'ello! My name is Prince Blueblood Soluna. And before you run away in disgust, I wan to tell you something about myself.

You see, my cutie mark is of a compass rose. You might be wondering what a Prince like me would use this for. Well it represents my desire to find perfection.

In other words, my special talent is Critical Analysis.

Imagine my surprise when I saw absolutely NO ONE had a critical analysis group here on Fimfiction! I mean there are editing groups and review groups, but not a single group whose main goal was to provide reasonable feedback and to pick apart stories. Such a travesty and crime shall not be ignored any further. From this point on, welcome to the ONLY group for critically analyzed stories!

So what do I mean by Critical Analysis? Well, I don't just want ordinary reviews. I want people, ponies, and bronies, who are willing to dive deep to give honest, unbiased criticism to help other authors get better

Hate a story? Go into great detail WHY you hate it!

Love a story? Rant and Rave about the masterpiece!

Featured Trash? Featured Gold? Explain why you think they deserve that spot or why they disgrace it!



There are various ways this group is organized so here are the options.

1. Critical Analyzed Stories: This folder is for any story that you wrote a critical review for in the comments section. We have divided it into good and bad in order to direct he flow of traffic.

2. Stories for Critical Analysis: Want honest good feedback on a story? Add it here and maybe someone will tell you why it's amazing or trash!

3. Critical Analysis and Review Thread: If we accept criticism from the comments, why have a thread folder? Simple! MST3Ks!! Place stories that you reviewed in the forums HERE!! So if you wanna follow in the footsteps of, say, Linkara, this is the folder for you!

4. Forum. This is where the magic happens. THIS is where you can put large, outstanding and wonderful MST3Ks/reviews. This is pretty much the face of the group.

One last thing. It's respectful and really helpful for all of us if you tell the author that their story is added to the group. The point of all of this is to give feedback, positive or negative to, most importantly

HELP PEOPLE BECOME BETTER AUTHORS!!

So go wild! Have fun! Let's go review some stories! And rememberr, NEVER. EVER. Stop thinking critically!

-Prince Blueblood Soluna

Comments ( 2 )
  • Viewing 1 - 2 of 2

is there any pony analysing the stories?
we have 7 stories awaiting right now.

Ok, I'll give this a whirl.
I could supply a list of stories for the reviewers and analalytics to rave about.
Should be interesting to see how these ravings will go, or so I hope.

  • Viewing 1 - 2 of 2