The MLP Horror Show

by Ruby_Sparks


Chapter 8: The Decision

Twilight, Fluttershy, and Spike walked down the hallway, with irises that were smaller than usual. “OK, we’ve met nice guests…” Twilight began.

“Some creepy ones…” Fluttershy continued.

“And a filly that was a scary doll…” Spike finished.

“What’s next?” Twilight asked in stress. “We go back to where we started?” Once they stopped walking, they were back at the receptionist desk. “Why did I say that?” Twilight complained to herself.

“Ah, so you made it out of there!” Gregory said with a surprised, yet happy tone.

“W…What do you mean?” Fluttershy asked, nervously.

“Well, your friends…” Gregory began. “…They’re all dead.”

“WHAT?!” The trio shouted in unison. Twilight turned to face Fluttershy and Spike.

“We have to get out of here!” she muttered. They started running towards the doors. But then, before they could escape, Gregory blocks the doors.

“Oh, I’m afraid you seen too much.” He stated. Then, he grabbed a knife, and threw it at Twilight.

“Noooooo!” shouted Spike, as he jumped up to block the knife from hitting Twilight. The knife went straight through his stomach, and he stopped breathing.

“Spike?!” Fluttershy shouted, with tears in her eyes.

“No…” Twilight started tearing up at the sight.

“No. NO. NONONONONO!”

Twilight faced Gregory, with tears streaming down her eyes, as her irises went tiny. She stamped her hoof down. “What do you want from us, you mindless freak?!” She shouted. “You killed our friends already, so what more do you want?!”

“Well, that’s not the way to treat ponies is it?” Gregory quoted Applejack. Twilight calmed down a bit, but she was still very angry. “Tell you what." Gregory spoke, about to strike a deal. "I can bring all of your friends back to life. But on one condition.”

“That is?” Fluttershy asked, her tears drying up.

“You stay here for the rest of your lives.” Gregory replied, then had a slight chuckle.

“What are you going to do?” Fluttershy turned to Twilight.

Twilight was panicking slightly, mostly because she is becoming slightly insane, but she is thinking what will happen with each outcome.

“Don’t worry, Princess.” Gregory reassured her in a sinister tone. “We have all night.”

Twilight then sighed, in defeat. “Gregory…”

“Yes?” Gregory asked.

“Could you book a room for 7?” Twilight asked.

“Of course, Twilight.” Gregory answered with a smirk. “I hope you enjoy your stay…”

Fluttershy put a hoof around the purple princess.

“Did I make the right choice?” Twilight asked Fluttershy.

Fluttershy nodded. “I believe you did.”