I'll set this up to make it easier. They and the main 6 are still friends, mostly everything plays outvtje same with
Some very minor changes here and there. Fluttershy and Rainbow are Male too so that Aj isnt the only male. Does this work as well as them both being female? Does it work at all? Go.

7002469
Uh, hello? It’s AJ and Rarity. It works. Period. As if a silly little thing like gender was going to be an issue.

7002469
Everything works if you do it right. It's always a matter of execution. There are awful stories about pairs I love and amazing stories about the stupidest crack ships.

7002469
If it's written well.

Male AJ and female Rarity only work if Dash is still female.

Everyone knows that.

7002553
Why is that? Im pleased with these answers. TEACH ME WHY THIS IS

7002559
Because Rainbow is the far superior choice for Rarity dating. If AJ and Dash are the same gender, obviously she'll choose Dash. So to make it work they have to be different genders and Rarity needs to be straight or gay/a lesbian. Then, she won't even be attracted to Dash.

Then you ship Dash with Sweetie Belle.

Depends on the writer i guess

7002561
K

7002469
RariJack will work great, as long as it's written well.

Gender flipping AJ will work great, as long as it's written well.

Smooze x Tom the Boulder would work great, as long as it was written well.

There's a pattern here.

7002469
Applejack is worst pony already. Giving her a dick simultaneously makes her worse and doesn't matter because she's already the worst possible thing.

Do you just hate Rarity that much?

7003107
k.