• Member Since 10th May, 2012
  • offline last seen Nov 16th, 2022

Matthew Penn


I write imaginary stories about cartoon horses.

T

Rainbow Dash was going to make history. It was going to be a day nopony will ever forget. With a heart of steel and a force will and determination, she creates the largest sonic rainboom the world has ever seen. She successfully pulls it off... but she never came down.

Now everyone is on an emotional roller coaster as they come to terms with the loss of their most loyal friend in their own ways. Through all of the pain of their internal struggles they have to endure, they soon discover that some things are beyond their control, like the death of a good friend; how the lives of the ones we love are not truly lost if we live their's through our own, and how the best thing to do is to continue the legacy they left behind.



Special thanks goes to Matthais Unidostres

Chapters (21)
Comments ( 54 )

What happened? I was going to read this story once it got almost done. Where did the content go?

The author is doing a complete rewrite from scratch, and the old chapters are gone.

6274500 I've written a few blog posts about a rewrite.

6274661 I was wondering if this was a rewriting of the story or if someone stole it and published it as 'his'.

You can’t just get over things like this in a short time. You can, it may be hard but you can get over it in a very short amount of time. when i was a small child my grandfather who meant the world to me died of cancer. the day after i found out that he died i was fine. oddly enough not a tear was dropped by me.

6282029 It's hard for me to move on when somebody close to me dies. Back in middle school my favorite grandparents died a year apart from each other, and it tore me apart inside. I felt numb during that time. I accepted that they're gone, but I don't want to lose anybody else.

I guess I the problem I have is learning to let go.

6282054 HIIIII you published this about a minute ago and now i'm responding already! :D

I shouldn't read this because of the severe loss I have had this past two years, but I read it anyway. I am bawling. Like a child. My gods.

I love it. Please continue!

6282975 Don't worry, I will this time.

This made me cry.. Again!

Without Rainbow Dash to guide her, who can she turn to?

Who, indeed?

Just a guess on my part, but I think that it's going to be a certain yellow Pegasus.

Just a note Pinkie pranked Gilda once. All the other pranks were done by Dash.

Even so I really like how you have Pinkie trying to actively forgive Gilda (just like in the Griffonstone episode actually). You should have more moments with Pinkie and Gilda remembering Dash considering how important Dash was to the two of them.

Hmm... With the element of Loyalty gone... Who will replace her role? Maybe it's... Scootaloo...

Eh, who knows. I might as well be full of cheese. Why cheese in particular is something to ask Pinkie.

Chapter seven needs a lot of editing..

It's sad that the rainboom who gave Pinkie purpose and happiness was also the one who took away her happiness in a dead friend.

My guess, Rainbow Dash isn't dead. After all, they Never Found The Body.

6304051 I'm writing an alternate storyline where Rainbow Dash doesn't die, but is severely injured. It's going to be published in September.

This story you're reading now, Rainbow Dash is dead. She's bleeding demised. She's not pining. She's passed on. This pegasus is no more. She has ceased to be. She's expired and gone to meet her maker. This is a late pegasus. She's a stiff. Bereft of life, she rests in peace. If you hadn't nailed her to the perch, she'd be pushing up daisies. She's rung down the curtain and joined the choir invisible.

This is an ex-pegasus.

This needs some work with grammar and mostly tenses here and there....

6304387

:pinkiehappy:

I snorted my soda over my screen when I got the reference.

Fantastic joke.

I'll be attending a service of my own soon enough, but your never really prepared for this, noone ever is.

I'm sorry. I left a like, but I just can't read this. Reading the description Made me cry:applecry:

Damn all this dust in here!:fluttercry:

Please re-read your chapters before posting them. They're okay, but not as good as your first chapter.

I really like the way you are using Dashie's death to delve into Pinkie's character. I have always thought of Pinkie and Dash being pretty close so it affecting her greatly makes a lot of sense to me. I am also liking how you are using this as an opportunity to go into her family dynamics. It will be interesting to see where this goes.

i have a theory if i recall Rainbow's final trick was called the Rainbow "TIME"-extravaganza so if there isn't a body or at least anything that is apart of Dash like a piece of her mane or feathers then maybe her trick accidentally sent her back or forward through time.
it's not a solid theory, but it just makes sense to me.

Sometimes the most private moments have to be done in the dark of the night.

Truly this is a touching tale so far. Very emotional.

Please do keep up the good work upon such a great story like this one.

That reminds me: Whatever became of Tank the Tortoise, Rainbow's pet, in your story ?

Surely some pony must have recalled him by now, right ?

Please do keep up the good work.

6431598
Tank never entered my mind when I wrote this... at all. It's probably too late to add him in the story now.

I'm sorry.

Poor Scootaloo, where's Princess Luna when you need her in this case ?

Great update and nice bonding between Scootaloo and the Apple family. It's nice to see her relax a bit.

Please do keep up the good work upon such a great tale like this one.

6431882

It's never too late for Tank to make an appearance. Besides aren't Tortoises a long living animals ?

Why not have him fly around Ponyville looking for Rainbow Dash or at least notice something is wrong ?

Pie sisters reunited. Wonderful update to the story. Great showing of Pinkie to understand the effect her first party had on her family.

Please do keep up the good work upon such a great story.

Pinkie chapters are best chapters!

but bodies cant just poof even with that much force there would have been something left a feather or hair... omg the feels

6483888 im also noticing a lack of Luna helping with nightmares

Touching. Just truly touching. Mr. Cake was right and the fact that the girls missed Rainbow's own birthday just added more fuel to the fire that is the grief in their lives.

This would be something that Rainbow would request for Pinkie to do. No need to answer.

Maybe it could be the thing to snap the rest of the girls out of their funk.

Please do keep up the good work upon such a great tale as I cannot wait to see what happens next in this story.

I actually think Pinkie might be a good surrogate for Rainbow Dash with Scootaloo. I think she would be very supportive of the sort of things Scoots likes to do and they both were very close to Rainbow Dash. Pinkie cannot naturally fly but perhaps that is something in a way they could share where Pinkie helps Scoots fly one way or another.

Interesting chapter, but I think Applejack had the right words to say. Rainbow Dash was important to both Pinkie and Scootaloo and maybe it would be better to let them be and hoping they can heal over time.

Still it was nice to see Pinkie almost acting like herself again and tries to get Scootaloo's birthday running.

The bigger question is whether Scootaloo will be happy by this or not ? Keep up the good work.

I think Pinkie would be good for Scootaloo.

This was something that had to be done for Scootaloo to find some sense of peace within herself.

It was both heartbreaking and understanding to see her trying to move on, but she can't due to her emotions bounding her down.

Please do keep up the good work upon such a great tale like this one as I cannot wait to see what happens next.

This party could be good for Pinkie and Scoots. I hope they both get to talk it out with each other as I think they can be good for each other.

I think this chapter made me actually officially favorite this story. Scoots and Pinkie have some great time in this chapter and I really like how they interact. For some reason I just have this feeling that with Dash gone that Pinkie is in many ways the next best thing and I think their mutual love and respect of Dash gives them a lot of common ground to work with. That last bit with Pinkie about to tell all her stories just is a wonderful moment and I hope we get to see more with Scoots and Pinkie.

No words, but just pure applause for what you have accomplished in this storyline.

I mean Not only was Applejack's words true as Scootaloo broke down after seeing the party at first, but in a way...with their own experience in loosing Rainbow Dash, Pinkie Pie and Scootaloo is slowly forming their own bond together as Pinkie's words to Scootaloo is sort of what they both needed to hear.

Scootaloo is really questioning herself and her position in life in the wake of Rainbow Dash's death is truly thought provoking.

Plus TANK finally makes an appearance in this story and is given to Scootaloo. :pinkiehappy:

Also Tank's a Tortoise not a Turtle.

Still this was a great way to end volume one of this story.

I cannot wait to see how you'll pull off the second volume.

So sad *sniffles* :applecry: :fluttercry: :raritydespair:

6282975 My mum passed away unexpectedly about 3 years ago

6282029 bereavement shock can create a temporary numbness, like a wall in your mind. Speaking from experience.

Needs Tragic and Sad tags.

After months and months and months of waiting I've finally read this interesting fic and... it's beautiful. Everything. I didn't had the chance of reading the original script but this re-write is perfect. Perfect timing, perfect feelings, perfect direction. I'll be sitting here, waiting for Volume II.

Login or register to comment