Princess Celestia rested on her haunches, clearly filled with misgivings. Her forelegs were wrapped tightly around Sunny Day, holding the mare to her chest as a foal might a favored plush toy.
“Though what I’m about to tell you occurred over 1,000 years ago, I remember it as if it were yesterday. The memory is imprinted on me so strongly it often comes during my lowest hours. When you were gone, Luna, I lived it over and over.”
Princess Luna, who was still bristling, began to settle. The hairs on her coat started to flatten after the unexpected revelation that her sister was keeping secrets. That was the very same mistake that she’d been admonished for, after all.
“When Solara and Nocturna had agreed to an alicorn summit, it was meant to be a place to discuss the tensions of the time. The rules were simple: neither House was to bring soldiers and King Sombra would host the gathering on what was relatively neutral ground.
“The Unicorn Temple of the Crystal Empire was the largest and most secluded of all, so it seemed to be a good location. One that would be away from the influences of the nobility and other important worldly ponies.”
With a light lift of my hoof, I asked, “Forgive my interruption, but who decided on that location?”
“Ultimately, Nocturna and Solara made the decision after speaking to a few trusted ponies. Archon Eira was the one that offered her temple.”
Archon Eira. I knew more than my fair share about the Unicorn Temple and an archon was a powerful pony. They answered only to the exarch and each ran their own temple. There was little doubt in my mind the Eira was the pony from the vision.
The plot was starting to come together. Who better to ambush and take alicorns by surprise than the ponies that looked to them as deities? It would be unthinkable. What sent shivers down my spine, however, was wondering what sort of creature could convince those very ponies to kill the alicorns.
Princess Celestia pushed on, “I honestly do not know why ponies were so up in arms. Disharmony was everywhere. The fact that we were nearing a civil war made no sense. Nopony could point out a cause or incident to spark such a rift. There was simply no reason for it and yet there we were, meeting on how to calm everypony down and set things right.”
Nimbus Knight had expressed similar thoughts. Ponies couldn’t remember why there was such aggression between the houses? That made no sense. I remembered why we had gone to war with the Sudramoar. How could everypony exist in a state of anger without reason?
Princess Celestia shrugged almost as if she could read my mind. “Yet, it doesn’t matter how or why. What matters is that we went. All of us. Luna had just recently arrived, as there had been a gap between her death and her new life. I was told that was normal.”
The princess’s horn illuminated with pure golden light and a small oval appeared on the wall. Images jumped to life within it, flying by faster than I could perceive until, all at once, they stopped on a small, dark blue alicorn foal. Little Luna.
“You were so small, and seeing you somehow reawakened the memories of our past lives that were buried deep within me. Not all of them, but enough to know you had been my sister and how much we’d loved one another.”
“I felt that, too… instantly…” Princess Luna whispered.
Princess Celestia turned to look at the images, and they started to move forwards. In each, Luna was growing ever so slightly with the passing time period, however long that was. She had arrived, as Princess Celestia said, with her cutie mark and was clearly manipulating toys with her magic.
“Alicorns mature very swiftly and can grow through our entire existence. I pale in comparison to Nocturna even now, and I have lived far longer than she ever did. She was able to practice magic more than I since the perpetual burden of ruling the kingdom did not fall on her shoulders, nor was she robbed of her mentor.”
Sunny looked up at the princess. “I’m sorry to stomp on such a cute memory of your sister, but I don’t fully understand how this relates to what happened at the summit.”
“Ah, but you see, it does. Very much so. Nocturna deemed Luna and I too young to attend and had made it clear she wanted us to remain home. I begged to go. I huffed, I puffed, I stomped, and I threw a fit before Solara and Lumina. So… they relented.”
Mentally, I was taking as many notes as I could. Nocturna had tried to keep the princesses… well, the Students, away. Was that a coincidence?
“When she found out, Nocturna was far less than thrilled. She stated Luna was too small to be left alone in Midnight’s Peak without my supervision so, as a compromise, I was given the task of foalsitting during the summit.”
My nose wrinkled. “Foalsitting Luna? I mean… forgive me, but was she really a foal or just an adult in a tiny body?”
Princess Luna snorted and lightly set a hoof on my head. “It is neither, Silent Knight… and both.”
Princess Celestia nodded. “Agreed. We existed in an awkward state. Our bodies were those of foals while our minds were developing quickly. What differs so greatly from other ponies is that we would receive flashes of who we’d been in our mortal lives and thus recall the skills we had mastered in them.
“Despite those facts, no, Luna could not have been left alone. She was still mastering her ability to feed herself successfully.”
"That is not how I remember it," Princess Luna said, a hint of embarrassment creeping into her voice.
The projection on the wall shifted to a moving image of tiny Luna levitating a spoon around wildly as she tried to get some sort of goo into her mouth. Out of respect and the knowledge that she’d seen several of my foal pictures, I buried the laugh deep inside me.
“Moving on…” Princess Luna sighed.
“To get my way, I agreed to foalsit provided that, during Luna’s naps and playtimes when she could be watched by our servants, I’d be able to attend some of the meeting. And, when the day of the summit came, that is what we did.
“In the main meeting hall of the temple, we gathered together to discuss the state of the kingdom and our houses. I didn’t think about it much at the time, but when we arrived, Nocturna levitated a saddlebag onto my back with instructions for me to hold but keep out of it. I just assumed it was her subtle way of expressing her displeasure for disobeying her wishes.”
“Was she prone to that?” I asked.
“Oh, yes. Lady Nocturna rarely came out and said exactly what she meant. Her punishments, guidance, and corrections were even more subtle. Not that I had much time with her. Solara was far warmer and sweeter.”
The princess hugged Sunny tighter, as if she was remembering some fond moment.
“The meeting started and it was almost immediately chaos. Lumina and Azuleka just couldn’t understand what was going on or why things were the way they were. Both claimed complete innocence and started grasping for reasons. As I said, nopony understood why we were where we were.
“Nocturna and Solara sat quietly and listened. As the Mentors, that was their place, after all. They’d given up their sovereignty many years prior. What was odd was that both of them seemed distant. Not aloof, but almost as if they weren’t listening. Even when Moonglaive and Dawnbreak got into it, they stood by the wayside.”
“Wait, Princess… I thought soldiers weren’t allowed,” I put in.
“Oh, Moonglaive and Dawnbreak weren’t strictly soldiers. They were representatives of their mistresses. Every alicorn tends to have a pony they’re close to. Luna has you, I have Sunny, Nocturna had Moonglaive, Solara had Dawnbreak, and so on.”
“Wait, how come I’m just your guard captain and not an official representative like they were?” Sunny asked.
“Do you want to be a representative?” I asked.
The mare’s nose scrunched up and she huffed, “No.”
I nodded. “There you go, sunshine. Princess, please go on. Some of us actually do understand the gravity of this and the weight on your shoulders.”
Sunny stuck her tongue out at me but set her hoof over the white pair that was holding onto her so tightly.
Princess Celestia breathed in before she continued, “It was during their heated disagreements that it happened. There was no warning, no monologue or explanation, just the flashes of magic as Archon Eira and her priestesses burst in through the main doors.
“Our reaction was swift, but for some reason, magic seemed difficult to achieve. The others struggled to throw up their defensive spells and the unicorns attending with us were powerless. I managed to shield myself without much trouble but fear got to me. I didn’t know what to do.”
Princess Celestia squeezed Sunny tightly, her gaze going distant. “That is when the killing started. First the loyal ponies like Moonglaive and Dawnbreak. They went bravely. Moonglaive had managed to kill two of the attackers. Dawnbreak managed one. It was not enough, though.
“With our attendants gone, it became a battle of wills. The priestesses worked together to focus their power while my companions struggled to understand what was draining their power. Azuleka and Lumina were slain before my eyes as I cowered.”
Tears flowed down the princess’s cheek as she sobbed, “I did nothing to save them! Dark spells, twisted by evil magic, slammed into them over and over and I couldn’t even extend my shield to them… not because of some charm, but because I was afraid.”
“In all of the violence, I saw Solara and Nocturna working together to fight back as best they could. Solara’s shields prevailed while Nocturna came to me. She grabbed me by the hoof and pulled me to one of the small side doors. Save Luna and yourself or all is lost, she said to me before pushing me out and slamming the door.”
Luna leaned forwards. “You… didn’t actually see Solara and Nocturna…” she trailed.
“No. I’d seen enough bloodshed and I was afraid. I galloped as fast as I could towards where you were, but there were priestesses also going that direction. They tried to kill me with horrible spells. Sickening green lightning and fire. I—” The princess stopped and buried her face into Sunny’s mane. “I killed them all, I had no choice! My magic worked, and that seemed to surprise them. They underestimated me.”
Whatever ill will Princess Luna had been feeling melted away to pity and concern. “And then you came to me. I remember. You swept me into your hooves and we teleported away.”
Princess Celestia shook her head. “No.”
“Yes… I remember. You crashed through the door, took me into your hooves, and then we were outside the city. You teleported us far away. So far we were in the snow and the city was not visible.”
"No..." Celestia whispered.
Sunny’s ears shot up and she gasped. “Wait… no… you couldn’t have.”
“Yes, I could,” the princess whispered.
Whatever it was they’d figured out I wasn’t catching on to. “I don’t understand.”
Princess Luna stood to her full height. “Am I to believe that we remained put and that is when the city was sent away?”
“Yes. I was so terrified. I knew I needed to teleport us as far away as possible, so I poured magic into the spell. Something went wrong. Instead of teleporting us away, I sent the entire city to… I don’t know where. It was just gone.”
Sunny tilted her head back and met Princess Celestia’s forehead with her own. “It wasn’t your fault.”
“I doomed thousands of ponies to some form of stasis. At least I know that now. At the time, I thought I’d destroyed the city and everypony in it. It crushed me. Were it not for Star Swirl and my need to protect Luna, I don’t know what I’d have done.”
My wings flicked. What a horrific burden. The room fell silent under the weight of the revelation. It was unlikely Princess Celestia had shared this with anypony in hundreds of years, and who could blame her?
“Why keep this pain to yourself?” Luna whispered.
“What was I to say? Oh, little sister, I killed thousands of ponies in a blink. Neither I nor Star Swirl have any clue how to restore them. There was nothing to be done but attempt to put it behind me and try not to think about it.”
"And thus you drew within yourself,” Luna replied as she went to hug her sister, squishing Sunny in between them. "This was too great a burden for one pony.”
This wasn’t the revelation I was expecting, not in the least. The secrets I’d been after might not be here, but I couldn’t stop yet simply due to the tears. I cleared my throat softly. “Princess Celestia… who is Maristella?”
The princess set her chin on Princess Luna’s shoulder. “I truly do not know that name, Silent Knight. It holds no meaning. Nor does the Forgotten Winter. I am sorry, I really am. That once again I can’t help and that I’ve lied for so long.”
“That’s okay,” Sunny whispered, squeezing her way out from between the alicorns. “We’ll figure it out. Silent Knight is really good at this sort of thing, right?”
I normally was when it came to standard operations. This was entirely different. Fighting an ancient enemy that was deeply involved in magic. I didn’t have a lot of intelligence to go on and our enemy clearly knew a great deal about us.
None of that mattered. Royal guards do not give up, nor are they afraid of a challenge. This was my mission and I’d complete it or die trying. “Yes. Yes, of course. We’ll put an end to this for good. I do have another question, though, Princess.”
“Yes?” she answered.
“Why aren’t there any more alicorns? From what I’ve learned, ponies are picked. Why haven’t you picked any? To ease the burdens?”
Princess Celestia sat up and exchanged a look with Princess Luna.
“No more secrets, Sister,” Luna replied.
“Very well. I am sorry for the burden you’re about to receive, little ponies. The truth is that we… that is to say, Luna and I… never learned how that is done. There can be no new alicorns.”
“WHAT!” Sunny shouted loud enough that I knew everypony in the palace had heard her and I didn’t blame her. What she had yelled, I’d repeated in my head. My stomach dropped.
The princess hurriedly looped a hoof over Sunny’s mouth. “Be silent, Sunny. Do you realize what would happen if ponies knew this?”
Sunny flailed a bit to get the hoof off her mouth. “Celestia! I should have known this! I’m your guard commander. What happens if you two are killed? Wait, will you die? Do you die of old age?”
Princess Luna softly replied, “We don’t know.”
“You don’t know!” Sunny gasped.
“We don’t know,” Princess Celestia repeated.
They didn’t know. These were the last two alicorns and they didn’t know. If they died, who would raise the sun and moon? Who would lead the kingdom? Alicorn magic was far beyond that of the unicorns. There was no comparison.
My heart started beating faster and my thoughts raced as I tried to figure out a plan. What would we do? What could we do? There had never been a great deal of danger for the princesses. At least not prior to the assassination attempt in Nordanver. This was entirely different. A threat that could not be denied and an outcome that could not be measured.
“We should increase your security,” I said softly. That was something we could do.
Sunny nodded. “Yes. More house guards. Better house guards… heavily armed house guards. We’ll close the gates, secure the doors, and move everypony to administration offices.”
Princess Celestia shook her head. “No. We will not be walled off from our subjects.”
Without regard to rank, Sunny poked the alicorn in the chest. “That is my decision to make, not yours. Your safety is my responsibility and it is one of the few things in life I take serious.”
The princess set her hoof on Sunny’s cheek and smiled. “And I appreciate that, but no. The security we have now is sufficient. After all, if these ponies can manipulate others, what is to stop them from manipulating our guards?”
Sunny’s jaw dropped. She sputtered, “I—they—no—we…”
“Need to assume we’re susceptible,” I said, forcing confidence into my voice. “At least until I can undergo Nimbus Knight’s training and hopefully start to teach it. The fewer ponies we have, the easier we can keep an eye on them.”
Princess Luna nodded. “Yes, this is a wise course of action. We still must learn who our enemy is. But how do we do that?”
I shook my head. “We go over all of the intelligence we have and see if we’re missing anything. We’re going to need more ponies on this. Ponies we can trust. I want to bring Brigadier Armor in on this, plus the ponies waiting outside.”
“Very well,” Princess Luna said.
Sunny squirmed. “What do we do in the meantime?”
“Act as if nothing is wrong,” Princess Celestia put in. “I believe Silent Knight would say, if we show our cards, the enemy will be aware that we know of them. We’re better served with that advantage remaining ours.”
“Well said, Princess. That is exactly right. We’ll need to keep this to as few ponies as we can. Otherwise, we go about life as normal while we quietly prepare.”
“I don’t know if I can do that after knowing all of this!” Sunny groused, throwing her hooves in the air.
Princess Celestia wrapped a foreleg around the mare and tugged her in. “Oh, hush. You will, and you’ll do it without telling Azurite and Soarin.”
“I can’t tell my mates?!”
“If you tell Azurite, everypony in Equestria will know,” I said flatly.
Sunny’s ears wilted. “This is going to be hard.”
I nodded and turned to go open the door. We would need the others to assist us. This was not a secret to keep from Midnight Snow. Perhaps if I showed her this trust, she would be on our side.
When I reached for the door, I paused as a thought crossed my mind. I turned back. “Princess Celestia, what was in the saddlebag?”
She looked up from where she was consoling Sunny. “Of all things… all six Elements of Harmony.”
“The other alicorns gave them to Nocturna to hold during the summit, and she just casually gave them to you?” I asked, my startled disbelief plain in my voice.
Princess Celestia shook her head. “I don’t think she ever casually did anything.”
“Me either. All right, then. Let’s brief the others. We’ve work to do.” I pulled the door open and looked at the waiting ponies. “If you’d all join us, please. We have a lot to discuss and your kingdom needs you.”
☾
I sat at my desk, going over the final preparations for General Ironhoof’s return. The first airships would start arriving as early as tomorrow morning with the last showing up by sundown.
My body was giving out on me. I’d been working my normal duties during the day and training at all hours of the night, usually after Crystal had fallen asleep. Reliving memories repeatedly was like reliving the physical exertion. I felt Nimbus Knight’s fatigue each time I finished. It was wearing on Exemplar Ferrel and me.
This situation would only be temporary, however, as once Ironhoof was home, I’d be able to relieve myself of this command. There would be no more ponies to bring home and I could certainly delay any career choices for a short period of time. No Royal Guard or military position was as important as this.
Word had come via messenger that Shining Armor would also be arriving soon. I’d sent for him in a personal letter, strongly encouraging him to come visit to advise me on the very career I was now delaying. He’d forgive the subterfuge once he was briefed on the situation at hoof.
“Major Knight,” Minister Sombra said in his normal speaking voice. He had actually come to my door instead of just shouting for me from his office.
I immediately stood. “Sir!”
“I just finished reviewing the final plan for the homecoming and I’m impressed. You’ve gone above and beyond for this welcome ceremony and reintegration program. Is everything truly going to come together in time?”
“I am very confident it will, sir. This is going to bring closure to our kingdom, so every pony and agency involved is eager to give their very best and then some.”
Minister Sombra thumped my door with his hoof. “Good stallion. I knew you’d get it done. Have you given any thought to my offer?”
No? Not lately, anyway, but that would be an inadvisable answer. Everypony in the know had to continue on as if nothing had changed. “Yes, sir, I gave it thought and it is still high on my list. I’ve not made any decision. Although, after this duty, I might want a few weeks of leave before deciding.” I tried to push some levity into that. It would really be to focus more on my own operation.
“I’m glad to know I’m still in the running, and you can absolutely have leave. Don’t think I am unaware of how long you’re here each day and how much effort you put in. On that note, and not to be a hypocrite, but I’m going to leave for the evening. I have a social engagement.”
My ear flicked. He’d never had one of those before that he hadn’t mentioned it to me. Usually, they were affairs of state and I would have some duty to perform. I cleared my throat. “I didn’t see it on your calendar. You don’t need me? Something fun for a change?”
He shook his head. “You can’t help me with this, Major. As far as the fun part, only time will tell. Princess Celestia has set me up on what the ponies of these days call a blind date.”
“What did ponies in your time call it?” I asked.
“Mares meddling.”
“Ah, yes. I guess things don’t really change, do they?”
Minister Sombra shook his head. “In over a thousand years, it seems not.”
A thousand years apart and we still had that in common. A thousand years… He turned to leave but I’d shaken off the fatigue with that thought. Now my mind was racing.
Princess Celestia wasn’t the only pony in the Crystal Empire when it disappeared. There were many, many more. Most of them would have little involvement with important activities, but Minister Sombra was previously king! He’d been specifically led away from the summit by the very ponies that murdered the alicorns.
This was another avenue of investigation I could pursue, but I would have to do so with the greatest of care. “Sir?”
He paused. “Yes?”
“Does the name Maristella mean anything to you?” As I asked the question I watched his face.
His head tilted as if he was struggling to make sense of the question. “Maristella? Isn’t she the assistant to the mayor of Baltimare?”
“No… I mean, yes. Actually, yes, that is exactly right. I apologize, I should have been more specific. I’ve been reading from the Haven library again. Do you recall a Maristella from your time?”
“Ah, investigating history again? Shining Armor mentioned that was one of your passions. The name doesn’t really ring a bell, but I’ll think about it. To be honest, I lost some memories when I was… well… wherever I was. They come back every now and then.”
I nodded. There was no reaction when I’d said the name. No attempt to hide anything. Just genuine recognition of the mayor’s aide. “Thank you, sir. Just one more for you. How about Kalinda?”
Minister Sombra tapped a hoof. “Now that one I know. She was an alicorn from long ago.” He paused and chuckled. “Sorry, that isn’t a very useful context. When I was in my time, Kalinda was ancient. She preceded even Solara, so I know very little about her.”
I lightly shrugged. “When it comes to alicorns, that seems to be normal.”
“I’ve noticed that, but it wasn’t always that way. The ponies of this time barely even realize there were other alicorns. I find it… off-putting. Though I suppose the lack of aggression between them is a welcome change.”
“Indeed,” I replied, trying not to overplay my cards. “I was reading an old book by a nox pony general. Both names came up without context.”
Minister Sombra replied, “Ah I see. Well, I don’t know much about Kalinda. I’d have to imagine the nox ponies would know even less. Regardless, I don’t think anypony really knew her. She was gone before I was born. I vaguely remember some legend about her being an amazing artificer.”
“The sort that creates magical items? Celestial steel and the like?” I asked.
“Absolutely. That and more, at least as far as legend holds. Who can say if any of it is true? At any rate, I’d love to continue this conversation, but I should go. I wouldn’t want to keep Blueberry Muffin waiting. I’m sure we’ll have so much in common.”
I smirked. “Best of luck for you, sir. Just remember, all the mares are into Saddle Arabia right now.”
He grunted, “Just a bunch of sand,” before heading out of my office.
I leaned back in my chair. Kalinda was an alicorn. Was Maristella, too, then? If she had been, surely Princess Celestia would know her. There were never more than six at a time to my knowledge. Not that that said much.
The real question was, regardless of what she was, had Maristella been in the Crystal Empire when the princess sent it into stasis? If so, she could have returned just like the rest of the ponies. That would certainly explain why things were happening now.
There was also another issue to address along that exact same line of thought. Had Nocturna and Solara been slain, or did they slay all of the dark priestesses? Princess Celestia had not seen.
If the memory was to believed, I knew there were additional dark priestesses outside of the room performing their ritual. It was more likely that they’d just been sent away like King Sombra and the Crystal Empire.
They were my enemy. Those were the ponies I’d need to find. They’d lead me to the Forgotten Winter, and then the princesses would be safe. Now I just had to figure out how to find them.
Of course you give us answers with this chapter and, yet still, more questions! Silent has years of conspiracy and history to unwind if he does not want to be fighting a defensive battle.
And I would love to know why Celestia was so underestimated. Did the Elements of Harmony protect her?
Remind me if I forgot, but who has made the cover art for your stories?
Poor Princess Celestia: having to keep that terrible memory of the Alicorns' murder locked away inside her memory must have had a terrible effect on her.
Also, I'm hopeful that Silent will find a lead to the Eternal Winter.
You know the chapter was good when it leaves you shaking with excitement!
I might just be misremembering, but I thought Sombra and Luna had some sort of relationship going on.
7821628
Solara's magic apparently worked too. That's 2 out of 3 day Alicorns who could use magic, and only because the details of how the 3rd died isn't mentioned. Or it could be something totally different like what you suggested.
I BLEW THE HOUSE DOWN!!!!
I love Sunny Day, but she doesn't seem capable to handle this level of situation.
Huh, interesting. Answers and questions. So much unknown. Silent is right: if Sombra returned, so did the surviving dark priestesses. Might be who the Night Mares were, or were ponies taught by the dark priestesses.
So, there was discord during the time of the summit and no one knows why. Celestia may say it doesn't matter why, but I think it does. It didn't sound like there was too much division among the alicorns at the summit. They seemed confused as to what was happening. It's almost as if something out there caused this discord so that the alicorns would all gather in one place at the same time, and said place being where there are agents that are willing to do its bidding. I sense a master manipulator lurking.
Although something crosses my mind; Celestia knew it was the Unicorn Temple. Did she confront the exarch afterwards? If not, why? And if Celestia and Luna were the only ones who escaped the Crystal Empire, how did the memory crystal of the betrayal end up in the possession of the exarch, since every exarch has always known about the betrayal?
7821628 I agree. The Elements of Harmony being in Celestia's possession is the only real difference I can see, since the elder Alicorns were having such difficulty.
A chapter the day after Christmas. Congratulations you absolute legend.
I think Sunny and Silent are actually the reincarnations of Solara and Nocturna respectively.
Friends, I may have some bad news.
We know not what became of Solara and Nocturna. Yes, it's reasonable to assume they perished, but the fact is we do not know what became of them. Perchance one or both of them yet live, for they were very powerful indeed.
Stopping the magic of an alicorn is no small feat. Surely, it would require another alicorn, or if not an alicorn, someone very powerful indeed.
The Night Mares answers to a mistress of unknown identity, but to command such terrifying creatures, she must be very powerful indeed.
Curious, don't you think?
7822108
Not necessarily. Celestia only witnessed the deaths of Azuleka and Lumina; Solara and Nocturna were still alive when Celestia was shoved out of the room by Nocturna.
Nocturna's and Solara's behavior at the summit is suspicious, rather like they knew it didn't really matter and were waiting for something. Combine that with Nocturna "casually" leaving the Elements of Harmony in Celestia's possession—six items that we as the audience know are involved in the creation of at least one canon alicorn—and I smell something fishy was going on. Celestia's "overreaction" to protect Luna may actually have interrupted a counterplot.
Think about it. Sometimes a sting is needed to dispatch another's plot.
Who would be this... Blueberry Muffin? I almost have suspicions on whom it might be...
I wonder if Twilight were to become the new Alicorn. will it cease tension?
Pretty sure Windigoes Apocalypse is that Forgotten Winter.
The plot thickens and suspicions are raised. oh my godess the story manipulates our minds! we'll see enemies where there are none, and friends where there are enemies!
Dang talk about a bomb shell of a reveal. As for the bit about the not being able to create alicorns... I have a feeling that magic and the world has a way of balancing itself.. Or that Silent may find out the knowledge himself during his searching. An interesting time.. though id be more fearful if the ones who massacred the alicorns somehow got out of the stasis that Celestia place them in by accident. And poor Sombra. I hope he has fun on his date lol
this chapter really posed more questions than it answered.
and in that light I have a question.
ware is this story in relation to the show time line?
Sombra on an unscheduled outing? And we know that he was King of the Crystal Empire? The same empire where the alicorns were murdered? Something's screwy here...
Looks like you have a LOT of reading to do about the past, SK. Good luck.
Mmmm, creamy. Absolutely creamy! Go Anzel! Go!
She don't listen so good, do she?
this bit confused me, Celestia is saying that sunny is a representative and then sunny askes why she is not a representative
7822861 Nowhere. It stopped being canon ever since the season 2 finale.
Okay, so someone was pushing the civil unrest that led to the summit where the alicorns were assassinated, that does not feel unrelated.
I like the idea of the latter, because that sounds really funny.
I'm slightly confused about these two paragraphs. It reads like Sunny is complaining about not being a representative immediately after being named as effectively being one.
Ahhh, so that's what happened. Not quite the "Celestia is a secret martial badass" that I speculated, but that was a bit of a long shot. Given the functioning magic once she left, I wonder if the real solution to the entire ambush would have been for everyone being magically suppressed to retreat and regroup out from under the effect. That's basically what Celestia did, but it just might not have worked for everyone in the room to try that depending on how the fight progressed.
Ooooo, and so that is what happened to the Crystal Empire. If the goal was getting away from the assassins, at the very least that was an effective method. The mentions of Star Swirl are interesting, I wonder how involved he was with either court.
Oh, okay, that explains the answer last chapter.
Oh crap. Let that be a lesson about keeping vitally important bits of lore inside just one or two vulnerable skulls.
Huh.
"Greatest of care" is a bit of an understatement.
And lo, in the span of a single conversation, my hope for Sombra X Rarity blossomed forth unjustified from nothing and then withered away.
It would be really interesting if Nocturna and Solara (or maybe just Nocturna on account of the greater Q&B focus on her) are out there laying low and working their own angle on the Forgotten Winter problem. Maybe that lost alicorn lore isn't really lost after all.
7824013 I thought this myself.
7823586
Celestia is not saying that Sunny is a representative, she is saying that Sunny is a pony that is very close to her. Being a representative and being very close to an alicorn are two distinct things (but they often happen together because of the closeness). Also, times change and Celestia probably doesn't need a representative like the had in the past.
Answers are manifesting and connections are finally coming together. However with every reveal there seem to be more mysteries...Silent Knight has his work cut out for him...
Minor point of clarity regarding "representatives." Changed the line to:
“Wait, how come I’m just your guard captain and not an official representative like they were?” Sunny asked.
Sunny feels as if she is less than what Princess Celestia is describing.
DANGER, semi-spoilers below.
7821628 Just pulling the curtain back more and more! Of course that leads to further curtains but we're getting there.
As to why they underestimated here. A few things. The first being that she was "the student" of the day and the alicorn version of a teenager. Not typically a big threat. The other major reason is that they didn't seem to expect her magic to work ;)
7821645 Painted Wave did Memoirs and Secrets. Magica Rin did Trials. PW will be doing all of the book covers which, in turn, will update the story cover art.
7821690 Forgotten Winter ;) I'm sure he'll pursue it deeply!
7821744 Shake on! I'm really pleased to hear that ^_^
7821836 Not story wise, no. Comment wise people were all about that! It was a very popular theory/fanon.
7821870
Indeed, but to what extent? And poor Sunny! She's capable! She's a great pony ;D
7821973 Excellent analysis and hypothesizing here. Well done!
More excellent questions! I'll be addressing most of it if not all. It depends on how the final draft shakes out. As far as the very last one... Who said some others didn't get away too? We only know Celestia's perspective.
7822108 I do try terribly hard to keep to the schedule. The Monday after New Years might be hard but we'll see!
7822378 This is a very valid point. Multiple valid points actually. Excellent hypothesizing.
7822440 These are some lovely thoughts! Well reasoned and posed! Absolutely love this sort of comment ^_^
7822479 Blueberry Muffins is just Blueberry Muffin in this case ;) A random mare Celestia thought might fit Sombra.
7822494 That largely depends on if we believe the same tensions still exist that existed prior. Most ponies seem to have forgotten them.
7822513 Time will tell! We'll know for sure "soon."
7822685 That is exactly right =D
7822808 There is certainly the risk that the plotters came back too :D At least those that aren't killed.
7822861 Quill & Blade follows the show pretty close through season 2. After that it diverges in an irreconcilable way.
7823084 It's just a date! With Blueberry Muffin! The muffinest pony.
7823132 But I'm lactose intolerant =\
7823182 She does but to her point the former is more of an official role vs just being a close pony.
7823586 Indeed, I wasn't clear here. Explanation above :D
7823730 Fact!
7824013
How about a little of both? :D
Indeed, I didn't express this idea correctly. Sunny is a confident and guard captain but not an official representative in the style that Moonglaive was.
Quite a lot. He was one of Lumina's house advisors. He spent a lot of time with her and Solara. Thus the perfect mentor for Celestia once she had no alicorns.
Many great thoughts here. Struggling to stay quiet! Gah!
7825542 That is how I meant it, yup, yup!
7826881 Silent will be very busy, that is for sure!
7827386 Doesn't mean you can't be a cream peddler.
7827386 No doubt he'll be protecting his wife in doing so.
Does Minister Sombra look the same as he did in the show?
One more thing!
Who is Exemplar Ferrel? I don't mean like, "Who is this character that I have somehow never noticed before despite her being around since almost the very beginning?"
I mean, who is she really? What do we know about her? We know that she sees visions of possible futures and that she has trouble remembering things that happened both long ago and recently (which is strange in itself, as it seems less like she's absent-minded or just forgetful, and more like something is interfering with her ability to remember). But most critically, we know that she is quite old and does not look like she's nearly as old as she actually is. There is some powerful magic at work there, I'm telling you.
And let's not forget how she always seems to be in the right place at the right time. Not in the, "How convenient" sense either, but look at it. She always seems to be exactly where Silent Knight needs her to be, when he needs her to be there. And honestly, I'm not convinced that when she does see a vision, that she really sees two false outcomes and one real one, rather than simply one real one. She's always there providing Silent Knight with exactly the wisdom he needs to overcome the obstacles in front of him, even if he doesn't always realize it.
It's... well, it's probably nothing. Nothing important, at least.
It's just all very curious, don't you think?
7827386 My point was Celly had just named Sunny specifically as an example of an alicorn's representative. Whether she felt it before or not, Sunbutt just made it official by saying it to her face!
But that was just my reaction to the snippet as originally written.
I sense detective work ahead!
Didn't Nocturna have prophetic visions? Or am I remembering that incorrectly? She seemed rather well-prepared considering it was a surprise attack.
And I too hope that there's a very confused Solara and Nocturna wandering around somewhere up north. Or just chillaxing at Donut Joe's.
Finally... I'm voting Ferrel for first new alicorn of the day, and Silent for first new alicorn of the night. Who cares if he's a he? That just makes for juicier drama when the other alicorn mares take notice!
The plot thickens!
Damn this book just gets better and better!
wait so if the Empire returned, wouldn't that mean its temple returned as well? This is getting good and I am happy that I am slowly catching up.
7821973
Celestia knows that's where the ceremony was being held, and that someone was involved. But that doesn't mean the entire temple was involved. Though I agree with you, it would be suspicious if she didn't confront the temple leaders at some point ... and it seems as though she hasn't.
Yes, then you take her out for ice cream.
You'll find out when the Forgotten Winter wins.
This sounds more and more like the two Mentors knew what was going on - if they were not organizing it themselves.
That sounds extremely ominous.
It was worse than I could have possibly imagined!
Reincarnation? Or just name sharing?
I'm kind of wagering on neither ... but we'll see.
So you ever going to give a reason why stallions never get all powerful or turn into alicorns or?
8307428
There were male alicorns. They were previously mentioned.
Hmmm... Time to call Twilight in? If anyone can solve a magical problem it would be her. And Pinkie CAN keep secrets...