When Sunset Shimmer gets a letter from a not-so-secret admirer, she thinks it's just a bump in the road. She doesn't know it's all about to end. But Cheerilee knows. She's always known.
Cheerilee's first Hearth's Warming away from Ponyville isn't going so well, so Starlight and Trixie offer to share theirs with her. Things... don't quite go as planned, but at least their hearts are in the right place. (Sequel to "Teach Me Goodness")
For four years, Sunset Shimmer has carried a torch for Miss Cheerilee, and for four years, she's struggled to look at her without thinking of the one who got away.
Sunset Shimmer's apartment is invaded by a giant, cosmic eyeball, which is generally kind of a bummer, and almost as annoying as the constant advances Twilight keeps making toward herself.