Chapter 1
Twilight Sparkle was walking down the road to Sweet Apple Acres. She needed some apples for a pie she was baking. As she approached the Apple family farm, she heard loud moaning coming from somewhere in the orchard. Curiosity peaked; she followed the moans, which led her to a sight she never thought she'd see. She saw Big Mac fucking his sister by one of the apple trees. The purple alicorn watched in awe as Big Mac thrusted in and out of his sister.
She then remembered why she came here in the first place.
"Hi AJ", Twilight blurted out.
Applejack gasped and looked to her left to see the shocked and embarrassed face of her purple friend.
"Twi, I can explain! Well...actually I can't", AJ said, hanging her head down in embarrassment.
"It's okay, it's just...just...ugh!" Twilight yelled in frustration. She galloped away as fast as she could. Big Mac pulled out of his sister and the two earth ponies ran after Twilight. They eventually caught up with her as she entered her castle.
"Twi we're so sorry..."AJ began.
"I'm not upset that you fuck your brother AJ, I just...something suddenly came up, okay? Important princess stuff. I gotta get ready to go to the crystal empire. I'll talk to you later. Bye", the princess of friendship said, slamming the door of her castle. AJ could tell that Twilight wasn't exactly being honest with her, but she also knew that Twilight needed some space, so she and Big Mac made their way back home.
Twilight ran to her room and shut the door, ignoring Spike's pleas to find out what was wrong. The princess of friendship hid under her blanket and wept.
"Why couldn't you do that to me Shiny? Why do you have to be such a good guy? How come AJ gets to fuck her brother and I don't?!" Twilight lamented in her head. She didn't dare voice these frustrations out loud.
Spike, meanwhile, kept knocking on her door begging to know what was troubling her. Starlight Glimmer ran into him and said, "What's going on here?"
"Twilight came home upset and she won't tell me what's wrong", Spike said.
Twilight then opened the door and glared at him. "There's nothing wrong Spike. I'm taking a trip to the Crystal Empire...alone! Have dinner without me because I won't be back until tomorrow morning at the earliest. Bye!" she said before teleporting outside the castle and galloping at full speed to the train station. Spike was about to run after her, but Starlight stopped him.
"I think it’s best to just let her be" Starlight suggested.
"This is just so weird even for her," Spike said, confused.
Twilight Sparkle arrived in the Crystal Empire a few hours later. She trotted briskly to the palace where she hoped to find her brother. Luckily for her, he was in the throne room. Unfortunately, Cadence was there too, but that was only a minor inconvenience to the purple alicorn. On the way in, Twilight told the guards not to let anypony enter the room.
"Hello, Twilight. What brings you here?" Cadence cheerfully asked
"I need to talk to my brother. Alone" Twilight said.
"Oh dear, well I'll just be in the library if you need me" Cadence said. She trotted off to the library with a puzzled look on her face.
"What's this about?" Shining Armor asked
Twilight looked around nervously, making sure the coast was clear.
"Shiny..." Twilight started, shaky.
"Yes, Twily?" Shining Armor said
Twilight turned around and lifted up her tail, presenting her marehood to him.
"I want you to rut me!" Twilight said, desperation heavy in her voice.
Shining armor let out an exasperated sigh and said, "Twily, we've been over this a million times. I'm not having sex with you."
"But why?" Twilight asked
"Because incest is wrong,” Shining Armor replied
"AJ and Big Mac do it" Twilight said.
"What?!" Shining said shocked.
"Yeah, I caught them fucking in the Apple Orchard. He was really giving it to her good. Unfortunately, I kind of interrupted them. Poor Mac, I don't think he got to finish. He must have blue balls now. I won't give you blue balls though. Now come on, let's fuck! Cadence might get curious and come back if we wait too long. We don't have time for foreplay" Twilight said, trying to sound seductive. She then performed a quick birth control spell and said, "Now you don't need to use a condom."
"The answer is still no", Shining said.
"Oh come on", Twilight said.
"No, Twilight" Shining Armor said, firmly.
"Please", Twilight begged.
"No", Shining Armor said, annoyed.
"Just do me this one time and I'll never ask again,” Twilight said.
"I said no Twilight!" Shining Armor shouted.
Cadence heard the shouting and ran into the room.
"What's going on in here?" Cadence said, concerned.
Twilight bolted out of the throne room before either Cadence or Shining could say a word. She teleported out of the palace, finding herself back on the streets of the Crystal Empire. She wandered around the city, unsure of where to go or what to do. She then found herself in a part of the city she had never been to before, a part of town illuminated by red lights and ponies posing seductively next to signs advertising their services. When she reached the end of the street, she saw a changeling standing in front of a building next to a sign saying, "I will do anything for love". Next to that sign was another, displaying a menu of sexual services he was willing to perform and how much each act would cost. This gave Twilight an idea, a real, devious idea. She trotted up to the changeling and said, "Hello, um…I am in need of your…services."
"Oh, sure, princess. What would you like?" the changeling asked.
"I want you to transform into my big brother, Prince Shining Armor, and fuck me" Twilight said, blushing, also a tad nervous.
"I can't do that! I'll get thrown in the dungeon!" the changeling said, worried.
"You won't get thrown in the dungeon, I promise. I'll pay you extra if you do this for me" Twilight said.
The changeling mulled it over before finally saying, "Okay, I'll do it. 25 bits and some love of course."
"Here's 50. I'll give you the love when we get inside", Twilight said, throwing him a bag of bits from her saddlebag.
The changeling buzzed with delight. In a flash of green flame he transformed into a perfect copy of Shining Armor.
"Shall we step inside princess?" the fake Shining Armor asked
"Call me Twily" Twilight said.
"So shall we step inside, Twily?" the changeling said.
"Sure, Shiny" Twilight said.
The changeling led her into his apartment where he did his work. It was a small place with one bedroom and a kitchen. The two walked over to the bed, which was near a window that faced the street. The window lacked blinds or curtains, which made Twilight a bit concerned.
“They won’t look for me, right”, Twilight thought to herself, worrying about the possibility that Shining and Cadence might come looking for her, “they probably think I’m on the train back to Ponyville.” She shrugged off her concerns and focused on what was about to happen.
"So how do you want to start?" the impostor Shining Armor asked.
"With this..." Twilight said. She then kissed the fake version of her brother passionately, momentarily forgetting that he wasn't the real thing. The impostor wasn't used to his clients kissing him, but it felt so nice. And the amount of love flowing through her was so high he didn't know if he could handle it.
Twilight then broke the kiss and said, "Now push me down on the bed and fuck me."
Now this was something the impostor was more used to. He pushed Twilight down onto the bed and positioned himself on top of her.
"So you want your big brother's cock, right?" the fake Shining Armor said.
"I've never wanted anything more in my life than your cock Shiny", Twilight said.
"There's a condom under the pillow. Why don't you help me put it on?" the impostor said.
"Sure, but I already used a birth control spell on the way over here" Twilight said.
"I'd rather not take chances", the fake said.
Twilight nodded and lifted the up the pillow with her magic and found the condom. She ripped open the package and pulled out the condom with her magic, letting the pillow drop back down on the mattress. The fake Shining Armor stood on the edge of the bed as Twilight used her magic to put the rubber on him. Now wearing protection, the impostor once again got on top of Twilight, sliding his cock into her pussy. Twilight moaned as he started fucking her, letting herself get lost in the simulated incest and forgetting that this wasn't really her brother.
"You like that, Twily?" the impostor said.
"Fuck me harder, Shiny!" Twilight begged.
"Anything for you, Twily" the fake said.
He picked up the pace, fucking her harder and faster. Twilight moaned louder, she loved the feeling of her "brother" inside her. She wished she could have this all the time. She never wanted this pleasure to end.
"Yes Shiny! Fuck your sister!" she said in between moans.
The fake Shining Armor kept up the pace. The love emanating from her was off the charts. He could feed a whole hive with this, if he was still part of a hive. He carefully breathed in the love as he fucked her. Twilight barely felt the love being extracted from her.
Intoxicated with pleasure, Twilight closed her eyes as she reached her climax, her body writhing in pleasure. Seeing this, the impostor reached his own climax.
Twilight then opened her eyes and gazed at the fake Shining Armor who in that moment seemed so real to her.
"I love you Shiny", Twilight said without really thinking.
The impostor gasped and it was then that Twilight remembered that the Shining Armor before her was actually a changeling.
"Whoops. I got carried away there", she said.
"It's fine. Ponies get carried away in their fantasies sometimes", the fake said. As he pulled out of her, he glanced at the window and saw the real Shining Armor and Cadence looking back.
"Um, Twilight", the impostor said, pointing to the window.
Twilight turned her head to face the window to see Cadence and the real Shining Armor looking at her shocked, their eyes wide and their jaws dropped. Dash, Pinkie, Fluttershy, Rarity, and AJ were there too. Out of all of her friends, AJ was the only one who didn’t look at her with a shocked expression. Instead, she gave Twilight a look that showed curiosity rather than shock, a raised eyebrow instead of widened eyes and a dropped jaw. The changeling quickly returned to his natural form and ran off. Twilight just wanted to disappear at that moment...and so she did. She teleported out of the shabby apartment and found herself not on the streets of the crystal empire, but in her old living quarters in Canterlot. Bewildered, she touched the books on the shelf just to make sure she wasn't dreaming. They felt real, much to Twilight's relief. She wandered around her old library when she saw Princess Celestia reading a book and drinking tea.
"Oh, Twilight! Didn't expect to see you here" Celestia said, startled.
Twilight jumped back a little and said, "oh sorry Princess, I was practicing my long-distance teleportation skills and I ended up here.”
"Oh I see. You don't mind that I'm here do you? This place hasn't been used at all since you moved to Ponyville and I figured it would be a good place to get away from it all" Celestia said.
"That's fine. I understand the need to get away from things" Twilight replied.
Celestia returned her attention to her book as Twilight resumed her trot through the old library. Memories came flooding back as she passed by the old books. She was about to read one when she heard somepony come in.
"There you are, 'Tia! I got a message for you from Cadence", Luna said.
Twilight froze. Luna whispered the message to Celestia. Her eyes widened in shock for a few seconds before returning to normal.
"Twilight, where are you? I want to talk to you about something" Celestia said, concerned.
Panic gripped the purple alicorn once more and once again she teleported, this time she ended up at her castle. When she arrived, she trotted up to the top floor as quick as she could and hid in the only room on the floor. There was nothing in the room except for a few empty boxes, which she could have sworn she told Spike to recycle. But that was trivial compared to what she had just got caught doing.
"I'll hide forever", Twilight said in her mind. She lay down on the floor, tired, ashamed and terrified of what her friends now thought of her. Several minutes later, she heard a loud noise coming from downstairs. Curious, Twilight crept out of the room and stood by the stairs. She heard the noise again, but this time she recognized it as Princess Celestia's Royal Canterlot Voice. She heard hoofsteps coming up the stairs from a couple floors below.
"Twilight Sparkle!" boomed Celestia as she entered each floor. Spike was with her too, and he checked each room on each floor for Twilight.
Twilight was shaking. She tried to teleport, but she was still exhausted from using her long-distance teleportation spells.
"Shit" Twilight thought to herself. She went back into the room and hid behind some boxes, hoping Celestia would give up and go home. Twilight heard her mentor's hoofsteps and voice as the white alicorn ascended the final staircase to the top floor. She then heard the door open.
“Twilight? Are you in here?” Spike said. Twilight stayed silent.
“Search the room” Celestia said.
Spike did as he was told while Celestia watched from the doorway. As he reached the back of the room, he saw an opening between the vast stacks of boxes. He looked through the opening and saw Twilight crouching and hiding her face in her wings.
“Twilight?” Spike whispered.
She turned around to see her faithful dragon assistant with a concerned expression on his face. He knew Celestia wanted to talk to Twilight about something, something that seemed rather important, but he had no idea what. Twilight mustered up all of the energy she could and teleported just outside the room. Twilight then trotted down the stairs as fast as she could, hearing Celestia’s hoofsteps behind her. When Twilight reached the ground floor, she saw all of her friends standing there along with Shining and Cadence. They were greatly concerned for their friend. Twilight panicked and bolted for the front door. Just as she was about to reach it, Rainbow Dash blocked her. Twilight then turned around and tried the back door, but was blocked by Luna. Twilight sighed in defeat.
A few minutes later, Twilight and her friends, with the exception of Spike because he was deemed too young, gathered around at the dining room table. Princess Celestia was the first to speak.
“Twilight, we are not here to punish you. We just want to understand why” Celestia said.
Twilight sighed, she really didn’t want to talk about this, but she knew she wasn't getting out of this either.
“...I’ve had feelings for my brother since, well, ever since I was old enough to have those kind of feelings”, Twilight said, nervously.
“But why him?” Celestia asked
“I don’t know really know why. I guess my familial love for him just evolved into something else. I thought maybe those feelings would go away after he got married, but I still want him” Twilight said.
“Have you tried dating other ponies?” Celestia asked
“I may have had a few one-offs here and there, but none of them worked out. I just can’t get Shining out of my head” Twilight said.
“I…think you mean heart”, Cadence said, “First love is always the strongest. Even when you know you can’t have them, that love still lingers.”
Twilight nodded in agreement.
“Truth be told, I've always had a feeling you felt something for him. It wasn't until today that I finally got confirmation. I'm not mad, I'm just a little shocked,” Cadence said.
"We all feel the same way, darling. We're all a little shocked, but we'll get over it", Rarity said.
"We'll always be there for you" Fluttershy said.
"We're still friends, even though you want to bang your own brother", Rainbow Dash remarked.
"Rainbow Dash!" Rarity exclaimed.
"What?” Rainbow Dash said.
"There ain't nothing wrong with banging your own brother!" Applejack blurted out.
Everypony gasped.
"Um...I don't do it with my own brother if that's what y'all are thinking! I'm just...um...trying to make Twilight feel better", Applejack lied unconvincingly. An awkward silence followed.
"Thanks everypony. By the way, how did you guys even find me in the first place?" Twilight said, breaking the silence.
“Well, I could tell you were upset so I gathered the girls and we all bought tickets to the Crystal Empire”, Applejack said.
“We were really worried for you, so we followed you to the palace”, Rarity said.
“But the guards wouldn’t let us into the throne room because they said you were speaking to Shining Armor privately”, Rainbow Dash said.
“We waited outside the room for you, but then Shining and Cadence came rushing out looking for you so we followed them”, Fluttershy said.
“We went all over the city looking for you! It took forever, but we finally got a tip from a local who saw you trotting towards the red-light district, but we got turned around and by the time we found you, you were getting plowed” Pinkie said.
“I see”, Twilight said.
"My sister and I are here for you too Twilight," Celestia said, “Speaking of Luna, I believe it is time for her to raise the moon. Good night everypony."
"Good night and thank you" Twilight said.
Celestia and Luna then returned home to Canterlot. Twilight’s friends decided to return home as well. Cadence asked to stay for the night, so Twilight gave her and Shining one of the guest rooms. The couple went up to their room where they could talk in private. Shining Armor was still in shock over what his sister had done and the things she had revealed at the meeting. He couldn’t believe his sister was that desperate.
“She’s gotta get over this eventually, right?” he lamented to Cadence.
“I don’t know Shiny, these thoughts of hers have been going on for so long, I don’t think it’s going to just ‘go away’ overnight”, Cadence said.
“Why not? I used to have those kinds of thoughts about her too, but I managed to push them away. Why can’t she do the same?” Shining said.
“Did you really push them away or are you just telling yourself that?” Cadence said.
“What?” Shining said.
“I have solved many different love problems over the years. I have seen this before, one or both siblings repressing their feelings for each other. You would both be a lot happier if you just accepted these feelings and well…did it. Get each other out of your systems or maybe you two would really enjoy it and can make it a more permanent thing? Our marriage is open, remember?” Cadence said.
“I know our marriage is open, but I didn’t think it was that open”, Shining Armor said.
“It was just a suggestion Shiny. Just sleep on it, okay”, Cadence said.
Shining Armor sighed and said, “okay.” The couple then got into bed and fell asleep.
The next morning, Twilight sat in the dining room, pondering recent events. She was glad that her friends weren’t mad at her, but she still felt ashamed.
"I'm a terrible pony" Twilight lamented, staring off into the distance.
"No, you're not", a voice spoke.
Twilight was startled. She knew who it was, but she couldn't look him in the face.
"Shining, I'm so sorry,” Twilight said.
"It's fine, Twily", Shining Armor said, "I’m sorry I kept turning you down. I’m sorry you had to turn to a hooker to get what you wanted. Truth is, I have those kinds of feelings for you too, though I’ve tried to repress them. I didn’t want to admit to myself that I want to fuck my own sister."
Twilight gasped.
"I didn't want you to act on those feelings. I hoped if I rejected you enough you would get over it. I have thought about you ‘in that way’, but I didn’t want to act on it because I felt it was wrong. But no matter how much I repress those feelings they never go away. I'm sorry" Shining, confessed.
“Oh Shiny, you didn’t have to hide this”, Twilight said, giving him a hug.
Shining hugged his sister back and said, “Cadence and I had a talk last night and she said she’s okay if you and I fuck.”
"Do you really want to fuck me though? Or are you just doing this because I'm a pitiful pony?" Twilight said.
"You're not a pitiful pony. You're a beautiful pony", Shining Armor said.
Twilight gave him a kiss and then whispered in his ear, “so, how do you want to do it?”
“We can go to your room”, Shining whispered, “wait a minute, why are we whispering?”
“I thought it would be sexy, it’s also how I’ve always thought this would start out”, Twilight said.
“What happens next?” Shining asked.
“This…” Twilight said before giving him a deep, passionate kiss. Shining deepened the kiss and began stroking her mane. His member grew hard as he made out with his sister. He felt so dirty and yet it felt so satisfying for him to finally do this. Twilight felt the same way. When they broke the kiss, Twilight looked down and saw Shining’s hard, throbbing cock.
“Looks like somepony's ready “, Twilight said, stroking his cock with her magic.
Shining moaned as his sister jerked him off with her magic.
“You like that?” Twilight said.
“Oh yes”, Shining said.
Twilight then got underneath her brother and inserted his cock into her mouth. She sucked on it hard, her brother’s pre-cum dripping down her throat.
“That’s it, Twily. Just like that”, Shining said.
Shining’s words got her turned on even more, her pussy dripping wet with arousal. She used her magic to masturbate as she continued to suck her brother off. Shining was getting close. The forbidden fantasy of having his sister pleasure him coming to life was about to push him over the edge.
“Twily, I think I’m gonna cum”, Shining said.
Just at that moment, Starlight Glimmer walked in. She was taken aback by what she saw and the two siblings just stared at her speechless. Twilight removed her brother’s cock from her mouth and continued to stare at Starlight, unsure of what to say. After a few seconds of awkward silence Starlight finally said, “I was just going to say that breakfast is ready, but it looks like Twilight is already having her’s. I’m just gonna go…um…breakfast will be on the kitchen table in a minute, okay?”
Twilight and Shining simply nodded.
Starlight Glimmer then left the room feeling awkward and confused. Twilight got out from under her brother and stood up.
“Sorry, I got carried away”, Twilight said.
“It’s fine Twily. Do you want have breakfast first or do you wanna go to someplace private and continue our fun?” Shining asked.
“Well…let’s have breakfast first. I don’t want it to get cold. We can continue playing afterwards”, Twilight said.
Once Shining Armor’s member became flaccid again, the two siblings exited the room and joined Cadence, Starlight and Spike for breakfast. Cadence gave the two ponies a knowing wink as they sat down. Twilight couldn’t wait for breakfast to be over with. In awkward silence, everybody ate their breakfast, which consisted of pancakes topped with a homemade whipped cream, an addition that had been suggested by Cadence. Spike could feel the awkwardness in the air; he was confused why such awkwardness existed between his friends. When the awkward breakfast ended, Shining, Twilight and Cadence went upstairs. As they walked down the hallway towards their rooms, Cadence whispered to Twilight and Shining “So how was it? I could tell you two were up to something before breakfast.”
“Well, we got interrupted before either of us got to cum”, Twilight whispered.
“I’ll leave you two alone then”, Cadence replied, entering the guest bedroom her and Shining were using.
Twilight beckoned Shining to follow her into her room. Shining did so and once inside, Twilight shut the door and kissed him.
“Let’s get back to what we were doing” Twilight said, seductively.
Twilight then laid down on her bed and exposed her marehood to her brother, who began to salivate at the sight before him. Shining’s erection returned as well. Twilight’s horn then lit up as she performed a birth control spell on herself. Seeing this, Shining performed a similar spell on himself.
“You didn’t need to do that, Shiny. I already performed it on myself” Twilight remarked.
“I like to perform it on myself too. Just in case” Shining said.
Shining Armor then got closer to where his sister lay and touched her wet pussy. He then began rubbing her clit. Twilight moaned loudly as her brother massaged her clit with his hoof. He then replaced his hoof with his tongue and began licking her marehood up and down, focusing on stimulating her clit and savoring the taste of her wet pussy. Twilight moaned more as Shining went down on her; she could’ve cum just from this. He then slipped his tongue inside her, teasing her.
“I need your cock in me now, Shiny” Twilight begged.
This was the moment Shining had secretly dreamed of. He positioned himself on top of his sister and said, “ready Twily?”
“Yes, Shiny”, Twilight said.
Shiny then slowly inserted his member into his sister’s marehood. He loved the feeling of her tight walls hugging his length. He then started to slowly thrust in and out of her. Twilight moaned as her brother’s cock penetrated her marehood.
“Harder, faster”, she begged.
Shining had no problem with that. He fucked her as hard and as fast as she wanted. It was in that moment he realized how badly he wanted this, how badly he wanted to fuck his sister. Twilight moaned loudly, caught up in the ecstasy of the moment. For her, this was a dream come true. No other stallion would ever feel this good. She wrapped her hooves around him, holding onto him as he rutted her good.
“Cadence is so lucky”, Twilight thought as her brother made her feel every inch of his member.
Twilight could feel her climax approaching fast. Shining felt the same way about his climax.
"I'm gonna cum, Twily!" Shining said.
"So am I!" Twilight said.
“Can I cum inside?” Shining asked
“I wouldn’t want it any other way”, Twilight said.
At that moment, the two siblings reached their climax at the same time. Shining ejaculated inside her, thick ropes of cum filling her up so much that his cum spilled out of her pussy and onto the bed sheets. Twilight’s orgasm was even more powerful than the one she had with the changeling, her body writhing with even more pleasure than the last time. Shining experienced his own powerful orgasm, his body writhing in forbidden pleasure. Exhausted, Shining laid down on top of his sister, embracing her. They both closed their eyes and just enjoyed the afterglow without saying a word. As the afterglow faded and Shining's dick became flaccid again, he pulled out of her and lay down next to her. The realization then finally hit them of what they had just done. Both siblings felt an odd mix of joy and guilt at this realization.
"So what happens now?" Twilight asked
Shining pondered her question. Having sex with his sister felt so good, but at the same time oh so wrong.
"That was amazing. We really shouldn't be doing this though. What would mom and dad say?" Shining said.
Twilight sighed and said, "I feel kind of guilty too, but that was so good. Our parents don't have to know about this. Nobody does"
"I love you so much, Twilight, but...brothers and sisters aren't supposed to fuck each other" Shining Armor said.
"Says who? Princess Celestia only forbids siblings to marry each other. There is no law in Equestria that says we can't have sex", Twilight said.
"But…" Shining started to say.
"Of course there’s a stigma around incest, but like I said nobody has to know about this. Tell me Shiny, and be honest with your answer, what do you want this to become? Do you want this to be a one off or do you want this to be a regular thing? I'll be fine with whatever you decide" Twilight said.
"I...I honestly want this to be a regular thing. Being with you in this way is completely different than when I'm with Cadence. I love both of you and as long as you are okay with sharing me with her, then we can make this a more permanent thing" Shining said.
"I'm fine with sharing" Twilight said.
“And if you ever do find a special somepony, I won’t stand in the way” Shining said.
The two siblings then kissed each other once again. Unfortunately, it was time for Shining and Cadence to return home. The two siblings gave Cadence a knowing wink before she and Shining left to return to the Crystal Empire.
"Another love problem solved", Cadence said to herself as she and her husband left Twilight’s castle.