What would happen if Will, Jack and Elizabeth were replaced by Twilight, Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy? This is a re-enactment of Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl with every role being substituted with one of our favorite ponies. A pony's-eye view of what the life of a pirate would be like. Enjoy!
I should put a note here that there are hints of many shippings throughout the story, most of which involve Fluttershy. Stay tuned to find out which one prevails!
Rated T for possible potty-mouthed sailors, cider-drinking good times, and some good old (new) fashioned pirate (pony) violence!
(Note: This is the first of three stories I plan to create. I don't plan on doing any of the sequels at this point, just other variations of ponies and their pirate counterparts.
I do not own any rights to My Little Pony or Pirates of the Caribbean. Cover art is for show only, doesn't give anything away =D)
........... YOU.............. ARE AMAZING!!
MAKE MORE! RIGHT NOW! DO IT! I LOOOVE!!! 
Need Moar!!!!!!!!!!!!
Mooooooaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrr!
love it!!!!
Awesome! NEED MOAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ui16.gamespot.com/591/moar_2.jpg
Under Jolly Roger - Runnin' Wild
YaY!
I had an idea like this once. Keep it up.
A crossover of one of my favorite cartoons and one of my favorite movies?
MOAR!
encrypted-tbn0.google.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRl1uZbdx55IkVua5gsQXsl-bN5GiNY9lZZlOy4pzOqf597HbOFJQ
Instant favorite.
I will be keeping my eye on this one...
I can safly assume the replacment for Mr.swan is going to be The Mayor
but Thats only a guess keep up this brillient work!!!!!!! 
Let me guess:
Pinkie Pie is Jack Sparrow
Rainbow Dash is Barbossa
Who are you going to have as Murtogg and Millroy?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6nVil-4D9g
I couldn't resist the temptation, its such a fun story
Plz moar pony pirates
1174992
That was absolutely amazing. Just for that, another chapter tonight, I promise.
Well, Governor Swan is Elisabeth's father. So, Governor Swan needs to be Fluttershy's father, but we don't know Fluttershy's father. So I'm gonna say Angel Bunny... Yeah, that seems about right.
Also, this is brilliant. Have all my internet.
1177271
Glad you like
going by the comments here, I think I'm not the only one who looks forward to it 
to attempt to answer that could it be Snips and snails the only other two that could make any sence (dispite it beign insane to pair these two with pirates) is Diamond tiara and Silverspoon but...i still say its gotta be Snips and snails
I just gotta say I realy cant wait to see pipsueak (if he appers) (or read eh) just the fun of it. Brillient melding of the characters
you made them ery well melded though i have ot wonder who would be a better jack sparrow rainbow dash or pinkiepie (my moneies on pinkie) 
1185945 I second this.
You know who should do Pintel and Ragetti? Doctor whooves and Derpy. And Derpy with a glass eye
.
Also, Yay I have an honorable mention.
1186172 OMG you may just be right about the Derpy thing...maybe but still its Dr.whoove is abit to smart for the 2 fools or hell derpy two eh maybe i kinda hope your right i mean derpy is awesome~
SEE! 
I'm thinking Snips and Snails are going to be Murtogg and Mullroy
1186181 I've got a better idea for Pintel and Ragetti: Screwball (Discord's daughter) and Derpy. That's chaos and clumsiness together.
Also, ponify all the pirates of the caribbean movies!
I'm just hoping that Rainbow Dash is Jack Sparrow while Pinkie Pie is Barbossa. Why? Because this:
encrypted-tbn0.google.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcT57PzZ4tf6ipfx3VZzUNMAa4SKGC6pbiMszlSbqqQW-w9-aGfY3w
1188295 Pinkie as barb...jsut doesnt click with me...eh sue me we're see though I think this author has a trick for us yet though
and cool picture HA
U.B.
This was most amusing. I nearly lost it when I read Port Cheval. That was rich, and then the bit with the Flim Flam brothers was also good. Not quite what I had expected but still fun. In terms of Mr. Brown I am slightly torn, personally I can think of two possible characters. One being Big Macintosh, and the other being Berry Punch. I think I will make my final guess Berry Punch and hope for the best.
~ The Fictional Critic.
I'm also going to say Berry Punch, just because she'll be drunk.
My reaction to this chapter:
media.comicvine.com/uploads/5/52044/2060390-i_like_it.jpg
This chapter was just great.
24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m9kyczqWNQ1qg2nu5o2_250.gif
And I'm glad you didn't make Pinkie Jack Sparrow, I think that Rainbow Dash is a better fit for the character.
Do keep up with this story, its so awesome!
I don't think I do it justice, but its still a very fun story, well done To Be Somebody!
1210715
It's so fitting for the story. Trust me, you're doing an excellent job, and thank you so much for doing that! I'd love to share this with as many bronies as possible. 
I'm glad you liked the name, that one gave me some trouble. I also had to take Flim and Flam a little out of character, but I tried my best to portray their personalities without over-doing it. I'm happy to hear you enjoyed it.
1210745
This:
1211093
And this made me go re-watch Thor a couple of times.
1214519
I love your voice
Sooooo Partying is a form of Piracy now?
Dafuq.... However I do find it creative and I can totally see some hilarity is in stow, and thusly I can't wait to read it. 
: Good show ol' chap. Good show.
OHH!!!! I think I figured out the line up of the pony pirates!!!! This is gonna be goooooooood.
Please, oh please, oh please, oh please, oh please. oh PLEEEEEASE!!!!! Write moar chappies okie dokie loki?
My Money is on Derpy.
I implore you to write more.
Please make part 4!
I, Xana Erica Sparrow, daughter of Captain Jack Sparrow, would love it if you continue this.
::
:
:
Don't worry, every pony! If all else fails, I'll write my own! And, it'll have a lot more of the movies in it!
"So Flutters do you believe in the ghosties yet?"
Is this story dead?
Please do more of this over crazy/ odd/ masterpiece of a story.
That is all I and all your readers ask for.
I pray and hope everyday that you decide to continue this lovely story
Dead men tell no tales is especially true on this website...last update was nearly a decade ago and the comments section isn't far behind.
Next chapter?