So since group thread notifications are back, I decided to get the ball rolling in this group again.

My question for you all is, who would you rather have play QB for your respective favorite team? Luck already plays QB for my favorite team, but both QBs have done very well so far in their respective careers. But I would pick Luck myself, for the following reason.

He inherited a 2-14 team (which proceeded to lose even more pieces to free agency) and took them to the playoffs right away. He's proven that he can do so much with less pieces around him. I don't believe, at the moment, that Russell Wilson would be as successful as he is if not for that defense and the running back he has behind him. That's not to say he's not good, he's just not on the level of a Luck, Brady, or Manning yet in terms of making everyone around him better.

So, who would you guys pick?

It's easy Luck is far and away better. You put luck on Seattle and I'm sure they go undefeated.