May
12th
2016

So, just got back from seeing Captain America: Civil War. And it was amazing. I remember reading Marvel's original Civil War event. It was one of the first major comic events I read (having just got into comics) and ... yeah, it wasn't that good. Kinda the opposite. Partly because the pro-Registration side was, as Linkara observed, demonized throughout the series and most of the tie-ins, and in the end they were the winners and--according to remarks by the writers--were meant to be the right side all along! Even leaving aside the fact that the Superhuman Registration stuff was undone later. So yeah, Marvel can take a crappy comic and turn it into a great movie while DC can take several great comics and turn them into a crappy movie (and I say this as someone who generally prefers DC to Marvel).

What's the relevance to MLP? Well, it got me thinking: a big part of MLP episodes is that they often have messages or morals. Which isn't a bad thing, in and of itself. True, sometimes it makes things a bit formulaic and the plots easily predictable. Again, that doesn't make for a bad episode or a bad series. Heck, I got into My Little Pony in the summer of 2011 and I've been hooked ever since. It's the only show I watch on TV and I am head over heels in love with it. That doesn't mean I'm going to be pull any punches when I find an episode is lacking, quite the opposite, in fact.

Now, to tie my disparate thoughts together, most of the episodes of MLP that don't work (for me at least) tend to fail because of a failure of the moral.  This can take several forms. Sometimes they present a moral or lesson that is at odds with what was shown throughout the episode. Say, by having the characters who are supposed to be in the right, the ones teaching the lesson, act so unlikeable that it deprives them of their moral high ground. Sometimes the different messages they're trying to convey trip over each other and become a mess. Sometimes the moral itself really isn't a good one, or requires more nuance than they were able to get across. Sometimes ... it just makes no flipping sense.

So I put it to you, the readers. What do you think were the biggest moral misfires (as I like to call them) in MLP? Can be any season, old or new. What moral/lesson episodes failed to get their message across? What morals worked, but were messed up in the execution? What morals themselves just didn't work? What episodes left you scratching your heads in confusion or slapping your faces in annoyance?

Report Trinary · 185 views ·

Latest Stories

  • E A Hearth's Warming Swap

    Dashverse AU: The Mane Six are due to put on the Heart's Warming Pageant, but things get mixed up and turned around thanks to Fluttershy.  · Trinary
    7,241 words · 446 views  ·  55  ·  4
  • T Diamond and the Rough

    Dashverse: Rarity and Rainbow Dash are friends, but they don't have much in common. This becomes a problem when Princess Luna needs their help with the Equestria Summit and the two friends have vastly differing ideas on how to proceed.  · Trinary
    13,289 words · 579 views  ·  58  ·  4
  • T Friendship is Empathy II

    Sequel to "Friend is Empathy" set after "What About Discord?" Recent events weigh heavily on Twilight Sparkle and Rainbow Dash though they don't know why, at first. The answer comes in their dreams.  · Trinary
    12,154 words · 1,339 views  ·  82  ·  5
  • E Storm on the Prairie

    Set in the Dashverse AU: When Applejack and friends visit her cousin in Appleloosa, she's disturbed to find that Braeburn's been bucking tradition instead of apples.  · Trinary
    19,760 words · 615 views  ·  53  ·  2
  • E Rainbow Rises

    A retelling of the Season 4 episode "Rainbow Falls"  · Trinary
    9,087 words · 983 views  ·  57  ·  1
  • E Wedding Bells Bug Hunt

    Dashverse AU: The Canterlot Wedding is on and a changeling scheme to subvert the Elements of Harmony is underway! Can Rainbow Dash find the imposter?  · Trinary
    86,737 words · 2,961 views  ·  303  ·  15
  • E Rainbow Triumphant

    AU: A retelling of "Sonic Rainboom" episode, set in Dashverse (A universe where Rainbow Dash became Princess Celestia's student. A follow up to "Rainbooms and Royalty")  · Trinary
    39,235 words · 2,628 views  ·  256  ·  7
  • E The Incredibly Cool Godmother of Dinky Doo

    Winningverse: Rainbow Dash is Dinky Doo's godmother and it just hit her how big of a responsibility that is.  · Trinary
    15,073 words · 4,883 views  ·  428  ·  12
  • T Hot Heads, Cold Hearts and Nerves of Steel

    AU Dashverse: The Crystal Empire has returned and the foals of Equestria have gone missing!  · Trinary
    148,560 words · 6,186 views  ·  544  ·  10
  • E Friendship is Empathy

    Twilight Sparkle and Rainbow Dash's friendship is put to the test as past mistakes are dug up.  · Trinary
    12,112 words · 18,988 views  ·  1,326  ·  28

Watching

964 members follow Trinary

Trinary follows 45 members

  • Viewing 90 - 94 of 94
#93 · 7w, 6d ago · · ·

Do you have a certain chronological order for your Dashverse stories? I'd like to read them in the proper order, if at all possible :twilightsheepish:

#91 · 21w, 3d ago · · ·

When you get to the point in the Dashverse where Rainbow becomes a princess, I hope you do a crack-companion story where Twilight still ends up being the one who ascends and everyone is just confused save for a furious Rainbow Dash. Anyway, keep up the good work, AU's centering around the Mane6 being altered in some fashion are some of my favorite stories.

P.S.

Do you know of the AU story where Rarity owns a thrift store and AJ is still a socialite? I believe it was one of those stories where the Rainboom incident didn't happen. Those are the only aspects I remember and I can't find it anywhere. I'm starting to think I'm crazy and just dreamed it all.

  • Viewing 90 - 94 of 94
Login or register to comment