My First Pegasus

by Gruvian Scripts

First published

Jake Silver meets his girlfriend for the first time in person. The catch, she's a rainbow colored pegasus with a rather intimidating sex drive. But, he felt safe nothing too bad would at the movie theater...

Jake Silver is a human whose not had much luck with the ladies. That, all changed after he started dating a girl he met online in a fan forum. The catch was she wasn't exactly human, but a pegasus with a rather high sex drive. He decided to play the date safe, and go to a movie, limiting his rainbow mare-friends options. Or so he thought.


*Author's note: This, is sort of my experiment in the anonymous story. Though, I decided to give him a name, and slight personality. I think I'm going to use this universe for a spinoff sequel if y'all like it.

Chapter 1

View Online

Jake Silver leans against a wall for Starline Cinema. Specifically he is resting in its almost empty parking lot, watching his breath’s frost from the late fall cold. He was wearing a leather jacket, so the cold never bothered him. It wasn’t the stereotypical black biker jacket, though. Just a blue died sports jacket. Even though Jake wasn’t the sports person in high school (or currently college). He just found it efficient at keeping him warm. He, was that kind of glasses wearing dork, which made that night all the more awkward. Jake never expected his first date since grade school to be with an athlete; let alone a pegasus.

To be fair, few expected any interaction with pegasi until three years ago, when gateways to Equestria opened. Sure, it caused a lot of panic and confusion at first, but quickly became… boringly normal. Like if a new micronation popped up in Europe.
Both sides benefiting from cultural exchanges and trade. Contrary to popular belief, magic and science actually got off well. For us, magic helped solve a plethora of energy and environmental issues. For Equestria, we injected them with new creative ideas; most of which were good. One of such developments was the Mphone. A pony copy of smartphones powered by magic. They have great reception.

Jake checked his own phone for the time. His date was already 10min late, but he was not surprised. That’s why he fibbed a little to Rainbow Dash about the movie’s start time. Though known for speed, she was always late. Even on the message boards they met on where she replied with passion, but on a topic everyone else had moved on from.

Jake had taken an interest in Equestrian culture since it’s reveal. How could he not, it was another dimension with sentient ponies. Luckily for him, or more miraculously, the primary language of Equestria was English; albeit not called that. Oddly enough, French existed as a dialect called fancy. This, however allowed him to jump straight into their fiction. Primarily the literary variety. From there he quickly found Daring Doo, which unlike Indiana Jones had more than three good adaptations. His love of Daring Doo led him to bump into Rainbow Dash online, when she was still getting used to the online thing. Magic helped with that, but only to a certain degree. Their interactions didn’t start off smooth partially because of that, and also because of differing opinions on the books. However, over months, they started warming up to each other. And one day, she just sent him a private message from her Mphone, “want to talk about something else? Dork ;p”

A sudden whoosh snapped Jake out from his trip down memory lane. He found a slightly out of breath rainbow pegasus standing behind him, still in the middle of an apparent hero landing, with a smirk on her face.

“Just on time,” Rainbow Dash said boastfully.

“If on time, you mean 15 minutes late,” Jake said sarcastically, holding out his phone’s clock.

Rainbow Dash glanced away, and started scratching the back of her head.

“Yeah, well. You were waiting on me, and I’m here. Therefor I’m on time.”

Jake chuckled, trying, and failing to hold back his laughter.

“Did you even buy that excuse?”

Rainbow caught his laughter, and joined in. Her cheeks blushing.

“No. But worth a shot. And besides...”

Rainbow Dash flew up into the air to eye level with Jake. Before he had a chance to respond the pegasus had planted a kiss on his lips. Her, tongue following her lips lead until Jake started to loose balance, and stumbled back onto the wall as Rainbow pulled away.

“I have ways of making it up,” Rainbow said with a devilish grin.

Even though this was there first time meeting in person, or pony, he wasn’t too surprised by Rainbow’s kiss. He’s sort of had time to adjust to having a pegasus as a lover. Though, her lips and fur were warmer than he expected. And while being a long distance relationship, it had developed pretty far, and pretty fast. It all started to get, that deep, with what he thought was an innocent question.

“What is sexting?,” Rainbow texted Jake.

He blushed at the question, and was glad she was not there to see or hear his response. IM messages helped filter out most of his awkward um’s.

“Why do you ask?” Jake managed to reply.

“Just keep hearing about it. Keeps getting treated like a plague by squares.”

Jake had paused in thought. Trying to come up with a least offensive response as possible. He didn’t want Rainbow to think he was a pervert or anything.

“It’s… It’s when couples send photos to each other... Pornographic photos.”

Jake swallowed as he hit send, and nervously waited for a reply. He was soon met with a LOL emoji that caught him off guard.

“That’s all?” Rainbow Dash texted after her emoji.

“Yes...”

Rainbow Dash sent a devil emoji, and Jake sighed. She took it a lot better than he thought. Well, more humorous and not serious. Rainbow then sent a photo reply from her Mphone, and Jake fell out of his computer chair.

Rainbow Dash had sent a mirror selfie from her bathroom (he hoped) with the focus clearly on her exposed flank. Her tail lifted to the right giving a clear view of her sex. An especially good look with one wing stretching back her pussy, and revealing contrasting pink amongst her blue fur. Rainbow Dash completed the photo by sticking her tongue out, clearly directed at him.
A new message notification grabbed his attention.

“Having fun?”

Jake composed himself enough to be a little more bold in his reply. It was his turn for a little bit of humor.

“Not yet. But maybe soon. ;)”

Jake stretched out his arms, and cracked his knuckles. Proud he too can tangle with dirty humor. His confidence soon ended with Rainbow’s next reply.

“Oh? Then make sure to send me photos when you are,” Rainbow replied. Ending with another devil emoji.

“Oh, gosh we’re sexting,” Jake mumbled aloud to himself, pale as a ghost.

The usher didn’t give them any odd looks when they bought their tickets and popcorn. Ponies were not too uncommon anymore. Especially in theaters; Equestians loved movies. However, it was a just before midnight screening. Anything short of an alien invasion wouldn’t get the usher to raise an eyebrow away from the magazine he was reading.

“I take it we’re sharing the popcorn,” Jake asked rhetorically as they passed through the theater doors.

Rainbow Dash flew up, and snatched a hoof full of popcorn.

“Not that there will be much sharing,” Rainbow dash said as she threw the popcorn into her mouth with a devilish grin. “I love salty food.”

Jake gulped.

Rainbow Dash really did embody the devil emoji she so often sent post sexting. After the initial photo, Dash only grew more bold in her efforts. First it was just a few photos of her pussy and ass that she’d send to him, usually at the worst of times. He regretted being so open with his schedule.

Her bathroom was the most common location though. Whether it be the shower, toilet, or mirror. She tended to alternate between them. Though her favorite trend quickly became masturbating. Usually with her hoofs or wings, but on occasion with a stallion and human dildo shaped dildo. She learned to set her Mphone for a timed photo, and deliver true photos of herself mid orgasm. While not the best framed, and focused, this delivered veeery natural photos of a mare’s pleasure habits. Which, Jake prefered, and enjoyed.

The sexting went both ways with his enjoyment leading to hers. Rainbow, liked to see Jake’s cock right after he cummed. She, soon encouraged him for a live show. It was incredibly awkward for him to perform while under her webcam gaze, but he pushed through. It helped that halfway through, Rainbow decided to join the fun.

The movie was a newish animated feature. One both Jake and Rainbow had already seen. Normally this might be considered bad, but for a first in person/ pony date, it allowed a lot more talking. Especially when they were the only two in the theater. Though, it was less talking, and more witty commentary. Jake tending to focus more analytically, and Rainbow Dash more... emotionally. Specifically poking fun at the film and Jake’s attempts at humor at the film. That said, she loved the movie. Which is why she delayed trying anything else until it was halfway over.

It was when the main duo in the film had to investigate an, “all natural,” yoga class that Rainbow decided to make her move. The instructor just stretched in a rather explicit way (if the film had shown genitalia, which it being a PG film, it didn’t). Nonetheless, Rainbow leaned over to Jake’s ear as he was eating popcorn.

“Getting excited?” Rainbow whispered suggestively.

“Huh, uh yeah...” Jake replied not yet catching on.

“What if I, reenacted the scene for you in our next session?” Rainbow asked with her lips tickling Jake’s ear. “Or now?”

Jake immediately started coughing/choking on popcorn as his brain went into overdrive trying to process what was going on. However, Rainbow’s gaze remained fixed on his crotch. It twitched twice as a noticeable bulge started to form. Jake immediately attempted to hide it by crossing his legs. Rainbow Dash just chuckled at the failed effort.

“Don’t be so embarrassed, I’ve already seen your cock.” Rainbow said as she not so gently punched Jake on his shoulders.

Jake blushed as he rubbed his sore shoulder. His legs, loosening up slightly.

“But, we’re in public.”

Rainbow glances back casually.

“Really? Looks like a private screening to me.”

Jake looked around the theater, panicked. Looking for an excuse to object to what he knew was coming, while hoping to find nothing. Jake gulped when he realized his hopes appeared answered.

“So, want me to help with your little friend?” Rainbow said as she leaned heavily on Jake’s shoulder.

“Y, ye… yes!?”

“Good.” Rainbow said with a devilish grin.

Rainbow Dash changed positions in her seat, moving her front hooves over their shared armrest, and taking hold of Jake’s fly. While the theaters audio was fully functionally, his zipper seemed to echo as Rainbow opened his barn door. Rainbow giggled.

“Now, do me a favor, and relax. Just watch the movie.”

Jake nodded, and glanced back to the screen. His body trembling with fear and excitement. While he tried to follow her command, his mind was sharply focussed on the sensation of Rainbow’s hoof worming its way through his boxers. It quickly reached its target, and gripped. Jake flinched. Not because of the force, but how soft it felt. It wasn’t like what he expected a hoof to feel like. It was… warm and spongy beneath her blue fur. Jake squeezed the unused arm rest to his right. Trying not to look, or to be overwhelmed.

Rainbow Dash soon popped his erection free from his boxers clutches. Jake didn’t see it, but Rainbow Dash licked her lips. This was going to be more fun than she had ever imagined. Wasting no time, she started stroking his cock up in down as it stood exposed in the theater’s cold air.

“Your favorite scene is coming up, right?” Rainbow whispered in Jake’s ear.

“On, one of them.” Jake stuttered as his mind grew dizzy with pleasure.

“Oh? Well, let's try making it number one for you then.”

Without warning, Rainbow Dash leaned down and kissed Jake’s lower head; tasting a drop of precum. She kissed his cock a second time, but this time kept going lower, and lower. Her lips swiftly enveloping his whole cock with her warmth. Jake fell backward into his chair, letting out a moan of pleasure as he gasped for air. After recovering, slightly, he finally broke his promise, and turned his gaze back to Dash as her tongue squirmed around his member. Some drool dripping down from her lips and onto his pants. Normally the thought of saliva disgusted him, so much. He, didn’t consider himself a germ freak, but did always carry around a bottle of hand sanitizer. Which confused him all the more as to why the sight was turning him on so much.

“Oh cheese and crackers,” Jake managed to blurt out.

Rainbow pulled her lips free from his erection with a coy grin, dripping with pre-cum and saliva.

“Let’s test out your endurance.”

Rainbow Dash leans further over the armrest, and slides his cock in all the way to its base. She lifts her head back as she sucks him out. She stops at his head, and swirls it about in her mouth with her tongue before submerging his full length again.

Jake squeezes the other armrest in joyful shock. He, never expected it to feel this good. The warmth was overwhelming, and completely different from when he masturbates. The warmth and moisture helped with this, but what was causing him to moan the most was the sensation of not being in control. Not knowing where Rainbow was going. Yet, trusting in her.

Rainbow could feel Jake fidgeting. This only served to turn her on more, and she was already moist. She wasn’t in heat yet, but the unique musk of a human’s cock right in her face, its taste, and the adorkable virgin trembling in her grasp. Giving a blowjob in public was also a contributing taboo factor. However, she knew her new lover well enough to know he was close. So she decided to push him over the edge. Her pace increased as she submerged his erection faster and faster. Each time with a louder sploshing sound as her drool and his pre-cum just kept build up and spilling out from her lips. Her tongue no longer content with being left out started swirling around his shaft each time.

Jake jolted in his seat as his hand continued to dig deeper into his free armrest as he tried to hold himself back. It was a futile battle, doomed for failure, yet he fought on all the same. He didn’t want to disappoint Rainbow. Jake started humming an obnoxious radio jingle in his head as he focused his attention fully on the feature film. Forcing himself to watch the false climax. Yet, it was a doomed battle of endurance. Jake jolted again, and let out a gasp.

Rainbow caught on to Jake’s signals almost immediately. She pulled out his cock, all except for the head which her tongue did the final touches on. Rainbow enjoyed deep throating, but never liked a stallion going off directly into her throat. Then, Jake’s cum rolled over her tongue building up with is first wave before she swallowed. She then let the rest of his cum build up in her mouth. Then, once his cock stopped twitching, she slowly pulled her head free of his head with an audible pop that left a few drips of cum on her lips as she swallowed. She chuckled slightly as she laid eyes on her new lovers adorkable freshly spent face. Jake’s head leaned back in his chair as his brain played catchup.

“You lasted longer than most stallions. That should prove, fun, for both of us.”

“Um, thanks...” Jake said as he blushed and glanced away. “I… hope it didn’t taste that bad”

“Oh?”

Rainbow Dash tossed a kernal of popcorn into her mouth, with an audible crunch.

“Like I said, I like salty food.”

Rainbow swallowed the combination of leftover cum and popcorn as Jake gulped in fearful lust.
Rainbow then stretched her wings and legs before hovering out from her chair. She flew past Jake, and let her tail brush under his chin seductively.

“I’m going to, freshen up in that family bathroom. You’re free to join me, after you clean up your mess.”

Jake looked down to his semi-flaccid penis dripping with cum and pegasus drool. He blushed and quickly tucked his member back away as Rainbow disappeared into the shadows.

Interspecies sex had become oddly common after trade and travel relations eased. Equestrians were rather open to their sexuality, especially when in heat. Some theorized this was due Equestria being filled with many different types of sentient creature. So a pony loving a human was not any stranger than a pony loving a dragon. Overtime humans adjusted as well; especially the youth. Both Equestrians and humans took advantage of the zero risk of pregnancy for long, entertaining evenings. Not that Jake had any experience on that matter. His school focus had, left him in experienced with this, and most aspects of love. A fact Rainbow Dash loved taking advantage of.

Jake hesitated as his hand stood inches away from the family bathroom door. His, mare friend waiting on the other side, and much more prepared for what was to come. He let out a sigh, depressed at that fact, yet more at ease because of it. He knocked, causing a chuckle to emanate from the other side.

“Why’d you knock?” Rainbow whispered through the door.

Jake glanced to his sides to find the deserted hall, still deserted. With a gulp, he pushed open the door to find darkness.

“Light switch is to the right of the door.” Rainbow whispered in the abysis.

Jake shut the door, and clicked the lock. He felt his hand up to the light switch, and flipped it. The fluorescent lights flickered on, and Jake’s back hit the door as he jolted. His glasses falling slightly down his nose.

Rainbow Dash rested on a closed toilet seat with her front hooves folded comfortably on its surface. Her rear laid exposed with her tail swishing back and forward occasionally. Regardless of which side her tail swayed, her whole sex was exposed and pulsing.

“I… I thought you said you weren't in heat?”

“Oh, I’m not. We’d not even make it to the bathroom if I were.” Rainbow said with a devilish grin. “My marehood just looks forward to you repaying my affection.”

Jake approaches Rainbow. His heart a flutter with uncertainty. He’d, never done stuff like this to a regular girl. Now, he’s jumping straight to a technicolor alien. Well, Captain Kirk would be proud, he thought to himself.

Jake bent down on his knees as he reached his waiting mare. Her tail flickering across his chest as it switched sides again. Luckily for Jake’s knees, the family bathroom was always kept more clean. But, he wouldn’t have cared regardless, as his mare friend’s sex radiated heat before his face. Jake was human, so lacked an Equestrian’s nose, but even he could smell a hint of Rainbow’s warm musky scent.
Rainbow giggled as she watched her boyfriend stare in a trance at her rear. A bit of which reflected in his glasses. Years ago, Rainbow would have never gone out with such a dweeb. But, thanks to a certain former unicorn, she found adorkableness turns her on as well. Not that she won’t still take advantage of the Wonderbolt’s shared changing rooms, on occasion.

“Like what you see?” Rainbow asked with a slight shake of her rear.

Jake shook his head as he snapped out from his trance. He raised his right hand towards Rainbow’s honeypot, but froze it less than an inch away.

“Um...” Jake began with a gulp. “Do, do you want me to use my hands, or… or tongue.”

Rainbow Dash chuckled.

“What is with you nerds and trick questions.”

Rainbow Dash pushed her rear back, guiding the tips of Jake’s right hand into her pussy’s folds.

“The obvious answer is both.”

Jake took a deep breath. He knew he had to stop hesitating, and man up. For himself and his hot mare-friend. So, it was time to put his research to work.

Jake spread Rainbow’s pussy with his index and middle finger; sending a shudder down her spine. He opened and closed his fingers, and her sex. Moisture building each time. Jake quickly switched hands, letting his left thumb and index finger hold open Rainbow’s sex. His right hand took a finger pointing position, with his index and middle joined, and nearing Rainbow’s not so rainbow, pink pussy. Rainbow Dash started breathing heavily.

“Glad you're starting to enjoy this--” Rainbow was cut off by a soft moan of pleasure as Jake’s middle and index fingers penetrated her.

Rainbow Dash squirmed as Jake pulled out his fingers. He briefly adjusted his aim, then slammed home again. This time, his fingers going the full length in with his knuckles dripping with Rainbow’s juices. He spread his fingers apart within her, and felt around her love hole. Jake pulled his fingers out slowly, then placed a hand on each side of her pussy. His right, dripping with Rainbow’s juices as they dribbled down her ass and leg. Rainbow blushed as she glanced back.

“What’s, the hold up?”

Jake replied without words as his hands stretched Rainbow open, and his tongue dived into her folds. Rainbow struggled to stand, even though her front half was firmly secured on the toilet seat. She never expected him to be this bold, so soon.

Jake’s tongue swirled around inside Rainbow. He only paused ever so briefly to change position with one hand now fingering her clit as he continued to eat her out. Lap after lap, Jake tasted Rainbow’s growing arousal. Her sweet, salty juices flowed down his throat when not splattered across his face. He closed his eyes to focus on the task at hand, so this didn’t prove a problem.

Rainbow Dash breathes heavily. Her head turned away from Jake to hide her level of arousal. However, Rainbows short moans between deep breaths betrayed her desires. She bit her lip in a last bit of effort to hold herself back.
Jake curled his tongue in Rainbow’s pussy as he drove it as far as anatomy would allow. This resulted in Rainbow squirming.

“Ah… buck.” Rainbow whimpered as her whole body trembled.

Jake pulled his head back slightly as Rainbow cummed. Some of which squirted onto and steamed up one side of his glasses. He took off, and whipped off his glasses while still watching Rainbow. Dash’s rear legs buckled briefly while her body finished squirming from her orgasm. Her juices continued to spill on the floor. Rainbow Dash panted as she glanced back at her new boyfriend.

“Not… bad, for a newbie.”

It was Jake’s turn to grin mischievously, satisfied in her satisfaction. Dash just found him more adorkable as her juices dripping down his face sort of ruined the image he was going for. However, that was not the only thing she noticed. Rainbow blushed. Not from embarrassment, but lust.

“Well, it’s good to know you enjoyed it as well,” Rainbow purred as she glared at Jake’s new tent in his pants.
Jake’s eyes followed Rainbow’s gaze, and he jolted to cover his hard on. Unintentionally smearing some of Rainbow’s cum on his pants. Rainbow simply chuckled, and shook her flank slightly.

“So, ready for round three?”
Jake gulped, and nodded slowly. Rainbow adjusted her front half into a more comfortable position. Her rear tilted up slightly, still spasming from her last orgasm.

Jake unzipped his pants, and pulled his throbbing erection free from his underwear. He then reached into his pocket, and pulled out a condom with a shaky hand. Jake started to unseal the condom, and Rainbow responded with a chuckle.

“You know that's not needed with me.”

“Um, yeah...” Jake began with a nervous stutter in his voice. “But, but I hear this makes it less, messy?”

“Oh?”

Rainbow Dash stretched herself up from her throne, and tilted her flank back. She rubbed Jake’s erection around her vulva, still dripping with her pleasure.

“I thought you knew I like things, messy.”

Rainbow lowered herself back into a comfortable position, but with her flank tilting ever so slightly back and forward as her sex winked at him. The condom fell onto the ground, into one of Rainbow’s love puddles.

Jake rubbed his left hand up Rainbow’s flank, and positioned it for stability above her hindquarters. His right hand helped stabilize his erection as he leaned in towards Rainbow. Rainbow teasingly pulled her flank away. She stuck her tongue out playfully. Jake scooted himself closer. His hand positioning his cock right up against Rainbow’s winking pussy. Then, without warning, Rainbow slammed her flank back, taking in Jake’s full length in one go; along with a few fingers from his right hand.

Rainbow shuttered. It had been awhile since her last time. A whole week in fact. Jake was, far from as endowed as a stallion, but he still managed to scratch her itch better than expected. She bit her lip to hold back her own moans. Those boring textbooks were correct. A human’s anatomy was perfectly sized to hit a mare’s G-spot.

In contrast, Jake made no such effort to hide his moans of pleasure. Well, whimpers were more correct. Rainbow’s boldness caught him off guard, now his cock burned in the best way imaginable. However, he had a job to do. Jake shook his head to focus, then pulled his lower head back, to where only the tip tickled Rainbow’s folds. Then, he made his plunge, with an audible sploosh. Rainbow’s body jolted forward, wings springing open, and body quivering in ecstasy. Her rear hooves scraping against the floor struggling to stand.

“Not, bad,” Dash managed to exhale between breaths.

Jake didn’t want to lose the initiative, and placed both his hands up on Rainbow’s flank, and proceeded to buck her faster and faster. Each time his cock all but fully leaving her love hole, being tempted with the cool air outside, then plunged back into her fiery hot insides. Again, and again he felt this overwhelming contrast with fluids gushing out each time. Each jolt of pleasure that brought him closer, left him leaning more and more on Rainbow’s flank. Rainbow in contrast was getting more and more sprawled out on the toilet seat. Her body and mane growing more and more unstable and distraught as her lust grew. Jake couldn’t see it as his eyes were closed, but Rainbow had started to drool. She never had sex before that bucked her G-spot so directly, and rapidly.

“Dash, I’m...” Jake began, unable to finish before he finished.

Jake’s body jolted, causing him to almost collapse on his date. He was only able to let out a short moan before his white seed started shooting deep inside Rainbow’s pussy. The distinct, and thick stream subtlely tickled Rainbow’s insides they way a stallion's gushing torrents never would. This pushed Rainbow over the edge. Her wings shot outward again as her whole body trembled and jerked upward. This unfortunately combined with their fluids soaked floor, and her partner’s exhaustion to create a quite literally tipping point as Rainbow tumbled back onto Jake. They slammed into the floor in a reverse cowgirl position as Jake finished cumming.

“Ouch.” He managed to say with a sarcastic charm that unfortunately was lost on Rainbow amidst her orgasm.
Then, almost immediately, Rainbow’s spasming wings and body went limp. Her elbows propped herself up on the toilet with her body relaxed, while she caught her breath. Her juices still continued to soak Jake’s cock and pants.
“Sa… sorry...” Rainbow managed to gasp as she glanced backward.

Rainbow proceed to lift herself off of Jake. Normally, she would fly up, but her wings were still numb. Jake’s cock popped out from Rainbow’s sex covered in a mix of their cum. Her pussy continued to wink at Jake, and spill out their juices.
“I, suppose a public bathroom wasn't the best place for our first time.”


The bathroom door creaked open as Jake peeked outside. He checked both sides, then signalled his mare-friend behind him. Rainbow proceeded to burst out from the bathroom door, and nearly knock her boyfriend over. It took them a while to, dry off, before they could leave the bathroom. Rainbow didn’t mind the cramped space when she was distracted, but quickly grew stir crazy otherwise. Luckily for both, the bathroom had a hand dryer with a flexible head which sped up making Jake’s pants not look like he wet himself multiple times.

“So...” Rainbow asked Jake flirtatiously as she landed on the theater floor.

“So?”

“So how was it, cheery boy.”

Jake blushed, and looked away.

“It… it was nice.”

“Oh. Only nice?”

Rainbow hovered into the air and leaned on Jake’s shoulder. She placed her lips right next to Jake’s right ear.

“We’ll have to do better than that, at my place.”

Rainbow Dash kissed Jake on his cheek, adding a little bite to its end.