This story is a sequel to A Day in the Life
Butterscotch, the luckiest and most unlucky pony at the same time. He's a hit with the mares, but only because they feel sorry for him. Stallions hate him for his successes with the mares, but secretly pester him day and night about how he charms them. What's a poor stallion like Butterscotch going to do, especially when he gets something all the other stallions want?
R63 Fluttershy, Big Mac and Cheerilee. Love triangles ftw!