The Rainbooms and the ninjas were at their spot on the beach, until Fugitoid returned with a few pizza boxes, "I have returned with what you desired." he told the group.
"Pizza, awesome!" Mikey cheered, as they each took a slice.
Before Pinkie could eat hers, she got an idea, "Look, guys!" she molded her slice into the shape of a monster, "I'm a pizza monster!" The girls laughed, while Mikey squinted his eyes at her and spoke weary.
"I wouldn't joke about that if I were you, Pinkie."
"Why not?"
"Because... , there really is a pizza monster!" He answered in fright.
The girl were confused, while the turtles groaned, "Oh, no..." April groaned.
"Not this again!" Donnie added.
"Whatever are you talking about, darling?" Rarity asked Mikey.
Raph turned to Mikey with a pointed finger, "You better not tell them, Mikey!"
Mikey ignored Raph, and answered, "Only about the nastiest mutant ever known. By me," he looked around making sure no one else was listening in, "Pizza Face!"
There was a moment of silence, until the Rainbooms minus Fluttershy and Pinkie Pie burst out laughing, "No offense, Mikey. But that's the most ridiculous thing I ever heard!" Rainbow said between laughs.
"Yeah, a giant pizza mutant? That's just kooky!" Applejack added, while trying to stop laughing.
"That's because it is." Donnie told her.
"Yeah, Pizza Face was all a nightmare. But Mikey keeps insisting that he's real." Leo told the girls.
"That's because he is! You guys just won't believe me." Mikey frowned.
"All we believe is that you're delusional, Mikey." Donnie replied.
"Ok, if you won't believe me, maybe you'll believe, Sunset." Mikey took her hand.
"Wait, what're you-" Sunset stopped, as Mikey put her hand to his forehead allowing her to see the memory of when her first saw Pizza Face.
Mermory Pizza Face: Mushrooms
Olives
Mozzarella too
Pepper
Onions
Multitude a
Zombie Man: Ugh...
Yummy-Yumma-Yumma-Yay
Yummy-Yummy-Yumma-Yooooou
Humans taste so good inside a calzone, yes it's true
Hey!
The memory ended as Sunset gasped, "Whoa!"
"Well...?" Mikey asked hoping for some support.
"I did see a pizza monster." she admitted.
"Yes...?" Mikey asked beckoning her for more.
"But I've seen a lot a crazy things in your mind, so I don't what's real or fake." she finished.
"Are you kidding me?!" he asked in outrage, "I'm telling you, really happened!"
"Like how you said you met Megan Fox on a rooftop?" Donnie asked rhetorically.
"Or how you saw guys in cloaks spying on us?" Leo added.
" I did meet Megan Fox, I did see dudes in cloaks spying on us, and Pizza Face is real!"
"The only thing real is your imagination, Mikey." Raph replied, as the group minus Pinkie and Fluttershy laughed at him.
Mikey was getting angrier every second from their mocking, until he dropped his slice on the box and snapped, "Fine! Be that way! Don't say I didn't warn you." He stormed away in a fit of rage.
"Guess he wasn't hungry." Raph said, as he took his slice.
"Can you believe Mikey?" Leo asked the group.
"Yeah. Who would believe in something as ridiculous as that?" Donnie asked them.
Fluttershy and Pinkie looked at each other nodding before answering, "We would!"
The group turned to them in shock, "WHAT?!"
Raph coughed up some pizza, "Are you serious? Pinkie Pie I can believe, but you, Fluttershy? Why would you believe Mikey? He's obviously making it up."
"That doesn't mean he's not telling the truth," Fluttershy argued, "Was he making it up when he told you April's mom was really a very dangerous Kraang mutant? Or about Bebop, Rocksteady, and the other Turtles?"
"And the Squirrelanoids! Don't forget about the Squirrelanoids." Pinkie added, as the turtles, April, and Casey looked sheepish from all the strong points.
"I didn't think so! Just because he makes things up doesn't mean everything he says is fake." Fluttershy continued to scold them.
"And if you guys don't believe him that's you're problem, not Mikey's. Now if, you'll excuse us, we have to go find Mikey and comfort him." Pinkie rushed off while dragging Fluttershy with her.
Karai who wasn't truly laughing before didn't know what side to take since she wasn't involved in it, "She's got a point, you guys. What if Mikey is telling the truth?"
"Come on. This Mikey we're talking about," Donnie said, "A mutant mind controlling pizza? That sounds like something from a cartoon-" Donnie suddenly doubled over and groaned in pain.
This got everyone's attention, " Donnie, what's-" April began experiencing the same pain.
Everyone else did the same until they got up and dragged themselves off, groaning like zombies. Fugitoid was not liking this, "Excuse me, but where do you all think you're going?" he demanded, until he heard chattering sounds behind him. He looked back and his eyes gave off a shocked expression, "Oh, no!" he screamed, as something started piling onto him.
The group entered a sea cave on the other side of the beach along with Fugitoid being dragged by them. A figure was waiting for them, while standing in the dark, "Ah, welcome my little-a bambinos." the figure belched cheese all over them, sticking them to the cave wall, "Easy as-a pizza pie." he laughed evilly.
Back at the beach, Mikey was sitting down on a log moping with Derpy next to him. Mikey turned to the girl and spoke, "Ever feel like no one will believe you no matter what you do?" Derpy only shrugged in response, "Exactly." he sighed.
"Mikey!" Pinkie called, as she and Fluttershy approached.
"There you are." Fluttershy said in relief.
"Hey, girls. Why aren't you with the others?" Mikey asked suspiciously.
"Because we don't agree with them." Pinkie answered.
"So you believe me?" Mikey gasped.
"We do." Fluttershy confirmed.
Mikey was excited before becoming suspicious again, "Why?"
"Because let's think about it the stuff we've been dealing with for so long gets weirder and weirder," Pinkie began, "And even though your bros think Pizza Face is too ridiculous by their standards on what we deal with doesn't mean it's not possible."
"That's right." Fluttershy smiled and nodded.
Mikey smiled, "Thanks, girls. What's say we all go back, I'm starving for pizza."
"Me too." Pinkie agreed, as they started walking.
Fluttershy looked back at Derpy and spoke, "You're welcomed to come too." Derpy smiled and joined them.
The four went back to the spot, and to their shock saw the guys were gone, "Hey, where is everyone?" Pinkie asked.
"You think they left too?" Fluttershy asked.
Mikey looked at the empty pizza box and was horrified, "It can't be..."
"What can't be?" Pinkie asked curiously.
"Look!" Mikey showed them the pizza box with a message written in cheese.
"I have-a returned?" Fluttershy read it.
"But he blew up!" Mikey gasped.
"Who blew up?" Derpy asked.
"I know where our friends are, and who has them... , Pizza Face!" Mikey panicked.
"Pizza Face?!" The two Rainbooms gasped.
"Who?" Derpy asked in confusion.
"Long story." Fluttershy replied.
"But you said he blew up." Pinkie noted.
"He did. It makes no sense? How did he even get them?"
Fluttershy suddenly noticed some pizza slices move, "Um, guys? This'll sound crazy but, I think our pizza slices just moved."
"Really?" Pinkie asked, as they got closer to said slices. Suddenly the slices shrieked and the group screamed. One of the slices latched onto Pinkie's face, "Get it off! Get it off!" she ran around crazily.
Two others tried to grab Fluttershy and Derpy, only for Mikey to grab them out of thin air. Pinkie pulled the one off her face, and the two threw the slices on the sand and stomped them flat.
"Well, that explains it." Mikey said.
"Were those pizza slices alive?" Derpy asked.
"That's what's up, dudette," Mikey confirmed.
"But how did Pizza Face make off with our friends?" Fluttershy asked.
Pinkie gasped, "The pizza was all a trap."
"Obviously," Mikey replied, "Now we gotta find our friends."
"But how?" Fluttershy asked, "We don't know where to look."
"Why not follow the trail?" Pinkie suggested.
"Trail?" Mikey and Fluttershy asked, before noticing a trail of pizza toppings and cheese.
"How convenient." Mikey said.
"You do know he's probably baiting us into a trap?" Fluttershy noted.
"Even so. No one kidnaps my bros and friends," Mikey said seriously, "This time it's personal." he began following the trail.
"We better go." Pinkie told Fluttershy and Derpy as they followed Mikey.
Back at the cave, everyone woke up and realized they were trapped in cheese, "What the?" Karai asked in shock.
"Ok, this is weird." Casey said in surprise.
"What the heck is going on here?" Raph demanded.
" Ah, you're awake. I wasn't sure if were-a gonna ever wake up from your trance." the figure laughed.
"Who are you?" Twilight demanded.
"And why did you bring us here?" Leo added.
"Ah si` I suppose I should-a introduced-a myself. I am Antonio. But I prefer you call me back the name signore Michelangelo gave me," the figure came into the light, "Pizza Face!"
"Pizza Face?!" the group asked in shock.
"You're real?!" Donnie asked in disbelief.
"I don't-a see anybody else here, do you?" He laughed, "And to answer your question, I'm-a using you all as-a bait. So I can get revenge on that turtle for foiling my plan to eat you," he motioned to April, "Signorina, in giant calzone."
"You tried to what?!" April asked in shock.
"That is sick, yo." Casey said.
Raph spoke to the others, "Do you know what this means? Mikey will never let us hear the end of it!" he groaned.
"That's your biggest concern right now?" Applejack asked.
Pizza Face laughed, until a familiar voice called out, "Hey! Let my bros and friends go, Pizza Face!" Everyone turned to the cave entrance seeing Mikey, "We meet again..."
"Michelangelo, so good to see you again." Pizza Face greeted him.
"Yeah, well guess what. I ain't alone this time. I brought me some friends who actually believed me!" he shouted at the others who were wrapped in guilt. Pinkie, Fluttershy, and Derpy enter the cave armed with their ninja weapons.
"Hmm? What a coincidence, I'm not-a alone too." an army of mutant pizzas appeared behind him.
"Huh? I did not see that coming." Pinkie admitted.
"Get them! But the turtle is mine." Pizza Face ordered his minions who went on the attack.
The girls used their weapons to destroy the pizza creatures, while making sure they didn't latch onto their faces and turn them into zombies. Pinkie spoke to the fourth wall, "You know the world's gone mondo bizzaro when pizzas bite you back."
Mikey made it to Pizza Face and started fighting him, "How'd you know where to find us?"
"Please, the beach at Summer time is when I get my best sales." Pizza Face answered, as he tried spitting pizza at Mikey who kept dodging.
Casey having enough of watching their friends fight while they did nothing called out, "Pinkie, get us down from here!"
"You guys do know you can just eat your way out right?" Pinkie asked like it was obvious.
Everyone suddenly looked dumbfounded, "Seriously?!" Rainbow Dash asked.
"How did we not know that?" Sunset asked.
So everyone began eating through their prisons and finally got free, "Ninjas, take them down!" Leo ordered, as they joined Pinkie, Fluttershy, and Derpy in fighting the pizza creatures.
"Um, hello!" Fugitoid called, "I can't actually eat my way out," Shini used her weapon to cut the robot free so he could move, "Thank you." he went to help the others.
Mikey continued fighting Pizza Face, until the pizza mutant backed the ninja into a corner, "I have-a you now, Turtle!"
"That's what you think." Mikey motioned behind him.
Pizza Face turned around just in time to get knocked away by everyone, "That was for kidnapping us and getting cheese all over my bathing suit!" Rarity fumed.
"You all-a stay back, I've got cheese and I'm not afraid to use it!" Pizza face warned them.
"Well, I got sprinkles!" Pinkie called, as she mixed her magic into them, and threw them at the mutant.
Pizza Face swallowed them, and could feel a little spice in his stomach, "Ooo, that's a spicy meat-a ball!" he suddenly saw his belly glowing, "Wait, what's happening?!" he suddenly exploded sending cheese everywhere.
Luckily Rarity used her magic shield to protect everyone, especially herself. She lowered it down and looked around at the exploded mutant and defeated minions, "So that's it?" Shini asked.
"Not yet." Mikey said, as Pizza Face emerged from melted cheese having been reduced to one measly slice like before.
"No! Not again!" he cried, and was suddenly levitated over via Twilight's magic.
"Now what to do with you?" Mikey smirked while crossing his arms. Pizza Face only gulped.
Back on the beach, Fluttershy used her magic to call forth a shark who looked at them. Mikey spoke to it, "Hey, shark, hope you're hungry." he put Pizza Face in a slingshot and pulled it back.
"No! Please! We can-a talk about this!" he was sent flying into the shark's mouth and was swallowed whole.
"I'm surprised after all this and your first fight with him you still eat pizza." Fluttershy said in concern.
"Not even a pizza villain will ever keep me from loving it," Mikey answered. He then turned to the others, "So, anything you guys wanna say? Because I'm all ears."
The group looked shameful at each other, as Sunset began, "Yeah, I think we do."
"We're sorry, Mikey." Leo apologized.
"You were right all along." Donnie admitted.
"And we were idiots for not believing you." Raph added.
"Us too." Applejack said on behalf of herself and the other Rainbooms.
"Yeah." Rainbow agreed.
"Can you ever forgive us?" April asked hopefully.
Mikey smiled, "Come on, of course you're forgiven," the group hugged it out, "Oh, but just so we're clear... IN YOUR FACES, NONBELIEVERS! Ha-ha-ha!" he started doing a victory dance, much to their annoyance, "Who was right, I was right! Who was wrong, you were wrong!"
"Like I said, never hear the end of it." Raph grumbled.
"He does have the right to this." Fugitoid reminded him.
Sunset looked over and saw Twilight looking uneasy, "Something wrong, Twilight?"
"I was just thinking. If Mikey was right about Pizza Face, who knows what else he was right about?" she asked.
Everyone was concerned about that possibility. What if Mikey was right about other things, "I'm not sure I wanna find out." Leo said, as they were unaware of being watched via magic orb of the five hooded figures from before.