On the Implications of Tribal Magic in British Wizards
By Hermione Granger
Friday, Oct. 1, 2021
Many a person at Hogwarts this year, from students to instructors to even ghosts, are well aware of the number of Equestrian students attending- and equally aware that the Equestrian students are invisibly, magically divided into three tribes- Raeth, Aethr, and Etrah. The Equestrian tribal magic allows members of the Raeth tribe to use wandless magic at an almost instinctual level, while also making it very difficult for them to use a wand at all. The Etrah tribe is the most powerful, in terms of wand magic, and is also physically the strongest. The Aethr tribe gets a mix of both worlds: Some difficulty using wand magic, some physical strength, and, in a few notable cases, extreme physical speed.
But British wizards express none of these Equestrian magic effects; we do not have Equestrian magic.
Thus, when I discovered on Sept. 27, 2021 that the magical flow within the form of an Equestrian is comparable to that within a British wizard, I asked the question.
Can British wizards be divided into tribes of their own? What effects does it have?
As it turns out, from a preliminary study conducted on Sept. 28, the answer to the first question is yes.
For this study, we gathered a large group of volunteers and compared their thaumic flow patterns. British participants numbered 169 witches and wizards: G-23F, 22M; R-27F, 21M; H-15F, 12M; S-21F, 22M, plus all four Heads of House, the Headmaster, and the Gamekeeper. Equestrian participants numbered 533 witches and wizards: G-92F, 6M; R-273F, 19M; H-57F, 3M; S-79F, 4M. As lopsided as it appeared, the male/female distribution of Equestrian participants was approximately representative of all Equestrian students.
The magical flow patterns inside each participant were evaluated together and individually. It was found that not all Equestrians fall into the three tribes; a few lesser tribes were discovered, but could not be named. Some of these lesser tribes were merely highly specialized versions of the main three.
The British participants present were found to demonstrate flow patterns bearing extremely high similarity to Equestrian participants, and were also found to be divided into what appeared to be the same three tribes.
Naturally, there were a few exceptions. Two staff members, who were known to be possessed with recent, nonhuman ancestry, were found to not belong to any known tribe. All the other British participants could be classified into one of the three tribes; however, I found that nearly fifteen percent of British participants belonged to the specialized tribal variants, which are reportedly extremely rare in Equestria.
In an effort to identify any personality or lifestyle differences between tribes, we gave all participants a survey, containing questions relating to tribe, personal tastes, preferred lifestyle, and skills.
Members of the Aethr Tribe tended to have significantly more energy than the other tribes. Aethrs are prone to run around freely and lawlessly, and poke at what they want to; a vast majority of Gryffindors were found to be Aethrs. Of those that had experience on a broom, well over ninety percent of Aethrs were found to be naturals. Upper-year Aethr participants tended to be best at Care of Magical Creatures and Charms. It is worth note that very few Aethrs ever got lost more than twice on the way to class, even on the first day of their first year. Not one of the members of the specialized tribal variant remembered getting lost even once, suggesting a gift for navigation.
Members of the Etrah Tribe tended to be the calmest, the most receptive to rules, and had the best work ethics. Etrahs generally have no qualms with spending long hours doing manual labor, and tend to be stronger than the other tribes; a vast majority of Hufflepuffs were found to be Etrahs. Of those that had experience on a broom, not one was a natural- and well over ninety percent were found to have had severe difficulties learning to fly. Upper-year Etrah participants tended to be best at Herbology and Potions; to the point where only one non-Etrah participant had achieved an ‘Outstanding’ OWL in Potions, while about three quarters of all upper-year Etrahs had achieved such. Not one of the members of the specialized tribal variant had scored less than an ‘Outstanding’ on their Potions OWL. It is worth note that a vast majority of muggleborn Etrah participants enjoyed working on the family farm prior to coming to Hogwarts; those of wizarding descent were often found to enjoy helping their parents produce products for a family business, such as robes or cauldrons.
Members of the Raeth tribe tend to be calm and collected most of the time, but possessing of a short temper. Raeths were found to be almost universally possessed by a sense of curiosity, though a vast majority were willing to sate that curiosity through books, rather than experimentation; a vast majority of Ravenclaws were found to be Raeths. Of those that had experience on a broom, Raeths appeared to have no particular difficulty- or lack thereof- in flight. Some Raeths were as bad as the Etrahs; some were as good as the Aethrs. Upper-year Raeths turned out to be fairly well-rounded; they tended to have a high overall grade, and be particularly good at Transfiguration and Runes, though their Herbology scores tended to suffer. Equestrian Raeths have had extreme difficulty getting their wands to function, but a majority of British Raeths were found to have successfully taught themselves at least one spell prior to their first year at Hogwarts- and the rest experienced little or no difficulty learning their first spells after arriving. It is worth note that a majority of upper-year Raeth participants hoped for future jobs as instructors, designers, or magical engineers.
Participants from Slytherin House were found to have an approximately equal distribution between the tribes, and a majority of British Slytherins, especially those belonging to the Raeth or Aethr tribes, expressed either dissatisfaction or active dislike with their lot in life. It is worth note that these dissatisfied Slytherins were almost exclusively from pureblooded families of high birth, and that such dissatisfaction was found to taper off in later years, suggesting indoctrination.
It is worth note that muggleborn, half-blood, and pure-blood participants were each approximately evenly distributed across the tribes, suggesting that tribal identity is either random, or persistent in muggles as well.
We also had a few magical and physical tests, the results of which were analyzed on a by-tribe basis, with separation between Equestrian and British tribes. Physical exercises showed the same differences mentioned on the survey; differences between British tribes were far smaller than between the comparable Equestrian tribes, due to Equestrian tribal magic, but remained distinct and recognizable.
Magical results varied widely.
Equestrian Raeths were found to have direct, instinctive, and conscious control of their innate magic; many were able to demonstrate minor magical effects such as object levitation.
British Raeths were found to be natural silent spellcasters- requiring little or no training to use silent incantations, possibly thanks to a broader magical bond with their wand. While lacking in instinctive, conscious control of innate magic, some British Raeths were able to demonstrate limited control of their innate magic for wandless capabilities, commonly referred to as ‘wandless magic’; all such Raeths remained fully capable of wandless magic when separated from their wands. None demonstrated sufficient control for effects on the scale of the Equestrians, though the basic capability was demonstrated.
Equestrian Aethrs were found to have instinctive control of their innate magic. The only effect produced during our study was a mild electric current arcing through the hair, which was described by the students in question as ‘weather magic’.
British Aethrs were found to suffer only slightly in wandless capabilities when separated from their wands. Additionally, Aethrs were found to be capable of casting wand magic through their wands without issue when separated from the wand in question by as much as three feet, with no regard for obstructions. This included when another was holding their wand. Aethrs were found to be uniquely capable of summoning their wand mentally, not unlike how they might summon a broomstick, when separated by up to six feet. A quick trial showed the plausibility of this effect being used to retain control of their wand when struck by the disarming charm, though any such capability in an uncontrolled environment, such as a duel or legitimate combat, would require training and practice.
Equestrian Etrahs did not demonstrate any magic during our indoor study; however, common Equestrian wisdom indicated that Etrah magic took form mostly in their massive physical strength, and also made them natural farmers, giving them the gift to tell exactly what any given plant did or didn’t need, at a glance.
British Etrahs, however, demonstrated an ability to use their wand as if holding it from as far as fifty feet away, provided they were linked by stone or other earthen materials; when paired with a summoning charm, this was shown to give them the ability to retrieve their wand from such distances. Wandless magic was found to be significantly weaker than Raeth or Aethr wandless magic. A wandless power boost could be acquired, bringing them just above Raeth or Aethr levels, by either direct contact with their wand, or direct contact with stone or other earthen materials. Interestingly enough, a wandless defensive barrier was found to be far stronger when cast by an Etrah than by a Raeth or Aethr, even when without the power boost of stone or wand. Some upper-year Etrahs showed a low-level ability to see through stone or other earthen materials, or to see from it.
It is worth note that none of these wand-related tribal abilities (remote use, wandless magic boost, etc.) functioned with another wizard’s wand, only their own.
This concludes the material findings of our study.
Yes, we British witches and wizards are divided into tribes, and are possessed with tribal magic.
Thus raises the questions: Why? Where did it come from? Why is our British tribal magic so similar to, yet so different from, the Equestrian tribal magic?
Point of order: 'Harry Potter' is set in the 1990s.
10272931
Ooh, that's a good idea
10272929
Well yeah... this crossover is set in the 2020s.
10272929
Not in this story, apparently.
This is a great research paper and interlude
I legit never studied in school and I usually got at least a B.
10272954
Me too. Became my downfall when I hit college- it's a much more rigorous environment, there.
That said, I do identify as a Raeth/Unicorn...
Anyone that isn't blind by wizarding or racial pride will be quite quick in noticing this could have either astonishing implications for the past of the two peoples or at least for the nature of how magic expresses in living beings. And also question how such disparate effects weren't noticed before.
Sure, we know that a lot of things only are noticed when one goes beyond their preconceptions and make a proper study on them, but do the wizards know?
Seeing the actual paper is really cool, thanks for including it.
Some very interesting extrapolations from Equesttrian innate magic to British magic, and the reverse.
I love how the paper title follows on from both the story title and also the blog post titles. It's great.
10272939
She ever see her own?
10272976
You're welcome.
... Sorry it's nowhere near the quality, length, or detail that Hermione would actually provide. I'm not her, and unfortunately, I don't live in her world, either.
Also, it's a nice feather in Hermione's cap that she found this out before Lyra did, even with Lyra's "advantages".
10272997
Probably, yes. In later chapters, she knows what her tribe is, and that would be about the only way for her to know it. I imagine it wouldn't have been too hard for her to look at her own.
10273001
That's completely fair, trying to write the actual paper that Hermione or Twilight would write in this situation is beyond the scope of a story that isn't JUST the paper, heheh.
10273007
What is it?
Or is that spoilers?
10273012
Depends on how you look at it, really. Considering her tribal identity isn't mentioned for another ten chapters or so... and that the tribal identities really don't play much of a part in the story just yet, I'm not sure.
I mean, it's certainly something that can be guessed very easily (and accurately) by someone that has read The Gate, so I suppose I can simplify any such searches by saying that she's a/an Aethr.
Wait... The Equestrian population is 94% female? How does that work?
10273030
This is a very good question.
Presumably, polygamy is big. And so are large families. Either that, or mares/fillies were more likely to accept a trip to Hogwarts than stallions/colts, overall.
Harry potter is supposed to take place in 1991, so either Hermione is now a teacher at hogwarts, or you decided to place the events 30 years in the future, so, the muggle world is very different, and the pandemic just passed XD.
This research paper may start out as something done for students, but it's going to spread. The Unspeakables are going to be all over it like white on rice, and the British non-magical government, if they're tapped into the wizarding world covertly as the previous chapter seems to suggest will probably want to take a look at it.
That is actually a rather useful thing for them to know, especially if they can duplicate her test results.
Hopefully it gets used more for "additional instruction" than for "Sorry, you can't take this because we think you'd be bad at it." Maybe for mentoring suggestions for additional courses.
I find the potential combat insights interesting. Now, we know that Voldeshorts is returning, so it's useful, but I wonder if the Ministry is going to appreciate the increase in fighting skill that may also result, now that these people are learning about (and can apparently do) wandless magic or recover from the disarming charm...
I think wandless magic is supposed to be quite rare, so the fact that anyone was able to do it for the purposes of testing will alarm them. Admittedly, the Equestrians can all do it, but they don't count since they are foreign. For native Brits to manage it will probably raise a few flags.
10272598
... 0.o
Never mind then!
10273041
But there's still a problem. With a gender ratio that lopsided, there would be a tremendous evolutionary pressure towards being more likely to produce a colt.
Here's the reasoning:
x
of producing a colt rather than a filly, then, on average, their number of grandchildren will be proportional to1 + 14x
. (This assumes almost all ponies survive to adulthood.)So if the gender ratio was this lopsided, it wouldn't stay that way for long.
Thanks to one of my teachers for showing my class roughly this argument in a biology lesson.
I can only see a few ways out of this:
But in any of these cases, I ask, "Why?".
10273030
I'd suggest herds like in The Unity Pact.
10273166
A different default family structure isn't actually enough to make this work. See this comment:
10273155
Damn, you've got a solid hate on for Ron don't you?
10273111
Yes, I decided to place the events 30 years in the future.
10273155
#3, probably. As for why, I have no idea.
10273177
Canon Ron couldn't be bothered to fully read a scholarly paper like this one... so long as it wasn't in his required lists, which it wasn't. He's lazy, after all. For this same reason, he probably didn't participate in the study.
If he read it, he would understand it just fine.
10273172
Well, it was only a suggestion. But that would help explain why more mares/fillies were able to attend than stallions/colts. As a greater percentage of the population, there would be more of them. Plus, how many stallions are in the guard in this Equestria? And how many of those are essential positions? Not to mention how many other jobs are essential to the smooth function of Equestria.
10273285
This is true... for as much as the mares seem to be the majority in Equestria, all the crucial roles- like the train driver, the Guard, etc- seem to be filled by stallions.
10273250
I wasn't really aiming my comment at that part as much as other comments stating Ron was being pushed back as a side character in this one. Considering he was one of the main three in the original series it's a pretty big deviation from canon. Not good or bad, just a fact. No shots fired. Personally I don't think he was dumb as much as he was average. When you spend all your time with two characters that solidly stand out one way or another you're going to come off and pretty basic. Still enjoying the story though.
10273490
Yeah, no problem. It's not so much that I hate Ron, it's that I don't like how he comes across in canon. Yes, that's gotten exaggerated here... but it's not something that can't be trained out. I mean, I didn't like how Draco came across in canon, but like Diamond Tiara, he's also a fairly flat "basic antagonist"-type character, that I can mess with very easily, even before the story starts. Ron, as a main, isn't like that- so I have to train it out, make it make sense. He's a lot harder to work with, to me.
Well, where do you think the legend of unicorn and other mythical creatures came from?
10273155
I actually have my own personal headcanon to explain the gender balance issue: magic.
Specifically, Equestria has some form of magic to let two mares have a biological child together, but this will always result in a filly. (This doesn't work for two stallions, because stallions can't carry a child to term due to no womb.)
Pair that with an absence of bigotry towards different forms of sexuality (which, in a land founded on Harmony and backed by an immortal God-Princess determined to see it cultivated, is quite believable) and the gender balance will naturally move towards a high female:male ratio as an evolutionary equilibrium.
10273714
... That would actually tend to have the stallions die off over time, for an all-female equilibrium... and all the foals in the show have male/female parents, so...
10273850
No it wouldn't, because there would still be the basic chance of stallion/mare pares producing colts...and magic might also increase that chance, so stallions would never ACTUALLY die off.
10273886
I suppose, if "Stallion" was the dominant gene.
Just because, if two mares have two foals, and a mare and a stallion have two foals, that would tend to keep the ratio the same. Add the higher mortality rates of stallions (because they seem to be all the wrongdoers, guards, etc.), and, well...
10273893
The 'higher mortality rate' is a pretty big assumption.
10273932
Yes, yes it is.
10272358
So in this world, his scar is not a super-distinguishing feature?
Crystal? Bat? Non-pony? Changeling?
Is Gabby here? Thorax?
Ember?
Do I see a massive "What have I become?" reaction as humans change form en-masse?
Derpy?
Really? Not all earth ponies are farmers/plant people. That might be the specialized version of earth ponies.
Canon Unicorns tended to only learn a few spells related to their cutie mark. Actual spell-crafters who learn how to analize magic and get 2 dozen effects in the first year out of school are rare.
Twilight and Glimmer are the exception, not the rule.
10274188
According to another poster, the unidentified pony is the OC of one of his reviewers.
10273155
5. Some external force interferes with gender ratios
As an example, see The Deathworlders, in which the Igraean Hierarchy has been grooming the Gao for millennia to serve as a physical force with which the Igraeans could control the galaxy (replacing the Discarded, who once upon a time were the bodies of the Igraeans before their mind uploads). To that end, male Gaoian births far exceed female ones, giving them a proportionally larger capacity for military force. (Of course, this kind of backfired when the Gao threw off their Igraean shackles...)
10274197
No, it is.
However, just like in canon, it's hidden by his bangs.
10274220
Spike at the very least, yes. Amongst 13,000 Equestrians, there's almost certainly a few that aren't actually ponies.
No, there won't be any en-masse transformation. I'm not like that. Except in the backstory of Just Like Magic of Old.
And you are aware she's talking specifically about the British tribes after that, right? The Equestrians don't share the traits she's discussing there. (This includes Derpy- she's a regular Aethr, and it's her CM power that lets her do that).
And yes, not all British Etrahs were farmers. Note that she said "Majority" and "British"... which suggests that British Etrahs tended to want to be farmers, and so tended to be farmers.
Yes, Twilight, Starlight, Lyra, and Sunset are the exception, not the rule- in Equestria. Things are different in Britain.
10273714
Interestingly, that's also my headcanon. But I haven't worked through the evolutionary dynamics to see if it actually works.
10273030
According to the average stallion that has 10 marefriends "It works juuuuust fine :D"
10274546
Oh? Her Cutie Mark power allows her to navigate despite her visual disability? You know, I've always wondered 'why bubbles', but what if they're not? What if they're magnified water droplets, and her Cutie Mark power allows her to either sense the presence of water to such a degree that she can 'see' other creatures even if they're in a blind spot of her vision? Could also explain why she crashes into pony-made things so often; the absence of water would be the equivalent of a radar jammer to her sense, which she'd likely come to rely on more than she should, sometimes to her detriment.