The Critical Question

Sunny Starscout; with the help from her new friends Izzy Moonbow, Hitch Trailblazer, Pipp Petals, and Zip Storm; have done so much good in restoring Friendship and Magic to Equestria. However, one burning question has been on Sunny's mind: why was Friendship and Harmony replaced by paranoia and distrust in the first place? Why did the three pony races turn on each other after being united for so long before?

Well, after quite a bit of research and searching, Sunny was able to track down the one creature who knew the answer to that question. Even before entering his home, Sunny knew that it was going to be a tragic and heavy tale. . .

Takes place some time after the events of My Little Pony: A New Generation (2021).

Chapters (1)

Comments ( 7 )

Viewing 1 - 50 of 7
- Newest First
- Oldest First

Frazikar

Frazikar #1 · Aug 15th, 2021 · 3 · 1 ·

The problems wth humans is that if you don't keep things low-key and in small amounts, everything tends to spiral out of control far too quickly ...

Ciphers

Ciphers #2 · Aug 15th, 2021 · 2 · ·

Princess Twilight couldn't stand to see her little ponies regress so badly. So, one day, she flew to the top of the tallest mountain in Equestria and cried out for the Windigoes to come back, so that the races would be forced to come together once again, lest they all freeze to death.

I guess call the Windigoes to Murder a lot of ponies is a good and reasonable way to unite Equestria. that's Cold,Twi
Luckily they are all Gone, I rather see a divine Equestria than a Winter Wasteland (FrostPunk)

So, some of the Humans told the Unicorns that since they could cast spells, that they should be the ones in charge and in control, so that they may take care of the lesser Earth Ponies and Pegasi and keep them in line. And yet, some of the Humans told the Pegasi that since they could fly and control the weather, that the lesser Earth Ponies should answer to them, and the bigoted Unicorns should give up all of their possessions to the other two races. And still yet, some other Humans told the Earth Ponies that since they could neither fly nor cast spells, that not only had they been marginalized by the Unicorns and Pegasi for centuries, but they also had been trapped in a type of institutionalized slavery where they were forced to grow food for the other races.

so just because some Human say so,and The Ponies Throw away a thousand Year of Friendship and Tradition and hating Each other?what a simple-Minded Creature

While some Humans were ashamed and cut to the heart, others were enraged and insulted. One group of Human protestors with intolerance and hate in their hearts pushed their way to the front of the crowd, and they attacked Princess Twilight with everything they had. They threw rocks, they sprayed harsh chemicals, they tossed bottles with burning rags, and they fired weapons that launched deadly bits of metal at the Princess of Friendship.

did the Human just kill Their Trade Partner? Do they understand That action can Spark a War, just like you are ready to murder a president of a country

Not long after the death of the Magic of Friendship, Discord, the Spirit of Chaos appeared before all of Equestria. He declared that no Human would never set foot in Equestria, and no pony would ever return to the Human world. With a single snap of his talons, Discord returned every Human and pony to their own respective worlds, destroyed the mirror portal, and closed all other portals between the two worlds. However, this action drained all of the Spirit's chaos magic, and Discord gave one last smile as he collapsed and faded away.

And Discord Being xenophobic Again, he even Stole Ponies that WANT to stay in the Human world, against their will. Sorry Discord, Equestria is already Broken, your action all went in vain

Spike shrugged and said, "Equestria has always been THE main superpower in the world. Everycreature else tends to either envy us or follow us. When Friendship and Harmony died, it made sense for the other nations to lose interest and go their separate ways as well."

so you say that without Equestria,all nation are F***ed? No wonder why Creature in Equus Divine So Fast
"Equestria is Down, that nation have no use for us, Let's NOT help them and go away", what a bunch of hypocrite

Worst case scenario: they just destroyed themselves. It wouldn't surprise me."

good luck about that, Humans are F***ed, but we still survive

she offered them Friendship. . .and then they destroyed our world. They undid everything Twilight had accomplished. And for what?"

Do you mean she just Trades Stuff with them, and the Magic Part? they just disappear, not the Human fault, do humans want Magic to disappear? They Don't,she don't want to work with The human and find out why Magic gone

Sean Mulligan

Sean Mulligan #3 · Aug 31st, 2021 · · ·

I hadn't heard of puzzle place. Do you know where I can find it on regular tv or streaming?

Matthais Unidostres

Matthais Unidostres #4 · Sep 6th, 2021 · · ·

10959265
I don't think its on tv anymore. You can only watch it on YouTube.

Just_Me123

Just_Me123 #5 · Sep 22nd, 2021 · 3 · ·

Interesting head canon, and it even integrates the two MLP worlds, good job. We shall see if Discord or Spike are still around in the new world, and if not, the movie may have no time for it, but the series will eventually have to explain what happened to the immortals, so that will also be interesting to see.
One little thing, in your note you used racism when you should have said bigotry, Yes, racism is bigotry but it really is focused on race whereas bigotry is the more generic term for unreasonable hatred. Not a biggie, but it did sound a bit confusing until I realized what you meant. Sorry.

Wilddog88