Every painting has a story. This one is no different.
Written as a submission for the Quills and Sofas Speedwriting group's "Plain Jane" contest. Originally written in the span of one hour without a prompt and edited later.
Thanks to Moonshot, Bill Cipher, Silent Whisper, Equus, LostinFandom, Flashgen, Zontan, dawn, MasterThief, Shaslan, Wish, Snow Quill, Knox Locke, and Vis a Viscera for reading during the contest and providing their thoughts.
I'm a lazy hack so here's my comment from the original speedwrite:
Anyways, this story made me cry in its original form, and it made me cry again today. Great stuff.
10350309
Thanks wish! <3
I think this is even better now with the changes you’ve made. The story of a humble painting painted with love and the ponies it connected... Beautiful. Great job Red!
10350364
Thanks Snow!
Really good mystery fic, man. Especially in terms of you working up the early scenes like I said. It's a joy to read, then and now.
10350491
Thanks, glad you liked it!
How dare you make me feel emotions again, Red? These are unauthorized feels.
Seriously, it's so good, and your writing is just... *chef's kiss* amazing!
10350854
>:3
Glad you liked it!
Great job as always, Red. It was a very interesting way to frame a story. Nice job.
10354065
Thanks Bill! Glad you liked it!
Howdy, hi!
Damn, I loved this. A story told in reverse is really interesting, but certainly, a difficult feat to pull off. However, you really nailed it here. I loved the opening of the painting, the going back through its history to tell this tragic story about Soarin and Braeburn. It really tugged at the heartstrings.
Honestly, the whole thing is just a really interesting concept. You know the ending, you know how everything results, the ending gives you the beginning and it puts everything into context. The painting is this framing device for telling a romantic story and hitting those same notes of tension in a story like this, but well *in reverse*.
The whole thing is just incredibly interesting in execution. Awesome work.
Dammit. This story is gonna live inside my brain forever. Rent free. In the same neighborhood as Memento and Predestination.
I wish—just the tiniest bit—that it was a little longer, to give me some meat to chew through when I inevitably reread this a dozen times. But I'm always a fan of parsimony and this story is laser-focused. I doubt there's much, if anything, you could have added that wouldn't have taken away from its impact.
My god I cant explain how much I love stories like this, being a fan of very surreal and experimental movies. I always love it when a writer challenges that and makes a story that includes ponies (lol, I don't know how to word it that great) But yeah I loved this, great job