I leaned against one of the workbenches in Runic’s back room, watching him fiddle with some sort of machine.
Today I was prepared. I wore goggles, stood on a rubber mat, and had a lab coat on. With any luck, I wouldn’t be on the wrong end of an experiment. “So I understand you and Miley Hooves are going to see a show?”
“Yes,” Runic said as he turned a crank on the machine. “We’re going to see a rock show. I’m pretty excited!”
My eyes narrowed. “Runic, do you mean the new show in town, Pony Rocks?”
He nodded and continued to turn the crank. Slowly, a barrel rose up towards the top of the machine. “That one, yes.”
“You do realize that isn’t about actual rocks, right? It’s a musical show. Ponies sing and dance to rock music,” I explained.
Runic stopped and stared at me. “But… it’s called Pony Rocks! Rocks for ponies?” He started cranking again and finally the barrel spilled over into the top of the machine. It began to whir and sputter.
Eying the device, I went on, “I know, Runic. They’re trying to be clever. You may enjoy it, though, and Miley is really excited that you said yes. You wouldn’t want to hurt her feelings, would you?”
Throwing a switch, Runic replied, “No. I don’t like hurting anypony’s feelings.” A conveyor belt started to move, bringing bottles up to the machine that were then filled with pink liquid.
“Then you’ll still go with Miley?” I asked.
“Of course. Miley is a fun lab assistant. I’m sure we’ll have a good time,” he said, coming over to me and handing me a box of labels. He applied one to a bottle and I got the idea. We were making mare care products today it seemed.
“You think she is only a lab assistant?” I asked.
“That is certainly a step up from research project.” He chuckled at me.
I labeled more bottles and glanced up at him. “I see… So, Runic, I’m no expert on this sort of thing but I need to ask a favor, as a friend. Could you be careful with Miley? She may be a little sweet on you. If you don’t feel that way it is fine, but be gentle.”
“Sweet on me?” He tilted his head and put a label on upside down.
“Yeah, you know… like ‘special somepony’ type sweet. I think she likes you,” I said as I apologized to Miley internally. I really did want the best for her.
Runic put another label on upside down. “Oh. Really?”
“Really,” I replied before starting to take his bottles and turn the labels rightside up as he continued to put them on upside down.
“Isn’t that interesting,” Runic said and then added, “Is this a date, then?”
“I think to protect her heart she’d probably say it was an invite to a friend, but deep down she’d like it to be a date, and it does happen to fall on Hearts and Hooves Day.” I continued to fix all of the bottles Runic was messing up.
“I haven’t been on a lot of dates, Silent Knight,” Runic admitted. “As I told you that one time, mares don’t like talking about rocks on the first date. What should I do?”
“Just be yourself.”
The labels were getting far more erratic. The bottle I was trying to fix had six on it.
I continued, “Miley already knows you. She likes you how you are. Don’t do anything silly like pretend to be another pony. Although maybe you should talk about something she is interested in at least once.”
“What is she interested in? She always seems interested in what we’re doing here! Do I talk about that? She was there for it!”
“Slow down there!” I held a bottle in each hoof and tried to fix labels with my teeth. I sat down and stuck out a hindhoof to catch a third bottle. “She’ll prompt you, I’d guess. Just let her take the lead now and again if she tries. You’ll be fine. Please stop the belt, Runic. Runic!”
“Huh?” Bottles tumbled off the line and onto me. The top popped open on one and got all over my mane. “Oh, right.” He turned off the line.
I stood up from the pile of bottles and shook my mane out a bit. It suddenly had volume and glimmered.
“You look great,” he offered.
After looking myself over, I had to agree. Runic’s mare care products were the best and my mane had never looked shinier.
“Thanks, I guess. Look, I didn’t tell you this to get you worked up. I just wanted to be sure you didn’t miss out on something. I know a thing or two about missing the subtle signs that mares send. Actually, I could probably write a book about it. But I don’t want that for you. Just be yourself and you’ll do fine, okay?”
“Okay. I’ll just be myself. It will be fine,” he repeated. “Should I bring a gift? I know she likes quartz. “
I lifted a hoof. “Why don’t you just start with being you and see how that goes? If you have fun, you can worry about gifts and such then.”
“That sounds fair. I wouldn’t want to overdo it. Mind helping me clean up?”
I shook my head. “No, I don’t mind at all.”
We set about to cleaning up and fixing all of the bottles that had tried to bury me alive.
☾
Princess Luna and I sat across from each other at her game table. She was staring me down. Her vicious gaze didn’t rattle me at all. I had her and she knew it. Her magic slowly levitated several pony figures forwards by an exact, measured amount. They were perfectly painted and looked exactly like the members of her House Guard.
“‘Tis thy turn,” she said in an ominous tone.
Her moves had been very limited thanks to my strategy of bottling her up between two hills. Princess Luna played very aggressively and in war that was dangerous. I moved one unit of ponies up onto the left hill. Then I carefully pushed a group of pegasi up on the opposite one. It would all be over soon.
I pointed to the unit on the left. “Those ponies have crossbows—” I then pointed to where the House Guard was exposed. “—and those are the targets.” Picking up fifteen dice, I gave them a little shake before dropping them. We looked them over and I said, “Twelve hits… minus two to your armor saves.”
Princess Luna wrinkled her nose in a sour look. She rolled the twelve dice. “Two saves…” Gently she turned ponies over onto their side. She was careful about whom she chose. She stuck her tongue out before turning the figure that looked like me over.
“Well, you’re certainly not going to win now,” I teased.
She snorted and waved a hoof at me. “I think there is little chance of victory now. Thou hast outmaneuvered me again. Wilt thou show me mine errors?”
“If you would like. Thank you for the game,” I said before moving around to her side of the table. “It all starts with the terrain. Generally the high ground is always favorable. You seem to rely on the fact that your soldiers are better than mine. Never underestimate what unskilled warriors en mass can achieve under good leadership.”
The princess seemed to think that over. “What if both of our soldiers are highly trained?”
“It all comes down to morale, tactics, teamwork, and luck.”
“Luck?” She seemed surprised.
Slowly, I nodded. “It may not seem elegant or comforting but luck will always matter. We do the best we can and hope everything works as we planned… but plans never survive the first contact with the enemy.”
Princess Luna sat her hooves on the table and replied, “I see. Perhaps it is best if thou beginest instructing me in the art of war?”
My head tilted. “Why would you want to learn something awful like that, Princess?”
“The same reason that thou hast learned… just in case.”
That gave me pause and then I nodded. “Very well. A ruler of Equestria should know the basics of warfare, just in case. You'll have an easier time conversing with the generals.”
“Knoweth all royal guards as much about it as thou dost?”
I shook my head. “No, that is my father’s doing. That and my own interest. I’ve had a lot of time to study in the evenings.”
The princess lightly patted me on the shoulder. “I think thy time would be better spent looking for a new companion.”
“I’ve got plenty of companions,” I said, missing the point on purpose. I wasn’t sure I wanted to go over this with Princess Luna again.
“Thou knowest exactly what I meant. Thou canst not turn a blind eye to romance forever simply because of one…” She hedged. “...unfortunate experience.”
I cleared my throat and lowered my voice. I wasn’t particularly interested in Miley Hooves hearing this conversation. “Yes, I know what you meant, Princess. I’m the unit sergeant now. I’ve got a lot on my plate. There are a lot of ponies counting on me.”
“And what of thou? Is this not a life half lived?”
Softly, I rested my hoof over hers. “Princess, I am truly grateful for your concern. That alone is more than I ever saw for myself in my life. I have friends, family, and ponies that are concerned for my well-being. It is enough for me. I would like for it to be enough for the rest of you.”
Princess Luna blinked and looked me in the eyes. “If that is thy wish.”
“It is.” At least I thought so.
“Then we will return to the lessons of warfare. The romance shall be saved for another day.”
☾
Sunny Day slipped out of the shadows to fall in beside me as I walked towards Princess Luna’s chambers. The princess had asked me to see her before I went home for the day.
“As you were,” the unicorn mare said before I could properly salute. “That was some tussle the other night, wasn’t it?”
“Yes, ma’am. Again, I apologize for that. I can assure you that it absolutely won’t happen again.”
Sunny winked at me. “Oh, I’m sure. They’re all terrified of you. If you tell them to straighten up, they’ll straighten up.”
My ear flicked. “Terrified? Nopony is terrified of me.”
“You say that, but they are. After the other night most of my ponies are, too. You jumped into that fight, took some good licks, and still pulled the ponies apart like a professional. You didn’t even lose your cool, just gave that disapproving glare. I was impressed.”
It wasn’t clear to me where this conversation was going. “Alright, well, perhaps it is wise to be frightened by a first sergeant.”
“I’m not scared, though,” she said pointedly.
“You’re a lieutenant and, as best I can tell, nothing scares you anyway. What is your point?”
Sunny laughed a bit and replied, “No point. Just that I’m not scared. Bye!”
She made a right and took off down the hall as I reached Princess Luna’s chambers. I simply didn’t get Sunny Day.
The princess’s door was open and I went inside. Blackblade was keeping watch and the princess nodded towards him from her seat at her game table.
“Take position outside, please,” I told the earth pony and he did so.
After pushing the door shut, I went over and sat across from the princess. She was painting some more miniatures. The current one captured in her magic looked exactly like her. “Her name was Nocturna.”
I racked my brain for a moment before I pieced it together. Of course. Who else? “The figure?”
“The alicorn thou sawest in the stained glass. She was going to be my mentor.”
“Going to be?” I asked.
The princess shook her head. “I do not wish to discuss that. I felt thou hast a right to understand a little more of what thou hadst seen. That way thou mayest make an educated decision on what I am about to ask.”
“Are you about to ask me to go on another mission?”
“I am. Thou art uniquely suited to this work even though thou wouldst be unaware of it. I know circumventing Royal Guard procedures will givest thou pause. Were this not important I would never ask, but I must. Wilt thou be my agent?”
If it had been any other pony I’d have gone to the captain. Any other pony in all of Equestria and I wouldn’t give it a second thought. This wasn’t any pony, though. This was Princess Luna. My career would be in jeopardy and I certainly didn’t like keeping secrets, but when she said ‘uniquely suited’ I didn’t take it as an exaggeration. She seemed genuine.
“Yes. Within reason, of course.” There was nothing else that needed to be said.
“Of course. Thou hast my sincere gratitude.” She took my helmet off and set it on the table.
From a drawer, she produced a silver chain with a white crescent moon pendant. That went around my neck and my vision changed. It was the same as the last time.
“Fly west to the Smoky Mountain. Near the base on the western face, thou wilt find a stone circle set into the cliff’s face. Press the talisman to it and it will open. Report back what thou findest.”
“Princess, is there any way you could be less cryptic about this? What exactly are you hoping for me to find?” I asked.
She straightened and looked at me sternly. “This is difficult for me, Silent Knight.”
We had a staring contest and there was little doubt that she was going to win. I did my best to hang in there, though. If I was to be her agent, I needed to know more.
Finally, she sighed. “Thou art looking for ponies or any indication of where they may have gone.”
It caught me off guard. She’d had me and decided to tell me, anyway. Perhaps I should go easier on her. “Ponies. Alright then, I’ll be on my way.”
When I reached for my helmet, she set a hoof on mine and shook her head. Evidently, the princess wasn’t worried about me being brained.
Off I went to another crypt, most likely. Without my helmet, I decided to exit from the balcony. If there were ponies to be found, I hoped they were friendly. Friendly and willing to have a house guest.
What is up with the no‐helmet rule?
5645642 I can say for certain it has a purpose :D
5645645
Inverse tin foil hat? (i.e., metal helps propagate mind control signals rather than blocking them) Some bizarre prejudice against helmets on the part of the ponies he’s looking for? Sincere desire to ensure Silent Knight doesn’t end up with helmet hair?
Great job with this chapter. I really enjoyed it. I wonder what is going to happen at this new crypt. I also want to know when Silent will get into another relationship. I guess we will see soon enough.
You're missing out on a golden opportunity here Anzel.
Silent spills mare mane care product on himself. Every pony begins asking him why he smells like Iridescence!
5645671
I'm still waiting to see why Celestia is tagged.
NEW HEADCANNON HAS FORMED ITSELF FROM THE VOID! I think some of Silent Knight's ancestors were batponies.(if they existed) And he could have something from them twinkling inside of him. Something...primal. Mayby something could happen in the future for this hidden element to come out of the dark...
I also think that the cywilization that Silent is looking for were those batponies. And those thestrals blended into the general population with time.
5645963 I actually dropped the Celestia tag a while back because it didn't make sense. I'd originally planned for her to have more of a role and it never materialized. So now it is just Luna and Shining Armor.
this doesn't sound right to me, maybe if you said it like "I don't like hurting another pony's feelings" or "I don't like hurting other ponies' feelings"
1. Call up the navigators, and put a GPS telemarketer on the call.
2. That pun at the end was terrible.
I have a theory, BAT PONIES!!!!!!!!!. I mean, there hasn't been any mentions of them and there are caves so... I believe Luna looking for her bat ponies/therestials/Children of the night is pretty resonable.
This little mystery is building up to be really great. I cant wait for the climax of this story arc. Just curious, is the ponies that Luna i seeking out the thestral "bat pony" race? If its spoilery, dont worry about not telling me openly or at all, but this is turning out to be really good and I cant wait for the next installment. Do continue
Was that Warhammer tabletop or something else?
Curiouser and curiouser. Looking forward to more.
Keep up the good work. Deus tecum.
5645667
It's been implied that the helmets incorporate some kind of enchantment that either allows for communication or discrete surveillance.
At least, that's what I took out of it.
It may sound a bit silly, but I wonder if people are right about Silent having Thestral blood and the no-helmet rule is put in place so that it shows off his ears? His ears do seem rather long and pointed in most of the art, like I'd expect from a bat-pony.
So the other alicorn was supposed to be Luna's mentor... Interesting.
Some things have definitely diverged from canon in order to fit this story, but that helps establish time, at least a bit. We don't see any other alicorns besides Celestia and Luna present in the story of Luna's banishment, so Nocturna disappeared before Luna was corrupted by Nightmare Moon, and the fact that Luna specifies that Nocturna was supposed to train her implies that she disappeared long before then, when Luna was still young. Since Luna was still a unicorn in the window, it seems likely that she disappeared before Luna and Celestia ascended.
My guess is DIscord was involved, somehow.
Though I still think that the towns were in use until Luna's banishment. Luna knows exactly where they are, and exactly what's in them, just not what happened to any of the ponies there. The only gap in Luna's history that would have prevented her from already knowing what had happened to the cities.
HA! So many chapters ago, people laughed at me for proposing batponies!
Look at it now! LOOKKIT! I CALLED IT!
*patiently waits until his theory is proven solid*
5647959 People laughed at you? >_< That isn't nice! Time will tell on your theory though!
5647646 Well reasoned points. The diverging train is going to be ramping up a lot as we go forward.
5647542 Clever pony, you may have caught something folks have missed.
5647418 Hmm, that isn't the impression I meant to give >_< I may need to clean that up.
5646826 Essentially any miniatures war game. Technically speaking I was thinking historic miniatures (since the ponies used aren't "fantasy" or "future"). Something like Fire and Fury.
5646809 It would be spoilers but I think folks are starting to catch on to some of the ideas now.
5646772 It is a very valid theory!
5646750 Hmm pun? I hadn't intended to make one >_< Oops!
5648313
Still also waiting for the blue band explanation. If he marries a friggin batpony, I'll forcefully shove money at my screen. All of it. Forever.
5648318 Typically the story is written about 15 chapters in advance and I don't change major plot points based on user feedback. With that said, no reader has ever tried to bribe me so... how much is a bat pony marriage worth to you? ;D (I kid, I kid)!
5648321
*rushes to the bank and starts filling out a credit form*
Huh-wha?
*attempts to petrify you with his amazingly adorable batpone eyes while slowly drawing more and more zeroes on the form*
So Silent will find a special somepon within 15 chapters? Neato! Also, at least 15 more chapters to go, yay! He has to make Commander of the Royal Guard. And in the epilogue become the first stallion Princess.
5648390 I can't comment on that time line ;) I more was pointing out that I don't write the chapter going out when it goes out. This story is highly planned and, in addition to the words published, I have roughly 100,000 more in draft.
Process wise I laid out the outline a long time ago and wrote about 200,000 words in draft. Once it gets near release I go back and turn the draft into a more solid document which is then reviewed by my collaborator. That normally puts me about 10-15 chapters ahead of where the release is.
I can tell you for certain there are at least 15 more chapters that are chambered and ready to go. Then there are probably 25 beyond that that are mostly ready. Plus I'm still writing ;)
Memoirs is like a web comic. It will continue until there are no stories left to tell or I and/or the readers have lost interest.
5648403
You're still avoiding the VERY important matter of batpony marriage. Batponies are an endagered species! And since Silent is Luna's best confidant, he could, nay, SHOULD! do whatever it is in his power to bring back the forgotten people!
You wanna do this the hard way? Lets do this the hard way then.
*waves a hoof in front of your face in a Jedi Mind Trick*
Silent Knight will marry a sexy vixen batpony mare.
*stops for a second*
*waves a couple more Jedi Mind Tricks just in case*
*also tries out some Sith Mind Control*
...
*again, a couple times, just to be certain*
5648403 Gotta say that's a pretty good process you've got worked out there. It puts you way ahead of schedule and gives you room to change anything you find lacking with plenty of time to spare.
5648313 He is a house guard, and I thought it was an intentional pun. It was pretty clever, actually. Or it would've been if it were intentional.
5648608 If only I were that clever T_T
5648545 It works well for me and allows a lot of flexibility. One thing I do like is that I can sneak in new chapters without anyone knowing ;D
5648417 I'll take it to the board and see!
5648647
*sighs, throwing away the "Force Usage for Dumdums" away*
Guess that's the best I'm going to get. Anyway, as per usual, can't wait for another monday!
5648313
Maybe I just need to reread those passages.
5649012 If you do I'd appreciate you pointing it out to me. I'd like to look myself!
Luna having to be taught strategy by a pony less than tenth her age?
I call shenanigans.
I'm going to assume this is another of the moves away from canon.
5649035
Having reread, no, there is no implication of surveillance; I misremembered.
There is a clear implication for communication, though: When the helmet is removed while the armor is on, it changes the dynamic of social interaction. So far, we have seen it done mainly in private, when only two ponies are speaking to each other, and it signifies a desire to interact not as a guard, but as an individual.
In the most recent chapter, leaving the helmet behind is actually symbolic of this most recent development in Knight and Luna's relationship: He is no longer just her guard anymore, but is more akin to an extension of her will while he is in uniform, able to do what she cannot, and go where she cannot.
Out of uniform, he's still just a big, dumb, lovable goof. I would even go so far as to say that he is a snoogy-bear.
5649147 Oh yes you're dead on accurate that the "helmet off" changes all interactions between ponies. From that perspective I wholly agree with you.
5649153
Indeed.
Snoogy-bear.
You've got ships sailing everywhere, and yet still find a way to include miniatures games (btw, Knight would love Warmachine rules), and secret missions. I agree that Knight is now serving more as Luna's agent, than just as a guard. His sister and his ex are sleeping together, his cousin is hooking up with his subordinate, and his friend is trying to get with him. Very interesting settup here, and I'm guessing bat-ponies or Thesterals or whatever you want to call them are what she's got him looking for.
the tabletop game reminded me of warhammer 40k haha. anyway i loved this chapter. on to the others! when they come out. all in all this story is wonderfully written. im glad to have found it though Crystal Wishes story. Personally i ship the hell outta silent and crystal but thats just me.
*Crosses fingers* PLEASE be Children of the Night!
5648403 I highly approve of your writing process.
Edit: Comment 800, now there's a nice round number.
5654975 Much appreciated. It works for me and allows a lot of time to ruminate over the plot.
5649351 I'm really glad you came over! I think you'll find it interesting to read both stories.
5649270 Miniatures games are the best ^_^
5658583 Oh it has been and i am caught up with both stories at the moment . your both great writers. atleast in my opinion. great characters and a good storyline. and some of the first stories that actually made me give a care about shipping haha
Looks like you were slightly off with Smokey Mountain. It's plural and I bet the founders of the Hooffeilds and McColts killed eachother before their family could do much.
Indeed. And this isn't even Silent being dense(though he is getting much better at that! Character growth yey!) Sunny is in a league of her own.
Well. That's fascinating.
I didn't expect these little side excursions, but the add depth to the story. Also, that foreshadowing...
ok as before I am defiantly going to say she is searching for her thestrals.
as to the no helmet rule that is vary easy if you remember vary early in the story there is a huge clue Silent Knight has tufted ears he most defiantly has thestrals in his back ground and I am going to throw a guess out here and say that his father knows.
5645642
5645667
reminds me of a joke in an online cartoon:
"so, you're just a guinea pig?"
"no, i'm a 'lab assistant'."
Again with the no-helmet thing! Maybe I’m not over-thinking this one.
8764577
Didnt see your previous comment but as we all know he's looking for Thestrals, the no helmet thing is obvious. One, they'd see him an an Equestrian Guard and would probably attack him on sight. Two, he's suoted to it because the Knight famy has tufted ears, which he stated at the beginning of the story. Tufted ears are a Thestral trait, and Equestrian Guard armor hides your physical traits, which would include that.