The Wish For Another

by octavia1997

First published

After a long year of living with servants, Vinyl wants to do every thing on her own. Octavia, just wants to be left alone; as she has been in past years. When Vinyl asked Octi for help, what can go wrong? the sad part is, Octi needs more than help.

Not an Octavia and Vinyl shiping fic. It is not like that.

After a long year of living with servants and helpers, Vinyl wants to do every thing on her own. Octi, just wants to be left alone. When Vinyl asked Octavia for help, what can go wrong? oh wait, Vinyl has some other plans for Octavia.

The only problem is... Octavia need some help herself.

edited by: Darian Stephens

The Bridge and the cello

View Online

Just like every other night, Vinyl awoke to the sounds of a cello. The light tone of an ‘F’ sharp entered the room on a silver stroke. Vinyl tried to tune out the noise, but it changed to a higher tone. Probably something on the ‘A’ string. Vinyl pushed herself out of the cozy covers, and started her stroll to the door. Upon opening the door, just as she figured, it stopped. She started to Octavia’s quarters, only to find that she was missing, once again. Vinyl sighed and headed to the stairs. Like every other night, they were darkened and lost in the smothering shadows. She nearly tripped over a step; gracefully catching herself on the guard railing. She pursued the gray mare’s trail. It’s not too hard to follow somepony lugging a hunk of wood and metal around.

The trail lead to the door, it was barely ajar, but open nonetheless. She walked to the door, and started to open it, trying to stay as hidden as possible. The door creaked, but only in small strives and whispers.

Vinyl didn’t really mind getting caught, after all, it wasn’t her fault she woke up. “Geez Octi. You couldn’t have picked a worse time. Last time it was midnight.” she murmured, shuddering as the cold air passed through her fur.

Octavia started to become more and more paced, she started to run, or tried to run; with a cello, nopony could really run. Vinyl just walked her slow pace, knowing where she was going; after ten times of going to the same place, you kinda get used to it; even if you don’t make it all the way. Vinyl had waited for the right time to bring it up, and decided it was time. As soon as she caught Octavia in the act, she would talk to her about it.

Vinyl watched at a distance as Octavia set her cello’s endpin into the rocky base of the hill’s floor. Like any other night, Octavia drew her bow, and laid it on her silver and bronze strings. She started to play a song, a song of pure wonder. Every night it sounded better than the last. She wanted to talk to her, but after every run through of the song, she would play it once more, making it sound of a dying symphony. Like every other night, the song was the same, and never different from the original. Vinyl started to think to herself, Well, maybe I could interrupt her song just this once. Just to talk to her about this. Let’s see
before Vinyl could answer herself, she was drawn in by a new song. This song was so majestic, nopony could fully resist it. Vinyl started to walk up the hill from her hiding spot in the bushes. She started to creep up behind Octavia before reaching the floor she sat on.

With no warning, Vinyl pulled her friend in the biggest hug she could. The sudden grab threw Octavia off, making dropped her cello; ultimately shattering on the rocks below. While Vinyl was rubbing her mane against the soft grey skin of her dear friend, Octavia was mourning over the loss of her wonderful instrument. She was even more depressed than she already was.

Vinyl decided to have the first word, “Oh my gosh! I loved that song so much, what's it called?” She was hugging Octavia even harder, squeezing the air out of her.

Tears entered Octavias eyes, “It was called ‘Waltz no.1’, but now it is gone with the cello.”

Vinyl loosened her grip, “Oh I’m sorry about that. Is there anything I can do to make it up to you?”

Octavia started to walk down the slope to retrieve the remains of her beloved cello, “No, just go home, and, I don’t know, make bass or whatever the hell it is you do.”

Vinyl was sad as well after a mean remark like that, “Okay, I guess. I’ll just wait-”

“No go right now. I don’t need you here, You’ll just break something, again.” She didn’t want Vinyl around anymore.

Vinyl lowered her voice, “Oh okay, I guess. But I can help you get your pieces back, or something-”

Octavia raised her voice some, “No.”

Vinyl was lowering her voice in response, “bu-”

Octi raised her voice, “No!”

vinyl lower her’s once more, “I can help-”

octavia was in full rage, “Nein, gehen Sie weg bereits!”

Vinyl got scared by the long words, and threatening tone, “Okay, suit yourself”

As Octavia started to move down the dew and moss covered cliff side, Vinyl began to walk away. After a minute of going down the cliff side, Vinyl came back and started to watch Octi. Octavia noticed red eyes staring at her from atop the cliff, got scared and lost her balance. Octavia started to plummet to the earth just like her cello a while ago. Vinyl noticed and tried to catch her; she nearly missed, grabbing her hoof in the air with her magic. Octavia was mad, but in no place to complain.

“Well Octavia, aren’t you glad I was here?”
“No, not really.”
“Well, sucks to be you. So why were you going down, anyways?”
“I was going to get something.”
“Get what?”
“A piece of my cello.”
“What piece?”
Octavia let out a sigh “The bridge.”
“You mean that white piece?”
“Yes, it means alot to me. I got it from somepony special.”
“No problame-o. I got this,” Vinyls horn started to light up with a wonderful light blue aura. Out of the deepness of the valley came the entire cello, the bridge held above the rest of the rubble. She dropped everything except the bridge, bringing it close to her face, she started to read what was inscribed on it:

~Ihre Liebe, Silber-String~

Vinyl pushed it into Octavia’s hooves; she held it close to her chest. Vinyl wanted to ask, but was a bit shy, and out of place to be asking. She was hoping Octavia would explain some, easing the stress on the white mare.

Octavia let out a sigh, “So, I guess you want to know what it says, right?”
Vinyl shook her head, “It is up to you; Only if you want to share.”

Octavia started to walk up to Vinyl, she got close enough to her ear to say what she wanted to say, “it said, ‘Your love, Silver String.’ I’d rather not talk about him though.”

“Fine by me girl; So we going back or what?”

“I guess so. I don’t have any reason to stay here. After you, Miss, Scratch.”

Vinyl donned her shades “You know I don’t like it when you do that. Fine Miss. Fancy bowtie... Okay Octi, lets go.”

Morning Surprise

View Online

As Octavia and Vinyl started to walk back to their little cottage, Octavia kept to herself and Vinyl wandered aimlessly, trying to keep in a strait line; drifting to the right, and into Octi’s side. She didn’t seem to mind.;She just got really annoyed, and would push her away, grinning deviously. She had something on her mind, but probly would get lied to once over. Dare she ask, or remain silent and not get an answer. Octavia opened her mouth, but no words arose. Vinyl stopped and grabbed Octi’s tail.

Vinyl started, “Octi, are you sure you are going to be okay? You didn’t seem to well back there.”

She opened her mouth and words entered the air with the wind, “oh, sorry. I don’t know what got over me.”

Vinyl smiled, “Oh that’s okay. Every pony can be like that at times.”

Octavia opened her mouth to ask her housemate what she had longed to ask for, but nothing came out again. She stumbled on her words; she gave up and responded, “Oh, okay.”

Vinyl looked at Octavia and removed her glasses, “Octavia, you thought I was lying. Don’t you?”

Octavia’s eyes started to fill with tears, as she looked into Vinyl’s red eyes.

Vinyl walked closer to her friend, “Well I wasn’t. I liked the song. Not even liked… loved! Don’t you ever doubt me and music.”

Octavia was a bit scared, “Okay.”

Vinyl lunged herself at Octi, and squeezed her once more. This time Octavia embraced the hug and did the same in turn. They hugged for a minute or so, and the tears of Octavia ran down her face onto Vinyl’s white fur; dampening her already chilled neck. Vinyl was the first to try and release, but Octavia held on, and started to cry even more. She tightened her grip around vinyl’s neck and upper body. She started to make words but they died under the sniffle she emulated.

“It’s okay. Vinyl’s got ya.”

Octavia deepened her head into Vinyl’s chest, and started to mumble words. The fur of Vinyl muffled the sounds, silencing her.

“Tavi, are you going to be okay?”

Octi shock her head to say “no”, ruffling her fur.

“Okay I’ll tell you what, when we get home ill make you breakfast. Would you like that?”

Octavia pulled her face out of vinyl, “Please, no.”

Vinyl chucked, “Its too late for that Octi. Common, if you stay out any longer, you’ll catch a cold. Come on, we have to get you inside.”

Octavia pulled her head out of the fur and placed it onto the white mare’s back; walking in sink down the snow covered path, towards the far off cottage of Octavia. The walk didn’t last long, and died after a while. The moon had set and the bright sun rose over the tree line, stretching over the snow of late spring. Vinyl continued walking until they hit their small living quarters. The snow had melted and the water trickled down the front wall. The light reflected off making a small involuntary rainbow reach for the sky. Vinyl smiled and Octavia just pulled her head out of vinyl’s coat and composed herself. The two gazed into the rainbow as it stretched off the wall into the air; dieing short lived.

Vinyl pushed her glasses down and started to approach the door. A note was pinned to the doorway. It was addressed to Octavia Treble Clef. Vinyl undid the tack and took the letter inside. Octavia stared at the wondrous rainbow some more. After a minute or so, Vinyl dragged Octavia in, and sat her at the sofa. She sunk into the soft pillows and silk liner.


The sound of a bell rang five minutes later, Vinyl came out of the kitchen in a soggy, and yellow stained apron. In her hand a plate of pancakes. Atop the decorative stack of black and brown pancakes, were a bottle of maple mare syrup, and a jar of cherries from cherrilie’s farm. Vinyl placed the tray of almost cooked jacks oh the coffee table, and pull Octavia a chair.

Octavia just stared at the average looking meal before her, “So you made breakfast. Is it eatable?”

Vinyl punched Octi’s arm softly, “Ya, I cooked them with a skillet. Are you saying they aren’t any good?”

Octavia felt a little bad, “Oh I guess I could eat some of them, they look…”

“Look what?”

“Just look.” Octavia picked up her fork and a piece of blackened pancake, and brought it to her mouth.

Vinyl stayed intently as she chewed the cake. Octavia stopped and looked back at vinyl, and didn’t do anything. After another minute of staring, vinyl left to get the letter.

When Octavia was abut to spit the under cooked morsel out her mouth a paper hit the back of her head and she swallowed. She tried to cough it up, and started to gag on the batter. Vinyl dropped a letter in from of Octi and hit her on the back, making her ingest the horrible food.

“Soooooo. You got a letter. OPEN IT!!!”

“Geez fine.”

She unrolled the letter and browsed the contents of it. It was brightly written and very hard to read against the brown paper. Octavia started to read aloud:


“dear Octavia T. Clef,

We are inviting you to join us at the apple festival in pony ville and then the cherry festival else where. Im sorry I forget the name sometimes but we hope to see you their. Oh and if vinyl wants to come, please teach her proper manners, and get her a cute bow like yours, she would look nice in one.

Sincerely, lieblos.


P.S. vinyl owes me about ten hugs. I’ll be expecting her.”


Vinyl staied blankly, “Well that was creepy… did you like the pancakes? Want to eat more?”

“No! next time I’ll make breakfast.”