• Member Since 29th Mar, 2013
  • offline last seen Yesterday

Allsmiles


Comments ( 12 )

Hmm, good start, but I will with hold anything really positive or negative till I see the story more flushed out. I follow with great interest.

2337621
An understandable position. I hope that it provides you entertainment as I flesh it out.

Nice chapter again, good recounting of Equestria going to Tartarus. And poor Scholar unicorn...

2359607
I am very glad you feel that way, I hope chapters continue to impress as they come.

2362283
Thank you, I am glad that you feel so, and indeed... I don't doubt that there are many ponies who share a pain similar to his in that world.

so, Applejack knows the scholar, or met him before

Just to make sure, I imagine the scholar as a slightly more elderly stallion. Not granny smith age, but not as young as the mane six or Big Mac anymore.
Thus the swearing seems to be a bit over the top and pulls me out of the immersion somewhat.
If you want to make him younger, than this surely achieves that. But if you want to portray a more elderly and more sorrowfull stallion, you might want to cut back a bit on the colorfull swearing. ;)

Okay, I like this guy already. He's got a good heart and see the madness that is going on around him.

(And I too wonder how this all happened. What, did the Elements just go insane all of the sudden? Are the ponies of Equestria so bloodthirsty. It's too hard to imagine that a peaceful nation that doesn't even have much of a standing army and is so bent on friendship, start tearing itself apart and lower itself to such evils.) Celestia weeps for her country, tears lost upon madponies.

Keep up the good work.

I freakin' love this story

so... are you going to just end this here?

2951071
No. Incomplete tag still applicable.

2951135
Thanks, it would be incredibly unsatisfying to for the story to end like this.

Login or register to comment