Chapter 1
You have been visiting this pony world for about a year or so, and you have made friends with the Elements of Harmony. They have been great companions, but there's something inside that you wanted to tell them.
You have fallen in love with them.
Not just one of them, but all of them. 'How in the world is this possible?' you think to yourself. You don't know, but you need to tell them how you feel to get it off your chest.
Twilight: she is an alicorn princess with both a unicorn horn, and pegasi wings. The reason why you love her is because she has been put in the spotlight in front of an entire country, but she is scared to screw up her royal duties. You understand from previous experiences, and you want to care for her, with all your heart.
Rainbow: she is a pegasus who can control the weather in 10 seconds flat. The reason why you love her is because she claims she's the fastest pony in all of Equestria, and she is very loyal to every pony, especially you. You've also been told how awesome you are from multiple humans and ponies alike, so you know how she feels.
Pinkie: she is an earth pony that makes every pony laugh, and also breaks the laws of physics sometimes. The reason why you love her, is because no matter how sad you are, her baby blue eyes and cute smile will always make you day. She will definitely be a keeper.
Rarity: she is a unicorn who owns a boutique in Ponyville, which you visit a lot to look at the beautiful outfits she has created for other ponies. The reason why you love her, is because she is the most generous pony you have ever met, in fact she has made several jackets for you to wear. You look at her beautiful mane, and wish you could comb your fingers through it.
Applejack: she is an earth pony that works on a farm, which you are familiar with back home. The reason why you love her, is because she is strong, and will always be honest with any pony (lying to her will be difficult). She can be a bit country for your taste, but that doesn't mean you can't love her.
And finally…
Fluttershy: she is pegasus who is very shy when she's around other ponies, but is never shy around you however. The reason why you love her is because she is very kind and warm when she's near you. She has a voice like an angel, and will always be kind to the animals she takes care of.
Hard decision, isn't it? When you see them, you only see them as one big unit, not 6 separate ponies. You can't choose just one, because they all are blessings in your life.
With that being said…you start to head towards Twilight's castle, where you have been invited to one of Pinkie Pie's parties…
You knock on the door to find Twilight's number one assistant, Spike. He looks at you with a smile and asks you "Hey Anon! How are you?". You respond with "I'm doing great. Do you know if Twilight and her friends are here?". Spike gets a confused face and simply says "Yes…why?". You answer him with "Oh uh…isn't Pinkie throwing a party in here?". The purple and green dragon nods with a smile, and let's you in.
As you make your way down the hallways of this shining castle, you start to think of how to tell the Main 6 your feelings for them. 'Hey girls, I love you all' no that sounds stupid. 'Hey, do you want to be my marefriends?' okay that sounds dumb. Maybe this is stupid, but you had to try it, and if they say no, then you would probably be depressed for the rest of your life. Alright, you're about to enter the cutie map room, good luck!
When you walk into the room, you see Pinkie giving cake to her friends, Rainbow showing off, Rarity taking little sips of her punch, Fluttershy is being as cute as ever, Applejack is enjoying some of the cake that Pinkie brought from sugar cube corner, and then Twilight is enjoying the Harry Potter books you gave her for her birthday in Canterlot. As you take a step into the room, Pinkie notices you first. "Anon is here!" she said running towards you to give you a hug. "Okay Pinkie." you say, but the pink earth pony wouldn't let go of you, before Twilight pries Pinkie off of you. The cutie map has 6 chairs for all 6 beautiful ponies, but the girls decided to make you a personal chair at the table that they gave you during Hearth's Warming. You took a seat between Twilight and Rarity, where both give you the 'look'.
"Well Anon, how have ya been lately?" Applejack asks with a smile on her face. "I'm alright" you said "because I get to hang out with all of you". The girls blush, including Rainbow who never likes that 'mushy' stuff. "Oh Anon, you know how to make us blush," Rarity says. Twilight starts to ask "what have you been doing recently?". Pinkie bursts out saying "ARE YOU DOING ANOTHER COMEDY SHOW?". "Woah, calm down Pinkie." You say to the pink pony "I've just been trying to figure out something". "Like what?" Rainbow says. You take a deep breath, look at The Main 6, and start to confess your feelings for them.
"I've been visiting Equestria for a year now, and I have something inside of me that I want to tell you all. You all have been a blessing in my life, and I hope I'm the same with all of you. You all have truly made my life better with every minute I spend time with you, but there's one thing that I have to say…"
"What?" Fluttershy asks
You stare at all of them for the same amount of time, and finally say "... I'm in love with all of you."
The Main 6 all get a shocked face when you say that, and they stay silent for a while before Twilight speaks. "You're in love with us? Why?".
"Because I can't choose just one of you. I want to love all of you with all the respect I can give to all of you, and you all have been so kind to me since I came here. If you say no, I'll understand."
The Main 6 all look at each other with a smile on their faces, and then Rarity speaks. "Oh Darling, you are a blessing in our life, and I would love to be your marefriend."
"You are one of the nicest human beings that I have ever met, and I will love you no matter what." Fluttershy tells you.
"How could no pony love you? You are the coolest, and most loyal human ever!" Rainbow says.
"I've always loved you Anon, but I haven't been able to tell you how I feel. Now I know that I have to be honest with you." Applejack tells you with an honest face.
"You're very funny Anon. You always make ponies smile when you're around, and that's why I love you" Pinkie says.
"You see Anon, we have all been in love with you for a long time. We came up with the idea to make this party so we can confess to you. We always wondered if you felt the same, and now we have no fear…" Twilight says.
"WE LOVE YOU ANON!" They all say.
Now you're beginning to blush. 'How long have they planned this?' you think to yourself. They all stare at you with loving eyes, even Rainbow! You took a while before speaking again.
"D-Do you all really mean i-mmm?"
You were cut off by The Main 6 who tackled you onto the floor, and they were all taking turns kissing you on the lips. You feel good that you were able to tell them how you feel about them, and I think they feel good too.
"So...can we cuddle now?" said Pinkie.
You get off the floor and simply said "Sure"
You all hung out in Twilight's Living room sharing kisses, hugs, jokes, and overall having a peaceful time. As you and The Main 6 start to nap, you are able to say one more thing before you dozed off into a dream where you hoped Luna will allow The Main 6 to join you.
"I love you all."
"We love you too Anon."
Now you have 6 ponies who you love, and who loves you too. Nothing will convince you that this was a bad Idea. Today was a good day.