One day as she's talking with her friends, Apple Bloom accidentally lets it slip that she has a crush on Tender Taps, the little orange show pony.
"What do you mean you like Tender Taps? Do you have your first crush, Apple Bloom?" asks a shocked Scootaloo.
"Yes, I have a crush on Tender Taps, he's cute, handsome, funny, a good dancer," replies Apple Bloom blushing.
The two then take this information and tell Apple Bloom to go get some supplies for their school project all on her own. While Apple Bloom is out gathering supplies, Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo are setting up the tree house for a date for their friend and Tender Taps. Apple Bloom has no idea. Once she has the supplies gathered for the project, she takes them back to her house and then she's sent out to take pies to all the rest of Ponyville by her sister, who is in on the whole thing. Apple Bloom doesn't think anything of it, however, because Applejack always sends her out to do the Ponyville pie deliveries.
Meanwhile, back at the club house, Sweetie and Scootaloo put the last touches on the date setup. There's flowers and breadsticks. Everything is perfect. Sweetie and Scootaloo share a hoof bump, they then go and give the invitations for a dinner for two to Tender Taps and Apple Bloom. They grin, Apple Bloom and Tender Taps don't have a clue that Sweetie and Scootaloo have set up a romantic dinner for the two of them.