• Member Since 11th Jan, 2019
  • offline last seen 3 hours ago

Gay For Gadot


Just a lesbian with a laptop.

Comments ( 409 )

I’m already sold on this cuz of the transgender topic

I’m non-binary

Ice Star #2 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 11 · With ·

As I said before, this is pretty astonishing stuff, even just from the two chapters that I looked at. Finding a mature story that handles anything as consensual, ethical, and wholesome instead of being degenerate trash is always a shocker. So few mature stories are worth checking out because Fimfiction will be forever be filled with people who would rather write about their unholy trinity of glorified sexual abuse (rape, pedophilia, and incest) instead of anything with the qualities above. You've got a lot of funny lines, thoughtful characterization, and well-paced drama in here.

I'd recommend this to people who (like me) would rarely touch M-Rated stories because so many of them are just a) porn (not really for me thanks) and b) fuckin' degenerate trash as I said. This is such a huge leap away from that ugly trifecta of content, and it's also got some really cool trans Trixie!

Please write more stuff like this. I'd be 100% down to pre-read buildup chapters of stuff like this again in the future.

10561675

Hope you enjoy it. :twilightsmile:

10561692
Also there’s a petition to help stop Transphobia

Go over to LGBT or Transgender Bronies community pages

10561686

Thanks again for your help, fam. :heart: I hope you at least read the beginning of the third chapter, because there's some more wholesome stuff at the Teen rating there. My goal with writing stuff like this is to portray sex in a healthy, affirmative, adult way that, as you said, can be hard to find on here. So why not write it myself? :ajsmug: And I hope folks enjoy reading this as much as I enjoyed writing it.

Is this connected to 'Cloak and Daughter'?

10561696

I just saw that. Signed.

Ice Star #9 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 1 · With ·

10561697

hope you at least read the beginning of the third chapter, because there's some more wholesome stuff at the Teen rating there.

Well, I guess that's something I've gotta add to the to-do list for this week. I'll have to drop a second comment for that too.

10561721
Both have Starlight Glimmer, a transgender character, take place within a few seasons of each other and are written by the same author. It seems like it would make sense to have them connected.

10561740

That is all true, and you're not wrong at all in your logic. Both trans characters also wear cloaks. I actually do make a slight allusion to Cloak And Daughter in this fic, but they are not meant to be in the same continuity. This is a StarTrix story starring gay Starlight, whereas Cloak And Daughter is meant to be "friendshipping, but also StarBurst hints if you want them".

Not a fan of the transgender elements, or transgender Trixie... both of which have never been enjoyable to me... in fact are a bit squick.

That said, this was well-writen and you have good clop skills.

10561748

Well, I appreciate that you gave the story a chance despite your personal preferences. I appreciate the compliment as well. :twilightsmile:

10561752
Cheers!

Seriously, if I read the latter half of your final clop scene as the ending to a futa-potion fic... one-hundred % boner zone!

Ice Star #15 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 18 · With ·

10561748

Not a fan of the transgender elements, or transgender Trixie... both of which have never been enjoyable to me... in fact are a bit squick.

This, of course, is coming from the galaxy brain who is most well-known for writing a series where a father rapes his underage daughter and it’s shown as ✨hot✨!

You literally could not have worded this any worse or been the worst possible person to say this.

Scampy #16 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 9 · With ·

10561748
10561757

Not a fan of the transgender elements, or transgender Trixie... both of which have never been enjoyable to me... in fact are a bit squick.

This is a seriously gross statement. If you find transgender elements disgusting just by default, while acting like "futa" is totally some different thing when it kinda just exists as a way for people who are attracted to trans women to pretend they aren't while still indulging that attraction, you have some really bad transphobic beliefs you need to work through hon.

10561757

I've been debating whether to respond to this comment, or not, and, if so, how.

Alright.

Why is there a difference to you? Why is one okay and not the other? Either way, it's Trixie, and that's her body. How is that being her natural body part somehow squick or less "enjoyable" than if it was just a temporary spell, or whatnot? I'm genuinely curious, because, to me, there's not a difference. And to Starlight, there's no difference, either. Which is the whole point of the story.

Elu
Elu #18 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 3 · With ·

10561686
Cannot agree more with this.

To the author: although I myself am not really a fan of romance stories anymore, especially M-rated (despite the fact that I've written sexual stuff), yours is pretty good and, as Ice Star said, also unique and wholesome. Such stories also help me overcome the cultural norms imposed on me, among which is fear/hate of non-binary people and pretty much everyone who belongs to LGBTQ+. Thank you for this fine piece of art :twilightsmile:

10561763
So that explains why I blocked them. I've plenty of writers blocked - even if it does nothing to hide their content - who have written glorified sexual abuse. We seriously need a site-wide system of blockable tags, similar to how derpibooru does it. I could certainly do without the entirety of the "porn" tag, for once.

10561797

Thanks for reading the story! I'm glad you enjoyed it and found it affirming. :twilightsmile:

Posh #20 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 9 · With ·

10561748

Not a fan of the transgender elements, or transgender Trixie... both of which have never been enjoyable to me... in fact are a bit squick.

10561763

This, of course, is coming from the galaxy brain who is most well-known for writing a series where a father rapes his underage daughter and it’s shown as ✨hot✨!

You literally could not have worded this any worse or been the worst possible person to say this.

“Ah, the Trans Genders................ there Fornication’s are shall we say................. not to myne Tayste?”

*drains the contents a crystal gauntlet labeled “JUICE THAT MAKES YOU INCAPABLE OF COMPREHENDING IRONY” directly into own mouth*

“But enough witless Prattelle. It is Thyme to depickt Parental Fuck-Cumming, that Noblest and Most Refined of Sexual Art Formes.”

-Clopficsinthecomments, probably

A wonderful story portraying the hardships of trans people. While I do not personally have any experience with Trans people, I understand the plight these people are in around the world. Trans people can't help being themselves, this is who they are, and we should all support them through it all. They are humans, and deserve our respect.

That said, I was really moved by Trixie's plight, and her fears for what Starlight thinks about the real her. The story in it's entirety was eye-opening to me, and it really made me more open-minded about these topics.

All in all, it's a wonderfully writren story with lessons everyone should learn from. Great job Gadot!

10561822

Thank you for reading, Shekh! I'm glad you got something good out of it. Appreciate your kind words. :twilightsmile:

Comment posted by Third Wheel deleted Dec 2nd, 2020

10561829

I can't speak for Ice, but I find it... strange, that someone who writes incest and rape is "squicked" out by the presence of a transgender character. That was my point in replying.

Posh #27 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · · With ·

10561829 I mean, there’s a difference between writing a story that depicts sexual abuse and incest in a realistic and disturbing manner, and stories that fetishize the act as masturbation fuel. I don’t think Ice’s take on the latter is really all that controversial.

Comment posted by Third Wheel deleted Dec 2nd, 2020

10561823

I could be wrong, but I believe you meant:

P E N I S

(In other news, I have probably talked about dick more in the previous week and a half than I did in the rest of the pandemic.)

10561763
10561792
10561807

I make no defense here of my own fetishes, nor any attack upon the fetishes of others. I think you should try to emulate GfG's type of response to those who are not fans of the transsexual stories: acknowledge that others have different tastes and likes/dislikes than you and move on. Or just ignore my comment entirely.

Honestly, I had debated whether or not to leave a comment at all - I wanted to praise the author for their talented sex-scene writing, while being honest about why overall the story was not for me... but I was worried that my honest feedback would be unwelcome. GfG took it exactly the way I had hoped: as a compliment to their work despite having to overcome a squick factor.

I'd also heavily disagree that futa and transgender are related, and certainly they are not in my mind, but that's probably a discussion for somewhere else.

Elu
Elu #31 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 9 · With ·

10561829
There is a huge difference between serious writing about such topics and plain fetish fulfillment. You can write about such topics, obviously, but if you just make it into "oh my, it tickles my insides in a pleasant way", then there's a problem.

I think the line can be safely drawn between serious stuff and plain porn. Plain porn of those disgusting things isn't acceptable to me. A cursory glance at your page revealed that what you write is plain porn, especially considering the cover arts. There is nothing about your stories when it comes to this that isn't just fap fuel.

10561848

Exactly. I won't assume anything until/if Clopfics replies, but the futa comment was one of two reactions I was hoping not to see on this story. But I'm happy to have a conversation about it.

10561797
I too must confess that stories involving transsexualism aren’t my cup of tea. And I mean that in the most polite non-phobic way. I’m just not really interested.

Maybe some day... I mean wasn’t always fond of F/F(cisgendered) stories. But now, when it comes to them, I can’t get enough.

I will also confess that I wasn’t too keen on reading M-rated romance here at first. But I eventually got over that, and have read a small handful of things. Some with the porn label, but nothing of the particularly kinky/fetish/anthro sort(the last one just weirds me out). I like things simple that way.

GfG, even though this particular story does not interest me. You keep doing the varied stuff.

And I’ll let that be my two cents on the matter. Nothing more.

10561829
I appreciate this comment very much - this is the kind of feedback I am perfectly all right with.

I write all sorts of different stories, some incest, some foalcon, some dark, some rape, some lovey-dovey vanilla... and even some non-clop. I 100% understand that some people will not like... or even vehemently dislike my work.

But the fact that you have an objective response to the concepts and the realization that, for some, there is enjoyment in the fantasy-fetish despite that it might be abhorrent to others, is all I think any artist could ask for... the 'it's not for me, but I understand it might be for others'.

Cheers,

Elu
Elu #35 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 5 · With ·

10561860
Yeah, there are just taste differences. It's just kind of funny when someone who writes pretty disgusting stuff sees transgenderism as squick. After all, squick is a sense of not just dislike, but disgust and repulsion.

Comment posted by Third Wheel deleted Dec 2nd, 2020
Scampy #37 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 13 · With ·

10561863
i.imgur.com/qsqkTy3.jpg
Fun facts with Wallflower \o/

Ice Star #38 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 20 · With ·

Lmao, the butthurt "b-but muh fetish ain't bad reeee!!!!!11111!!!!!111!" people are coming out. It's cute they think their red-thumb fee-fees being hurt means anything. :ajsmug:

10561797

We seriously need a site-wide system of blockable tags, similar to how derpibooru does it. I could certainly do without the entirety of the "porn" tag, for once.

Or we could just delete borderline illegal and genuinely harmful content so that they aren't large, insular subgroups. Bye-bye pedos, rape, and incest. Better to not have them at all than have them fester and think they belong.
10561807
You're a treasure, Posh.
10561829

I'm not a fan of Clopfics's stuff either (can't comment on them as a person, haven't interacted with them), but I feel like it's unfair to act excessively against certain kinds of writing and imply negative things about everyone writing something like that.

Yeah, I'm sure they accidentally write it, edit it, send it off to other editors, publically post it, place it in groups, and advertise it as an acceptable commission content. After all, there's nothing wrong wth writing extremely fetishized sexual abuse as long as we cling to the "reeeee no kinkshame" and act like "b-but it's not REEEEEEEEEal" band-aids still hold water. After all, psychological studies and research just doesn't stand up to feelings, now does it? Scientific evidence backing up why certain content is illegal in most countries and similar testimonies just can't stand up to circular logical fallacies and angry furries.

Are incest, rape and pedophilia sexual abuse? Yes.

Wow, one of your types actually admits it?

Damn, and you still go on. You got the point but then you dropped it.

But I've always felt that's a known implication when writing and reading about certain kinds of stuff. At least when I do it, I work under the assumption that people know it's wrong, and whenever I read a story with similar topics I assume the writer does as well.

Wew, I've never seen a more convincing argument than, ah, assumptions.

And a lot of the time it does really feel like people mishandle certain stuff, even in porn, which is why I heavily dislike many popular writers on this site. A the same time, some of my favourite writers have also written incest and rape, so it feels bothering to see you lash out against the concept at large and not against the execution.

Are you naturally this retarded? Because if you put effort into this, I'm genuinely sorry.

Except, the only effort you put into this was logging into your alt instead of using your main account. So, no, not sorry.
10561842
And the gold star goes to Posh.

Posh #39 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 7 · With ·

10561853

I make no defense here of my own fetishes, nor any attack upon the fetishes of others.

Not a fan of the transgender elements [...] in fact are a bit squick.

I mean, I guess if you ignore the actual things which you typed on your keyboard, then...

Trans people having sex isn’t a fetish, of course, but I’m borrowing your definitions for the sake of argument

Elu
Elu #40 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 6 · With ·

10561870
I have already blocked you as I've nothing to discuss with people who write sexual abuse in the form that you do. I want to neither see you nor your stories. I'm not and will never be interested in debating it more than I already have.

10561792
I don't want to muck up your comment section any more... really wasn't my intention, for which I do apologise GfG.

I doubt that we'll come to any sort of catharsis on this, but you've asked so politely I do feel that I should answer as best I can...

For me, the temporary vs. actual nature of the body part actually is critically important. I do see sex and gender as a binary for 99+% of the population, and that percentage of 'other' makes me feel... uncomfortable, and unturned-on.

I'll add that the 'futa' bit would always be in context of a futa x female. The futa x male would equally extract the 'squick' feeling from me. I've explored my sexuality thoroughly over the years, and I know what is and is not attractive to me as a person -- m/m or things related to m/m just generally aren't.

With your story, as someone who is not a proponent of trans issues/concepts... my mind / libido actually reads it as a bit of a 'confused' M/F situation. Trixie is a sort of strange stallion who has become confused about her gender, but still has a ding-dong and gets it on with some pretty sexy times with her marefriend: hot, but with strange conflicting mental undertones about who Trixie 'really' is, and her current mental state.

As a futa-fic, it would be more straightforward (And also ridiculously porny and corny... cuh-porny?) involving a mare growing a trouser-salami to really give it to her marefriend. My mind/libido, primitive as it is, would be able to turn off and just enjoy the dicking down.

Want to be clear here: I am in no way suggesting you should have written a futa fic! As I have tried to make clear, different strokes for different folks... I can see how this would be a poignant piece for people into trans works. I'm not.

I just wanted to let you know that despite that, you wrote some dang good pony smut scene.

I'll stop messing up your comment section now. :)

Elu
Elu #42 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 11 · With ·

10561872
You. I like you. You speak my thoughts perfectly. I would also like to see all that stuff removed and banned from the website. Honestly, this should be demanded more all across the MLP community. Unfortunately, this community has attracted many less than, well... desirable people. If you want to rant with me together on that or something, feel free to DM me. I don't think the author is very appreciative of what is happening in the comments right now, although this isn't unexpected to me.

Comment posted by Third Wheel deleted Dec 2nd, 2020

10561881

With your story, as someone who is not a proponent of trans issues/concepts... my mind / libido actually reads it as a bit of a 'confused' M/F situation. Trixie is a sort of strange stallion who has become confused about her gender, but still has a ding-dong and gets it on with some pretty sexy times with her marefriend: hot, but with strange conflicting mental undertones about who Trixie 'really' is, and her current mental state.

When I spew shit, I normally do it into the toilet, but go off, girl.

Ice Star #45 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 14 · With ·

10561853

I make no defense here of my own fetishes, nor any attack upon the fetishes of others. I think you should try to emulate GfG's type of response to those who are not fans of the transsexual stories: acknowledge that others have different tastes and likes/dislikes than you and move on. Or just ignore my comment entirely.

"Transgender" isn't a fetish any more than "woman" is a fetish. You apparently decided to read most or all of a story that contained a trans character, advertised that it contained a trans character in the description, then said that you were "squicked out" because it depicted a trans character. You are a man with a peanut butter allergy going to the fucking Jif factory, eating all the contents, and wondering why you need to go to the hospital. More than that, you are now suing the company because you felt that you now think peanut butter is evil and no one should ever have it.

There are more levels of stupid in here than there are kinds of cheese in France. And since this is a mature story, I'm allowed to bring up something as profane as France.

Honestly, I had debated whether or not to leave a comment at all - I wanted to praise the author for their talented sex-scene writing, while being honest about why overall the story was not for me... but I was worried that my honest feedback would be unwelcome.

Your feedback literally consisted of "transes are icky girl should no have peepee" and then proceeded to say "but girl can have peepee if it follows this haha funni porn trope" on a serious story that doesn't even have the porn tag. Not to mention, you didn't even think before comparing "transgender woman" (or in this case, a mare) with something that becomes transphobic when associated with trans women. GfG and Scampy tore you a third and fourth asshole respectively (you tore the second because you made such stupid comments) in pointing out how gods-damned illogical your attempt at a point is.

GfG took it exactly the way I had hoped: as a compliment to their work despite having to overcome a squick factor.

She's doing the equivalent of a politician complimenting macaroni art. You are a gods-damned imbecile. You have absolutely no horse in the race to comment on what is disgusting because you literally have written sexual abuse in the three digits and admit you get off to it.

You are a buffoon.

I'd also heavily disagree that futa and transgender are related, and certainly they are not in my mind, but that's probably a discussion for somewhere else.

You read a story where a lady horse has a dick and got upset that she doesn't have a dick in the way you want her to for a reason that makes no sense. For someone who is inisiting that they wanted to read about a girl with a dick and her girlfriend and that you aren't actually an angry piss-baby, you sure are being fucking anal about the whole thing.

Comment posted by Third Wheel deleted Dec 2nd, 2020
Scampy #47 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 7 · With ·

10561881
Like I said before, and as this entire comment makes painfully clear, you have some really deep-rooted and extremely harmful transphobic beliefs. Maybe you should work through those and grow into a more accepting and understanding person. The world would be a better place for it.

I'm not holding my breath, though. Everyone can change, but not everyone wants to.

Ice Star #48 · Dec 2nd, 2020 · · 13 · With ·

10561888

Thanks for insulting me, my partner, and some of my closest friends. I really shouldn't have commented on this in the first place. I hope you too have a nice day.

Thank you for having remarkably poor taste in the echo chamber you immerse yourself in. If they're the kind of people who are the kind of headcases that can't realize putting content glorifying sexual abuse out there (even in small-scale societies like a fandom) is bad, they will always be worth insulting.

Red thumbs look good on you.

10561853

Alright.

I was more than happy to respond cordially to your initial comment, as I know this is a sensitive topic that has real-world impacts to many people. That's why I had two transpeople pre-read this for me (and give useful insight) before I posted this.

If you had not responded again with the "futa" comment, you would not have gotten the responses you have here. Nor would I be typing this. One of the goals of this story was to educate and help others, including myself, understand. This is a perfect opportunity to do so, for anyone reading this. Even if you don't agree, I ask that you at least consider what I have to say.

I make no defense here of my own fetishes, nor any attack upon the fetishes of others.

This is not a fetish story. I already have a story with the fetish tag, featuring cis characters, and plan on using that tag in other things. Being transgender is not a fetish. Dating/loving/having sex with a transgender person is not a fetish. The presence of a transgender person's body parts, whether altered by hormones, surgery, or nothing, is not a fetish. I did not write this in a fetishistic way, taking very deliberate steps not to. It's a story about two people wanting to be together, and struggling with what that means for them (primarily Starlight). To call it a fetish is to misunderstand not only the content and subject matter, but the intent.

I think you should try to emulate GfG's type of response to those who are not fans of the transsexual stories: acknowledge that others have different tastes and likes/dislikes than you and move on. Or just ignore my comment entirely.

Honestly, I had debated whether or not to leave a comment at all - I wanted to praise the author for their talented sex-scene writing, while being honest about why overall the story was not for me... but I was worried that my honest feedback would be unwelcome. GfG took it exactly the way I had hoped: as a compliment to their work despite having to overcome a squick factor.

I do... to a point. I can abide people not liking my stories, for whatever reason. Maybe they don't like StarTrix, or longer stories, or me, or whatever. I knew the story was going to get downvoted due to its trans content, just as my other transgender story was. I do not take it personally. If a downvote does not come alongside constructive critique, it means nothing to me. It's just a button someone hit. To be angry about that is absurd.

To reiterate, your initial comment, I had no intention of arguing. You were kind enough to read something that is not normally something you are comfortable with, and even more kind to say that I wrote it well. Great! Fantastic. I will at least give you some kudos in doing that to begin with.

I'd also heavily disagree that futa and transgender are related, and certainly they are not in my mind, but that's probably a discussion for somewhere else.

The comments section of a story is a conversation, just as much as the story is, and I can't abide "futa" being put on a pedestal as if it's something different than what I wrote. It's not. The fact that you can say you're uncomfortable with Trixie having a penis and identifying as a mare in one context, but not the other, shows that the context is what makes you uncomfortable.

From my experience on this site (dating past this account's age), as well as on the internet in general, futa content is very, very much enjoyed by the same audience that will rail against transgender material. If nothing else, I hope you see that the two sides of that coin are related. It begs the question: why? In either case, you have a female with a penis. What's the difference?

Well, in my experience, futa content is heavily fetishistic. It focuses on impossible sizes, and giant loads, and all kinds of other porn-logic stuff. Transgender stuff is... well, more honest, open, and authentic. Even when it includes titillating material, the focus is still on the person(s) involved, and affirming their gender and state of being above anything else.

In other words, futa fetishizes the same thing that its fans often condemn. I'm not saying you are doing this, necessarily; I'll let you tell me and the world what you think of transpeople. I'm just speaking in broad terms of what I've seen.

There is a reason this story's SFW content overshadows its NSFW content. It's meant to be hot, yes, but it's also meant to tell a story about identity, acceptance, understanding, and affirmation. In other words, it's not a fetish story, because there's nothing that should be fetishized. Things that should be explored, and talked about, and understood, but not fetishized. Yes, Trixie has a dick, but what's more important is that she's a mare, and she loves Starlight, and Starlight loves mares, and Starlight loves her, and that's all the explanation needed. Whether that dick is there by birth or magic, it should be approached the same. To say there is a difference is to misunderstand the context of it all.

To sum up, futa content is fetishized trans content. The only difference is the story we tell ourselves about it. And I didn't want to tell the wrong story. I hope that clears some things up.

I just want to make a second comment talking about the whole drama in the comment section of this story before I head to bed. Everyone had their preferences for what they like in a story, and that's completely normal. It's a natural fact of who we are as Humans.

However, to those who like stuff such as borderline illegal stuff, do not be surprised that your interests will get bashed whenever people encounter them. To many, such as I, it is revolting and should never be allowed in a civilized society. Those of you who like this sort of thing should seriously consider seeking help. Also, never compare those disgusting topics to the transgender issues, they aren't and won't ever be on equal footing.

My comment is quite harsh, and I want it that way. I'm never one to be antagonistic, but I have my morals and I will stick to them like glue.

Login or register to comment