I sat down across from her and settled an illusion across myself, my thestral traits fading into those of a pegasus.
I looked at her with a small smile before letting them fade away again.
Fluttershy seemed to shrink in on herself, taking up as little space as possible in her throne but her illusion faded away as well as she hid behind her mane.
Seeing her like this…
It was honestly agonizing.
Lighting my horn, my headache increased but I ignored it as I cast a bubble of sound and sight around the entire room. “There,” I finally said, “Now nopony can hear us. Anyone looking in, will just see us talking normally”
She just nodded slightly.
I took a deep breath, “I know the you in the other world,” I told her quietly but seriously, “And so does Midn- Twilight.”
“S-she… k-knows?”
“She knows,” I confirmed, “And she doesn't care. You can talk to her, Fluttershy.”
Fluttershy closed her eyes tightly, taking deep breaths before she let them out again and nodded, “I-I understand.”
Thestrals lived like this here still. Afraid of discovery.
It made me…
Furious. More than furious.
“No pony else knows here,” I said, “Well… Spike knows, but you can trust him to keep it a secret until you want it known.”
Fluttershy’s eyes went wide.
“Not that you have to unless you want to,” I quickly said and stepped up, putting my hoof on her throne, looking up at her, “Fluttershy, you’re not alone. There are thousands of batponies in Equestria.”
That really got her attention and she met my eyes for the first time, “T-thousands?”
“Thousands,” I told her seriously, “Where I’m from, we have joined together and formed a village. Nocturnis. A place where batponies can live in peace, without needing to hide.”
Fluttershy swallowed and looked down at her hooves again, “That… sounds nice,” she said quietly.
“I can also tell you that the Fluttershy I know there, all her friends know. None of them care either,” I told her gently, “I don’t think they would here, either.”
Fluttershys illusion instantly went back up.
…Fluttershy…
I took a small step back, “Just… know you’re not alone, Fluttershy,” I told her, “remember that. And that you can trust your friends with anything.”
Then I turned to walk out.
“P-Prince Page?”
I looked back at her at the sound of her quiet voice, “Yes?”
“A-an entire village?”
I nodded, “An entire village,” I confirmed, “We created one. Gathered every thestral that wanted to come. Thousands did.”
Fluttershy swallowed and nodded, “T-thank you.”
I smiled at her and then I left the bubble, canceling it as I did before pushing the door open to see everypony but Pinkie waiting there.
I paused and then shook my head, “Relax, I just let her look at me until she calmed down and answered any questions she had,” I told them with a smile, “I know I can look scary.”
“Oh,” Rainbow said, “Why didn’t you just say so!” and then trotted past me back inside.
Applejack and Rarity followed her but Midnight paused as she watched me, “Go on girls, “she said, “I’ll catch up in a minute.”
As they returned inside, Midnight wrapped us into a bubble of silence, “Are you okay?” she asked softly, putting her hoof on my shoulder..
I shook my head, “Not sure I am. Seeing her like that again… it hurts.”
“I know,” Midnight admitted, “I had gotten used to how she is at ho-”
She broke off and shook her head, “...When did I start thinking about it as home…”
“I’d say when you and Tempest became a thing,” I told her quietly.
“Tempest,” she said quietly and sniffed slightly, “She must be so worried.”
I pulled her into a hug.
###
I looked out over Ponyville in the light of the moon, watching from a balcony facing the small village.
I was in a different universe. It was just starting to sink in.
This was… actually not a new experience for me, but this time there was a chance for me to go back so I didn’t panic.
I trust Midnight.
I trust Midnight. I trust Midnight to find a way back because I sure as hell couldn't do it on my own.
I trust Midnight.
I closed my eyes tight. I trust Midnight. I’ll see everypony again. I’ll get back home.
I’ll get back home.
I trust Midnight.
“Prince Page?”
Blinking my eyes open, I turned to look back to see Princess Celestia approach across the room. A pair of guards stopped outside as the door closed behind her.
It was… so strange. She was Celestia. She looked identical to Sunshine. But she wasn’t. It was the eyes.
She didn’t look at me like Sunshine did.
“Princess Celestia,” I greeted her in turn, turning go give her a small bow, “I didn’t think you were still in Ponyville.”
“I was not, I returned just before sunset,” Celestia said, “I wanted to meet you in person. When you are lucid.”
I nodded and smiled up at her, “It’s night,” I said, “I would have expected Princess Luna.”
Celestia smiled back sadly, “We decided I would meet you. Considering what Twilight said, meeting me would be easier for you than my sister. You are married to her in your world?”
“I am,” I agreed, “And… you’re right, thank you.”
That would have been difficult. This was hard enough as is.
Celestia regarded me for a long moment, “...But not as much easier as I expected,” she said quietly, “Your Celestia and you…”
“No,” I said and took a deep breath, looking away, “Sunshine and I never… it’s complicated.”
“But you love her.”
I shifted my wings before I looked up at her again, “It’s complicated. We’re so far apart, she is in Canterlot with Luna, I am in Nocturnis. She is of the day, I am of the night. Being that far away from my Luna is hard enough.”
Celestia slowly nodded as she walked up to look out over the village next to me, “Twilight told me of your Thestrals,” she said, “I… had no idea there were so many left. Do you believe there are so many here as well?”
“Nothing I’ve seen says otherwise,” I said and turned to look out next to her.
She was silent for several long moments, “Is there something we can do to help them?”
I didn’t answer for several long moments, putting my hoof on the railing before I looked up at her, “I think… that they may just want to get away from the light. They don’t want your help. All they want is a place to feel safe, a place away from being afraid.”
“You blame me.”
“No,” I told her, turning to look up at her, “I know you and Luna did everything in your power for everypony in Equestria, Thestrals or not. I don’t even blame other ponies. It’s just their nature to be fearful of those that are different. But I know many of my bats do.”
Celestia looked at me for several moments, “Prince Page,” she said a bit firmed this time, “I think you underestimat-”
“What would happen if I walked into Ponyville tomorrow?” I asked, cutting her off, meeting her eyes, “I may not know you, Princess, but I Know You. I know that the pony that forged Equestria despite the resistance, through steel, fire and willpower is not deluded enough to think there will be any other result than panic.”
Princess Celestia, alicorn of the Sun, actually took a step back, flinching before she looked to the side.
I looked up at her. She looked so much like my Sunshine. But she wasn’t.
But she had the same chinks in her armor and for my bats, I’d use every single one of them if I had to.
Celestia was quiet for several long moments, “...So what would you have us do?” she asked quietly as she turned to look at me again.
“Princess Luna,” I told her, “Have her find them, talk to them. They tolerate her, if it’s because she’s of the night or because she was my wife, I don’t know for certain, but it’s the best I can suggest. Don’t tell them what to do, ask them what they want. Find the strongest unicorns of the land, have Twilight teach them the decursing spells. Give them somewhere to live, not just somewhere to survive. They have been surviving so far. Living, not so much for most of them.”
Celesita looked down at the floor, letting a small sigh out before she nodded, “I need to discuss matters with my sister.”
“I understand,” I said and then let my breath out, “...I’m sorry,” I said, “I didn’t mean to sound like I blamed you for any of it.”
“But you should. It was my… mine and my sister’s responsibility to see to the safety of all ponies in Equestria. And we have failed the thestrals,” she said before she regarded me for several long moments, “I came here to see you, to get an idea of who you were. Twilight said you never wanted to be a prince, that you did all you could to avoid it actually. But that my counterpart made you one anyway… and I think I understand why now.”
I scowled at her, “It was necessary at the time and now I’m stuck with it.”
Celestia smiled sadly, “So are we all.”
The Alicorn curse to be stuck as royalty for eternity and have millions be dependent on you, never to be free of responsibility.
Thanks for chapter, have a good day.
meanwhile in a shadowy realm: GIMME! I WANT IT! GIMME THE CROWN!
...wait, I just realized that the changelings aren't accepted here. who will adopt all the cuddlebugs!?
11297197
OH NOES! TEH SKITTER!
11297197
This is the real problem here. Who knows they might go the Canon route and become colorful things. I hope not but it could happen.
Those who don’t want power are usually the ones who should have it
Celestia
11297249
11297197
We already know the castle is there and starlight is/was there, so its not a far stretch to think the mc maybe around when the cuddlebugs get tie-dyed.
Great chapter. Canon timeline has a lot yet to do and learn from it.
Midnight/Twilight's 'To do list:
- Get Tempest back
- Get the other Tempest as well (the fun has been )
- Fluttershy come to trust Twilight truly
- Build Nocturnis or make Ponyville it?
- Save the Changelings so they get cuddlebug piles in Ponyville ♡♡♡♡♡
(Added by Pinkie Pie)
- Avoid Rainbowpuke bugs since only classic Changelings are always in Fashion
(Added by Rarity)
- Become Friendship master of the universe
(Added by Spike)
- Make time to write the awesome Pegasus Rainbow Dash your experienced adventures
(Added by NOT Rainbow Dash)
- Eat more Apples
(Added by Apple Familie)
- Help CMC become CMC Cutie mark service (^.~)/)(\_(ツ)_/)(\(^-^)
(Not added by the CMC)
- Terminate Tirek to make a Stallion Alicorn
(Definitivly added by Celestia) (σ ͜ʖσ)
- Buy more Books
11297277
Oh, now THAT would be an interesting encounter.
Imagine Page's shock if he encountered a Rainbow Skittles.
"When did I start thinking of it as home?"
Home is where the heart is. You built a life there, after accepting that there was no way back. And home accepted you in kind. Midnight Sparkle will never be forgotten on Page's world, and you may come to realize that you want to leave... but as a princess, you may not have that choice.
Regret? Or is there some small resentment lurking?
Yeeeah... that could get awkward
The two of you are making it complicated
...CELESTIA LEAVES PAGE ALONE...
Page: ...I can feel you, Lord of Chaos. Did I pass your vibe check? Can I call you Discord?
Discord: Impressive you can sense when I didn't want to be seen...and yes to your questions.
*Discord appears lounging on a floating cotton candy*
Discord: I'm uhh...sorry for my temporary insanity in the last comment section. Fluttershy is so fragile when it comes to that part of her. I didn't want you to hurt her.
Page: Its okay. You care about her.
Discord: So...thousands of batponies huh? I want a list of the ones closest to Ponyville...the male ones.
Page: Discord. DON'T.
Discord: I'm not gonna hurt them! I just need to...scout the options for her. If an entire tribe needs saving, we need little tiny Thestrals to be born! Love and animal conservation...if that isn't a gift meant for Fluttershy then I don't know what is!
Page: *sigh* Some things don't change no matter the universe...
11297327
And now, we kinda know why, or at least ONE of their excusses.
You can't just keep drip feeding me chapters like this! It's unfair! How am I supposed to get a new chapter notification and ignore it when the story is so good.
Absolutely loving this arc btw! I'm getting closer to doing a full re-read!
A deafening silence settled upon the two. After a moment, Page smiled and looked at Celestia.
Page: So, this world's Luna-
Celestia: I'm going to stop you right there.
Page: But-
Celestia: Nope! I get enough of that from Cadance.
Page: Well, you didn't even-
Celestia: I'm sorry, Page, but neither your sky nor your sunshine are in this universe.
Celestia backed out the room as she spoke, punctuating the end with a slam of the door.
Page: Wait, how did she know about those names?!
11297194
The weight of don't wanting to find yourself in Earth with dying climate...
11297249
Guess Thorax will take the Canon place?
11297253
Not them
11297258
Yes, but not always are they the best choice...
11297277
Only Classic Changelings are in fashion 24/7
11297300
Just good she is rather a token princess in Canon...
Also Tempest in Page verse can come life in Canon and kick her own ass in bed.
11297328
Thestral army of foals... The weapon of cutness to surpass the Elements
11297338
Their is a mountan worth... Mostly time will bring them all together. 10,100,1000,10000 years? For Alicorns they are numbers... Like days for us i guess...
11297300
Couldn't have said it better myself, and to be honest there is little more to say of the chapter except that Celestia's counterpart is... Interesting. There are a few ways things could go from there and I'm excited to see which comes to pass.
Aside from a localisation problem, grammar jackboot of the day:
Fluttershy's illusion
Good chapter
I had thought that in the canon dimension that many thestrals were working for Princess Luna and had a few punny names towns? If it doesn't then it ain't canon!
Also those who are given power when they didn't want it or like what happened to Page will always do this...
(*ScreamingInTheInsideWTF!!!!!!!*)
Celestia's is shocked by Page's words and knowledge of her. How many want to throw their bits in that she is also slowly getting the hots for Page....?
11297197
If I recall correctly, Pageverse had Thorax and Pharynx go Skittles as a duo and noling else biting. Page even thought at the time "maybe if they'd seen it happen..." so now we have the HiE trying to make sure things go the way they did in canon but with a more diegetic logic.
Well now we know how Paige gets sent back into the past
11297353
...AFTER SLAMMING THE DOOR SHUT...
Celestia: ...is he freaking out?
Discord: Confused at the moment but we are getting there.
Celestia: Excellent! He might be here only a few weeks at most so we better enjoy messing with him while we can!
*Celestia and Discord giggle like school girls*
11297475
Thorax and Pharynx go Sparkly in the Phasmaverse.
I don't recall anything like that in the Pageverse though. Pretty sure they are normal Changelings here. Can't actually recall Thorax at all, actually, but I have so many AUs tangled up in my headspace, that I usually have to re-read a few to remember who does what.
11298011
No, Phasmaverse has them ascend to "normal" royalty. Practically the whole point was to unskittle the bugs.
11298033
Ah, yes. For some reason in my head they went Skittle too.
Still not sure about the Pageverse Bugs. I'll have to re-read and see what happens.
Kind of want to re-read the Phasmaverse again now too, now that Part 1 is finished.
11298011
Thorax puts in a brief appearance in A Very Batty Hearth’s Warming (i.e., the short story right before this one); he’s the drone that welcomes Page to the Canterlot hive in Chapter 2 and also sees him back out after his visit, so even without digging any further back it seems pretty clear that no Skittling happened to him in this universe.
11297544
Gotta get back.. back to the past ... sam-o-ri Page.
11298109
what story are you talking about?
11334385
The story "Changing Expectations" by the author KKSlider, I think. This is it, I think. I tried to add a link here, but, just in case it doesn't work.... https://www.fimfiction.net/story/480268/changing-expectations
the curse was before your time
11298033
The best kind of cuddle bug
There is it
In every universe, Flutterbat is best pony.
camo.fimfiction.net/4xcsIdAf375unsOt7J9Ozsl067Y4ajCkTfuNneEyj5A?url=https%3A%2F%2Fvignette.wikia.nocookie.net%2Fmlp%2Fimages%2F3%2F37%2FFluttershy_turns_into_Flutterbat_S5E13.png%2Frevision%2Flatest%3Fcb%3D20150713125935
Welcome to the club.