Truth or Dare
"Well, Jackie? Truth or dare?" Pinkie asked enthusiastically.
The orange mare gulped and looked around at all of her friends. Every single one of them looked at her with smiles and sultry looks. Although they had just started, the game had quickly turned saucy. It was mostly Pinkie's fault, as she decided to share some very odd truths with the group.
"Uh..." Applejack began. "Well, uhm... Truth, Ah guess."
Pinkie nearly hit the roof of her room as she jumped up in excitement. It wasn't unlike her to act like this, but it still seemed strange to them. It was as if the pink pony had otherworldly powers, in particular when she jumped.
"Woohoo! Truth! Truth! Truth!"
"Fine, fine," Applejack sighed. "Ask yer question."
"Have you ever had sex with your brother?"
The rest of their four friends gasped in unison. Fluttershy had already crawled into a corner and closed her eyes, but at the mention of the word 'sex', she managed to bring herself back into the game.
"Pinkie!" Twilight began. "That's none of our-"
"Ah have."
Complete silence overtook the room. Every single pair of eyes fell upon the orange mare staring at the floor. She sighed heavily and looked at each of her friends.
"Ah know it's wrong! But Ah was in heat and he... Well, y'all done some strange stuff too! Don't ya judge me!" she scolded them. "Dash, yer turn. Truth or dare?"
"Well, I'm no chicken like the rest of you." She gave each of her friends a careful look. "So I'm going to pick dare! I am the bravest, most awesome pegasus in Equestria, after all!"
Twilight, Applejack, and Rarity all rolled their eyes and sighed. Pinkie Pie merely sat there staring at Rainbow Dash as she buzzed with energy.
"All right," Applejack said and lowered her head. "I dare you... to... Git in bed with a mare!"
Rainbow's expression quickly turned from confidence to fright.
"Wha-What?! I don't even like mares! Take back your dare!" she exclaimed, her face flustered and voice stern.
"Well, Ah guess ya ain't the toughest pony in Equestria after all... Chicken," Applejack gloated.
"Nopony! Calls me! Chicken!" Rainbow Dash roared as she shot up into the air. She looked more like a bull than a pony due to her excessive exhaling. Even though Twilight was gulping and moving away, Applejack simply smiled at the cyan mare.
"I'll do it! Just you see! I'll even get the hottest mare in town!"
"Ah'm flattered, Rainbow, but my barn door don't swing that way," Applejack chuckled.
"N-Not you! That mare from the marketplace! She works at the daycare, remember?!"
"You think she's hot?" Fluttershy asked meekly. Both Rarity and Twilight giggled at her question, causing Rainbow to send them harsh looks.
"I, I don't... Ugh... Whatever! Let's just get on with the game!"
"But Rainbow, dear, you have a dare to carry out," Rarity pointed out. "If not, your name will forever be 'Chicken' Dash." She followed up her words by bawking at Rainbow Dash, much to the amusement of everyone but the daredevil herself.
"It's midnight! She's probably not even up! I'll do it tomorrow," Rainbow grumbled. "Can we just play the game?"
"Do you promise to do it tomorrow?" Pinkie asked, her tone unusually serious.
"Yeah, whatever."
"Pinkie promise?"
"Okay, okay, yes! I Pinkie promise!" Rainbow threw her hooves to the floor and sighed. "All of you can call me a chicken if I don't, okay?'
"Fair 'nough, sugarcube. Now, then. Yer turn."
"Sweetie, I'm going to go shopping."
"Okay."
"I'll be back in an hour, okay?"
"Ugh! Stupid aliens! Leave me alone!"
Button's mother chuckled and went out of the room. If her son was this lost in his video games, there was no reason to worry. At most he'd try to eat all the cookies in the house.
It was quite the beautiful day to go shopping. The birds were singing, the sun was shining bright, ponies were talking, and there was a blue pegasus outside the front door.
The moment Button's mother slid the door open, she was greeted with the purple eyes of the strange mare in front of her. She looked nervous as she stood there, her hoof digging at the ground. Button's mother had heard of this mare, but never actually met her in person.
"Can I help you?" she asked curiously; when her husband wasn't home, it was unusual for visitors to come by.
"Uh, hey. My name's, uhm, Rainbow Dash," the cyan mare responded quietly. Her hoof kept digging at the ground beneath her, tossing dirt and pebbles aside. "I was wondering if, um, you wanted to, you know..."
Rainbow Dash mumbled something Button's mother couldn't quite hear. Button's mother had heard tales of this heroic, loyal mare, but they didn't seem to ring quite true in this moment.
"Wanted to?"
"Go on a... You know, hang out," Rainbow sighed.
"Hang out? Why would you want to hang out with a mare you don't even know?"
"I just... Look, let's just hang out, okay? Can't I just tag along or something?"
"I... guess. I'm going to the marketplace."
Rainbow smiled weakly at Button's mother and stepped back, allowing her to exit the house.
"Lead the way." She flew a few feet up into the air and waited for the earth pony to begin walking. Button's mother stared at the cyan mare for a few seconds before simply continuing on with her day.
"So, you work at the daycare?" Rainbow asked as the two of them went down the road.
"Yes, I do."
"Is it any fun?"
"It's a lot of fun. Foals are so sweet and innocent; it's a joy to work with them," Button's mother responded. Although the fear of mugging nagged the back of her mind, she still abode by her rules of courtesy.
"That's cool," Rainbow mumbled. She had quickly regained her spirits, and a smile was slowly forming on her muzzle. "Do you like mares?"
Button's mother stopped dead in her tracks. Rainbow had to perform a U-turn in order to stay close. She stared right at the earth pony, who was sporting a raised eyebrow and open mouth.
"What?" Rainbow asked.
"Did... did you just...?" Button's mother looked to the ground and shook her head. "What are you up to?"
A heavy sigh left Rainbow's throat followed by a stern stare.
"Look, I'm no good at this, so let me just give it to you straight: I... "want" to get in bed with you, so what do you say?"
The two mares stared at each other, each of them with quite the different expression. Rainbow felt uneasy and stressed, and her furrowed brows and piercing gaze reflected that. Button's mother, on the other hand, couldn't quite believe her ears, and as such stared at the pegasus in utter disbelief.
"You... want to get in bed... with me..." she repeated quietly.
Rainbow looked around, making sure there were no ponies around to hear them. "It's not that I want to, but if I don't, my friends get to call me chicken forever, okay? And you're the... prettiest mare around, so can we just do this or what?"
Although she didn't exactly enjoy the idea of being with another mare, Rainbow couldn't help blushing throughout her sentence. She never had to approach anyone like this; usually she just had to sit back and wait for stallions to come.
Button's mother shook her head and closed her eyes. "I'm flattered, but I'm already in a... relationship." She stepped past Rainbow Dash and sighed. "If you'll excuse me, I have shopping to do."
She only managed to take a few steps before the cyan mare was once again in front of her, blocking her vision.
"Come on! I need to do this! Won't you help me, please?" Rainbow pleaded. "I'll be the laughing stock of Ponyville if you don't!"
"That's not really my problem," Button's mother replied and moved forward. Rainbow moved ahead and blocked her path once more, her face and voice turning even more desperate.
"I'll let you do whatever you want! Please! If you do it, I'll leave you alone forever, okay?"
Button's mother stared into Rainbow's eyes. The mare seemed genuine enough, which is exactly what made her worry. Either there was something very wrong with this mare, or she really was just that afraid of being called 'chicken'. No matter what she needed some serious help.
"You'll let me do whatever I want, eh?" Button's mother asked. It had been many years since anyone had ever told her that, and that stallion had run away screaming, never to return to Ponyville.
"Yes! Anything!" Rainbow exclaimed, her eyes and mouth smiling at the mare in front of her.
"Okay, I guess I can wait with grocery shopping. Come on."
Rainbow Dash pumped her hoof into the air followed by a quick loop. She even performed a little victory dance before finally calming down and landing on the ground in front of Button's mother.
"So, uh, what are we going to do?" she asked calmly.
"You'll see. Let's go back inside."
Both mares turned 90 degrees and began walking back towards Button's mother's home. A devilish smile crept upon the earth pony's muzzle as they walked; her mind was already planning out every little detail of the time to come.
Before long, Button's mother was showing her new acquaintance to the bedroom of the relatively small house. Thankfully her son was still playing video games in his room, as evident by the loud noises escaping through the crack underneath the door. Despite this, Button's mother still locked the bedroom door once they had both slipped inside.
"I've actually never, um," Rainbow began. Her eyes darted across the room, landing everywhere but on the eyes of her host. "You know... Been with a mare."
"I'm sure you'll do just fine," Button's mother responded. She walked forward until she was mere inches from the young, athletic pegasus. "First things first: get on the bed."
Despite the shaking of her legs, Rainbow obediently walked to the bed and got onto it. It wasn't nearly as soft as her own cloudy bed, but it definitely wasn't bad either. The sheets in particular felt nice on her fur, and it was quite soft, too.
"M-Maybe we could just talk. I'll tell my friends we... did it, and you don't have to trouble yourself," Rainbow mumbled. Even she knew there was no way around this. Not with the spell Twilight had cast upon her. Yet still she asked; she just wanted to avoid this dare at any cost.
Her eyes were glued to the bed she sat on, but she could hear Button's mother walking closer.
"And when they ask questions, what would you tell them?"
"I dunno. That we... had sex, I guess?" Rainbow shrugged and gulped. Although not looking, she knew Button's mother was rummaging through boxes, and it sounded like they were underneath the bed.
"What if they ask for details? What then, Rainbow Dash?"
"I, uh, I'll..." She had never been good with words, and now more than ever she needed just the right combination of letters. The poor mare could, however, not find them.
"Exactly." Button's mother popped up in front of Rainbow, forcing the pegasus to look right into the eyes of her host. As she stared into those light blue spheres, a loud 'click' filled the room.
Rainbow looked down to see her front legs cuffed together with her hind legs soon to follow. "Hey!"
"You said I could do whatever I wanted," Button's mother reminded her with a smile.
"B-But-"
"Shh -" Button's mother shoved a gagball into Rainbow's mouth "- You're mine now."
Rainbow only managed to let out a few muffled words before she was roughly shoved onto the bed face first. She landed with her rump raised high and her head lying on the sheets, turning slightly as her eyes followed the movements of Button's mother.
"You have quite the body, Rainbow Dash," Button's mother said quietly as she moved onto the bed. "Work out a lot, do you?"
"Mmph!"
"Really?" Button's mother chuckled. "That sounds tough." She crawled up behind Rainbow, which hid her from the cuffed pegasus' gaze.
Dash heard the sound of leather moving around and her eyes went wide. She wasn't quite sure what was about to happen, but every single thought that entered her mind frightened her deeply.
"Why didn't I just pick truth?" she thought. "I'm screwed!"
"Tell me, have you been with many stallions?" Button's mother asked casually. Knowing Rainbow had no chance of responding, she put her hoof at the blue mare's entrance and began moving it slowly. Something resembling a gasp wiggled its way around the gagball and out of Rainbow's mouth.
"Really? That many?" Button's mother smiled as she felt her hoof turn wet rather quickly. "I would have thought more of the Element of Loyalty."
"MMPH!" Rainbow Dash squirmed underneath her host in a pitiful attempt to get free. All she managed to do was make the chains between her hooves ring out and play the song of her captivity.
"Well, I guess that means you'll be ready for this."
Something long, thick, and black entered Rainbow's vision through the corner of her eye. Her eyes went wider and wider as the fake dick engulfed everything in front of her. Never before had she seen something that big nor thick. There was absolutely no way any mare could take all of that inside her.
"Do you like it?" Button's mother asked cheerfully. "I called it the 'Cunt Destroyer'."
Rainbow slowly began shaking her head, her eyes still plastered to the dick next to her. Regret filled her mind as it slid away; slid back towards her poor hole. No matter how hard she tried, she couldn't combat the hoof coaxing her into lubricating her own vagina. The fear had left her unable to think straight, even when all she wanted to do was think of anything but sex.
"Remember: anything I wanted."
The pegasus' wings immediately sprung to life when the flared head pushed against her pink folds. They had received no stimulation, yet there was nothing she could do to lower them.
"MMPHMPH!" Rainbow groaned through the gagball. "MMH MPH MMPH!"
"What's that?" Button's mother asked as she pushed forward just slightly. "You want me to ravage you until you can't fly straight?"
"MMPH! MMMM!"
"If you insist."
Rainbow wanted to do nothing more than scream, but Button's mother had robbed her of a mouth. All that was left for her to do was hold her breath as the giant rod penetrated her most private of parts.
She was used to stallions moving quickly; she did encourage them to, after all. This, however, was something completely different. There was no stopping, no mercy. It kept pressing on and on, spreading apart more and more of Rainbow's insides as it forced its way into her.
"Like it?" Button's mother chuckled. "You're awfully quiet."
If not for the gagball, the pleasure itself would have silenced Rainbow. They had always told her size didn't matter, but in this very moment she knew this not to be true. With every inch that crept inside her, her mind wiped itself of thoughts.
Never before had a stallion been this far into her, and she worried no one would ever be able to. She quivered and clenched every single muscle in her body as the dildo plunged into depths never before explored.
"There we go," Button's mother said calmly once she could press no further. "I guess it's time to ride your rainbow road. Brace yourself."
Despite her warning, Rainbow was not prepared for what followed. She had already almost become numb in her legs, and once the monstrously huge dildo began sliding out of her, it made her entire body spasm.
She couldn't quite believe what was going on inside her body. Here she was, in bed with a stranger, and a mare no less, yet it was so much more enjoyable than any stallion who had ever been graced with her awesome presence.
Rainbow wasn't even the one leading as she was used to; and it frightened her more than anything. Everything could happen, and everything was a bad estimate. This brown mare could do anything to her in this situation, and she had already proven herself to be strange.
"Enjoy it?" Button's mother giggled. "Well, I'll continue no matter what, so you might as well try."
The mare beneath her didn't even attempt to respond any longer. Rainbow simply closed her eyes and groaned in a mixture of pleasure of terror.
"Ready to see what a mare can do?" Button's mother whispered and wiggled her hips around. Although only the head remained inside Rainbow, she still moaned in ecstasy.
"On your marks..."
Sweat dripped down her cyan forehead.
"Ready..."
Her wings trembled in anticipation of the movement.
"Set..."
"MMMPPH!
"GO!"
Rainbow felt as if her walls were being stretched to their absolute limit as Button's mother thrust forward. Despite having already been filled, it was quite something else to feel it going forward at such a pace.
This was no stallion, no creature wanting to pleasure both parties invovled; this was a crazed mare hell-bent on making Rainbow suffer the the fate of too much pleasure through her power and authority.
"You must have taken many stallions in your life," Button's mother moaned quietly. "I've never gotten inside a mare this easily."
The words leaving her mouth barely registered in Rainbow Dash's mind. There were far too many things going on for her to focus on such worthless things as words. When one's cunt was being this thoroughly slammed.
Speed and agility was what Rainbow favored more than anything, and Button's mother certainly lacked neither of the two. In fact, she far exceeded what most stallions could perform, and it pleased both Rainbow's mind and slippery pussy.
"Good little girl, aren't you?" Button's mother slapped Rainbow's flank, causing the mare to groan. "Taking it all like the stallions in the alleyways!"
Despite the words being untrue, Rainbow still felt herself blush simply at the thought of the act. She had been sorely tempted by offers before, but had never lowered herself to such heinous acts.
"I bet you've taken three at the same time!" Button's mother moaned. She once again slapped Rainbow's flank, this time much harder than before.
The contrast of pain and pleasure coursing through Rainbow's body was too much for her to bear. She was quite the fast pony, and that speed applied to most everything she took part in, including sex.
As the flared head continually prodded her womb, her insides lit on fire as they spewed out slippery, warm fluids. Rainbow moaned into the gagball as louder as she could as she let herself go with the orgasm.
"Already?" Button's mother chuckled. "Time for round two!"
Even though she was enjoying wave after wave of extraordinary joy, Rainbow's eyes went wide as her lover spoke. The dildo wasn't slowing down. In fact, it only seemed to go faster and faster inside her.
Her senses overloaded as her oversensitive flesh was repeatedly stimulated by the fake dick inside her. Every time it spread her apart, it sent her body into wild spasms and fried her brain.
"What's the matter? Can't handle a simple mare?!" Button's mother teased with a moaned.
"M-Mmph! MMPH MMMH!"
Rainbow did all she could to voice her disapproval, but words were useless. Every time she tried to get away or resist the mare behind her, it only served to increase the ferocity of the thrusting. She was trapped.
"We'll be here for a while! Get used to it!"
There was no fighting the second orgasm. It came even faster than the first, and it was far more potent, too. As if electrified, Rainbow shook and twitched underneath Button's mother. Although the pleasure was increased tenfold, as was the searing pain in her cunt.
Rainbow couldn't even rest in between each orgasm; the dick just kept going and going. She had to surrender to its vicious intent and incredible size and simply take it. The entire bed rocked underneath the two mares as she got pummeled by the rod of love.
"Oh yeah, you love it, don't you, slut?! You want more don't you?!"
Rainbow was too far lost in her own little world of pleasure. She had no capacity do anything but enjoy herself. The foul words spoken by her lover only served to enhance that pleasure.
"'Element of Loyalty'! Ha! Look at you! Getting slammed by a stranger!"
The cyan mare gurgled and groaned into the gagball, her voice no more than a whimper. Her third orgasm was already raging inside her body.
"You're nothing but a dirty cunt!"
Every part of the world disappeared from Rainbow as she rode the high of her ecstasy into an unknown level of joy. There was only rough, rhythmic slamming and vile words being spat at her.
"Your friends must love this sloppy pussy!"
There was no point in fighting anymore. There never had been. Button's mother was determination incarnate, and Rainbow Dash had become a slave to her will. She was the submission to her domination, and she enjoyed every last, filthy second of it.
Each minute seemed to bring about a new orgasm for Dash. When she lost count, it seemed her body had been trapped in an infinite loop consisting of mere seconds worth of rest, followed by a release more powerful than the previous.
Words and phrases more depraved than any stallion's mind left the throat of Button's mother in between each of her breaths. They crept into Rainbow's ears, slithering around inside her mind and filling it with such wondrous images of absolute joy.
No matter what the mother said, however, it could not compare to this very experience. The feeling of being this full, this worthless, it filled Dash with pride she had never known before.
All of her friends would see her lying there, taking it all like the animal she was. The memory recording spell Twilight had put upon her would make sure of that. Though her friends trusted her, they had to make sure she didn't cheat. Now they would definitely not doubt her ever again.
Rainbow's lips turned into the weakest smile the world had ever seen as the thoughts ran through her mind. Her friends would see all of this, see her dominated by this mere earth pony. The thoughts unwillingly brought upon her body yet another orgasm, and she moaned weakly, as she had not enough strength to be loud.
Even though she could clearly hear the dildo leaving her ravaged cunt, Rainbow still felt it inside her. Her walls were spread far and wide, and they showed no sign of retreating to their previous position.
Button's mother panted as she dropped onto her back next to Dash, a smile on her lips and a glint in her eye. A large, sticky dildo was pressed against her belly, raising up along her chest as she inhaled.
"I'm glad you... came by..." Button's mother panted as she looked into Rainbow's soulless eyes. "Now... get out..."
Despite her exhaustion, the mother turned Rainbow onto her back and quickly released her of both cuffs and the gagball. Rainbow didn't realize how sore her mouth was until that red, shiny ball had been removed. Her legs, too, had marks from where they had been cuffed.
She wanted to speak and move closer to her lover, cuddle close and enjoy the afterglow; there simply was not enough strength in her body or will in her body to do so.
Button's mother had other plans, too, it seemed. Rainbow felt herself hit the floor with a loud 'thump' as she was pushed out of the bed. The mother quickly followed suit. She grabbed a hold of Rainbow's mane with her teeth and began dragging the ravaged mare through the house.
The sound of Button's video games were still flowing through the halls, which pleased his mother greatly. The last thing she wanted was for him to come out and start asking questions.
Rainbow didn't offer any resistance as she was dragged all the way to the front door. She simply moaned and cooed quietly as the wood scraped against her chin. Her entire body was an ecstatic ball of pleasure, and there was no room for pain.
Button's mother put her hoof on the knob, ready to move out the cyan mare. As she stared down at the broken pony, however, a devious smile crossed her lips.
"Wait right there," she chuckled before running off.
She quickly returned with a sharpie in her mouth, the grin still present. Having already removed the hood, she began scribbling on Rainbow Dash's buttcheeks, chuckling to herself as she did.
Once she was done, she threw the sharpie away nonchalantly and opened the door slightly. She looked around at the street, making sure no ponies were close to her home.
Feeling confident nobody would see her, she quickly dragged out the still moaning Rainbow Dash and placed her right in the middle of the street. She propped up the cyan mare's hind legs so that her ravaged hole was on full display.
Although she wanted to admire her work, Button's mother knew it wasn't worth getting caught over. She quickly ran back inside and let out the full extent of her laughter once the door was closed. Some days were just so much better than they should be.
On a deserted street leading to the very edge of Ponyville, an insecure stallion stopped up. He had initially run towards the poor pony lying there, seemingly hurt. But as he came closer, he realized this pony was not hurt nor sleeping; she was in ecstasy.
Her rump was proudly presented to him, sitting there with the tail flicked out of the way. Everything was visible: her tight anus, her lean flanks and that sloppy, stretched cunt. It was leaking juices onto the ground, and it had already created a little puddle.
On her butt were various words written with a sharpie. "Use me!" with an arrow pointing to her gaping hole, "cocksleeve", and "in my mouth, too".
The stallion considered himself a respectable individual. Mares, however, did not. They didn't quite seem interested in a pony with braces and glasses. As they said, he probably wasn't manly enough to please them.
This one however, she couldn't deny him. She would probably like it, too. And he'd get some experience. A win-win situation, as they called it.
It wasn't that he didn't want to simply walk away, but his growing member had something to say about that. Once his eyes had fallen upon the beautiful, cyan mare in the street, there was no turning back.
With a gulp, he placed his hooves on her back and exhaled sharply.