Sweetie Belle Missing

by Braven

First published

One night can change a life. After a mysterious incident caused the disappearance of Sweetie Belle it's up to Rarity and her friends to track down the cause of this and find the lost pony.

There are few things more worrying than the unkown.

In this adventure spanning across Equestria, Rarity and her friends search for a missing Sweetie Belle and uncover a larger mystery involved with her disappearance. Friendships are tested on this journey as they face difficult challenges.

Timeline-wise this takes place before the end of season 3.

Chapter 1: Dark Tidings

View Online

Sweetie Belle has gone missing. That was the only thing on anypony’s mind that morning in Twilight’s library. The usual comforting demeanor that the library had a habit of emanating was nowhere to be found. It was replaced by a heavy, almost chilling atmosphere that would instill anypony with worry.

And there was certainly good reason to worry. Twilight Sparkle awoke from a terrible sleep that normally wouldn’t be enough to be considered a nap, however with how stressed and fixated on her current goal she is it was more than adequate for her needs. She rolled out from under a pile of old fraying books and scrolls that she vaguely remembered dropping from exhaustion and then surveyed her surroundings.

Twilight spotted Fluttershy asleep by an open window with an equally open book in front of her. She looked peaceful with the morning light gradually approaching her but Twilight knew that peace was temporary. Fluttershy had been using her animals to help in the search and pass along messages, she spent most of her time by the window waiting for news from them.

Casting her gaze towards the door, Twilight found Rarity looking over five different books with an absent-minded expression. It was clear that she hadn’t managed to get any sleep last night, her normally immaculate mane was tangled and jutting out all over. Twilight carefully approached Rarity and tapped a hoof on her back in a friendly, reassuring manner and asked a question she already knew the answer to.

“Good morning Rarity… were you able to find anything?” Twilight was careful with how she carried her words. If she sounded too worried then that would reflect onto Rarity as well, adding unwanted stress. Too happy though then she would sound disingenuous of her situation. Rarity let out a sigh that was almost a whimper before she responded.

“I’m afraid not dear,” she paused to give time for her sleep deprived mind to catch up before continuing. “I should be out there searching too, my poor Sweetie Belle could be scared or worse somewhere out there while I’m just sitting here reading dusty books and learning nothing useful.”

Rarity did find something about Granny Smith being older than Ponyville itself that she would have found interesting under better circumstances. Twilight shared her sentiment but knew that this was their safest bet for now.

“I know Rarity but we have to find something about that blue light in case the others can’t find anything.”

Twilight thought about her friends Applejack, Pinkie Pie and Rainbow Dash who were currently launching their own search and investigation outside. She had entrusted each of them with a small gold locket that contained a lock of Sweetie Belle’s mane. The lockets had been charmed by Twilight with a spell that causes them to glow once the conduit, in this case Sweetie Belle’s mane, is within a close proximity of roughly ten pony lengths to the owner of said conduit.

Rainbow Dash had taken her locket to the skies as she sped across the boundaries of Equestria. Deciding that her search would be better to start there and work her way inland, making sure to double check any tall peak or suspicious mountain along the way. Pinkie Pie had chosen a more sporadic approach, choosing instead to rely on her Pinkie sense along with a bit of luck to find Sweetie Belle. This led her to bounce between all the well known settlements and the more obscure ones too, the ones that like to avoid maps and elude tourists, she wasn’t entirely sure where she was currently but that was exactly what the pink blur was after.

During the incident that occurred two days ago that the locals had now started unaffectionately calling “The Vanishing” Apple Bloom was found unconscious at the scene where locals had reported seeing an eerie, almost sickening dark blue light that didn’t illuminate in the same sense that normal light would. This was slow and methodical, almost grasping at the air towards anypony who had spotted it. Before any semblance of fear could creep its way in, the light dissipated with a grating hooves on chalkboard kind of screech.

With Apple Bloom unconscious, Applejack decided it would be best for her to keep her search close to Ponyville and use this chance to question locals while occasionally checking in on her sister’s condition at the Apple family farm. Sadly though other than being able to put a name to the event Applejack wasn’t able to glean any useful information from the locals and she had already turned Ponyville upside down twice over.

All six mares were reaching a peak of desperation and frustration at not being any closer towards Rarity’s lost sister.

“Um.. you guys?”

The silence that had been forming while Twilight thought back to her friends was shattered by a familiar and comforting meek voice by the window. Both her and Rarity slowly swiveled to give Fluttershy their attention, being careful not to be too hopeful. Surprised that her friends were looking at her this attentively, Fluttershy briefly froze and went wide eyed, like a deer she had once accidentally gotten the jump on. Regaining her composure she continued.

“Well I’ve just heard from Angel, who had heard from some of his rabbit friends, who had heard from their cute little bird friends who had heard-” Fluttershy froze once again when she noticed her two friends wearing a very irritated expression, they were not currently appreciating this light hearted attitude given the situation and were now waiting for Fluttershy to say her piece so that they can go back and find anything on the Vanishing.

Fluttershy steeled herself though because she knew this was important news that couldn’t wait. Before her friends could protest she blurted out: “Apple Bloom is awake!”

From this rushed statement hope started to find its way back to Rarity, like a hot drink fending off a cold night.

“That’s wonderful news darling! We must go see her at once!” Rarity’s previously addled mind was now sharp and focused, running on the adrenaline flowing through her at the sudden leap forward the search will no doubt take after two days of stagnancy.

Rarity looked over to Twilight for confirmation, though she was ready to gallop out the library regardless of her decision. She gave an assuring and confident nod towards Rarity before she spoke.

“Yes. Let’s go check how she’s doing and see if she has any answers for our questions about Sweetie Belle”

Using her magic, Twilight opened the front door of the library allowing Rarity to gallop out with Fluttershy following close behind as best she could. Twilight quickly threw on her saddlebags filled with various potions from Zecora while turning her attention to a pile of books that had been peacefully snoring.

“Spike! Keep looking for any information on that light while we’re gone!” With that said Twilight now went in pursuit of her friends after accidentally slamming her library door. The sudden noise and vibration awoke the pile of books which did indeed turn out to be the resident dragon.

“Huh.. wha?”

This was the most Spike was able to muster in terms of a sentence as his half asleep mind had not caught up with his now fully awake body. He looked over towards the five books Rarity had been idly flicking through during the night and noticed that one of them was far older than the rest.

This book could barely be considered a book in the conventional sense. Sure it had pages and what were presumably covers but it was stitched together very amateurly, as if it was done in the dark. The binding along the back was only half of what it used to be and it was holding the front and back covers to it with rotting string. The unusual thing about this book however was the printing on its pages, as it looked brand new and professionally done.

Spike cautiously eyed up the book. “Hmm, there’s something about you that doesn’t sit quite right, I bet you know something and I’m going to find out what that is!” Spike exuded confidence as he sat down to read the book, all the while an unsettling blue light began to wrap its way around the ceiling of the once peaceful library.


Up in the sky not too far from Canterlot a seagull was flying towards an isolated mountain that wore a snow covered cap that was gradually being shaken off by an erratic rainbow darting all across its surface at harsh angles. That rainbow is what brought the seagull to this particular mountain. Thanks to the tailwind that this messenger was riding it took no time to get within landing distance of the mountain which had become concerningly quiet.

Before the seagull could investigate it was caught off guard by a strong gust of wind that had blown it off balance, causing the bird to flail its wings as it tried to level itself through several rolls in the air.

“Oh come on! I know this stupid thing glowed somewhere around here!”

The source of the rainbow circling the mountain and the seagull’s current predicament was Rainbow Dash who would be able to put a rabid dog to shame with her appearance and attitude after two days of searching for Sweetie Belle across Equestria with no leads.

“Where are you hiding her you overgrown rock!” Rainbow Dash took a swipe at the mountain with her left hoof only to regret it immediately, “Arrrgh!”

Defeated and frustrated, she let out a powerful scream before landing on a somewhat flat section of the mountain to bury her face and now injured hoof into a small pile of snow.

The seagull had managed to recover, if a little disorientated, and landed next to Rainbow Dash and observed a solemn expression from the pegasus peeking out from the snow. She met the seagull’s gaze and let out a pained sigh causing her to deflate a size briefly before dragging herself onto her three working hooves.

“What do you want? I’m kinda in the middle of something.”

Rainbow was about to take to the air to continue her search after saying her piece but the seagull started to let out a series of squawks with intonation as if trying to replicate pony speech.

“Hey slow down! I have no idea what you’re trying to say.”

Rainbow Dash had started to hover and was taken aback by the frantic speech from the bird. This time it was the seagull that let out a sigh. Worrying that its journey could turn out to be a waste, it started to make exaggerated gestures with its wings to try and convey the message.

“There’s a big party out in Canterlot tonight and they need me there for a top secret mission to prevent the assassination of a prized pumpkin?” The seagull paused, shook its head, and then continued.

The pegasus let out an overemphasized gasp. “Are you saying that there’s a massive pack of timberwolves about to heist a train filled with luxury cakes and clothing!?”

The seagull paused once more and realized that the pegasus wasn’t taking the one-sided conversation seriously, suspecting that she was trying desperately to hold together some sense of self. In this case the seagull would be more right than it realized, Rainbow Dash felt fragile right now, one more reminder of the bleak situation that led her to this mountain and she would shatter.

After noticing that the seagull seemed to have caught wise to her using it as an outlet Rainbow Dash let out one more sigh, turned around in the air and looked back to give a downtrodden: “Later…”

Before she could make an escape her flight path was cut off by the seagull showing an impressive feat of speed that surprised her. This time the seagull made a smaller, more methodical gesture with both wings and seemed to outline something vaguely circular in shape before taking an imaginary bite out of it.

“An.. Apple?”

The seagull, relieved, gave Rainbow Dash a determined nod at her correct guess. She slowly landed to the ground, her mind was a race course of thoughts passing by faster than she could make sense of any of them. She knew that was important. She knew this was related to the situation. Rainbow recalled a memory that made her ill with worry, it was a memory of Fluttershy visiting her in the dead of night to let her know that Sweetie Belle had gone missing and that Apple Bloom was being rushed to the hospital.

Suddenly her mind was focused, “Of course,” she thought to herself.

“Is it Apple Bloom?” Rainbow Dash asked this cautiously, hoping to be correct, and hoping for good news.

The seagull nodded. She could feel her heartbeat reverberate in her head from it pounding as hard as it was. Excitedly she asked, “Is she better? Is she OK!?”

The seagull nodded, and this time smiled, or at least it was a good impression of a smile given the bird’s lack of facial muscles in its beak.

“Well why didn’t you start with that then!”

The seagull narrowed its eyes at the brazen response, but there was no point trying to complain about it as the blue pegasus was already far out of sight.


Around the same time there was a pink pony named Pinkie Pie bouncing her way through a small abandoned hamlet surrounded by a forest, her similarly bouncy pink mane looked a bit more out of control than usual. The buildings surrounding her were too old to be considered modern, but too new to be seen as ancient. In their prime they would have been crude looking with their mismatched stones as the foundation and thatched roofs with too many gaps that would have often allowed water in. A surprising amount of them were still intact but many had fallen in on themselves.

Occasionally, in between her bounces Pinkie paused, her usual bubbly expression replaced with one of dread and her mane would start to flatten. These were starting to become more frequent and longer, especially now. The locket she wore around her neck had started glowing when she entered the hamlet a little while ago, however the pink pony had already checked every blade of grass here with nothing remotely suggesting the existence of Sweetie Belle.

Pinkie had too many unwanted thoughts starting to form. The pony had come to a complete stop now, she felt unease, there was something happening to her that was far removed from happiness. That was her favorite emotion, the one she loved seeing on the faces of others, even if she struggled to feel it sometimes she would wear a happy expression so that her friends could feel at ease and know that she was a pony that anypony could rely on.

But her friends weren’t here.

The pile up of uneasy thoughts had reached its tipping point. Pinkie Pie felt her veins run cold like ice, her chest started to tighten and the tips of her hooves had an unpleasant prickly feel to them. It was getting more difficult to breathe, she tried taking deep breaths but could only get halfway towards one, right as she was starting to feel faint she heard the proud screech of an eagle above.

The bird was approaching her, but not in a threatening way. Pinkie recognised it as one of Fluttershy’s animal friends. With this a new thought entered her mind, if her friend did indeed send this eagle then it meant she was relying on Pinkie for something.

A warmth started to spread through her, it felt as though somepony had covered her in Equestria’s most comfy imaginary blanket. The majestic bird had landed on a nearby stone wall that was one sneeze away from collapsing. It observed the pony with patience, letting her regain some of her luster until finally, she was able to take deep breaths and bounce a few times in place to make sure she still could.

“Hiya!” Pinkie addressed the bird with as much pep as she could manage right now.

The eagle responded with a nod and was ready to begin the arduous task of overcoming the language barrier but before it could raise a wing Pinkie gasped and said, “Are you saying that Fluttershy got her animal friends to run a network of messages across Equestria looking for me and Rainbow Dash just to let us know that Apple Bloom is awake and we should head back to Ponyville right away”

Perplexed by the pony’s apparent omniscient nature the eagle gave her a suspicious nod.

“Well why didn’t ya say so sooner!?”

Moving faster than any earth pony should be capable of, Pinkie galloped the length of the horizon in an instant, passing some smartly dressed timberwolves along the way. Before she knew it she had approached the outskirts of Ponyville and spotted a familiar speeding rainbow blur making its way towards the hospital.

Rainbow Dash landed just shy of the main door to the hospital, causing a couple of potted plants to be blown off of a window sill. Standing right next to her in her blind spot was Pinkie Pie.

“Gah!?” Rainbow shouted in an alarm, not having seen her friend's approach. “Pinkie! What the heck? How did you sneak up like that? Actually nevermind that, did you find any clues on Sweetie Belle?”

Hiya Dashie!” Pinkie responded with genuine joy at the sight of her friend. “Apart from my locket glowing briefly I haven’t found anything, but I did find a bird that let me know that Apple Bloom is awake!”

Rainbow Dash gave her a knowing nod, “Hmm yeah I had a bird come tell me the same thing, that’s why I’m here, speaking of. We need to get in there!”

“Um.. Hello.” A familiar pegasus was standing behind the both of them, causing Rainbow to jump a little and let out another yelp, before they could get a word in, Fluttershy quickly spoke, “If you’re looking for Apple Bloom she’s not here. The doctor’s said that she was just sleeping. They wanted her to stay so they could keep an eye on her but Granny Smith talked them out of it and brought her back home.”

“So how is she now? One of your animals mentioned that she was awake,” asked Rainbow with concern.

“Oh yes well she is awake but she hasn’t said a word yet. Applejack is trying to get her to eat some breakfast while Twilight and Rarity look through Zecora's potions to see if any of those could help.”

Hearing this, Pinkie chimed in with her thoughts, “Well I betcha she just needs a visit from her favorite party pony!”

Fluttershy looked at pinkie and gave her a warm smile, “I think that sounds like a wonderful idea Pinkie Pie. Since the others were busy I sent out my animals to give you the news and made my way to the hospital in case you both were here.” She paused and then thought aloud, “I’m surprised you both got here before me, you must have been close by.”

“Ha! I’m the fastest pony in Equestria, it was no problem for me” Rainbow Dash boasted this fact proudly before remembering, “Wait we don’t have time for this. Let’s get over to Applejack’s place right now then!” Her two friends nodded and ran into the direction of Apple Bloom.


Inside the kitchen of the main house at the Apple’s family farm Apple Bloom was gradually starting to enjoy the idea of breakfast and was now eating some pancakes with vigor that Applejack had cooked up for her.

“Now careful there little lady. I’m glad you’re feeling fit enough to eat finally but you still need to chew.”

Applejack lightly reprimanded Apple Bloom but was mostly happy to see her sister well. Apple Bloom had still yet to say a word so she opted for a defiant expression before continuing with her pancakes. Applejack could hear Twilight and Rarity investigating the potions over in the living room, she was happy that Rarity had something to distract her but her happiness was starting to feel like guilt now that she knew that her own sister is safe while the state of her friend’s sister was still an unknown.

For now though Applejack made her way over to the sink to attack a pan with a particularly stubborn bit of pancake batter burnt into it. As she did so, well timed snores with the rhythmic creak from a rocking chair could be heard from a corner of the kitchen where Granny Smith had taken up a temporary residence. She had been about as helpful as a candle with no wick but her presence was always a comforting one for the Apple siblings, and this instance was no exception. Feeling at ease, Applejack’s mind drifted and focused more on the conversation in the living room.

“How about this one Rarity?”

After extensively looking over the list that Zecora provided Twilight had concluded that the Silence-Me-Not potion would be the most useful and was seeking that much earned confirmation from her friend.

“Goodness no!” exclaimed Rarity in sheer horror at the sight of the potion. “The vial is green and the cap is a ghastly yellow, those colors should never be together like that so there must be something wrong with it darling.”

Twilight raised her eyebrow, “I don’t think the aesthetics of the bottle would affect the potion inside. It says right here that if you struggle to speak your mind, this will free you from your verbal bind.” She had copied Zecora’s rhythmic tone to try and emphasize that there was a second opinion involved here. Reaching over the table that the two ponies were sitting at, Rarity grabbed the visually offensive potion and tossed it aside causing Twilight to quickly grab it with her magic.

“No, no, no that simply won’t do dear, this one is much more pleasing.” Rarity spoke triumphantly and presented her friend with another green vial but this time it was sporting a white cap.

Twilight looked at the potion with panic, “Not that one! That will turn Apple Bloom into a yeti!”

The back and forth would continue but Applejack was more focused on the now clean pan that she had won the battle against. After one last appraisal of the pan she was satisfied enough to place it down on the drying rack, as she did so the front door violently swung open, allowing a blue and pink blur in the form of Rainbow Dash and Pinkie Pie to enter the house.

“Apple Bloom!” Shouted Rainbow Dash, managing to spot the young filly immediately. “How are you feeling? Did you see what happened? Do you know where Sweetie Belle is?”

“Ack!” exclaimed Apple Bloom, accidentally swallowing a pancake that had been chewed less than she was used to, causing her to start a coughing fit.

Hiya everypony!” Pinkie had bounced her way into the kitchen shortly after her friend, ignorant of Apple Bloom’s plight.

Furious at the now shattered peace in the kitchen Applejack went to pat her sister’s back while confronting the source of the commotion. “Dagnabbit Dash why couldn’t you just open the door like a normal pony, and why all the questions? Didn’t Fluttershy say that Apple Bloom ain’t been talking? And even if she was, this kind of energy wouldn’t be helping none either.”

“Well I’m sorry for being worried! And what do you mean not helping, she clearly said ack just then.”

“That ain’t a word and you know it.”

“It is too a word, come on Apple Bloom let’s hear you talk, just what the heck happened?”

Applejack wasn’t finished with Rainbow Dash just yet but before she could share her grievances she noticed that Apple Bloom had stopped coughing and was mouthing words with no noise to them. Between her attempted words she was able to let out small grunts and gasps of air that could almost be confused for something with meaning, but the longer this went on the more she became frustrated at her lack of speech until she gave up attempting entirely.

“I think this should help you out, it’s from Zecora.”

Twilight had entered the kitchen with Rarity by her side and was presenting Apple Bloom with the vial of Silence-Me-Not, much to the dismay of her fashion-wary friend. She looked at the potion with scrutiny, the mystical zebra hadn’t done her wrong before so without too much thought she swiped the potion where it was suspended in the air from Twilight’s magic and then drunk the contents of the vial with a series of fast paced gulps.

“Hey careful there, it might not be safe to drink the whole thing, what does that there list say about this one?” Applejack pointed to Twilight as she shared her concerns and tried to grab the potion from her sister, her hoof was quickly swatted away by Apple Bloom’s, giving her enough time to finish the concoction.

“Relax sis, these ones are usually meant to be drunk all at once.”

After replying to her sister, Apple Bloom looked shocked that the potion had worked as fast as it did, or that it had even worked at all. Similarly the rest of the ponies present in the kitchen shared a look of surprise amongst them, except Twilight Sparkle who looked elated.

“Aha! I knew it was magic! Didn’t I say it would be magic causing this? I need to write this down.” Twilight had pulled out a quill and a small notebook that she was using to keep track of the investigation before continuing, “How did it feel not being able to talk? How did the magic feel that caused this for you?”

Applejack, now recovered from the shock of her sister talking, gave her friend a raised eyebrow, “While we all admire your enthusiasm Twilight, maybe this isn’t the best time for it?” Twilight gave her an embarrassed smile and stepped back two paces to give Apple Bloom some more room. She did however keep her writing utensils at the ready, suspended in the air next to her with the familiar purple glow of her magic surrounding them.

Applejack sat down next to her sister, now sharing the long bench that wouldn’t be out of place at a picnic table and gave her a reassuring hug, “I’m glad you’ve got your voice back sugarcube, how are you feeling?”

“Hmm, I’m alright I think, I can’t remember too much though.”

“Well… what do you remember then?”

Apple Bloom thought to herself briefly, trying to recall events that felt all too recent to her before responding to her older sister.

“Wellll, in the morning I had waffles with you Granny and Big mac. I thought they were a little overdone for my tastes but I liked them well enough with some syrup. Then you tried to make me wash the dishes so after purposefully smashing one of them so that you could let me go early after thinking I wasn’t capable of washing up I went into Ponyville to go meet up with Scootaloo and Sweetie Belle. Along the way Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon tried to say something that was probably mean to me but I was going too fast so I couldn’t hear what they were sayin’. When I did meet up with my friends though Scootaloo didn’t even have her Scooter with her which I thought was weird but-” The verbal onslaught was stopped in its tracks with a well placed hoof to Apple Bloom’s mouth from Applejack.

“Whoa there little one. I knew you shouldn’t have drunk that whole bottle, now you’re talkin' too much. Slow down a touch, who even is this Scootaloo you’re mentioning?”

Apple Bloom looked at her sister with panic and confusion. She knew that she had been talking fast but wasn’t expecting that the most confusing part of the story would be about the existence of one of her friends.

“What do you mean sis? This is Scootaloo we’re talkin’ about, I’ve known her for ages! She and Sweetie Belle are my best friends!”

“Well I’ve known you for your whole life and I only remember you having Sweetie Belle for a close friend. Speaking of, do you know what happened to her? Nopony can make heads or tails of that night and you were the only one there so I’m sorry but this is pretty important and it can’t wait.”

Applejack felt guilt for pressuring Apple Bloom as much as she did but at least she was safe so she can always forgive her later. She glanced over to Rarity who wore an expression of concern and anticipation.

Apple Bloom looked to everypony in the room but was greeted with mostly confused expressions, it was clear that they didn’t remember Scootaloo either. She couldn’t properly process the situation unfolding and could only manage the start of a muddled sentence with no tangible words before everypony was distracted by the front door opening once again, this time in a much more reserved manner. Fluttershy had finally made her way to the house after struggling to keep up with Rainbow Dash and Pinkie Pie, even with her going as fast as she could.

“Hello… what… did I… miss?” Fluttershy’s speech was disrupted with desperate gasps for air as she tried to recover after over exerting herself.

“Fluttershy! You remember my friend Scootaloo right?” Apple Bloom asked, desperate for validation on her friend’s existence from at least one pony.

“Oh my… um… no?”

“Oh.. OK.” Apple Bloom was at a loss for words, as far as she knew nopony had ever come across a dilemma like this.

“I think-” Twilight broke the brewing silence with the intention of spreading some ease to Apple Bloom and to also gain some much wanted answers. “I think it would be best for you to tell us what you remember from the other night. We might be able to figure out what happened to your other friend since whatever happened to Sweetie Belle could be related. Apple Bloom nodded at this, what Twilight had said to her made sense so she thought carefully about that night and recounted the events to everypony present.

“Well… me, Sweetie Belle-” She paused briefly to give everypony a serious look “-and Scootaloo, were out by the edge of Ponyville at night near the Everfree Forest. We had spotted something lightin’ up the trees so we were trying to see what it was. We were out there for ten minutes and didn’t find anything, but then, “it” showed up.”

“What do you mean by “it” sweetheart?” asked Rarity, fearful for the answer.

“It was too dark to see clearly but this wasn’t the shape of any pony, or any creature that I know of. It kept changing and it didn’t make any noise, and there was lots of this weird dark blue light comin’ out of it.”

“Was the light magic?” asked Twilight, who had been actively scribbling down notes during the conversation.

“Uh-uh, it was kinda like magic but it moved on its own, it was like it was lookin’ for us. I remember that the light grabbed Sweetie Belle, she screamed something fierce and I was too scared to do anything. Scootaloo dived in to help but that thing grabbed her, they started to fade away and were lookin’ see-through but then some of that light got a hold of me too, and I remember feeling my mouth was starting to hurt and then I heard a horrible screechy sound before everything went dark. Next thing I know I’m waking up in my own bedroom.”

There was a heavy silence in the kitchen, every pony there was busy processing the story they had heard. It was certainly more than they had been able to find out by themselves in the past two days but not by much. Rarity was horrified that Apple Bloom had gone through this but fear started to creep in, at worst she thought that maybe Sweetie Belle had been taken by some unpleasant Diamond Dogs, not an unknown like this, not something that she couldn’t even picture. As thoughts of Sweetie Belle’s very existence being erased crept into her mind like a malignant force, the silence was broken by an unlikely source who had stopped rocking in her chair.

“There be dark tiding afoot ponies.” At some point during Apple Bloom’s tale Granny Smith had awoken and spoke with familiarity of the situation.

“Iffin what yer sayin’ is true young Apple Bloom, then it might already be too late for poor Sweetie Belle.”

Chapter 2: Preparations

View Online

Time was no friend to Rarity. It stretched out the seconds to make them feel like minutes as if to torture her with her current thoughts. Too Late had never been something on Rarity’s mind until now, it was an oppressive thing to think about and it lingered for her now, setting up its own space in the corner of her mental landscape so that she could be tormented by it in the future whenever it fancied.

“Granny, what the hay are you going on about? How do you know anything about this and why didn’t you say something earlier if you did?” Applejack asked in an interrogative way, upset that Granny Smith had been potentially withholding information from her.

“Now calm yerself Applejack, the last time I saw something like this was when I was a filly, memories that far back don’t come so easy when you’re my age,” said Granny Smith sourly.

Twilight had stopped scribbling her rushed notes when Granny Smith had started talking.

“So something like this has happened in the past? What can you tell us about it?” she asked inquisitively.

“Well let’s see here,” Granny Smith paused and tried to remember as many details as she could muster. “It was right around the time that we first started settlin’ the area for Ponyville. Strange disappearances were happening just like they are now, although back then it would only be for a few hours at most, nopony could really remember where they had gone so we just assumed they were slackin’"

“Yeah yeah yeah, that’s great and all but I don’t see how ponies from olden times skipping work relates to all this?” asked Rainbow Dash with an impatient tone.

“Hold up there Dash,” said Applejack, unhappy that her friend was interrupting her grandmother. “Granny may seem like she’s as aware as a chicken foraging in a bear den but if she says she knows something about this situation then she means it.”

“Oh come on, you're taking her side now? You were the first one angry at her!”

“I’m her family so it’s alright for me, that said I ain’t angry with her I was just shocked-”

“That’s the same thing!”

“Oh for pete’s sake DashI was just trying to say that we should stop interruptin’ and let Granny say her piece so that we can go out and look for Sweetie Belle that much faster.”

The fatigue from the past two days had caught up to Rainbow Dash, she hadn’t been feeling her best but now that fatigue was replaced with frustration at the potential misplaced use of her time.

“Well I heard your Granny! It sounds like she’s suggesting that Sweetie Belle is already dead-” Rainbow Dash quickly tried to cut herself off by putting two hooves over her mouth but she was too late.

Rainbow Dash looked towards Rarity in a panic and her expression was worse than expected. Her once pristine face was taken over by terror, her stomach lurched as she tried to stay conscious. She was unable to respond to Rainbow Dash, unsure whether to be angry or forgiving, the room spun wildly for her and she felt herself drifting away from the situation as time sadistically turned her seconds into hours now.

“Right that does it Dash you’ve gone too far now! I know we’re all a little on edge from a lack of sleep but that doesn’t give you a right to go and suggest something so awful,” said Applejack as she moved within a forelegs length to confront Rainbow Dash’s behavior.

“Well it’s been two days! I’m not exactly happy about this but maybe we’ve got to face the facts here.”

Rainbow Dash pushed Applejack back hard with both of her front hooves, creating some distance between them. Both ponies quickly closed the distance again between them intending to butt heads. Before they could though, Pinkie Pie managed to rush her way into their path, beaming an unnatural smile.

“Heya party ponies we oughta turn these frowns upside down and get rid of this icky tension if we want to find Sweetie Belle”

“Out of the way Pinkie you’re not needed, I’m going to give Dash there a piece of my mind,” Applejack snapped.

“Not.. needed?” Pinkie responded, feeling another attack coming, her fake smile started to crumble.

“Applejack! Be a bit nicer to Pinkie she was just trying to help her friends!” said Twilight who had now set aside her investigation notes on the table next to Apple Bloom’s half eaten breakfast.

Apple Bloom had been observing the feud with horror, she had not seen everypony so tense before, she was currently watching Fluttershy who had been attempting to quell the situation but kept getting cut off by everypony talking at unpredicatable intervals, her voice unable to carry enough volume to be heard.

“Oh dear… I think we should all take a moment to calm down and think rationally,” squeaked Fluttershy, her words falling on deaf ears once again.

Things were getting a bit too serious for Apple Bloom’s liking but she knew they wouldn’t listen to her, she looked towards Granny Smith with pleading eyes but was met with a half smile and her grandmother shaking her head, letting Apple Bloom know not to get involved.

Tensions were bubbling faster than anypony could manage, the argument was now turning into a way for the friends to vent their frustrations.

“Well Twilight maybe we wouldn’t be in this mess if you got Princess Celestia involved from the beginning!” shouted Rainbow Dash, making sure she could be heard over everyone else.

“You know I sent letters to her right away! I haven’t been getting any responses and she isn’t in Canterlot at the moment.”

“Well she wasn’t anywhere else in Equestria I can tell you that, I’ve already searched everywhere through the skies!”

“If you had searched everywhere then you and Pinkie would have already found Sweetie Belle,” concluded Twilight.

Hearing Pinkie Pie’s name Applejack voiced her thoughts to everypony.

“That’s assumin’ she even bothered to look at all and wasn’t out there smelling the roses.”

“I did search though! I tried my bestest and the locket even glowed once but I couldn’t find her,” Pinkie Pie defended herself with tears in her eyes, she could feel her heart in her throat and it was getting more and more difficult to keep her composure in front of her friends.

“What!? You mean it glowed and you still couldn’t find-”

“ENOUGH EVERYPONY” Applejack was cut off by an earth shattering bellow from Rarity who had a complicated expression on her. It was a harsh mix of anger and sadness showing everpony that her limit had been reached, she let out a pained sigh before continuing.

“I’m sure you all mean well and you have your own fair share of grievances but please... Can you allow me this one selfish request to hear out Granny Smith to see if she knows anything that could help us find out what happened to my sister?”

The kitchen had gone silent and Rarity’s statement was met by sheepish nods from each of her friends as they took some distance from each other to listen to Granny Smith.

“You youngins’ are filled with all sorts of energy,” said Granny Smith, impressed with the scene that had broken out in her kitchen. “Now Pinkie Pie, what was this you were mentioning about a glowing locket? If I’m not mistaken Applejack mentioned you were using those to find Sweetie Belle.”

At these words a listless Pinkie Pie regained some energy, her mane inflating like a fluffy balloon.

“Oh, I did!” she said, hoping to bring the energy of the room back up for her friends. “It happened just before one of Fluttershy’s animal friends came to give me a message. I was out in an abandoned village that was all crumbly. It only glowed for a little bit though and I couldn’t find any clues there.” Pinkie Pie held out the locket around her neck in one hoof, observing it with a determined expression, hoping it could glow again and spread some much needed joy to the others.

“Hang on there’s no way that’s true,” said Rainbow Dash, taking to the air to bring the attention of the kitchen her way. “My locket must have been glowing around the same time and I was on top of a mountain, I was nowhere near you!”

“Ooooh were you able to find any clues?”

“Hmph, not a one, it only glowed for a short bit of time for me too.”

After hearing this news Granny Smith reached into her scarf and pulled out Applejack’s locket, surprising everypony and causing Rarity to observe Applejack with suspicion.

“Well this here locket was also glowin’ for a bit not that long ago too.” Granny Smith closed her eyes, deep in thought, the other ponies waiting with anticipation. Once she finished piecing together the intricate weaves of thoughts in her mind Granny Smith opened her eyes and smiled.

“Perhaps then… it ain’t too late for Sweetie Belle," said Granny Smith with a soft reassuring smile. "Now I mentioned earlier that the ponies back then would return none the wiser of what happened to them but this would only happen if they were on their own.”

Granny Smith rocked her chair forward using the momentum to slide off and onto her hooves.

“After about a week of these disappearances going on there was finally somepony that had seen what was going on. They described that spooky blue light you’ve been going on about yanking a pony out of sight somehow. There was only one problem though.”

As Granny Smith she had made her way over to a large wooden dresser and picked up a small picture frame of her as a filly smiling and surrounded by at least a hundred ponies as they posed in front of the sign for Sweet Apple Acres under construction. She gave the picture a warm smile as she reminisced to herself about old almost forgotten bonds that were made with the other settler ponies before continuing.

“That pony was never seen again.”

A gasp could be heard from Flutteshy as she held a hoof to her mouth, her friends shared similar shocked expressions mixed with worry. Twilight Sparkle looked on with worry and grabbed her notes and quill with her magic once more.

“I'm so sorry to hear that, do you know what could have been different?” she asked. “Were there any other ponies that went missing?”

“Hmm, yes there were five altogether that didn’t return. The thing that was different for them is that there was at least one pony with them at the time they were taken, that’s why I figured it would be too late for Sweetie Belle. We even had the princess helping us search and she wasn’t able to find them, however this activity with your magic lockets is making me think that hope ain’t lost just yet.”

The heavy atmosphere that had been lingering in the kitchen lifted all at once from Granny Smith’s words, causing a collective sigh of relief to break out amongst the ponies and even a genuine smile from Pinkie Pie. Twilight Sparkle started to flick through her notes to double check if there was anything she missed so far.

“Well the book I found on those lockets mentioned they’d only be effective if the pony it's looking for is still alive so she must be safe in that sense at least,” said Twilight as she set aside her notes on the table.

Even Rarity started to feel some reassurance after this. She looked down at her hooves and almost allowed herself a smile but thought better of it for now, at least until she could see that her sister was safe and sound. The big question for her though was the next step, so she approached Granny Smith by the dresser who had set the picture frame in the exact position it was before.

“What must we do now? I’m happy that you’ve changed your opinion on my sister's fate but if even Princess Celestia was unable to find those ponies I’m not sure where we could start,” said Rarity, observing the picture frame as she spoke.
Granny Smith smiled and gave Rarity a gentle tap on the back with one of her rattling hooves.

“I think it would be best if you had a chat with the Princess. I'm sure she can set you on the right path.”

“You heard Twilight earlier, she has tried getting in touch with Princess Celestia and to no avail. Nopony knows where she is.”

“Ha! Have a bit more faith in me, I’m not senile yet. If i’m not mistaken, ain’t there more than one Princess in Canterlot nowadays?” Granny Smith asked in a cocky way, a smile full of smugness plastered on her face.

“Princess Luna of course!” shouted Twilight Sparkle in surprise. “I can’t believe I didn’t think to ask her, she may not know where Sweetie Belle is but there’s always a chance she knows where to find Princess Celestia!” Fluttershy who had been standing next to Apple Bloom as a fellow observer approached Twilight, moving her hooves in a delicate manner as if to avoid another argument amongst friends.

“It’s OK Twilight, none of us have slept particularly well recently, it can be easy to miss what’s in front of us.” As if to prove her point, Fluttershy placed a hoof on Twilight’s shoulder in a gentle, reassuring fashion that only she could pull off.

“Thanks Fluttershy,” said Twilight, smiling as she patted Fluttershy’s hoof before turning to the rest of her friends. “Alright everypony our next move is to head over to Canterlot. I think it would be best for all of us to go. I need to let Spike know that I’m heading out, meet me at the library when all of you are ready.”

Grabbing her saddlebags of potions with her magic, Twilight slung them over her back causing them to sit uneven from her haste. Her friends watched as she galloped out the front door, nearly tripping over the bench Apple Bloom was sitting on as she started to compile a new set of notes more organized than the previous.

“Hey wait up, it doesn’t sound like it’s safe for us to be out there by ourselves!” shouted Rainbow Dash in alarm, opting to fly out the window. An unlucky flower pot was blown off its home on the windowsill and crashed into the ground as she passed.

Full of renewed energy and hope, Pinkie Pie wrapped both of her forelegs around Fluttershy’s and threw her over her back as if she were a pair of saddlebags.

“Hehe! Come on Fluttershy lets get after them!”

“Oh dear,” said Fluttershy with concern as she accepted her fate.

Before anypony could react, Pinkie Pie was already halfway down the farm road, her impromptu saddlebags letting out yelps whenever there was a bump in the path.

“Um Rarity?” asked Apple Bloom. “Can I come too? I want to help find Sweetie Belle!” She looked towards Rarity with pleading eyes. Rarity met her gaze and gave Apple Bloom a weak smile that was meant to be a reassuring one.

“I appreciate that you want to help sweetheart but I can’t let you put yourself in danger, you need to stay here and watch out for your Granny.”

Rarity could see that Applejack was watching over them with a conflicted expression.

“We could really use your help Applejack,” said Rarity as she organized Apple Bloom’s mane to fit just that little bit neater on her head. “I’ll understand though if you’d prefer to stay here”

A sigh escaped from Applejack. “I do want to help but-”

“But nothing young missy,” said Granny Smith, cutting off Applejack. “Family’s important but you can’t go using that as an excuse to neglect your friends. We’re safe Applejack and your friends need you, go be that pony they can rely on.” While she spoke Granny Smith wrapped the chain of the locket she’d been holding onto around Applejack’s neck.

Applejack held the locket in her right hoof and looked towards Rarity. The usual elegant air Rarity carried herself with couldn’t be found, her fur was even beginning to show signs of matting in places. Applejack's gaze found its way to Apple Bloom who met her with a beaming smile that stretched to the sides of her face.

“Alright, if you’re sure you’re all good here.”

“Ha! I can take on anything, plus Big Mac is here for backup if needed,” said Granny Smith confidently.

“Shoot where even is that big lug?”

“Well his sibling has been slacking on her apple bucking duties so he’s been doing the harvest.”

“Yikes I definitely owe him one,” responded Applejack with a sheepish smile. She gave Granny Smith a gentle hug and moved over to Apple Bloom to give her a much more aggressive one, messing up her previously neatened mane.

“I appreciate this Applejack, it’s certainly reassuring knowing that you’ll be there,” said Rarity in a relaxed tone.

“We’ll find her safe and sound ya hear? Let’s get ourselves over to the library and quick.”

Granny Smith watched the two ponies leave the farm and out of sight, she smiled and returned to her rocking chair which gave a few disgruntled creaks.

“Good luck out there youngins’”


Spike found himself at the edge of the Everfree forest, the branches on the trees closest to him swayed in the wind, almost beckoning him to join the entanglement of wood and vines. A group of ten timberwolves could be seen amongst the trees, attentively watching Spike, convincing him against returning. Returning? He pondered this word, finding it difficult to understand how he could return to somewhere he hasn’t been to before. With a muddled mind incapable of producing clear memories he backed away from the trees with caution, deciding it would be better to keep his eyes on the woods until he managed to back away far enough to the buildings of Ponyville.

A hooded figure holding a battered tome watched Spike trip over a plant pot before scrambling to his feet, fleeing around the corner of the nearest building, away from the forest’s gaze.

Spike sprinted his way through Ponyville, narrowly dodging ponies along the way. As he approached the library his pace started to gradually slow until he was until he started walking towards the library instead. Something wasn’t right, he couldn’t figure out what he was running from, there was fear in him but no reason for it and there was a small cut on his right arm causing blood to gently trickle out but no memory associated with the injury.

Deep in thought, Spike reached the library, looking curiously at the open door. He found a disheveled Twilight Sparkle who was uncharacteristically tossing aside books with abandon as she searched for something. As she lifted a particularly large collection of musty books her eyes locked onto Spike.

“There you are!” she said, rushing towards Spike to bring him into a constricting hug. “Where did you go? I’ve been looking for you. Oh and you’re injured!” Encasing some nearby cotton buds in her magic, Twilight dabbed one against the cut, slowly turning half of it red before moving onto another.

“Um, I’m not sure where I’ve been actually,” said Spike, stretching out two claws from his right hand along the bottom of his chin. “The last thing I remember was reading this weird book but I couldn’t make out any of the writing. Then all of a sudden I was next to the Everfree forest and I felt like I was being watched so I ran back here.”

Twilight was horrified at the news he told her, she had just heard a similar story from Granny Smith.

“How are you feeling Spike? I think whatever took away Sweetie Belle may have taken you as well.” A shocked expression found its way across Spike’s face now.

“Oh.. I uh, I think I’m OK, apart from my arm the only issue is that I can’t remember anything.”

“Well you’re safe now, I’m going to be heading to Canterlot with my friends to find out where Princess Celestia is, it seems she may know more about what’s causing all of this. I’ll drop you at the Apple Farm and they can watch out for you,” Twilight spoke in a calm motherly tone as she started wrapping a bandage around Spike’s wound.

“Wait I can come help-”

“And I’m sure she could, but I’m worried, there’s something we’re overlooking and I have no idea what to expect other than danger.”

“Hmm it’s not often I see you this serious about something that isn’t a book,” said Spike with concern for her. “Alright I won’t come but be careful out there, I know you’re all Equestria’s saviors and everything but now you’ve got me worrying.”

“Thank you Spike. I will be.” Twilight neatly tied up the ends of the bandage into a bow before giving him a much more gentle hug. Their moment was interrupted by Rainbow Dash who crash landed just outside the doorway.

“Oh good you found him!” Rainbow Dash said as she scrambled to her hooves. “I was totally ready to deliver bad news because I wasn’t seeing him at all out there.”

“Thanks for looking for him,” smiled Twilight. As she did she noticed that Pinkie Pie was standing next to Rainbow Dash.

“Gah!?” screamed Rainbow Dash before falling off her hooves.

“Hiya ponies!” Pinkie Pie said with excitement. “I was over at Fluttershy’s helping her feed the animals before our trip.

“Help…” A weak voice belonging to a much paler than usual Fluttershy could be heard from Pinkie Pie’s back as she slid off like a heavy towel would slide off of a bathroom rail and landing on the ground in a similar fashion.

“Hehe, oops!” said Pinkie Pie with a now embarrassed smile.


Just shy from the entrance to Ponyville, Rarity was walking closely behind Applejack, she felt hopeful and almost confident that Sweetie Belle would be OK and that they could actually find her. There were dark rain clouds forming in the skies, slowly strangling away rays of light, the clouds though contained no water and were not naturally made by the weather pegasi.

Rarity looked at the looming clouds with apprehension, the drab color they brought to the sky was upsetting enough but she could tell that there was something unnatural about them and they appeared to be gaining volume at a fast pace.

“Applejack dear, do those clouds above look a bit off to you?” she asked, still fixated on the sky above. The only response Rarity had gotten though was silence. She craned her neck away from the sky to double check that her friend was still there in front of her. Applejack certainly was still in front of her but she appeared to have stopped mid-stride and her usual bright coloration was muted. Rarity reached out a hoof towards her, “...Applejack?”

Before her hoof touched Applejack’s shoulder Rarity noticed that there were several ponies near and beyond the entrance that weren’t moving. It’s not that they were standing still either but that they had frozen in place during whatever activity they may have been up to at the time. One pony had thrown some popcorn in the air waiting to catch it in his mouth and another pony was mid-air on the way to the ground after tripping over an unfortunately placed rock. Even falling leaves opted to take a break from gravity for the time being.

The clouds above though still moved and were encroaching on Rarity, but out of the corner of her eye she saw movement from something else. Just off the path to Ponyville there was a hooded pony moving amongst the grass, seemingly finding joy with the rougher terrain.

Analyzing the figure Rarity could tell that he was most likely a stallion though he was no bigger than the average mare. His fur was pitch black and Rarity could just about make out a few streaks of silver from his mane poking out from under his hood. There was an air of grace to the pony that Rarity would have normally admired, the fur on his legs looked to be well kept and unaffected by the ground he walked on and the brown hooded cloak he wore was not frayed or dirty.

Looking upon him the fur on Rarity’s neck stood up, there was something deeply unsettling about seeing him move in a frozen world, she thought it wise to not call out to him and instead started to back away towards Applejack. Before she could escape though the pony she was watching with caution stopped and turned towards her, Rarity was unable to make out his face still but his piercing red eyes were all too visible, almost seeming to glow as they fixated their gaze on her.

“I do hope you’re able to find your dear sweet sister… Rarity,” he said with a soft spoken voice.

“Pardon?” asked Rarity. She was flabbergasted by his voice and words, it almost sounded reassuring as if one of her friends spoke it but she felt like his words carried a heinous meaning. Pleased with her reaction the pony smiled sadistically and chuckled to himself before pulling out an old tattered book from under his cloak that Rarity recognised as one of the ones she attempted to read at the Library.

“We’re here Rarity,” said Applejack.

Caught off guard by the voice coming from behind, Rarity gave out a loud gasp, unable to even scream from her surprise and fell to the ground as she turned to face Applejack whose orange fur was back to being bright and vibrant.

“Pete’s sake Rarity, what's got you so spooked? It’s only me,” said Applejack, unamused with her friend’s reaction. Rarity snapped her gaze back around to where she saw the hooded pony but instead only witnessed the usual peaceful roaming expanse of the outskirts along with clear blue skies and not a single pony in sight, just the odd bird or two practicing some swift aerial maneuvers.

“Applejack please tell me you saw somepony out there,” asked Rarity, still scanning the area where she had spotted the stallion.

“Hmm no I don’t recall seeing anypony,” responded Applejack, allowing Rarity to sigh with relief. “We ain’t got time to be lookin’ for strangers right now. I saw Pinkie zippin' across Ponyville to the library so we best be getting there quick.” She extended a hoof towards Rarity who accepted it after a brief pause.

Once Rarity was back on her hooves she gave her surroundings another once over before being pleased that the hooded pony she saw was no longer around. She would love to chalk it up to her exhausted mind playing tricks on her but Rarity knew deep down that what she experienced could very well have been real. Despite this there was no time to consider the implications of what happened as the safety of Sweetie Belle was still very much at the forefront of her mind.

“Right you are darling, let’s be off,” Rarity said with renewed confidence as they both galloped towards the library. When the building drew closer they could see a shocked Rainbow Dash and a worn out Fluttershy splayed on the ground. Twilight greeted the new ponies with a confident smile.

“Looks like we’re all here, let’s go everypony,” she said, stuffing extra notes and quills into her saddlebags with her magic.