In my mind I think that a Nightmare Rarity x Spike shipping story is a classic here, but do you think that I should make a Nightmare Rarity x Spike story myself?

3140931 it depends on how you tackle it.

There's rape, there's redemption and there's him trying to make it work with her being evil, or her making him evil.

3140938 I'm not much of Sexual story kind of guy.

no

go away

3141269 Then that takes out rape. Good.

If you want a place to start that isn't sexual for something representing a precident, you can go ahead and read my story, A Nightmare Rarity Story: A Knight in Shining

Has kind of a sad ending, but there aren't that many Nightmare Rarity stories that aren't dirty, so that's what you get.

Hope it helps

3142404 What!? I think a Nightmare Rarity x Spike shipping is a good one.

3142432 Okay then.