Alone during the holidays, Berry Punch believed that she'll spend her Hearth's Warming like any other: in a blacked out stupor. But at her darkest point, will an unlikely pony be the key to start her path of recovery?
Izzy invites Discord over for Hearth’s Warming dinner with her friends in Maretime Bay following his attempt to destroy magic. Discord remembers the last time he had a group of friends and is unsure if he is worthy of a second chance…
(Takes place between "Mane Smelody" and "Nightmare on Mane Street".) Pipp tries to look for a way to make up for her hoof polish unintentionally hurting Mane Melody's reputation. She eventually gets the idea to do a special charity livestream.
Hitch burdened by the relentless stress of his duties in Maretime Bay confronts the shadows of his own heart and discovers an unexpected love in the midst of chaos and self-doubt. Will he find redemption, or will the darkness find him instead?
Misty begins have to questions about her past, and decides the only way to get some answers is to do research in Bridlewood. Izzy and Zipp offer to help, but they and Misty will be surprised by what they uncover.
Twilight has fallen ill with a seemingly incurable disease. As Rainbow Dash keeps seeing flashes of her life with her, she is more than determined to save the life of the one she loves, even if she has to lose herself for it.
When Misty discovers Senor Butterscotch, she asks Izzy about why she created the fake unicorn. Izzy reveals it all stems back to her childhood in Bridlewood.
(Partially based on a request.) Scootaloo and Apple Bloom have a feud that leaves Scootaloo feeling guilty. She tries to find a way to make things right with Apple Bloom, but isn't sure how to do it.