• Member Since 1st May, 2016
  • offline last seen Sunday


I love pones.

Comments ( 37 )

One day, I will find a fic featuring the Apples that isn’t incest. Probably the same day I find a fic that doesn’t call genderbent Twilight “Dusk Shine”.

Originality is dead.

Applecest is like a hot mug of coffee in the morning. It never gets old. :ajsmug:

There was a time, long ago, when the preferred pairing was Applejack/Rainbow. I miss those halcyon days...

In an alternate timeline, someone noticed AJ's lewd drawings were quite good. What's more, she realised ponies were willing to pay a good sum for them.
This starts a bootleg drawn porn market that secures the Apple family's future in Ponyville.

I don't agree with your comment, but my r63 fic doesn't use Trotsworth's names, just for the record.

You are one of one, then. I appreciate you sacrificing your fic's popularity in favor of effort.

Isn't official male name for Twilight exatly Dusk Shine? I think I remember that from some article with Faust?
So... you an wait, but propably never gonna happen.

I'm pretty sure all of M6 have official male names...

They actually don’t, all of the male names are fan made.

No, they don't. The common names that are most frequently used were created by Trotsworth. Not because they're good names, but because he was one of the first brony artists to draw r63 art.

The fact that people think those names are canon says more about just how creatively bankrupt some of these authors are than anything I ever could.

What's the name of your r34 fic? You have, like, sixty of them.

I never read anything r63(beside one story with Shining Armor) but I don't understand why you're so butthurting about the names. It's the least important part of creativity. Nothing compared to the plot and conflict.

And please stop littering the comment section with it. It has nothing to do with the story.

Better comment on how autistic incest and foalcon are and how I should burn in hell for writing this.

I mean, I'm more than happy to say you'll burn in hell for any number of things. Are you wearing mixed fabrics right now? Have you ever eaten shrimp?


It's r63, not r34. Rule 34 is "if it exists, there is porn of it"; rule 63 is "if it exists, there is a gender-swapped version of it".

Only one of them is r63, even though I've pondered a sequel for a while. It's among my more controversial stories because some readers have... strong opinions about Twilight's decision, to put it mildly. The original comment thread was inadvertently deleted, though, so there's not nearly as much fire in the comments now.

TBack to Normal
When Twilight learns returning to Equestria comes with a steep price, a secret from her past leaves her with an impossible choice.
Trick Question · 9.8k words  ·  451  111 · 3.6k views

I'm sorry for responding to the comments in that case. I'll take any future responses to PM.

I'm pretty sure I read some article with Lauren about that, but it was long ago, and now I can't find it.
Or maybe watched it.
Well, that isn't that important information, how. It just the way it is.. and, well, if anyone should start using "other" alternative names, there will be only confusion, because that wouldn't be R63, but just OCs. So, it's easier that way - everyone understands it.

“Here's to porn! The cause of, and solution to, all of life's problems.”

This isn't how economics works though... :applejackconfused:

Human incest can lead to genetic instabilities, yes... Equines, however... we inbreed horses as is. The genetic instability rate for them is FAR smaller fo then that us, based on their DNA. We have 24 pairs, they have 40. The more pairs, the lower a chance of stuff going wrong. I know most people will question it as “More means more things to fuck up” but genetically, it’s actually the opposite.

We inbreed Horses, Dogs, pigs, sheep, and a great many others...

Um... what now? Quality? Farm equipment IRL has lead to better quality than things harvested 'by hand' IRL.

Oh well... it's fantasy... I can give it a pass.

Good story.


Farm equipment IRL has lead to better quality than things harvested 'by hand' IRL

Have you even watched "The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000" episode?

so did it work? is the farm doing well?

Flim and Flam only lost that because of three factors:

1. The apples got outside help
2. They overcompensated for that help by turning up the suction to the point in which they were pulling more than just apples
3. They turned off the quality control unit

If it wasn't for these factors, they would have won the contest without a doubt. Their machine was capable of harvesting and processing apples into cider at a pace far beyond what the apples were capable of.

I got your arguments but I don't know why people sometimes assume that everything that a writer writes is their perspective. I just a storyteller who told a story about a pony family that thinks they can save their farm by sticking to this plan. It's THEIR point of view, not mine. They may succeed or may fail, I have no idea(unless I decide to write the sequel). It's not about what makes sense or what doesn't. It's about what the characters believe. And I think it's been shown enough times that the Apple Family are quite conformists :applejackunsure:

“This red line is consumer demand,” Applejack explained. “When our granny had laid the foundation of this farm, the town was small and its demand for apples was smaller still. But as it continued to grow, more ponies became (began) settling down here, their demand for apple products becoming as diverse as their (the) cultures they had come from. And finally, after Twilight has become a princess and erected her castle, more than ever ponies are now moving to our town to build a life here, ….(and)….some of them are farmers.” Applejack’s brows drew inwards, hard grooves cutting into the bridge of her nose. “We’re already beginning to lose some of our most loyal customers to them because we can’t meet deadlines. In my estimation, we have ten, maybe fifteen years if we’re lucky to rectify the situation and catch up with the demand.”

If you are depressed: Watch porn!
If you are angry: Watch porn!
If you are sad: Watch porn!
If you are broke: Make porn!

It's a solid enough premise but they are way too nonchalant about this. If Applejack and Applebloom are in heat then they should be all over Big Mac's cock. Not even a hint of forbidden pleasure from incest or excitement for their first impregnation. There needs to be more seduction and passion.

Plus, Applejack isn't the type of pony to let something like estrus stop her from getting out there in the fields.

This is your official review from Dirty Little Secret's Dirty Little Contest!
Remember to vote in the contest's poll -- voting closes at midnight, June 6th.
And make sure to allow notifications from the contest group and/or follow Dirty Little Secret to get the full results and the awards show post on June 9th!

------ Review ------

Please keep in mind, I know I can be overly critical and negative at times. I can always find something to nitpick, even in the greatest works of literature ever written. Please don't take it personally!
-Does a really nice job of being sloppy and steamy by the end.
-Pretty great climax.
-there is little time left until the breeding season ends. -- doesn't sound like AJ.
-Applejack's fucking was kind of short and rushed.
-“Do you think there’s going to be more than one foal?” Apple Bloom asked as she shuffled herself closer to Big Mac and put her head on his chest, a big satisfied smile on her face. / “Of course I do,” Applejack said. “It’s Big Mac we’re talking about. -- uh... that's not how biology works, you know... the number of foals is entirely dependent upon how many eggs the mother releases. The amount/virility of the sperm doesn’t matter -- it can still only fertilize as many eggs as are available to be fertilized.
-Great job of going over the top without making it so crazily over the top that it loses you.

------ Scores ------

To clarify what these scores mean, check my judging rubric.
Cloppability: 97/100
Allure: 75/100
Enticement: 80/100
Immersion: 90/100
Prose Quality: 90/100
Total Score: 432/500
The more specialized scores for individual prizes, as well as the results of the community poll, will be published when the full results are announced. If this story wins any awards, there will be another post in the story comments sometime after June 9th announcing that this story has won.

Thank you for participating, and thank you for contributing to Fimfic's collection of clop!

Congratulations on winning Dirty Little Secret's Dirty Little Contest!
For the full results, check the Dirty Little Award Show.

This story won:

Fetish Fuel: Sister
When it comes to brothers and(or) sisters getting it on, you have no equal. Just don’t wake up Mom and Dad. Your clopfic had the best scene involving two (or more) siblings.

Yes! Triplets for each of his sisters! I hope we see them in hot as fuk sequel!

Would you mind if I do a reading of this on my Youtube Channel?

Before them, Applejack stood in front of a white canvas scattered with pictures and charts and numbers Big Mac was too tired to process. Most likely something to do with profits and such.

Usually Big Mac does the math.

It depicted a red stallion with an orange mane mounting a mare with a cowboy hat from behind.

Couldn’t they ask from help from their cousins or go to a fertility doctor?

Where I can find the art? Cropped i cant reverse image search but it does look familiar... no pun intended

Login or register to comment