You Face Against Nightmare Moon
Deep in the dark castle of the Two Sisters the evil Nightmare Moon was sat on her throne laughing maniacally. Below her hooves Twilight Sparkle, Applejack, Fluttershy, Rarity, Pinkie Pie and Rainbow Dash were bound in dark purple chains.
The elements struggled to free themselves from the magical chains wrapped around their bodies.
"Mwahahaha! There is no escape! The night shall last forever!" she boomed in a loud voice.
"Noooo! Do you realize without sunlight the entire world shall become a lifeless, barren icy rock floating in space?!" Fluttershy cried out in anguish, with tears streaming down her cheeks.
The mad mare merely continued to laugh maniacally. "Yes! The night shall last forever!"
"Yeah! We’re all gonna starve to death if we can’t grow anything!" roared Applejack.
"These chains are so unfashionable!" wailed Rarity in grief as tears flowed down her cheeks.
"Seriously?!" roared Rainbow Dash.
"Yeah! How can you worry about fashion in a time like this?!" shouted Twilight as she glared daggers at the wailing Rarity.
"Oh, who will save us from these horrible chains?!" Rarity screamed.
"Our new human friend Anony will!" shouted Pinkie Pie with a look of proud determination on her face.
There was a long awkward silence, before everyone burst out laughing hysterically. Pinkie Pie on the other hand looked hurt.
"Oh Pinkie, that’s a good one!" said Rainbow Dash as she wiped a tear from her eye.
"What?! I’m being serious! You’ll see, Anon will save us!" she yelled as she looked at Dashie with narrowed eyes.
"Oh please, we y'all know Anon is a nice pon--- humane. But he’s underpowered. He can’t hope to defeat an overpowered alicorn!" said Applejack.
"Hey that’s not nice! How many times has Anony given you a belly rub?!" she shouted angrily.
"Like I said, he’s a real nice humane. But he ain't no hero."
Suddenly Pinkie Pie’s tail twitched, before a moment later the large double door from across the hall opened. In which you the human walked in dressed in a fine black tuxedo.
"Yay Anony is here to save us!" shouted Pinkie Pie excitedly with her eyes sparkling in joy.
Nightmare Moon’s horn flashed placing duct tape on all their mouths. Before she turned to roar at you in a loud booming voice. "What is the meaning of this?! How dare you ent…., " her eyes widen in shock.
"Wait! Are you a human?!" she shouted in a shocked voice.
"How did you--" you began, before she cut you off.
"Oh please, you humans seem to randomly teleport into Equestria every few centuries," she said as she waved her right hoof nonchalantly as she rolled her eyes.
"Now, approach handsome human. So I may have a better look at you!" she added as she looked at you with bedroom eyes.
The elements exchanged looks of confusion. Apart from Pinkie Pie who had a look of hope in her teary eyes. Nightmare Moon smiled broadly once the human stood before her.
"So, what is your name, handsome human?" she said in a most unusual soft voice.
"My name is Anon. I hope we can be friends."
"Hah! Friends?! The last human I met one thousand years ago said we were friends with benefits! But we never had any butt fun together!" she roared angrily.
"Oh Luna, he sounds awful!" you said in a shocked voice.
"Luna? I don’t go by that name anymore! I am Nightmare Moon!" she bellowed in rage as lightning struck from behind her.
"You’ll… you’ll always be my Luna," you said in a low voice as you looked down sadly.
"What?! You swear you already know me?!" she said with wide eyes in shock.
"I do! You are best pony! Every night when I felt lonely I dreamt of you. I dreamt that I was cumming inside your amazing, big fat royal pony butt," you spoke in a low voice as you stared at her with a look of hopelessness in your eyes, some tears falling down your cheeks. "I know I can save you. I know deep down, the mare I love is still in there."
A bright blush briefly appeared on her cheeks, before being drowned out in her anger.
"Lies!" she roared as her eyes glowed bright red in rage. "You are just like the last human I met! A rude fopdoodle! Who only pretended to be my friend! Just so he could get close to my sister Celestia and cum inside her butt!"
"No! I love your butt!" you shouted with your hands in the air.
"Lies! You love my sister's butt more than mine! You find it superior to my bony thin butt!" she roared as she slammed her hoof down, thus she created a large crack in the floor.
"My butt is far too small! You probably already fucked my sister’s butt! Oh, how she loves to keep all the nice human phallus to herself," she added, grumbling.
You placed a hand on your chest with a look of hurt in your eyes. "I never came inside Celestia’s butt! Your butt is superior! I love you Luna and nopony else!" you shouted as you gave her an imploring look.
"Lies! All the handsome humans love my sister’s bigger and fatter rump!" she roared as tears fell down her cheeks
"No. I love your butt Princess Luna. I dreamed of it every night. Your butt is my moon! For the moon outshines the sun," you said softly, staring deep into her eyes.
For a brief second, you could have sworn she looked at you with bedroom eyes.
"Nu-no!" she said in a low voice, just before she began shouting once again. "Even if that were the case! Surely you don’t love my butt now?!" she bellowed in rage.
"Not true. I know deep down the mare I loved and masturbated to every night is still in there," you said in a pleading tone as you stared deeply into her eyes.
"But I’m ugly now! You can’t love a monster like me!" she screamed, tears falling down her cheeks.
"Nonsense! You got the best glorious fat royal booty,“ you said as you walked toward her with your arms outstretched.
“Stop it Anon! You’re lying to me!“ she roared as her horn flared with deadly magic."I will kill you now and--Hmm!?” you cut her off when you wrapped your arms around her and kissed her passionately.
You pressed your lips into her shocked pony mouth, swirling your tongue around her huge alicorn tongue, gently caressing it. A moment later she wrapped her hooves around you as she began to moan sensually, returning the kiss.
Time seemed to slow down as you and Nightmare Moon passionately kissed. Tears of joy began to fall down her cheeks.
However, eventually she slowly parted lips with you.
"Did you really mean all that? You think my butt is superior?" she said in a low, soft voice that could put Fluttershy to shame.
"Yes, my sweet Luna. Your butt is the most superior butt," you said softly as you stared deeply into her eyes. Eyes that were now sparkling in joy and becoming teal colored.
"Oh Anon!" she screamed in happiness as she hugged you close.
Suddenly there was an explosion of rainbow light, followed by the shadowy avatar of Nightmare Moon being rejected out from her body.
"Noooooooooooo! Curse you Anon!" Nightmare Moon screamed as she faded away into nothing.
The elements, now free of their magical chains and duct tape cheered when they saw that the alicorn now holding you was Princess Luna.
"Yay! Luna is back!" shouted Pinkie Pie.
And then there was a blinding flash of light, followed by the appearance of Princess Celestia standing next to you.
"Anon, you have saved my sister with your human handsomeness! How can I ever repay you?" she said in a soft voice as a warm smile formed on her lips.
"To tap your sister's sweet ass," you said as you gave her a nasty grin.
"Huzzah!" shouted Luna excitedly as she clapped her hooves together.
"Princess Luna," she said in a serious tone. "It is been a thousand years since I have seen you like this. Time to put our differences behind us. We were meant to have sex with handsome humans together, little sister. Not fight over them."
"Sister?! Will you accept a threesome with handsome human?" she stood up, magically levitating you onto her back, before she embraced her sister. "I'm so sorry! I missed you so much, big sister!" she said with tears in her eyes.
"I've missed you, too. We shall have sex with the human together!" she said as she looked at you with bedroom eyes.
"Hey! You know what this calls for? An orgy!" shouted Pinkie Pie with her hooves in the air.
And then you had sex with the two immortal alicorn sisters along with Twilight Sparkle, Applejack, Fluttershy, Rarity, Pinkie Pie and Rainbow Dash. The other six ponies all became immortal alicorns when you came inside each one.
The End