So i was sitting here thinking about "A Harmonic Sonata" and found myself thinking how would things would have played out had Sonata been Celestia's faithful student (and a Unicorn) and Twilight had been a Siren? Meaning from the very start twilight was one of the 3 sirens banished by starswirl, and Sonata was born a Unicorn on Equestria. As such I am going to issue a fanfic challenge.

The Challenge is simple, write a fic in which Sonata was Celestia's student and Twilight was one of the 3 Sirens banished from Equestria while following a few rules listed below

1: Try and keep their Personality's as close to cannon as possible. of course some change in their personality's will be required

2: The EoH Bearers, must be the same meaning Apple Jack, Fluttershy, Pinkie Pie, Rainbow Dash, and Rarity. and then with Sonata as the Element of Magic.

3: Shipping is totally allowed

4: OC's may be used.

5: Have Fun!

if you have any questions feel free to ask