Thanks for the fave on Anything but Textbook!!

IT BEGINS.

Derpy is clearly the Herp of Durr

>>70457045 So it does. My mistake, sorry on that- but that's old hat now. The Mage is no longer Derpy.

Also, I'm not going to be so obvious in my intentions. I've actually decided to make this crossover as newbie-friendly as possible, while still being loaded with enough base-comic referencing to keep the bronystucks entertained. On top of that, I do actually want to try my hand at drawing images to go with the text- that's actually causing some delays, as I don't have, well, ANYTHING that might work with this.

The main thing you should be learning from this is big plans+pitifulPerfectionism make for DEEEEEEEEE-LAAAAAAAAYS.

>>70267026

Alright. I'm just basically brain-storming because that's what I do, I look at every possible outcome and try to find the most likely one.

I got that Derpy was the Mage from this sentence.

""I will do that. Thanks for the mail, Derpy!"

The Mage said her goodbyes, and took off."

Unless Dash takes off (which doesn't happen, she stays in her home) then that sentence implies that Derpy is the Mage, but it could just be a simple grammar mistake.

>>68256825 "Obviously you'll need to invent eight new classes and aspects."

Okay, firstly, Pinkie is NOT the Space Player(though I can see why, and I got it handled), Derpy is NOT the Mage, and only Dash's Father has the power of breath. There are a few other points I disagree with, but those are the most common conceptions/ did I imply Derpy as a Mage? In any case, our opinions on classes overlap a grand total of Twice.

Second, I'm not headcanoning new aspects/titles. That cannot go anywhere productive- Hussie's got most of the best ones taken, and when you said eight of each, my brain wept in a corner of my skull.

Third, Derpy is Derpy, and will be called as such... but Derpy is special, and I don't mean that in the retarded way. I mean that in the awesome way, once *shot*.

Fourth, I'm kinda gonna be sidestepping the whole "gender numbers" thing- but the re-population thing is under control, I'm going to be a little clever in that one. I'm going to flat-out avoid the whole gender-title distribution quarrels, by using the remaining ten. Again, if another boy-specific title comes up, I'm going to be clever.

Fifth, I'm not going over ten characters in this session. I have enough trouble keeping the ten I have constantly relevant in the story so far. Their aspects and titles are pretty much finalised- unless some new canon debunks something I have planned, that's not going to change.

Sixth, I'm not above directly copying someone's title. I'd probably run to the hills with it, honestly.

Seventh, There's already plenty of Troll Romance for my ten ponies to have. Probably already too much- Twilight already has c3< from "Look before you Sleep", and a level of <> with Pinkie (Evidenced in Griffon and Baby Cakes, and requited in Pinkie Keen). And that's just to start.

>>60866086

Well, considering the other Homestuck/MLP crossover out there has troll-like characters, I suggest having just a plain old session involving ponies maybe with the session that created the ponyverse being relevant. Remember that there SHOULD be an equal number of males to females in all S**** sessions, so a 20 player session should work. That would mean that you would have to come up with some OCs.  I guess I could list some of the more obvious background male characters in the show that should definitely be chosen.

-Doctor Whooves (Best Time hero possible unless you want Vinyl Scratch to be the Time hero. A new class would definitely work here, but it HAS to be an active class. )

-Soarin (No clue what his aspect could be. Obviously you'll need to invent eight new classes and aspects.)

-Braeburn (He is the Knight of APPLOOOOOOOSA. Seriously this time, he should be a Knight of (new aspect))

-Stormchaser or whatever his name was from Hurricane Fluttershy.

-Twilight's study partner? I have no clue where this was going in the story, so I dunno his/her gender. (Damnit, English needs gender-neutral pronouns)

-Prince Blueblood (Imagine the shenanigans. Troll jokes, <3< between him and Rarity (This is a ship made for spades.), and he can even be the Prince of Blood or something vague like that.)

And that's pretty much all I can think of in terms of male characters.

Obviously Pinkie is the ? of Space because of the fact that she 'tends to know things she shouldn't', which is a trademark of Space heroes (being awake on Prospit since they were very young. I'd prefer Bard for her class Even though she really isn't that destructive, she breaks the 4th wall all the time which DEFINITELY constitutes destroying and allowing destruction of Space. UU said that Bards are generally a wild card that lead to the end or the success of a session, sometimes both. On the other hand, Bard is supposed to be an exclusively male class, but pretty much ALL sessions have rule breaking in tons of ways. )

Twilight has no definite class that I can make out of her, since you gave Mage to Ditzy Doo (PLEASE, call her that and have Derpy as a nickname. PLEASE.).

Rainbow Dash gets to be the Thief of Breath.  

Applejack can be the... damn I can't think of anything that currently fits her. New class AND aspect time for her.

Rarity can be the Sylph of Heart. If you don't like Heart for her, change it to Sylph of *new aspect*.

Fluttershy damn well is the Maid of Rage.

Vinyl Scratch gets to be the Seer of Void, seeing before or after a hypothetical Scratch, or maybe seeing which choices would lead to having a Scratch become necessary.

Ditzy Doo is obviously the Mage of ?. Maybe a new aspect? I really don't feel like any of the current ones would fit her, except maybe Doom, but Sollux already has Mage of Doom.

Octavia can be the Rogue of Voice or some sound related class.

Lyra can be a new class and aspect.

>>58155815 Short answer is no.

Long answer: Well, in a week my school will be out, and next term is so zetta light, that I can't really see it waiting too much longer... BUT I am trying to make this as complicated as humanely possible, in TRUE homage to the original Homestuck, while creating few OCs.(...Creative interpretations of background characters not included.)

This includes, but is not limited to:

Keeping everyone's characters intact with all the mechanics. (Pinkie Pie's strife specibus, for example, is now so utterly perfect for her...)

Finding good ectobiological parents, in canon.

Having a clear, well-thought out storyline.

Leaving myself open for several more sessions.

The arc numbers 9, 5, and 7, being placed EVERYWHERE.

Good chumhandles!

Weapon names... my god, Twilight's final weapon has a name I am so proud of.

And finally, but most importantly...

"asdhidsefitrs"

Any idea when My Little PonyStuck will have the full release?