A Nightmare Night To Remember
It was finally time for Nightmare Night in Equestria. For newly reformed villain Valystine, it was her first. Much to her delight, she had with her her dearly beloved, Dr. Creatio, to help her celebrate. Despite the isolation of her cottage in the Undiscovered West, Dr. Creatio was able to get many of his friends to travel there and help make her first Nightmare Night a special one. Valystine and Dr. Creatio hosted a costume party and were delighted to see the array of costumes his friends wore. Of course, they themselves had dawned spooky Nightmare Night costumes as well. Dr. Creatio had dressed himself up as an evil Dr. Frankenpone while Valystine had dressed up as a rather seductive vampire.
As nighttime befell the land, the party had only truly just begun. The glow-in-the-dark decorations and enchanted lightning bugs made the spring to life in the dead of night. Scarily delicious alcoholic beverages were served along with spookily delightful themed foods and desserts, even the music was terrifyingly amazing. It was a truly magnificent party, but what’s a Nightmare Night party without a few spooky tricks in store for the guests? As Dr. Creatio mingled amongst his friends, Valystine managed to slip away unnoticed to her basement. With a smirk on her face, Valystine created a spell that would turn all of her guests into a hybrid of pony and the creatures they were dressed as.
Valystine snuck back upstairs with her new spell, sealed in a small, skull-shaped bottle. She made her way over to the punch bowl and poured the entire bottle into the alcoholic punch. After giving it a quick stir, she filled cups with the enchanted drink and passed them out to everypony attending the party, including Dr. Creatio and herself.
“Attention, everypony, attention!” Valystine called out “I just wanted to make a quick toast to thank everypony for coming out and making my first Nightmare Night a truly spectacular one. So, thank you all. Now, drink up!”
A roar of cheers erupted in the crowd momentarily before everypony, excluding Valystine, who only looked on with a smirk on her face. A few moments passed before a sudden cloud of smoke and audible ‘pops’ came from each pony. When the smoke cleared, each pony was now turned into the pony-creature hybrids they had dressed as. Seeing that her spell was a success, Valystine drank from her own cup and joined them. She was now a literal vampire and Dr. Creatio was now an ‘evil’ Dr. Frankenpone. The mare who had dressed as a bat was now a batpony, the stallion dressed as a dragon was now a dragon-pony hybrid and so on.
Unbeknownst to Valystine, there was a couple of ‘unfortunate’ side effects to the spell. While it had been mostly successful, Valystine had accidentally given all of the males- as well as three mares- incredibly larger penises and had accidentally made all of them considerably horny. Dr. Creatio trotted up to Valystine, trying to keep his frankendong from flopping all over the place.
“What did you put in the drinks?” He questioned, raising his eyebrows.
“I made a spell that would turn us all into hybrids of costumes and ponyselves,” Valystine answered with a nervous chuckle “I might have rushed it a tad and accidentally and unknowingly allowed it to have those side effects.”
“Well now we’ve got horny and confused guests,” Creatio said with a gesture of his hoof “it would’ve been insanely funny with just the hybrid part, but now the side effects have made it, well, you know… uncomfortable. It would probably be wise to go and whip up a cure.”
“Wait, she did that to us?” Questioned Ember Fall, one of the mares who been given a cock.
“The side effects were unintentional, however the turning of you all into hybrids of pony and your costumes was very much intentional,” Valystine explained, her voice apologetic “I am deeply sorry for any discomfort I may have caused.”
“I like have a gigantic dick as much as the next stallion, but, uh, messing with our bodies like this without consent? Well, that deserves a little punishment, wouldn’t you all agree?” Suggest Thunder Whisk, one of the stallions.
A noise of agreement came from the crowd as smirks flashed on their faces. Valystine looked over at Dr. Creatio worriedly, only to find that he, too, was smirking at her.
“If you’re suggesting what I think you’re suggesting, as her significant other, I should go first,” Dr. Creatio said he wrapped a foreleg around Valystine’s neck.
“She’s got more than one hole, you know,” Thunder Whisk said with a laugh.
“Her pussy is mine, though,” Dr. Creatio said as he sat on his haunches “you can have her backdoor.”
“I call dibs on the mouth!” Ember Fall exclaimed with a giggle.
Before Valystine could get out a single word, Dr. Creatio had leaned back and used his magic to lift up Valystine up in the air and gently sat her down on his massive, exposed cock. A loud moan escaped her throat as her pussy stretched and adjusted to his size. Thunder Whisk trotted up and mounted her from the other side, then swiftly shoved his equally massive cock inside her asshole. Valystine let out another moan as she felt him enter her back hole. She could feel the wall between both cocks get thinner due to their sheer size. Wordlessly, both stallions began thrusting slowly.
Ember Fall trotted up and presented her cock to Valystine with a smirk on her face. Valystine, accepting her punishment, grabbed Ember’s cock with a hoof and brought it to her mouth. As she began to suck off Ember Fall, Valystine used her magic to pump the shaft. The sight of Valystine being fucked by three different ponies sent the others into a horny frenzy. The gathered themselves into groups of three or four and began fucking away like it was nopony’s business. This encouraged Thunder and Creatio to thrust even faster, earning another albeit muffled moan from Valystine.
As time went on, moan after moan and wet slap after wet slap filled the room. Thunder Whisk and Creatio were now pounding away at Valystine’s holes as fast as their bodies would allow them. At this point, Valystine had came three times and her pussy was absolutely drenched in marecum. So much so that it dripped down and soaked her ponut. As for Ember, she had already cummed four times inside of Valystine’s mouth and was now pounding away at Valystine’s throat. Valystine moaned loudly as she could feel another orgasm building up rapidly, threatening to make her explode with another gush of marecum. After another few thrusts from all three cocks, Valystine came the hardest she had since they started. Thick and deliciously musky marecum gushed from her pussy like a geyser and dribbled down to her ponut.
Her major gush sent Dr. Creatio and Thunder Whisk, as well as Ember Fall, over the edge and into their own orgasms. One after the other, their thick, milky cum filled and slowly oozed out of all of her holes. Valystine swallowed Ember’s seed as her eyes rolled into the back of her head and intense pleasure washed over her. As if on cue, the rest of the orgy joined in a chorus of moans and orgasms. Mixed cum puddled on the floor beneath them. Thunder Whisk and Ember Fall pulled their cocks from their respective holes and sat on their haunches, panting with satisfied smirks on their faces. Dr. Creatio passionately kissed Valystine and held her close.
Suddenly, clouds of smoke suddenly erupted from each pony and slowly dissipated. When the smoke disappeared, everypony was now back to normal. Ember’s new cock was gone and both Thunder and Creatio’s cock had returned to their normal sizes. Everypony was now back to their normal ponyselves and back in their costumes.
“The cure was sex. Who knew!” Ember said with a laugh.
“Pfff, yeah. Now this was definitely a Nightmare Night to remember,” Thunder Whisk said as he laughed as well.
Valystine looked from Dr. Creatio to Thunder Whisk to Ember Fall and grinned from ear to ear. Everypony laughed in agreement as they began to clean up their passionate mess.