I'm not the shy, timid girl that everyone thinks I am.

by Mpony1

They don't know everything about me

Flutteshy just finished correcting all the girls misunderstandings. Finally putting thier minds at ease, now that they know that the shy girl was never a killer.

"Oh" Sunset replied awkwardly before laughing in an embarrassed manner "Boy, we jumped to some pretty crazy conclusions."

"Yeah," Pinkie Pied added "Guess it's a good thing the power at Sunset's house went out before she could reach the cops."

"You tried to call the police?!" Rainbow Dash shouted in shock.

"We really jumped tah some crazy conclusions" Applejack explained.

"Oh, girls" Fluttershy said frantically "I'm so sorry for leading you into thinking I was a killer!"

"Fluttershy, don't apologize!" Rainbow Dash said fiercely "They accused you of being a murderer and snooped around our house. They should apologize to you!"

"She's right, Fluttershy" Sunset said with an ashamed sigh "We're the ones that were wrong here. We're really sorry."

"Yeah, we really are."

"Sorry, girl."

"So sorry, Dear."

"Sorry, Flutters."

"Sorry to misjudge you, Shy."

"Oh girls" Spike gave Fluttershy a look "and Spike, I forgive you." Fluttershy took a deep breath and steeled herself. "But I have to disagree with what Rainbow said. I do owe you all an apology....we both do."

"WHAT!? But flutters they accused you of being a murderer and thrash our house." Rainbow spout back.

"Yes they did and after hearing their side of the story we also have ourselves to blame as well."

Rainbow look at her girlfriend flabbergasted. She doesn't understand why she would think they were at fault.

"And how is it that we are the blame. We didn't do anything wrong."

Fluttershy facepalm herself, shaking her head at RD rash stupidity. Once again she was going to have to explain things so that this time, rainbow would understand.

"Rainbow?" Fluttershy says as she tries to speak as calmly as possible. "Were you even paying attention to what the girls were saying, especially Sunset's story."

Rainbow scoff and crossed her arms. "Yeah Sunset thought you murdered me. Which was stupid and got the rest of the girls into believing it. Which led to all this mess."

Fluttershy takes a deep breath to calm herself before speaking. "Alright Rainbow lets take a step back to when all this started. According to Sunset, she was jogging late at night till she came by our house. Which I may add, to her was simply my house and my house alone, for she didn't know that you moved in with me a month ago." Fluttershy raised an eyebrow. "Seeing how we kept that and our relationship a secret the whole time."

Rainbow didn't have a retort to that so she just stood their silently and listened.

"So looking at this from Sunsets perspective. Thanks to us being too loud, she over heard us and from her point of view. It sounded like I was and did murder you."

"But that's not what happen Shy." RD retorted. "We were just roleplaying and had an accident."

"Then explain to me Rainbow. How the HELL was Sunset supposed to know that?"

The girls were surprised at Fluttershy sudden outburst. This was the first time they ever heard the shy girl swear.

Rainbow open her mouth to say something but couldn't come up with anything. She slowly starts to realize what fluttershy meant about them being at fault as well.

"I mean seriously Rainbow. The girls just learned the truth about our relationship moments ago. We chosed to keep it a secret because we were too nervous to tell them sooner." Fluttershy let an annoyed scoff. "Thinking back on it now. That was the most stupidest thing we ever agreed on. Seeing how they all accepted us.....we should of trusted them more."

Rainbow held her head down in shame. Knowing full well that Fluttershy was right. She raised her head to look at her when she resumed talking.

"Now as I was saying. Sunset didn't know a thing about our relationship. Most of all she doesn't know "Everything" about me and if their was anything about last night roleplay that is real. It was when I said that I'm not the shy, timid girl you and the others think I am. There's more to me than anyone could even imagine. Everyone including our friends only knows the shy, quiet, animal loving Fluttershy, because that's the only part of myself I show out in public. So when Sunset heard how I was acting last night. She no doubtly couldn't believe how out of character I was being, and why would she think that. Because the years she'd known me all the way up to now. She knew only the SHY me, the QUIET me, the me she could easily pick on back when she was a bully."

Fluttershy gave Sunset an apologetical look. Before turning her attention back to Rainbow.

"So she thought she heard me murdering you? Well I can't blame her. I mean what else was she supposed to think? That you and I were having bdsm sex that gone wrong right off the bat?"

"UMMM?!" humed Rainbow. Not being able to answer the question.

"Of course not. What in that situation makes you believe she would think that or anything else." Fluttershy let out a deep sigh to calm herself."

"S-she wouldn't!" Said Rainbow dejectivly

"Exactly!" Said Fluttershy. "and let's not forget that she did try to remain optimistic and hoped to see you at school today." Fluttershy frown. "But because of the accident you got hurt and had to spend the day at the hospital and since you told me to keep what happened a secret combined with my poor job at covering for you. It only made things look as if I did murder you."

"Ok! I get your point but their is another way they could of easily figured out that's not what happened!" Said Rainbow.

"And that would be!?" Asked Fluttershy.

"The way you acted at school." Rainbow answered. "I agree with you on why Sunset thought you murdered me,I have no argument against that. But seriously they also believed that you were trying to dispose of my body in broad daylight, on school grounds, where literally anyone could see you do it and that's a fact since Applejack saw you digging outside her classroom window and Twilight saw sneaking around while dragging a huge bag. So when they all got together and shared what each of them saw. None of them didn't think how weird it was for you to risk getting caught burying a body in public?"

Silence.

Sunset and the girls winced at that. Now that they think about it that was definitely something they should of consider from the start. Rainbow was right, why would a killer try to dispose of a body in a populated area in broad daylight when they can do it in non populated place at night in the dark. If they had only thought of that for a second then maybe they would of thought twice on the matter and talk to Fluttershy about what Sunset heard last night.

Sunset rub the back of her head and put on a sheepish grin and chuckles. "Oops! I guess in the end we did jump straight to conclusions."

The rest of the girls agreed.

Fluttershy sighed. "Ok, you have a point there but you know that would mean they would probably come to me and asked about last night and I would have no choice but to tell them everything just to clear my name and of course bring them to the hospital to see you."

Rainbow Dash winced at that. She remembered telling Fluttershy to keep what happened a secret from the girls but since neither of them knew that Sunset over heard them and thought a murder had taken place. It was understandable that Fluttershy would have to tell the truth if they came up to her and accused her of murder.

Rainbow sighed. "You're right Shy! At least this was settled without getting any cops involved." Rainbow turned to face her friends. "And I'm sorry for putting all the blame on you girls like that earlier. Like Fluttershy said it was stupid of us to keep our relationship a secret from you, if we had been honest and forthcoming from the beginning," Rainbow blush. "We at least wouldn't have to share all our secrets with you."

Fluttershy face also turned red from remembering telling her friends about what she and Rainbow do at night.

The girls faces also turned red when they remembered that Fluttershy plans to cosplay as each of them while having sex with Rainbow.

Everyone stood there in awkward silence until Applejack broke it with a loud cough.

"Well! I'm wrecken we all learned something from this experience?"

Sunset nodded. "Yeah! No more nighttime jogs for me. And I'll never take something I overhear out of context again. From now on, I'll gather all the facts before assuming anything. I just hope you can forgive me for all this trouble I caused."

"Oh, of course I can." Fluttershy said before nodding. "But don't blame yourself like that. Remember you didn't know about Rainbow and I relationship until now and even if you did you also didn't know what we like to do at night, especially when theirs so much none of you don't know about me. Which is why I have a proposal."

"And what's that?" Asked Twilight.

"First of all, despite everything being a huge misunderstanding. You five still broke into our home and made a big mess."

The girls winced at that.

"We'll clean up the mud we tracked through your house" Sunset offered.

"Here's a better idea" Rainbow said "How about you girls clean the whole house."

"WHAT?!" Rarity shriek.

"Done" Sunset agreed to the consequences despite the loud, wailing moan coming from the fashionista.

Rainbow nodded pointedly "You can start in the bedroom. Make sure to bring an extra large bottle of Dr. Cleanser. That place is a mess."

"No, Rainbow! The bedroom is our mess so we'll be the ones to clean it up" Fluttershy suggested.

Rainbow groaned. "Fine! That's fair."

Fluttershy turned her attention back to her friends. "And second when we all of us get together tomorrow. I'm gonna tell you all "EVERYTHING" about me that's not related to the shy, animal loving me you have all grown to know and since you already know some of those things now, it's only better that you get the whole story."

"Are you sure about that, darling?" Asked Rarity.

"Yeah we don't wanna make you like you're being force to." Said Pinkie.

"Its ok girls, I want to do this and it's about time I share the part of myself I keep hidden with you all." Fluttershy acknowledge.

The girls glance at each other before facing Fluttershy and nodding in agreement.

Fluttershy smiled.

"Well if that's all, I think we should take our leave," Said Rarity. I'm a mess and in dire need of a shower. Now if you'll excuse me" she said as she walked towards the stairs "I have to get home and work on covering up the fact that half my hair is missing."

One by one, the feather-covered girls followed Rarity to the stairs, mumbling words of apology. Despite everything Fluttershy said they still felt guilty about the whole ordeal.

"Our bad on this whole incident" Applejack said as she tailed Rarity up the stairs, feeling quite humiliated.

"Really sorry about the misunderstanding" Twilight said as she carried Spike to the stairs while limping "Oh, by the way," she said nervously before disappearing up the steps "Congratulations!"

"Yeah, we're really happy for ya!" Spike's voice called out.

"You bet!" Pinkie Pie piped up as she followed Twilight "I'll have a 'Congratulations-on-getting-together' party ready for you by the end of the week!"

"You better be clean for it!" Rainbow Dash called out.

With the others gone, Sunset was left alone with Rainbow and Fluttershy.

"I'm really sorry for causing all this" she said guiltily to the pair.

Rainbow sighed. "Its not your fault Sunset. Like Flutters said we can't blame you for what you thought you heard and if I why in your position." Rainbow shrug. "I have no doubt that I would of thought the same way too, so forget about, ok!"

Sunset nodded. "Ok! Well, I better go" Sunset said as she headed for the stairs, she turned back one more time and said "See you both tomorrow at school?"

"If you don't, don't get the wrong idea!" Rainbow Dash called out.

Giving one more sheepish grin, Sunset disappeared up the steps, leaving the blue and yellow pair alone. At least for a few seconds before remembering something and quickly returned to the doorway.

"Oh! Fluttershy! Before I forget theirs one last thing that's bothering me!"

"What is it!?"

"Earlier when I asked you about that long thing I saw you pull out of your locker after school...?"

"You mean the paddle we use in our roleplaying!?" Fluttershy questioned. "What about it?"

"I was wondering, why did you bring it to school?" Sunset asked.

Fluttershy face instantly turned red as she realized the little mistake she made. She turned to face Rainbow who's face was also red. Seeing if it was ok to answer Sunset question. Rainbow glanced at her and nodded, giving her girlfriend the ok. After all what does it matter at this point, they already told their friends so much about their nightly escapades, so what's one more secret revealed.

"I always bring that paddle to school with me everyday. Rainbow and I like to have fun on school grounds where I bend her over my lap and spank her with it. During our free period we would go somewhere private to mess around and with majority of the school still in class it made things easier." Fluttershy explained, face still red. "Because I got use to always taking it with me, I packed it up without thinking and didn't realize it till I got to my locker. I left it there seeing as I wasn't going to be using it with Rainbow in the hospital." She answered.

Sunset could only blush after hearing that two of her friends engage in sexual hijinx at school.

"Oh! Ok!" Sunset nervously. "Well! Umm, thanks for sharing.....I'm gonna go now and leave you two alone.....Oh and I'm not judging you," she said quickly, not wanting the couple to get the wrong idea about how she's acting. "Its just a lot information to take in all at once, you know."

Rainbow shrugs. "If you think that's big news we might as well tell you why I'm having Fluttershy roleplay as all of you." She said with a smirk.

"OK GOING NOW SEE YOU TOMORROW!" Sunset quickly said as she to left the house.

Rainbow Dash stood there for a few moments, completely silent as she stared in the direction the surprise guests had gone. Finally, with a sigh, she shook her head.

"Arrrggg, this is not how I wanted the girls to find out about us."

"I know!" Said Fluttershy. "I'm just glad it was them we had to tell this to instead of the police."

"I hear that, although I think we should consider sound proofing the house." Rainbow suggested. "We got lucky with Sunset but if anybody else had heard us, I don't want to explain my sex life with some stranger."

"I agree! We should asked Sunset about that tomorrow. She once told me theirs a spell that can sound proof a room that she would use back in Equestria so she can study quietly." Said Fluttershy.

"Cool sounds like a plan." Rainbow chuckle from a thought that came to mind.

"What's so funny?"

"Oh you know! I couldn't help but think about deeply about all this. I mean Imagine," Rainbow Dash said in amazement "them actually thinking that you could kill me. How crazy can an imagination get?"

"I know, right?" Fluttershy agreed in surprise. "I would've thought they would've known better than that."

"Yeah, I can't believe they actually believed that I couldn't fight back" Rainbow Dash shook her head again "I mean, really, you overpowering me? That's a little farfetched isn't it?"

At those words, Fluttershy's eyes went into mischievous slits.

"Oh, really?" she spoke in her dominatrix voice "Care to put that theory to a test?"

Rainbow Dash, catching onto what Fluttershy was implying, grinned.

"Sure. You're on."

---

From outside the house, two voices could be heard.

"Hey! Let go! Fluttershy, what are you doing?!"

"What's the matter, Rainbow? Unable to fight back against a delicate flower like me?"

"Wait! No! Don't do that! Stop! Oh, no fair! I want a turn and go put on your Sunset Shimmer costume, I still have a bit of pent aggression for the mess she caused."

"If we asked you think she would join us, I would love to get a little payback from all her bullying I've endured."

"Who knows! It would be great if we can get all the girls involved. We could try asking them tomorrow but I won't get my hopes up, Shy!"

Fluttershy let out a heavy sigh. "I know but one can dream." Fluttershy stood up and walks to her closet, open it up, and pulled out her Sunset Shimmer outfit. A shirt, leather jacket, skirt, boots, wig, green eyes contact lenses, and amber skin dye.

"Be right back!" Said Fluttershy as she left the room to change.

When she finally returned she was a perfect look a-like as the real bacon haired teen, that anyone could be easily fooled.

"Hey there Rainbow!" Sunshy said in a voice that sounded just like the real Sunset. "Fluttershy said you wanted to talk to me about what happened today."

Rainbow Dash stood up and walk up to the fake Sunset and stared menacing into her eyes. Feeling the bacon wig-haired girl with fear and excitement.

"Indeed I do Shimmer!" Rainbow said as she slowly closed the door behind fake Sunset. "I'm also going to teach you a lesson for over assuming things and messing up my house." She said as the door closed.

Minutes later. Fake Sunset screams of pain and pleasure could be heard from outside. Luckily no one was around to hear it this time.

Comments

[SUPERETHAN2]

Nice alternate take on the original. To be honest Rainbow being an ungrateful jerk in the original didn't really bother me, since I can understand why she would react to them thinking shy murdered her in that way, especially in that initial moment. Not to mention even in the original Fluttershy calls her out on it, despite it not being as effective. My only issue was Rainbow saying they should have had a better reason than believing one of their friends was murdered to look in their house, since Fluttershy for god knows why says it's a fair point, when it's anything but. Also nice take on the "wrestling" match. I always figured in that moment they weren't acting and Rainbow learns the hard way that Fluttershy actually has true power behind her dominatrix act. Though I like the idea of it being more playful and an act much better. I especially like them wanting to bring the others into it, since it shows how similar they actually are and how they ended up together.

[SUPERETHAN2]

"Oh you know! I couldn't help but think about deeply about all this. I mean Imagine," Rainbow Dash said in amazement "them actually thinking that you could kill me. How crazy can an imagination get?"

"I know, right?" Fluttershy agreed in surprise. "I would've thought they would've known better than that."

Fluttershy just spent most of the fic defending them, believing Rainbow was murdered and did a great job that said girl herself, who is notorious for being stubborn, was completely and genuinely convinced, instead of grudgingly doing so. Yet, here they both express surprise that they believed that.

[Wahtiff]

I definitely remember feeling real miffed by Dash’s attitude in the original, so seeing a story addressing it is a welcome surprise.