand what she did. She should be happy that Alex showed mercy
Maybe, maybe, maybe...
Great to hear! Enjoy Tartarus, glad this first lesson could be your last!
10732305
10732315
I also stick to my opinion on Cadance not being a victim for obvious reasons. Anyone who's still in denial can read what's right there in the finale of I Am Not Sombra and see how it directly contradicts what Cadance is telling Twilight here.
This chapter:
I Am Not Sombra finale:
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/462778/32/i-am-not-sombra/8-4-the-lie-i-wish-it-was
(entire conversation is right there as proof I am taking nothing out of context)
Sombra was Cadance's subordinate, she was using him to take over Equestria for herself. This is precisely why the "But Sombra is a villain too!" argument falls flat on its flank, besides him saying directly in his thoughts that he was not interested in conquering Equestria, as already pointed out. I see any more "Cadance is a victim!" style arguments, I am directing them straight to this comment and what other people have argued better than I.
10737854
it shocks and disappoints me how people are still defending her despite her being characterized as rigidly textbook sociopath.
More textbook than real life people, to be honest.
and she still has potential for redemption because studies have shown sociopaths can LEARN empathy,
To be clear, she'll never be a kind or loving person and whatnot, but she CAN LEARN TO BE BETTER TO COEXIST WITH OTHERS AND ESTABLISH MEANINGFUL CONNECTIONS.
maybe magical healing? Because right now our limitations are just understanding of the brain, but if magic can perform surgery on an extremely minute level or just alter the psyche, thats even more chance to be redeemed
10737931
People who sympathize with sociopaths very often get taken advantage of by sociopaths. Truly hope people are only defending this story's Cadance because they haven't yet divorced her from the show's Cadance.
Physical copies? What would the covers look like?
10755012
pbs.twimg.com/media/Ex7BAYQWEAA4C-9?format=jpg&name=4096x4096 Like this
Not mere hours and she's back to trying to manipulate ponies. So sad...
10773207
https://m.Evil Woman (Electric Light Orchestra)
Yeah, you're right... (Don't know where that https.m came from.)