• Member Since 8th Feb, 2019
  • offline last seen 5 hours ago

ScisetShimmerEvan


Retired Fanfict writer, brony, creator of the SciSet Chronicles, loves Owl House, likes EQG & G5, a steam train lover, loathes Forgotten Friendship and a huge Sunset Shimmer fan!!!!!!!

E

This story is a remake of the Equestria Girls Special "Forgotten Friendship"


Sunset Shimmer. We all know her for how hard she has worked to become the girl we all know and love. And more than that, so do her friends. Until they didn't! Everything she had worked so hard on has been erased, gone as if never existed! No one remembers her, except for the once horrible and tyrant girl she once was that made people suffer and afraid when she ruled CHS with an iron fist! But what if not everyone had forgotten her? Would the help of a single person make it different? Would they be able to solve this memory loss mystery, track down who caused all of this, and fix it before it's too late!!!

Cover art by ilaria122

Chapters (6)
Comments ( 51 )

I’m getting that Forgotten Friendship Vibes right now when reading this

Is there going to be any kind of violence in this story?

10752018
There won't be any scenes with blood but there will be like 1 scene where Fluttershy gets hurt in a future chapter. My lips are sealed currently on how it happens so better wait and see.

The story has the "Spike (EQD)" tag, and since who's going to be helping Sunset seems like they would get more attention than Spike, I want to guess Spike going to help, yet that seems somewhat too obvious a choice. Flash Sentry or Sci-Twi (not being losing her memories this time, and could be why there's a "Sci-Twi" tag) look to be a good candidates, but I'm going to be a little bold and swing for the fences.

Who's going to be by Sunset's side is Wallflower Blush, and Trixie really is behind the lost memories.

10752270
Yes your correct, sci twi and spike the dog don't get affected by the memory stone. Spike will still have many lines in the story despite sci twi will have a big role in this I knew it be best I still included Spike. And wallflower will still be the cause of this and trixie is only gonna make 2 or 3 more appearances in this story.

I’m starting to enjoy This version a lot more :twilightblush:

10763035
Hopefully others will too, plus the story will get better for what happens in chapter 3

Okay and Twilight just remembers everything, curious.

Are they going to deal with Trixie and Snips and Snails?

Also noticed you left out anon A Miss in the memory sharing.

10764837
Trixie is only planned to appear 1 or 2 more times after this, and I didn't mention anon a miss during the memory sharing since I wanted the scene to focus on good memories instead of bad ones to fit the story.

Hmm, you were right. I didn't see the twist that happened coming!

10767526

What, she did? I thought she was trying to cause more trouble in this chapter, not trying to help.

10767901
Oh, nope trixie is only planned to make 2 more appearances in this story and she won't do anything serious like what she did in chapter 3

10785978
Well your in for a treat since the battle with have something no one will expect is coming

now i want to see how Timber reacts to Sunset being all like "She's taken"

Personally I thought Wallflower was the worst villain in the whole series. I erased everyone memory of so they wouldn't remember me and then I take the fact that I don't have friends out on someone who is trying to be a better person because they used to be a jerk. How selfish can you get. At least the others had decent excuses that were still bad ideas but still better than I'm keeping friends away and making sure you don't get them either.

10857556
Lol

10857572
Yeah I really dislike her a lot, in fact what she did in forgotten friendship was very similar to what I saw happen in a transformers tv show, specially transformers rescue bots season 2 final which involved around memories being erased as well, but worst.

enjoyed the whole story and in the end, it really did make sense. Great Work Evan

10863043
Thx my friend, it's something I'm glad worked out great in the end.

10949246
Yelp, I am too, it's one of many reasons I wrote this, other than the fact I really loathe "forgotten friendship."

The Sci-Twi/Sunset moments are so sweet 💕. I love those. Also I love the fact that they are all together again.

10949297
I thought it be s nice change since if sunset can't prove it herself than it's up to the girls to find out themselves they'd find much evidence sunset is telling the truth.

This is intense just like the episode. I can't stop reading the story.

Demon Wallflower is cool looking. I never liked Forgotten Friendship because someone hurt Sunset. They did for the dumbest reason too. I will visit this in my story too, and an angle with Wallflower too. I like your version better.

10949342
Thy do, I did plan on adding something extra to the ending but I ended up not doing it. I can explain the rest in a private message if you'd like.

Hi! I’m really excited to read this. Forgotten friendship is probably my favorite special. I’m a bit of a sucker for ‘Sunset Torture porn’. Regardless, I felt like Forgotten Friendship gave Sunset enough pain without it feeling ridiculous like in the Anon-a-miss comic.

As always, Sunset’s and Twilight’s interaction makes the story shine . I did feel it was a bit too jarring that they reached for a kiss. I probably got the timeline wrong, but wasn’t this before they began dating? It would’ve been really cute if Sunset was like imagining her kissing Twilight!

“Of course I do Sunset. Why would I have forgotten you after everything we’ve been through together.”

Ohhh kdfkfdjkdf. I love this twist! It honestly was kinda silly how Twilight doesn’t remember Sunset at all in FF. Like how does she think she got saved from midnight sparkle? It feels like losing her memory of Sunset would alter her character in a drastic way, and this wasn’t addressed at all in the show. Very happy you avoided this frustration.

Sunset wasn’t sure what to say or do and was still thinking this was a really bad nightmare that she so desperately wanted to end!

I’ve gotta say, this characterization feels very weird. In the special, we see Sunset keep her calm even though she was in a much worse situation than she is in your story, since in yours at least Twilight remembers her. I get that you want Twilight to comfort her, but I feel there could’ve been more natural ways to do this.

In your defense, you’ve already established in your canon that your Sunset is depressive, though it feels a OCC, it shows consistency in how you’ve written her. And you could interpret Sunset as being depressive in Anon-a-miss.

Also, I thought it was a good choice to skip Sunset going to Equestrian, it would’ve broken the the flow of the story and she already had her reconciliation with Celestial in your lore.

“They are not fake Trixie, they have shadows, dates, and everything seen in the picture proves they're real!” Yelled Sunset.

Lmao yeah, It made no sense how in the special they’re not more convinced by the pictures. Sunset could’ve just been like. Girls. These pictures have shadows. Or just shown them a video.

I hoped the conflict between Twi and the rest of the humane 5 wouldn’t have been resolved so easily. Imagine how much interesting drama there could be if she had to choose between Sunset and her friends.


This chapter also highlights one of your strengths. You have a good grasp of how to make emotionally painful scenes. It’s good to see these scenes often accompanied by moments of tenderness between Sunset and Twi, these moments of emotional violence contrasted against characters healing from their pain gives your plots a very nice contour. I think they would benefit a lot from making them more subtle.

Furthermore, I think this chapter elevates your original Twi x Sunset confession. The fact that Sunset has been depressed before, and Twi being there to help her makes the confession in that chapter more believable.

11225180
This story doesn't take place in the same timeline in my other stories and is why it's has the AU.

11225189
The whole point/reason I made this was because forgotten friendship is my least favorite eqg special and I thought on making my own version but with many changes.

“Only that’s it's felsic-intrusive igneous, granular in texture, most likely arranged in an equigranular matrix, with scattered biotite mica and amphibole, at least sixty-five percent alkali feldspar by volume, with a melting point of twelve-fifty centigrade, plus or minus ten degrees. Sorry I couldn't be more helpful.”

10785986
I have no idea what she just said

“Once those memories are erased, no one will be able to stop me now! Not even those seven girls!”

uh oh.... she is being corrupted by power

The stone had taken over Wallflower’s body with the dark magic following through her body. It was just like what the geodes did to Gloriosa Daisy at Camp Everfree but this time it was 10 times worse with all the memories the stone had inside itself were now a part of Demon Wallflower.

“Yes, yes! All this power flowing through me, this magic feels so good! But now I need more! MORE!”

OH CRAP

Login or register to comment