• Published 25th Nov 2022
  • 2,975 Views, 24 Comments

Coins for a Life, Lives for a Coin - Reviewfilly



An assassin enters Princess Celestia's bedchamber intending to end her life. She is not too bothered by the fact.

  • ...
4
 24
 2,975

Standing in the shadow of the Sun

The curtains next to the small window gently swayed back and forth as the night breeze made its way into the tower. The giant fireplace illuminating the room flickered from the sudden movement, but after a moment it continued to spill its cheerful glow and heat all over the room. The sudden warmth inside forced the cold air onto the ground where it lingered for a second or two, before warming up and mixing into its stale sibling.

A pair of hooves landed for a moment on the windowsill, before kicking off once more and hitting the floor in front of it. There was no sound. The knocks the impact would have made were suffocated by padded horseshoes, specifically made to render the wearer silent.

Their owner made his way towards the desk standing on the other side of the room with careful, measured steps. He eyed the figure before him with wariness. A white mare sat in front of the desk, her back turned towards the window. Her head was hidden behind a radiant mane, flowing with the pastel colors of refracted sunlight. Four golden horseshoes sat beside her, along with a small golden tiara on the desk, patiently waiting for their mistress to put them on again. A small black pen, enveloped in golden light, floated in the air in front of her. Occasionally it descended to leave a mark on something on the desk, before hovering up again.

As the intruder hoped, the mare did not seem to notice his arrival. He ever so slowly reached under one of his midnight-blue wings with his head and quietly pulled a knife from a small scabbard hidden below it. A flame from the fireplace glinted on the blade for a moment, before he saw his own radiant, green eyes in the reflection. Much to his relief, his face seemed determined. Even though the plan had gone flawlessly so far, everything hung on the next few moments. He took another step forward.

“Would you please stop where you are?” the mare suddenly asked. He froze in place. There was no urgency in her voice, nor a hint of shock. She didn’t even turn around. Before he could reply, she continued, “You see, the carpet in front of you was a gift from someone very dear to me and it’d pain me if you trod on it wearing those dirty shoes.”

The mangled remains of a few words escaped his throat. He had considered the possibility of being spotted, but he did not expect to be taken as a joke. He looked down and spotted a dark brown carpet. On it, woven in golden thread, the scene of a group of ponies dancing around the combined image of the Sun and the Moon gleamed in the light of the fireplace.

He snarled, blade still in mouth, as he stepped onto the carpet. “I’m here to kill you.”

Celestia sighed. “My little pony, that much was obvious from the get go.” She turned around and looked him in the eye. All the legends and testimonies described her as ageless, yet as he looked into her face, spotless and unblemished as it was, her eyes seemed older than time itself. “Before you do though, I can tell from your voice that you came from beyond my kingdom, so would you mind at least telling me why? I assure you, you haven’t tripped any alarms, you needn’t hurry.”

He remained silent and took another step closer.

“I mean it,” she continued undeterred. Her tone was tired, but also soft and almost motherly. “You have clearly been slighted greatly to come here and… Well, attempt what you are planning to do.”

He stopped for a second, then spat out the knife, catching it with his wing in the air. Though wings allowed for far less strength when stabbing, with the element of surprise gone, agility was preferable anyways.

“I’ve come for the prize on your head, Sun Princess. Your kingdom’s reckless expansion ignited righteous fury in many hearts and opened many coffers.”

“So, it is money,” she said quietly. “Figures.” She placed her pen on the desk and got up. She shot a glance at the colt before turning towards the chamber’s door. “Walk with me.”

Before she could reach the door, he kicked the floor under himself and with a strong beat of his wings leaped in front of her, sending a flurry of papers flying from the desk.

“You are not going anywhere.”

The Princess remained completely unfazed by the act. She merely ignited her horn and gathered the papers, placing them back on the desk with nonchalance. The colt’s blood boiled at the sight and he felt his wing grasp the dagger harder. His muscles tensed, like a loaded spring ready to explode.

“Of course not,” she said with a small smile, as she turned back from the desk. “I was waiting for you after all.”

“Enough games!” he screamed and pounced, putting all of his momentum and weight into a vicious stab aimed at the mare’s neck. The blade cut through the air with a quiet whoosh, yet, before it could get anywhere close to the Princess, it suddenly stopped in the air.

He almost stumbled as his wing became pinned, but with an instinctual correction from his free side he made a somewhat graceful landing. The moment he found his footing, he tried to move the dagger, but it was as if he was pushing against a mountain. He stared up dumbfounded and saw the knife’s hilt glowing with a ghostly yellow light.

“Many years ago somepony… whom I considered closer than all to me shared one of her dreams with me,” Celestia spoke quietly. Her face was illuminated by the same otherworldly glow emanating from her horn, as the one enveloping the knife. It wasn’t a harsh light, yet the flames of the hearth in the back of the room seemed to pale in comparison. “She dreamed of an Equestria where misery and death were not welcome. I’d appreciate it if you conducted yourself accordingly.”

He tried to yank away the blade a few times in vain, before giving up and letting go. However, the moment all four of his hooves were on the ground again, he pounced, aiming his hooves at the Princess’s horn. He should have expected being disarmed, but now his enemy was too. From what he knew, unicorn magic was strong, but it was also clumsy and could only manipulate a single object at a time. He was confident that he could dodge any attack she made with the knife.

Suddenly he came to a painful halt. He forced his eyes to look down and saw his own body covered in the same glow as his weapon. It was as if the aforementioned mountain grew two enormous hooves and pinched him between them. He flexed his muscles, but he couldn’t as much as move an ear.

The Princess was staring at him, her head tipped slightly to the side. Not even the slighted hint of exertion was visible on her face. “As I’ve said,” she began again with the same softness. “I wish for you to walk with me. I have some important business and I cannot allow you to stay here unsupervised.”

His struggles began to lose their strength and soon he felt completely exhausted. Finally, as he allowed his body to go limp, the radiant magic gently lowered him to the floor. As he stared up at the giant mare in front of him, he saw his blade fly towards him. He weakly tried to raise himself, but he couldn’t do as much as raise his hoof. His eyes instinctually snapped shut, as he waited for the blow.

Only it never came. He lay there for a few more seconds before slowly opening his eyes again. The knife was floating in front of him, but it was the hilt that faced towards him.

“As I was saying, I wish to keep misery from my lands,” the Princess explained. “Please put this away well before somepony gets hurt.”

He remained still for a little while, unsure if he was being tricked or whether he could truly believe her words. Then, without a word, he tentatively reached up and took the blade from the glow. This time it relented and he easily pulled it away. As the weapon slid back into its scabbard, he caught the Princess’s reflection for a moment. He wasn’t sure if it was merely a trick of the light, but the pony staring back at him appeared far more majestic than she seemed at first glance. Without a word he got up. Uneasy silence filled the room.

“Well, that was that,” Celestia’s voice broke the silence. “Now, follow me, please.” Her horn lit up again and the double doors to the chamber groaned as they opened to a small landing with a winding staircase behind, illuminated by torches. Two pegasus guards stood on the sides, who immediately saluted the Princess with a wing.

The colt’s heart sank. Was this a trap? Was she bluffing? Did she merely try to lower his guard before these two would do him in? But as they passed between them and stepped out into the landing, the pegasi merely measured him up with suspecting glares, but made no move.

The duo began to make its way down the staircase. “I’m sure you wonder why I’ve asked you to come with me,” said the Princess without turning around. The colt gave her no answer. “You see, as long as you’re with me, no harm will come to you. Some of my guards are a bit too eager to do their job.” She sighed. “I suppose I cannot fault them for wanting to do their best.”

They reached the base of the staircase, which lead to a hallway. Dim torches illuminated the roughly-hewn rock walls. Occasionally a wooden door broke up the monotony of stone. The pale moonlight shone through a few thin windows near the ceiling.

“I don’t understand,” the colt finally said. His words rang with uncertainty and suspicion. “You are protecting me… from your own guards? Is this some kind of game?”

“It’s just that the walk down the hall is just so very boring and I appreciate the company.” The Princess smirked, then began to trot down the corridor. Suddenly she came to a halt and turned around. “Oh, forgive my manners! In the ensuing excitement it completely slipped my mind to ask your name. Mine is Celestia,” she chuckled a little, “though I presume you’re already more than aware of that. What’s yours?”

“Wind Sower.”

“Beautiful name.” She gave him a small, approving nod. “Nice to meet you, Wind.” She turned back and began walking again.

The sounds of the Princess’s hooves echoed through the hallway and, as he walked behind her, Wind felt like he was merely a shadow to her — silent, dark, powerless, and insignificant.

He had to at least have a little bit of control. “Where are we going?”

“Oh, not far from here. So tell me, what exactly drove you to try to take my head?” she asked without even turning around. “I happen to be quite fond of it being attached to my neck.”

Wind felt his cheeks fire up again. “Your unfair imperialism! You always just take from everypony and never give!”

“Really?” For the first time there was a thorn of indignation hidden deep beneath the softness of her words. “Pray tell, how and what exactly have I taken?”

“Your kingdom’s been growing every year at a rapid pace. Ponies in the countryside now whisper that in a few years everything will be part of Equestria. Nopony should have this much power!”

“Rousing words, indeed,” she replied with little amusement. “But these are all simply slogans, fit for bickering politicians maybe, but not a young colt like you.”

“What do you know about what I’m like?” he asked with a scoff.

“Well, for one, the very first thing you talked about when swooping in was money. If it was truly ideology guiding you, you would do it for free. Next, you hesitated, even if only for a moment. A cold-blooded killer wouldn’t do that. Believe me, I would know.”

Once again the colt refused to speak, though a small sad sigh slipped from his mouth. The Princess did not seem to give it any heed and so they continued their walk until they reached an ornate door at the end of the hallway. It was locked with a great padlock which bore no keyhole. The Princess’s horn lit up and light enveloped the lock. A series of soft clicks could be heard from within and something let go inside. The mechanism slid open and the door opened itself with a quiet groan.

“Please, follow me.”

There was darkness inside, but then, as Celestia’s hornlight intensified, Wind quickly realized they were standing atop a small pile of gold coins.

“This is my treasury,” she spoke matter-of-factly.

“You… You have this much?” Wind felt his chest lighting on fire again. “You could help so many with this and you keep it all to yourself in this miserable castle! The lords spoke the truth after all, you really only take!”

The Princess brushed past him and idly picked up a coin with her magic. “You’ve given me no answer. I wish to aid you, if I’m able. So, please, tell me. What could drive a young colt as yourself to attempt murder?”

Her words washed through him like torrential waves. “It’s my…” He wavered. “Nothing else. I was being serious! I must stop you!” But he sounded unsure even to his own ears. Something warm and unpleasant played around his eyes, but he tried his hardest not to pay attention to it. Gritting his teeth, he continued. “You are a tyrant and a usurper! I don’t need your coins, I bet the blood of innocents sticks to each one of them!”

“Wind Sower.” Celestia suddenly dropped the coin and turned around. The previous serenity was completely gone from her face. As her overwhelming presence collapsed on him, he couldn’t help but take a step back. Her tone was quiet, but quickly rose in volume. “I am the master of the Sun and the leader of an army of thousands. My domain reaches as far as the eye can see and grows larger every day. My horn vanquishes the shadows and brings light to my subjects. In this land my word is law and my will shall be done. Do not take me for a fool.”

Her voice boomed like thunder and her wings flared, seemingly growing to reach from one wall to the other. Her whole body burned with a blinding glow, causing her features to melt into vague shapes. It was as if they stood on hot coals as the coins below them turned white from her radiance. The colt collapsed onto his flank and just stared at her wordlessly, unable to do as much as move a muscle. His nostrils caught the smell of something burning.

Silence took over the chamber, broken only by the colt’s small gasps and the Princess’s ragged breaths. Her eyes slowly focused and came to a halt on the small, terrified pony in front of her. She immediately snuffed out her glow, before lowering her wings and gaze. A ragged gasp escaped her lips. “Please, forgive me,” she whispered as she turned to the side. “After all this time, I’m still prone to losing myself.” She took a few steps, her hooves sending a few coins clattering over the floor, before facing the colt again from a more respectful distance. “I didn’t mean to terrify you. As my behavior may have made it clear already, I wish to bring no harm upon you. Nothing about that has changed. I merely don’t take well to seeing others hide their suffering and I can tell that you’re not being honest with me.”

“My sister,” Wind Sower replied, after staring at the floor for a few seconds. “We only have each other and I would do anything for her. We used to get by somehow, but just a little while ago she fell deathly ill. Her only chance to survive would be through a city healer, but they charge exorbitant prices and I have nothing. The lords promised me wealth if I did the job. I had no hope of getting so much with honest work. I could not say no.”

“Your sister…” Celestia echoed hollowly. She looked down at the pile and levitated a coin in front of them. “This will pay one of my uncountable servants, who make sure things run smoothly…” She dropped it back and picked up another. “This will be a widow’s, whose beloved fought and died in my name.” As she spoke she continued to pick up and drop smaller and greater piles of coins. “A village struck by a landslide… A farm ravaged by timberwolves… A hospital for a village that recently joined Equestia…”

She let the final coin fall back onto the pile, before looking back at Wind. Her voice was quiet and hoarse. “You see, ponies from the lands beyond often accuse me of hoarding. You’re very much not the first one to do so. But it’s not true. What would I even need all this gold for?” She let out a humorless chuckle and shook her head. Her pastel locks fluttered in the air, as if some otherworldly breeze, one that only she could feel, played with them. “Still, you see the problem. While I’d be more than happy to part with this treasure, if I allowed you to take anything from here, you’d merely shift the misery from your sister to somepony else in need. Would you be willing to do that?”

“I…” Wind Sower hesitated. The word “yes” hung on his tongue and yet he couldn’t bring himself to say it. A tear spattered onto the coins below, followed by another and then several more. “Princess,” he asked quietly between two sobs, “what am I supposed to do?”

“This is my yearly payment for managing the land.” Wind Sower looked up. Where he expected to see a great lump of gold, he saw only a tiny coin, far less glimmering than the rest. The Princess stared into the small piece of metal, as if she was scrutinizing her own reflection.

“Only this much?”

“Yes,” the Princess said, as she floated the coin into his hooves. “And I want it to be yours. Regardless of whatever insidious lies those lords told you about me, I am not without heart and I do wish to help you. While this won’t be enough in and of itself to save your sister, it should allow you to buy her as much comfort as possible until her time comes. It is all I’m able to do for her, as even someone in my office cannot vainly impose their will on those who belong to another crown.” The tiniest hints of slyness crept into her voice. “That is, of course, unless you’re truly willing to do anything for her.”

Wind stared at her through the veil of his tears. “Anything,” he echoed weakly.

“In that case I ask you to spend it on bringing her here as quickly and in as much comfort as possible. Become my subjects and then I shall do all in my power to save her. After all, it’s not like you have anything awaiting you back there, is it? Those lords? Even if you truly managed to kill me, they would never allow someone so powerful to walk freely and ruin their sleep. The next assassin would come after your head. Or, even if they intended to honor their words, the ensuing wars to claim my former lands would surely cause all available doctors to be ordered to help with the wounded.”

“But what could someone like me even give you in return?” Wind asked quietly, as he hanged his head low. He suddenly felt extremely small. “I don’t have anything.”

Suddenly he felt a wing drape over him. He slowly raised his eyes and saw the Princess looking back at him from above with a gentle smile on her face. “You have yourself and that is more than enough. I wish to unify all ponykind under a single banner and create a nation where the misery and death looming over your sister and the likes of her are not welcome. Where Harmony guides us, instead of envy or hunger for power. And for that I need ponies who follow me, willingly. Tell me, what is your cutie mark?”

Wind slowly got up and turned to the side. The image of a small storm cloud shone on the darkness of his coat.

“Ah. Do you perhaps enjoy wrangling clouds?”

“Yes,” came the sheepish answer. “Even as foals, my sister and I always competed to see which one of us could pop the most of them.” A sad smile played on his lips.

Celestia smirked a little. “I suppose that only makes sense. In that case I could use you as one of my weatherponies. With so much land there is always need for such skills and you’d never find yourself wanting again.” Her eyes slid over to his left wing, where the hilt of the dagger could faintly be seen. “It certainly also wouldn’t require you to kill anypony. Well, what do you say?”

The colt scraped at the coins with one of his hooves timidly.

“I… I think I just want to go home. Could you please lead me out?”

“Certainly.”


“I wouldn’t do that if I were you, pal. You see, that carpet is a keepsake of someone really important,” a dark gray pegasus mare said, as she stepped out from the shadow in the corner of the tower. She held a dull wooden spear in her wing which she pointed towards the intruder. Her teal eyes shone with determination.

“Silence! I’ve come to take the Princess’s life.” The small, cream-colored mare flared her wings. “Just stay there or I will… hurt you too!”

The Princess, who until then sat in deep focus at her desk, gently laid down her pen before speaking up, “And tell me, my little pony, why would you do that on this beautiful, cloudless night?”

“Because of your reckless expansion!” she screamed, stomping her hoof on the floor with a tiny thud. “The king promised a lot of gold to anypony who could take your head!”

The Princess of the Sun and her guard exchanged a knowing look and a smile. Many moons passed since the vulnerability of the window was discovered and it would have been so simple to fix this shortcoming. Both were entirely aware of this fact.

But sometimes life simply presents those in need with the most unexpected of doors.

Comments ( 24 )

What a beautiful little one shot. Hope the colt and his sister are well.

Toon #2 · Nov 25th, 2022 · · 10 ·

I liked where it was going but the ending felt... well disappointing. You contextualized the whole conversation as a pony that was desperate enough to go to the extremes. A good idea but by making the ending as another, you make it that never-ending nightmare of another colt or filly going through the same desperation. A never-ending nightmare that plagues the land. It makes the ending not cheeky or funny but sad, it also doesn't make much sense to have a child soldier when the last one failed along with how they went past the alarms and whatnot.

11432695
Thank you!

Hope the colt and his sister are well.

The last section speaks of both of their fates. :raritywink:


11432752

you make it that never-ending nightmare of another colt or filly going through the same desperation. A never-ending nightmare that plagues the land.

That wasn't really the intent of the story. The point here is that until Sunhorse can unify all the pony lands — and achieve the Equestria we all know and love — there will always be desperate souls and those who would use them to do their dirty work. It'd be extremely easy for Celestia to prevent those who seek her out to murder her from reaching her (she could lock her window for one,) but instead she chooses to allow them to come close so that she can attempt to save them. That's what the very last sentence is supposed to imply along with the fact that Wind's sister is now the Princess's bodyguard.

how they went past the alarms and whatnot.

The serious answer I can give is suspension of disbelief, the cheeky is that because Cellie lets them.

Makes me wonder where Luna is in all this? Or if this is post Nightmare Moon.

“Wind Sower.” Celestia suddenly dropped the coin and turned around. The previous serenity was completely gone from her face. As her overwhelming presence collapsed on him, he couldn’t help but take a step back. Her tone was quiet, but quickly rose in volume. “I am the master of the Sun and the leader of an army of thousands. My domain reaches as far as the eye can see and grows larger every day. My horn vanquishes the shadows and brings light to my subjects. In this land my word is law and my will shall be done. Do not take me for a fool.”

And ponies forget just exactly why Celestia still lives I see. One puny mortal is hardly a thing. Even an army.

11432762
Is the sister the new guard? What of the brother?

“Still, you see the problem. While I’d be more than happy to part with this treasure, if I allowed you to take anything from here, you’d merely shift the misery from your sister to somepony else in need. Would you be willing to do that?”

If your economic margins are that precarious, perhaps you really shouldn't be embarking on yon course of soft imperialism.

Try investing in agriculture, I hear ponies are fairly decent at that, with pegasus weather-control you could grow out-of-climate spices.

There's also the hypothetical, what would she do if it turned out he really did just want the money, or his Talent was actually just silent-killing. Be a bit of a waste of a nice speech.

11432807

Makes me wonder where Luna is in all this? Or if this is post Nightmare Moon.

The description gives it away already, but there are multiple nods in the story about Luna already being punted to the Moon.

11432810
Consider what Celestia says to him before the scene change and what she says after.

11432825

If your economic margins are that precarious, perhaps you really shouldn't be embarking on yon course of soft imperialism.

The scene was meant to be somewhat metaphorical. A bit of a "Teach a man to fish" kind of deal. Of course it's entirely unbelievable that a monarch wouldn't have the necessary funds to heal one random commoner, but that wasn't really the point of the whole thing.

There's also the hypothetical, what would she do if it turned out he really did just want the money, or his Talent was actually just silent-killing. Be a bit of a waste of a nice speech.

Well, she did scare the colt pretty hard, so it'd be very unlikely for him to have made up a sob story about an actually non-existent sister. And he'd be kinda crummy at his talent since Cellie was able to spot him without as much as turning around. Not to mention once his initial plan goes awry, he is completely nonplussed. Sunhorse had zero reason to believe that he was a "born killer."

I think I remember seeing this somewhere, either as a (far shorter) story, or a paragraph idea?
Otherwise, great writing!

what a great story xD

and nicely done Celestia xD

lovely story, and a nice little bit of lore for the time between luna's fall and the modern day...after all 1000 years and the forming of a nation do not pass without issue, and showing a calculating Celestia who turns problems into opportunities like this...very nice i even like to think this paid dividends later, maybe that pegasus she saved was an ancestor of rainbow dash, or flutershy? perhaps both, the assassin was the ancestor of loyalty and the ailing sister the ancestor of kindness.

11432810
The night in the end is described as cloudless and he is a cloud wrangler.

I enjoyed it. It was well written and characterized. But I didn't particularly like the ending all that much. It felt off and detached from the rest of the story and extremely jarring. One moment we're with Wind Sower, presumably about to see him lead out of the Palace. The next we're suddenly back at the beginning again, with a new character in the same position with no closure or reminiscing on Wind. Honestly I think it would have been better to have Celestia's point of view while being told off by a guard for letting an obvious assassin go, or her explaining her reasoning to the guard Captain for the whole event as they watch Wind fly away into the night.

The last scene just feels like an unnecessary repeat of the story for little gain. Having Celestia told off for letting Wind slip in her room like the other ones would have made a neater, stronger message towards ponies being used. Implying it rather then showing it in the exact same way again.

It was still an enjoyable read though, despite the somewhat jarring end.

I would like to think that the dark gray mare was Wind Sower's sister.

This could be a great story instead of just 1 chapter

But I do like the story

Some see the events repeating themselves as depressing. I see a task great enough to be worthy of an alicorn. If it takes centuries to bring prosperity to her continent, well centuries she has. Mortal's can and should attempt such great things, but, as Ecclesiastes 2 (esp. verse 19) says, it is impossible to know with certainty if the next generation wi!l continue the good work one began.

She cares for a whole country (at the least) and my fanon has her as an angel who God granted the privilege to live among mortals until.and unless she is slain. Further-more, that when she has assured herself of the need with many doubles checks and prayers that she will have Equestria take up the sword against every tyrant she can discover. If they turn not from their path, they shall suffer greatly, not out of vengence (even on behalf of another), for that is reserved for her Lord, but to deter others who would take up the same injustices, swapping only the face that selfishness wears. And unlike many mortal-lead nations her hoof will not withdraw until the changes she has made will last at least a full generation... and only so brief if the next generation are very great fools indeed.

I imagine Wind Sower is a lot more popular than his sister, Whirlwind Reaper.

... I was joking. :twilightoops:

Still, lovely snippet of a time of tumult. Celestia's doing her best to bring it to a close as quickly as possible, but that means stepping on some carefully polished hooves. At least she knows how to handle the responses.

11432825 She likely has a few tens of thousands of coins. But rules over millions of ponies. Tell me, how has our welfare system done with eliminating all poverty? How many trillions have been dumped into Africa, most of which was stolen by the corrupt leaders and warlords? Need I even mention China, seeing as how the beaten-down people seem to have finally snapped at the latest round of people being welded into their apartment buildings and left to die for the insane 'zero Beerbug' policy?

I find it amusing how many eagerly find fault with Celestia's little fairy tale land, while ignoring the glaring failures of humanity, which are too innumerable to count.

As for Celestia's ploy with the window, she could tell what sort of 'killer' he was at a glance, remember? She said as much. Had he been a SERIOUS killer... well, then she would have treated him SERIOUSLY... and he'd be a soot smear.

Unless we're talking Season 3 and onward show-canon Celestia. Then she'd get slaughtered by a pony wielding a marshmallow. :duck:

This Celestia, however, strikes me as one who's allowed to possess intelligence, patience, and grace.

11435790
Me, I'd have offered a nice nest-egg for his sister in exchange for the name of the one fool enough to try assassinating an immortal, and insulting enough to send a child.

Mayhaps a nice home visit is in order, if they're not fond of polite measures then we can progress to the impolite ones.

I like this. Very much, in fact.

Both the portrayal of Equestria's equivalent of 'dark ages' and Celestia's characterization as a benevolent ruler going through harsh times were very well-written and believable, plus I found the ending satisfying.

Great work!

Hey you got featured in the "popular now" listing, congratulations! :pinkiehappy:

11432752
I think you might have missed the point. I'd say more, but the author explained it well enough already.

11432762
I reread it and I still loved it, and I can imagine that the ending did imply their fate (like you said here), but somehow I felt that there could have been more setups before, so that the implication in the ending could be smoother. I get that Wind Sower is a weatherpony now and the clear sky implied that he came here again to strengthen the weather management forces, but his sister, not so much. Perhaps when Wind Sower talk about his situation, he could mention that her sister had a dream to be "the best guard of the lord" even though she is sick? I don't know, but I felt that this could make her appearance in the end more natural.

What do you think?

Still a great story and I really felt the emotions from both Celestia and Wind Sower in it! Thank you for this!

Login or register to comment