• Member Since 1st Jul, 2015
  • online

Omegathyst


Female Writer, Bisexual Writer, Smolder X Mare Crackship Connoisseur. Creator of the Smolderverse, and writer of many other kinds of clop and SFW stories (Commissions temporarily OPEN)

Comments ( 5 )

10197104
Thank you, it was such a great find on short notice :pinkiesmile:

Pinkie gave a small smile as she got up, wobbling over to a plate of mint chocolate brownies. Celestia took a slice of the cake at the center and sat next to Pinkie, deciding on what activity to plan for Rainbow Dash...

Do I smell a *sniff sniff* sequel?:rainbowwild:

This is your official review from Dirty Little Secret's Dirty Little Contest!
Remember to vote in the contest's poll -- voting closes at midnight, June 6th.
And make sure to allow notifications from the contest group and/or follow Dirty Little Secret to get the full results and the awards show post on June 9th!
You can also check the current ranking, thanks to garatheauthor's unofficial ranking of the scores that have been publicized so far.

------ Review ------

Please keep in mind, I know I can be overly critical and negative at times. I can always find something to nitpick, even in the greatest works of literature ever written. Please don't take it personally!
-It's cute seeing Twilight's embarassment in the beginning, even if it's not totally clear why.
-“Whoops,” Dash snickered. awesome existence,” Dash smirked. darling,” Rarity rolled her eyes -- improper dialog tags.
-Very short and rushed.
-A fic this short really should have skipped right to the part where Celestia shows Pinkie the desserts, making more room for the important parts.
-It's cute and hot to think of Celestia planning on fucking her way through the Mane 6 -- that really helps the enticement score.

------ Scores ------

To clarify what these scores mean, check my judging rubric.
Cloppability: 67/100
Allure: 12/100
Enticement: 85/100
Immersion: 50/100
Prose Quality: 80/100
Total Score: 294/500
The more specialized scores for individual prizes, as well as the results of the community poll, will be published when the full results are announced. If this story wins any awards, there will be another post in the story comments sometime after June 9th announcing that this story has won.

Thank you for participating, and thank you for contributing to Fimfic's collection of clop!

Going through the stories I've had on my read list for the better part of a year or more and now it's your turn.

“Huh, this says that Pinkie Pie is invited to spend time with Celestia...maybe she spelled my name wrong?”

“I sincerely doubt it, darling,” Rarity rolled her eyes at Twilight, a light smile on her face. “So, Pinkie, what do you think?”

Given the canon example of ponies being very bad at spelling, I can completely understand Pinkie's confusion. I'm not sure if you're referencing the show directly but I'm giving you credit regardless.

“Oh don’t say that yet,” Twilight flinched, glancing down at the ground.

Comma after 'Oh'.

“Sounds like an awesome existence,” Dash smirked. “Get to bang a mare here and there, maybe a stallion or two. And no lover to chew you out for it?”

Not really my thing when ponies talk like low-status humans but I see the value in it. Grudgingly, I'll admit Rainbow Dash does seem more the type to talk this way if we assume ponies speak in a raunchy manner off-camera.

“Hmm, maybe I should make her a cake…” Pinkie whispered, flipping through the pages. “Let’s see: chocolate, strawberry, breakfast-themed…”

Oh shit! There are breakfast-themed cakes? I want one! :pinkiegasp:

I love when people add food porn to their actual porn.

Standing amongst the crowd of chattering ponies, was Princess Celestia.

Who were you expecting, Margeret Thatcher? :trollestia:

“Thank you!” Pinkie squeaked, breaking away from the hug to jump to the table. Extending her cartoonishly-long tongue, Pinkie took a huge bite from the cake at the center before taking cupcakes into her mouth.

Bold use of show-accurate physics. Though, this does clash with the earlier Rainbow Dash scene. I'm curious why you didn't just stick with the show-accurate innocence throughout. I do find this style rather charming at times.

“Fuck, your guests really get the b-best treatment, don’t they?” Celestia gasped, bucking her hips forward. “Face your butt to me, Pinkie Pie.”

It really does clash pretty badly having profanity in this. :trixieshiftleft:

“Heh, somepony’s getting antsy,” Celestia giggled in Pinkie’s mane

Missing period.

“Fuck me fuck me fuck me fuck me fuck me!!!” Pinkie screamed, shots of mare-cum shooting around Celestia’s cock.

It's generally considered bad form to double-up on descriptive metaphors like "shots of marecum shooting". You should consider employing a synonymous noun form of 'shot' instead. This is also a pristine example of imprecise, bloated sentence structure with many words existing for their own sake and not providing context for the action being described.

Here's how I'd write it instead:

Pinkie screamed, bolts of marecum coating Celestia's cock.

On one final note: The word 'shoot' is something you want to avoid unless you're describing the action of a discharging weapon such as a gun or crossbow. There are so many better words to employ when describing liquid action scenes like this.

Pinkie gave a small smile as she got up, wobbling over to a plate of mint chocolate brownies. Celestia took a slice of the cake at the center and sat next to Pinkie, deciding on what activity to plan for Rainbow Dash...

Good note to close out on, letting us imagine the sex that's in store for the rest of the Mane Six.

Overall, I found the sex scene lacked crucial detail and found the pacing pretty rushed. It's good to slow things down when writing sex. If the sort of sentimental shite I'm prone to writing isn't your thing, you can precisely describe the anatomy or detail each sensation either of the two ponies are feeling. As a story, this frankly ain't nearly as bad as most short fetish clops I've read. It got the car moving down the road to its final destination. As someone who values story over sex, I respect the hell of that.

I can't find it in me to vote one way or the other so have my comment instead. Have a good day, Omegathyst.

Login or register to comment